All Terrain Tire reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 208 Reddit reviews across 9 subreddits and 12 posts to rank the best All Terrain Tire brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/f150, r/4x4, r/tires, r/GXOR, r/tundra. Top-rated brands include Falken (4.6/5), BFGoodrich (4.0/5), Toyo (4.8/5).
Stats
Reviews208
Subreddits9
Posts12
Brands24
Products67
208 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Falken
4.6
(54)
"Falken tires are the best aggressive all season tires you can put on a Subaru. I have had them on outback's & Impreza's and they are awesome."
"I have the AT4W WildPeaks on my truck as well and they are absolutely amazing."
"Wildpeaks are the way to go. BFG suck in the rain."
"At4’s. Aside from looking great they are a very high performing/long lasting tire."
"Wildpeak AT4s"
"Falken AT4Ws, have them on my Sierra and they’re amazing, super smooth on the road, surprisingly quiet, and cuts through wet roads like it’s not even there."
"I went from KO2 to Falken wildpeak at3 and it was night and day difference how good the Falken were in rain and snow."
"I've got about 2600 miles on the Wildpeaks. It's been all dry or wet roads so far. No issues at all. I don't even notice any tire noise."
"Wildpeaks, we have them on the wife’s GX. Can’t even hear them when on the highway."
"I’ve been really happy with my Falken AT3Ws. Their quiet, ride well, a grip well in every terrain I’ve tried."
#2
BFGoodrich
4.0
(30)
"Bfg AT KO3 hands down."
"If you grow some nuts get BFG KO3 and stop asking the internet what to don"
"Bfgoodrich trail terrain, imo its one of the best trail terrain/mild AT tires out there. pretty good manners on the highway, has a 60k mile warranty"
"BFG Trail Terrain"
"Off Road AT: BFG AT KO3"
"Owned Toyos and K02’s and firmly believe the KO2 is the best tire ever."
"Nothing beats BFGoodrich KO2’s. Aggressive and quiet AF."
"Got 75k miles out of my KO2s with piss poor rotation intervals. Great all around tire"
"I have BFGOODRICH Trail Terrain T/A tires on my 15 but it’s an XLT I love them they are great in the rain as well!"
"I have BFG KO2 ATs and they have done great in the snow and mud for me."
#3
Toyo
4.8
(17)
"Toyos have been the best for me in the rain compared to other AT tires and their snow rating is great too."
"Aftermarket AT3s are great through standing water and almost as good as a snow tire in snow."
"My Toyo OC AT3’s did admirably. Heck, I tried to get it to hydroplane (reasonably) a little and cut through it like nothing."
"Cant go wrong with either the Open Country AT3 Toyos or Wildpeak AT3W from Falken."
"My Toyo Open Country's are awesome. People have commented on how quiet they are too."
"Toyo Open Country AT3"
"I just put Toyo AT3 285 70r18s on my 2024 F150 XLT FX4 after a 2" level and they look great."
"Toyota AT3 open country. Expensive but the best all around truck tire I've ever owned."
"Toyo AT3 is a great tire, had them on 4 trucks now."
"Toyo AT3 are treating me great!"
#4
Nitto
4.4
(16)
"New Nitto Terra Grappler G3’s looks sweet and perform great."
"I love my nitto ridge grapplers. Just enough aggressiveness and not too much noise."
"Nitto all terrains look good, work well, and last a longtime"
"My last two sets of tires have been Ridge Grapplers, and I can't say enough about how much I like them."
"I put a set of 275/60r20 Nitto Recon Grapplers on mine about 4-5 months ago and they are absolutely outstanding. Rides smooth, great all weather traction (mainly rain down here in Houston), and will get me where i need to go when fishing down by the beach in those sandy areas."
"Absolutely love these tires. And they’re triple mountain rated. That’s the only reason I went with these instead of the Nitto Ridge Grapplers, but I wouldn’t turn back now."
"Nitto Ridge Grapplers have been my favorite tire so far. I’ll probably keep buying them. 60k miles on my last set. Quiet, long tread life, somewhat aggressive look."
"I am running nitto recon grapplers and made a snowboarding trip to Colorado last winter and they did fantastic."
"Probably the Nitto Terra G3s that have released. They are very light for what they are, and apparently 3PMS rated."
