1911 reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 228 Reddit reviews across 9 subreddits and 37 posts to rank the best 1911 brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/1911, r/CAguns, r/Firearms, r/10mm, r/NYCGuns. Top-rated brands include Tisas (4.3/5), Dan Wesson (4.6/5), Springfield (4.5/5).
Stats
Reviews228
Subreddits9
Posts37
Brands37
Products88
228 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Tisas
4.3
(41)
"I own Tisas, Girsan and RIA for imported 1911 pistols. Tisas is by far the best choice."
"I have several Tisas 1911's including .45 9mm 10mm, all run flawlessly so far."
"Tisas, I’ve had great experience with mine."
"A tisas GI 1911 for $500 or less and buy a case of ammo."
"The Tisas is a far better pistol than the other two. Fit and finish are outstanding."
"The Tisas is head and shoulders above the Girsan and FAR FAR better than my RIA."
"Tisas is your solution"
"Tisas or Springfield"
"I have a Tisas Stakeout and I love it. Just over $300 and I have never looked back."
"The answer is and always will be for any price point on this subreddit 'Tisas'."
#2
Dan Wesson
4.6
(35)
"I too, vote for the DW Vigil. Just about perfect for a concealed carry 1911 in my book."
"I used to carry the DW Vigil CCO, had to get rid of it for $ reasons. Finally got around to replacing it and got the Guardian. I absolutely love carrying that."
"My Dan Wessons are my "nice" 1911's lol."
"Don’t get discouraged by 45. My wife (very recoil sensitive) was on a 5" 9mm for the first year of her shooting, but switched to commander 45 because "it feels more balanced"."
"One of my favorite carry guns is my DW Vigil CCO."
"Dan wessons are just perfect especially for carry."
"Have owned multiple of both brands, Dan Wesson without question."
"The DW is just a better overall gun out of the box (internals, trigger pull, front sight, etc)."
"I love my Springfield but it’s no question, Dan Wesson all the way."
"Dan Wesson guardian will treat you right. It will be an accurate shooter and reliable."
#3
Springfield
4.5
(31)
"It quite literally is the standard for a duty rated 1911."
"I have a SA Mil-Spec with 15,000 rounds through it without a malfunction."
"Agree what others suggested: TRP."
"Springfield TRP... It's essentially the same look as the professional without the extra hand fitting."
"If you can get a Springfield loaded in 9mm, that would probably be a solid base."
"You will not regret owning one."
"Garrison was my first 1911, it's fantastic."
"Honestly you'll love that gun."
"Garrison is much nicer overall IMO."
"Great firearms that don't break the bank."
#4
Colt
4.4
(20)
"If I were looking for a 1911 in 10mm, it would be a Delta Elite."
"Colt O1911C is the way to go"
"Just get a Colt O1911SEA1. Novak sights and WWII style markings."
"I have a colt comp 70 and love it."
"The Colt/Walther 1911 would be my choice now."
"I pick mine up from the ffl soon but not soon enough."
"Plenty on Gunbroker."
"We have a Colt 1911 on our rental wall and has had thousands of rounds through it w/o anything breaking on her."
"I have the Colt 1911 Gold Cup Trophy in 45 and 9mm. I can recommend them both."
"Saw a NIB Colt Delta for $1000 today"
#5
Rock Island Armory
4.1
(14)
"I sold my rock island to a friend and kept the tisas, but I would buy another rock island in a heartbeat."
"I have a .45 RIA that runs flawlessly."
"I have the Ria 1911 and it's been fantastic I'd trust that thing with my life."
"I love my RIA. I’ve had it for 7 years and runs great. It runs flawless with the Mec-Gar mags."
"Rock island"
"Rock Island/Armscor 1911s are great value, and they offer 10mm versions now."
"Rock Island 1911 are solid and fully reliable pistols I would recommend all day long."
"I have one in 45 and it's run great for me. It was my first 1911."
