Concealer reviews from Reddit

Summary

We analyzed 524 Reddit reviews across 31 subreddits and 138 posts to rank the best Concealer brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Sephora, r/Makeup, r/MakeupAddiction, r/beauty, r/AustralianMakeup. Top-rated brands include NARS (4.6/5), NYX (4.5/5), Haus Labs (4.6/5).

Stats

Reviews524

Subreddits31

Posts138

Brands46

Products88

Top communities

r/Sephora111 r/Makeup107 r/MakeupAddiction72 r/beauty37 r/AustralianMakeup36

524 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

NARS

4.6

(65)

"NARS radiant creamy concealer will never let me down."

"My two favorite concealers are the NARS Rasiant creamy, and the Natasha Denona Hy Glam concealer."

"NARS soft matte complete concealer is the g.o.a.t."

"Nars soft matte is really nice"

"Nars is my #1 but this is a good option too imo."

"NARS pot concealer 100%, literally vanishes anything off your face."

"Only one that doesn’t break me out and if you let it sit before blending it helps increase the coverage."

"The nars creamy one is super good!"

"Never fails."

"This is the only one that has worked for me."

NYX

4.5

(43)

"Another vote for nyx Bare With Me. It’s unbeatable on dry skin."

"Seconding the nyx serum i honestly don’t even bother with skin tints anymore and just use that to spot conceal all over"

"Last I apply NYX serum concealer. It doesn't crease on me at all which is unheard of."

"NYX Serum Concealer, great value with a pump, not orange, not pink, very creamy."

"It's weirdly high coverage, super hydrating and the teeeeeniest dot does both eyes. It's also incredibly thin, so it hardly creases. I love it so much."

"The nyx serum concealer is 100% my favourite"

"I like the NYX bare with me concealer!"

"The formula is light weight and blends effortlessly with no dryness."

"Nyx bare with me concealer"

"It is very hydrating, and a great price!"

Haus Labs

4.6

(35)

"I LOVE Haus Labs concealer. I recommend it to everyone, it’s all I wear!"

"It's creamy and brightening."

"Fantastic for very dry/maturing skin and is my current favorite."

"Haus Labs concealer is excellent, I recommend checking that line."

"Has been my favorite."

"Is fuller coverage and blends like a dream."

"I tried a sample of Haus Labs and I swear my eyes have never looked that good before."

"I quite love using the haus labs concealer"

"Haus Labs concealer + immediately set with huda beauty powder gives me literal soft skin and no creases."

"Hydrating and better coverage than Tower 28."

Natasha Denona

4.6

(34)

"It is veryyy good as it hydrates the area in time, so its like skincare, but in makeup. The concealer is very pigmented, a little goes a long way"

"Natasha Denona. Put a small amount on your the top of your hand and dip finger or brush tap lightly where you need it, working in thin layers."

"Natasha Denona or Tower28."

"Natasha denona concealer!"

"My two favorite concealers are the NARS Rasiant creamy, and the Natasha Denona Hy Glam concealer."

"The coverage and consistency of the Hy-Glam concealer is by far the best as far as hiding the dark circles and not creasing all day!"

"Definitely Natasha Denona concealer"

"I love the Natasha Denona concealer. It's pricey but worth it."

"This is the best concealer of all time."

"I really like the Natasha Denona and Haus Labs concealers for oily skin & large pores."

Tower 28

4.7

(31)

"Tower 28 - best I’ve tried"

"The tower 28 hydrating concealer is amazing."

"I love Tower 28 concealer. I’m older and it doesn’t settle into lines/creases."

"It is so hydrating for me, doesn’t crease."

"I have dry skin and its done wonders for me."

"I absolutely love it."

"I’m a big fan of Tower28 concealer."

"I use 2BU, i'm stupidly pale and cool toned and it's perfect for me."

"Is quite magical for my hollow dark under eyes."

"Tower 28 concealer… trust me!"

Maybelline

4.4

(30)

"Super creamy, doesn’t settle into fine lines, and costs less than your iced coffee addiction."

"I love the maybelline age rewind :)"

"It’s super lightweight and makes me look like I’ve had a full night’s sleep."

"Maybelline instant age rewind in 00 and 095."

"Maybelline Fit Me Concealer also in the lightest shade."

"The perfect shade of pink that cancels out the dark circles really well."

"Maybelline Age Rewind concealer"

"The only under eye concealer I have ever loved is the maybelline age rewind."

"I always go back to Fit Me by Maybelline concealer for the past almost decade."

"Maybelline 160 brightener in the age rewind formula is great."

Tarte

4.7

(27)

"Tarte shape tape is amazing, hourglass is also amazing, (it’s my holy grail)."

"I also love Tarte Shape Tape, which is vegan and cruelty free."

"The coverage is great, easy to blend & has a nice finish."

"I would highly recommend you this."

"Tarte shape tape 8B or 12B depending on how fair you are."

"I LOVEE the tarte shape tape to this day and probably the best one"

"I use tarte shape tape concealer."

"I’ve been using Tarte Shape Tape Concealer paired with Tarte’s creaseless loose setting powder."

"I usually use full coverage concealer or foundation that has peach or orange undertones like Tarte shape tape concealer."

"Tarte shape tape."

Huda Beauty

4.6

(24)

"I really like the hudabeaty one (in papaya)."

"Try the huda beauty concealer. it doesn’t crease at all."