"Some other options include the ... nitto nomad grappler"
#5
Cooper
4.4
(16)
"Discoverer AT3 XLT on my 84 Dodge W150. Quietest and longest wearing that I have found."
"The Coopers were far quieter and longer wearing. Use them pretty much exclusively now"
"I love the coopers also"
"I'm running Cooper at3 xlt's. Great all around tire"
"Cooper has been my friend, just changed my AT3s after 75k miles, replaced with ATP hoping for the same quality this go around."
"Check out the cooper discoverer road+trail. Really great tire that I just put on my 22 f150. You can get them in p-metric sizes and they are very light compared to the falkens, with a better tread life warranty. They ride like butter and are super quiet"
"Really? I live in Lake Tahoe California and kept cooper at3 4s on my Subaru year round and now on my GX. Handles great in absolutely insane snow and ice."
"Cooper AT3s on our 4runners. They're very quiet, and we've never hydroplaned them."
"The new Cooper Stronghold has already gotten positive feedback from our customers"
"Cooper Discoverer Road + Trail AT"
#6
Nokian
4.6
(11)
"I have had Nokian Outpost APTs and they were fantastic in wet or slushy conditions and pretty great in deep snow"
"Nokian outpost APTs. I just installed some on my Subaru Outback and used them on a moose hunting trip driving 800km on pavement, 200km on dirt roads, rain, sun and a bit of snow."
"Nokian outpost apt, it’s exactly what your looking for the trail/apt (all-purpose terrain) tires are durable all-terrains designed for road use with decent comfort and mpg"
"3rd vote for Nokian Outpost APT"
"+1 for Nokian outpost apt. They’re exactly what you’re looking for. Aramid (Kevlar) sidewall for pothole resistance and an aggressive tread that won’t destroy your MPG."
"Nokian outpost APT. They handle well on and off road, last long, and have reinforced sidewall to resist punctures."
"Nokian Outpost nAT’s 10 ply + Kevlar, all weather, super quiet, great warranty and saves gas."
"Nokian makes a great all terrain that is intended to spend a lot of time in the snow."
"I just bought a set of Outpost APT's for our 23 Pathfinder, very nice tires, they handle well, have a good tread life."
"They are an excellent snowflake rated all purpose terrain tire, decent in pretty much any conditions."
#7
General
4.5
(10)
"General Grabber ATX. Hands down best AT tire I’ve ran on the road. Very confident wet-weather tire and rides great."
"Recon grapplers, I can’t rave enough about them."
"I’ve been loving the General Grabber’s on my Tremor."
"I’m rolling on General Grabbers 10 ply right now, great tires Imo"
"General ATX, one of the best all terrain tire in the snow and decent in off road situations. I got 65k out of my last set and was impressed by how they were."
"General grabber ATX, a true AT not a highway tire masquerading as one like the Michelin defenders"
"I have good luck with general grabber ATXs'"
"Some other options include the general grabber apt"
"General Grabber ATX"
"I’ve had good experiences with the general grabber atx and the Goodyear UltraTerrain, Goodyears did good in winter conditions haven’t had a chance to try the generals out yet, reviews say they’re good so we’ll see"
#8
Yokohama
4.3
(10)
"Overall I second the geolanders. I've had 3 sets of the geolanders now and they're great tires."
"Great towing rating, excellent wet performance. Never gotten stuck in loose-sharp rocks on steep trails at 11,000ft, snow, mud or sand. Never had a noise complaint."
"I just wanted to say I love the Yokos, especially the LT 10 plys."
"I've been running the Yoko G015s for many years now. Started buying them when I lived near Tahoe. 3PMSF rated so I could always get through chain control. Excellent tread life."
"I’m liking the Yokohama Geolandar CV4S. It seems to have a good balance between fuel economy and light “off road” ability."
"Yokohama Geolandar GO15 are very quiet. Best I have had for noise."
"I’d recommend a Yokohama Geolander AT G0015"
"I love the Yokohama Geolander AT G015. Just put a set on and they look great, but still ride really well."
"Yokohama A/T XD if you want something slightly more agressive than the typical at."
"Yokohama LT AT/S"
#9
Michelin
4.6
(9)
"I switched over to the Wildpeak AT/3s for my truck and the navigator has the Michelins. Will be putting the Wildpeaks on the expedition because they are pretty close to the Michelins but look more aggressive."