"Rock island armory for the price are pretty great. I own a couple and I have not been disappointed !"
"Rock Island is my budget choice."
#6
Kimber
4.1
(10)
"Kimber, own one, fired 3 and all three are most accurate 10mm’s I’ve shot & most accurate 1911 I’ve ever shot in any caliber from any brand."
"Kimber TLE/RL2 is the best 10mm 1911 overall, IMHO. That's my personal #1 over the others."
"I cannot find anything better on roster for that price range."
"Is great, low recoil, accurate."
"Love my kimber tle"
"Kimber just add some 9mm 1911. that are optic ready id probably go with that."
"Have you looked at Kimber? Fantastic feel and balance. Very accurate."
"My personal 1911 I use as a hiking gun and hunting back up is a Kimber and it runs great but Kimbers can be pretty pricey."
"Generally has good reviews."
"Stay far away from Kimber"
#7
Springfield Armory
4.3
(9)
"TRP, full rail or regular depending what you like, I have the full rail and am in love with it."
"Springfield target loaded or EMP are both great."
"I absolutely love my Springfield Armory Loaded Target in 9 mm."
"New or used?? Springfield Ronin,"
"Spring field ronin has been good for me, kimber has several you can find, ruger is decent (shot dont own). Tissa is good for a cheaper gun."
"SA Ronin or Magnum Research. You can get the Ronin optics ready but those are hard to find."
"If you only want the new car on roster smell, then Springfield TRP, Dan Wesson PM"
"SA Trp"
"The Ronin in particular is a good starting point."
#8
Les Baer
4.7
(7)
"Dead accurate I’ll go with Les Baer for the money and time saving."
"Les baer. I’ve shot a lot of guns and have to say my baer is the best."
"Les baer."
"You can get LB's new in that range!"
"Do you want classic or tactical? You can find Les Baers in that range."
"Nighthawk/Wilson/Wesson/Baer in the “semi custom heirloom quality with care” bracket imho."
"Off the shelf? Any of the semi-customs: Wilson, Baer, Nighthawk, ACW, Guncrafter Industries."
#9
Nighthawk
4.0
(6)
"Bang for the buck I would recommend alchemy or nighthawk."
"Nighthawk/Wilson/Wesson/Baer in the “semi custom heirloom quality with care” bracket imho."
"From the mass-produced but pretty awesome, like Dan Wesson and Nighthawk."
"It’s opinion based imo nighthawk/wilson combat"
"Have owned most of the nicer brands. I'd say something from Nighthawk."
"Off the shelf? Any of the semi-customs: Wilson, Baer, Nighthawk, ACW, Guncrafter Industries."
#10
Magnum Research
5.0
(4)
"10mm Magnum Research 1911 for sure in that price range, if you can find one. I love mine, made by BUL Armory in Israel."
"My magnum research 10mm is awesome very smooth pistol"
"Fantastic balance."
"It's my favorite pistol."
#11
Hornady
4.3
(4)
"Cant go wrong with Hornady critical defense"
"Settled on the Hornady critical defense, but I know some people have trouble feeding it in their 1911s"
"Mine personally is critical duty because my 1911s feed it reliably."
"You have hornady critical defense for a basic but consistent and well made round"
#12
Bul Armory
4.3
(4)
"The best 1911 under $1,000 is probably the Bul Armory/ Magnum research 1911."
"Bul Armory's 1911s - both single stack and double stack - perform well above their price tag."
"I am also considering the bul edc 2011. It is in my price range and I’ve been very happy with my bul tac 5"."
"Without a doubt it’s the Israel made Bul Armory imported by Magnum Research as the "Desert eagle 1911"."
#13
Sig Sauer
4.3
(3)
"I've been happy with my Sig Sauer 1911R."
"Sig Nitron 1911"
"Sig Sauer or Springfield for your specified budget."
#14
Wilson Combat
4.0
(3)
"Nighthawk/Wilson/Wesson/Baer in the “semi custom heirloom quality with care” bracket imho."
"It’s opinion based imo nighthawk/wilson combat"
"Off the shelf? Any of the semi-customs: Wilson, Baer, Nighthawk, ACW, Guncrafter Industries."
#15
GSG
4.0
(3)
"GSG makes a full size 1911 in 22 I'd definitely recommend upgrading the guide rod and springs."
"Ive had fun with my GSG 1911s in .22."
"I have both a gsg 1911 and a chiappa 1911-22 and they both run smoothly."
#16
Girsan
4.0
(3)
"My specific Girsan(MC1911S Hunter) is a little tighter than my specific Tisas(Duty SS45R). Better trigger. Better sights. Better grips."
"I have a Tisss and Girsan, both cost me around $500 each, the Girsan seems just slightly better built."
"I really enjoy shooting it. It's just the right size, eats any ammo I feed it, and it just runs."
#17
Ruger
5.0
(2)
"Ruger SR1911 in 10MM or 45ACP without question."
"My ruger sr1911 in 10mm has been flawless since the day I bought it."
#18
1911
5.0
(2)
"Honestly I’d use 1911 for gone defense, anytime that I used one or shot one at the range. It has never jammed on me and always ran perfectly."
"...continua a cercare un 1911 che ti piace. Sono certo che comunque non ti accontenterai."
#19
Cabot
5.0
(2)
"If money is no issue take a look at Cabot."
"If you want heirloom, Cabot makes some pretty cool one-of-a-kind 1911s."
#20
Rock Island
5.0
(2)
"RIA EFS, just got one and it's wonderful."
"I've put thousands of rounds through mine never had a problem"
#21
Guardian
4.5
(2)
"Fit and finish are beyond reproach and the trigger was the best I’ve ever felt in a 1911 out of the box."
"I purchased a Guardian 9mm this year joining my 45 Guardian."
#22
Walther Colt
4.5
(2)
"Runs great, threaded barrel so you can add a suppressor as well."
"Trigger is amazing, overall feel is excellent."
#23
Winchester
4.0
(2)
"Firstly Winchester Ranger-T if you can get them."
"No votes yet for Winchester ranger-T? Harder to find but expands to about an inch diameter in lucky gunner’s testing"
#24
Sig
4.0
(2)
"Check the Sig 1911R."
"Don't forget the Sig 1911R."
#25
Platypus
4.0
(2)
"Pm7 or a platypus 2011. Since I have a 1911 already I’d go with a platypus."
"I would get the platty, DW, or the TRP if you want traditional 1911 single stack in 45acp."
#26
Underwood
4.0
(2)
"Underwood ammo 230 hollow points or if you want a lighter option go for the 185s"
"Underwood 45 acp+p"
#27
Milt Sparks
5.0
(1)
"One of the best and nicest holsters i have is my milt sparks for my springfield EMP."
#28
Fusion
5.0
(1)
"Definitely fusion. I own a 1911 and 2011 from them. Legit company."
#29
SIG
5.0
(1)
"Finest gun I have ever shot."
#30
Advantage Arms
5.0
(1)
"It’s a conversion kit that mounts on your 1911 frame."
#31
Fusion Arms
4.0
(1)
"I’ve been eyeing the fusion arms xp-pro but currently it’s only cambered in 9mm."
#32
Alpha Foxtrot
4.0
(1)
"If you want thin, the Alpha Foxtrot 1911-S15 is a double stack 9mm 1911 that uses Shield Arms S15 mags."
#33
Alchemy
4.0
(1)
"Bang for the buck I would recommend alchemy or nighthawk."
#34
Charles Daly
4.0
(1)
"I've had good luck with my Charles Daly."
#35
Para Ordnance
4.0
(1)
"I love my para ord"
#36
PPQ
4.0
(1)
"Try a PPQ 45 if you can find one."
#37
Norinco
4.0
(1)
"They're solidly built and generally have better qc/tolerances than most newly made 1911's."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