"Michelin LTX M/S 2’s. Amazing tires and they’ve never left me stranded."
"Michelin LTX Defenders would have that thing riding like a cloud"
"I’ve got 51k on my set, still super quiet and smooth, easily have another 20k left in them. Great in the snow and rain and do fine off road if you air them down"
"I just put on defenders on my 2020 platinum, absolutely love them."
"Michelin LTX AT2. Mild for an AT but effective off and on road."
"Michelin defender LTX platinum which comes only in 20” rims. My understanding is that you get the performance of Michelin defenders with the looks of an all terrain tire"
"Shoot the new defender ltx m/s2 are a little more aggressive looking than the last generation and if those older ones worked great for ya I would just get new ones!"
"CrossClimate2 is great in soft mud."
#10
Goodyear
4.0
(6)
"Goodyear Wrangler AT"
"Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT"
"Goodyear duratrack"
"I prefer Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrack, mean looking but quiet for the lug."
"Im on year 2 of my Goodyear wrangler all terrain adventure a/t’s. I’m quite happy with them, not the best for towing though."
"Goodyear wrangler adventure with Kevlar."
#11
Firestone
4.2
(5)
"Firestone Destination AT/2 are amazing in the snow! Had them on my 2016 Explorer."
"Firestone destination AT2 or BFG trail terrain TA would be really good choices."
"Firestone Destination X/T will be your most lightweight choice."
"Firestone Destination AT2's is my pick"
"I’ve run a few sets of Firestone Destination AT2 that are quiet and perform well for our Michigan Winters."
#12
Mickey Thompson
4.3
(4)
"Baja boss AT are fantastic in wet so far. While K02 have been junk in wet for me."
"Mickey Thompson BAJA BOSS, Falken Wildpeak AT3 or AT4s, or Goodrich K02 or K03s"
"275/60r20 mickey thompson baja boss AT. Make sure they are the SL rated ones. You dont need E rated tires."
"Ive had the Baja AT for 60k"
#13
Kumho
4.3
(4)
"The AT52s seem to get broken in the first time you go off-road as well. They handle great on the street and in the rain as well."
"Kumho AT52, silent on the road and have taken every off-road trail I’ve thrown them at with zero issues."
"I'll second the Kumhos. They're quiet, work well in the rain, and do well off-road."
"My Kumho Road Venture ATs are pretty quiet. Good tires overall"
#14
Pirelli
3.0
(3)
"Pirelli scorpion all terrain plus, very underrated"
"I went with Pirelli Scorpion ATPlus. WAY better wet traction than the stock tires, pretty good in snow too - not that noticeable of a difference from the Blizzaks."
"I can tell you to avoid the Pirelli Scorpion ATR. I have them and wouldn't recommend them. Terrible when wet."
#15
Klever
4.0
(2)
"After looking I found the klever xt which are pretty much close to that. Good on road, off road, good in snow (also studdable) and pretty affordable at less than 200 per tire."
"The klever tire looks really good. It is even studdable for snow/ice."
#16
Maxxis
4.0
(2)
"RAZR A/T is pretty quiet, and does fantastically in the snow"
"I recently picked up a set of Maxxis Razr ATs. Well rated, aggressive AT tire that’s also has the 3PMSF rating for winter performance. So far really happy with them in summer conditions."
#17
Hankook
4.0
(2)
"Hankook Dynapro AT2"
"Hankook Dynapro AT2X"
#18
Continental
5.0
(1)
"Continental TerrainContact A/T is EXACTLY what you want amazing on the highway and the BEST tire in rain, bare none."
#19
Duratrac
4.0
(1)
"Duratrac RT. the new updated version."
#20
Vredestein
4.0
(1)
"I have Vredestein Pinza ATs installed. Decent on road AT style without the noise"
#21
Kenda
4.0
(1)
"The Kenda AT is a “budget” tire that punches way above its price point and would also be a fine choice"
#22
Pathfinder
4.0
(1)
"Pathfinder AT. Its their house brand 50-55000 mile warranty. Great all around all terrain tire."
#23
Open Range
4.0
(1)
"I like the Open Range A/Ts from Les Schwab and kept them on year round when I lived in the NW"
#24
Bridgestone
3.0
(1)
"Bridgestone has a newer one in 275/50-22 Ascent AT. Not a bad looking tire."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