"If you are looking for an expensive option-huda beauty hands down for more natural coverage."

"Huda beauty fauxfilter in 1.7 Honey is pinky and the formula is so good."

"It's really lightweight with perfect coverage."

"I use the Huda Beauty colour corrector which works wonders."

"I love huda faux filter one."

"I have the best luck with huda color corrector."

"You should try huda beauty."

"Some of my favs are the Huda Beauty concealer in Nougat and Natasha Denona in YN6 for full coverage looks."

Dior

5.0

(21)

"It has been great for my creases. It seems to last forever too."

"It’s expensive but also has almost double the amount of product most other concealers do"

"Dior is so hydrating and smooth."

"Dior forever concealer has good coverage, neutral to glowy finish, and never cakes or separates on me"

"I’d say go with the Dior forever skin correct. That one is hydrating but full coverage and I personally don’t have an issue with creasing."

"Some favorites... 1. Dior Forever Skin Correct 00"

"For dark under eyes I’m a fan of the Dior Forever Concealer!"

"Dior forever skin correct is amazing."

"Dior forever skin correct."

"Dior forever skin correct is amazing."

#10

Kosas

4.8

(19)

"Kosas Revealer concealer! I have it in multiple shades."

"Kosas revealer concealer."

"I use Kosas concealer, foundation and their glow IV."

"Kosas!!"

"I love the Kosas one. Only one that doesn’t crease."

"I swear by the Kosas concealer, it never creases on me."

"I use Kosas concealer."

"My fave concealer is Kosas."

"But that concealer is perfection."

"Kosas concealer is my holy grail for non-caking and no oxidation concealer."

#11

Glossier

4.5

(19)

"Stretch concealer by Glossier is my fave. Doesn’t go dry and cakey at all"

"Recently I've been using Glossier Stretch Concealer under my eyes and it looks so good, IMO."

"I love glossier stretch concealer"

"The Glossier Pot Concealer is surprisingly so so good!"

"Glossier stretch!"

"Another vote for Glossier. Finger friendly, and when I’m in a rush I can easily spot conceal and go without foundation."

"Then glossier stretch concealer, which is undetectable even on bare skin for me!"

"Glossier stretch concealer is really good for dry skin."

"I have literally never found a concealer that beats the Glossier pot concealer."

"Then I take the Glossier stretch concealer."

#12

Hourglass

4.8

(16)

"HOURGLASSSS"

"Hourglass"

"Hourglass is the best one I’ve tried."

"Hourglass or Too Faced Born This Way concealers are my favorites."

"Hourglass concealer is the one for me after trying sooooo many."

"For me (a night shift nurse) 🙏🏻"

"Has been the only one that has been able to properly conceal my dark under eyes."

"Is super concentrated."

"Amazingly full coverage!!"

"Makes my pigmentation disappear like nothing."

#13

Bobbi Brown

4.5

(13)

"Check out Bobbi Brown color corrector is Light Bisque or Light Peach."

"I find the Bobbi Brown undereye corrector to be really good. Doesn’t ever crease on me."

"My favorites - Bobbi Brown Undereye Corrector (stick & pot are both wonderful."

"Use Bobbi brown corrector under your concealer."

"My favorite correctors are Huda Beauty and Bobbi brown."

"I use Bobbi Brown color corrector and Kosas concealer!"

"Bobbi brown corrector before a lighter concealer."

"Bobbie Brown Stick Corrector- I have dry under eyes."

"I like the Bobbi Brown color corrector."

#14

Elf

4.5

(13)

"If you can find a shade match, it’s amazing. And it’s cheap."

"ELF Hydrating Camo Concealer worked really well for me."

"High end concealers aren’t worth it when this one exists."

"I currently have and rotate between Elf Hydrating Camo Concealer, NYX Bare With Me Serum Concealer, and Catrice True Skin High Cover Concealer."

"Great for dry skin"

"If you are in the usa: ELF camo concealer, Wet n Wild incognito concealer, infallible concealer."

"That’s the only concealer I’d buy of that level."

"They have the hydrating camo concealer in a fair rose color that fits me perfectly."

"I love the Elf Camo Concealer."

"Elf hydrating camo is pretty good and affordable!"

#15

It Cosmetics

4.4

(13)

"It cosmetics bye bye under eye"

"I think you should give the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye concealer a go."

"The it cosmetics bye bye under eye. I’ve tried the Nars pot and hourglass but the it cosmetics is what you’re looking for. Dewy and full coverage and although it’s thick you barely need any."

"It cosmetics bye bye under eye is so creamy and nice and a little bit goes a long way!!!"

"IT cosmetics bye bye under eye!"

"I like IT cosmetics Bye Bye undereye."

"I remember trying It cosmetics concealer and found it similar to Keramask."

"A little tiny bit goes a long way but it’s def full coverage."

"It cosmetics byebye undereye concealer."

"The It cosmetics one is good."

#16

Kulfi

4.5

(11)

"The only concealer that has ever worked for me is the Kulfi main match."

"Kulfi is the most hydrating and does not crease on me."

"Kulfi Concealer! Love this one. Not cakey, doesn't crease and it's hydrating."

"Kulfi is my favorite concealer these days."

"Kulfi is great for dry under eyes and does not sink into fine lines."

"Kulfi concealer or Urban Decay Quickie."

"I’ve been having luck with the Main Match Crease-Proof Long-Wear Hydrating Concealer."

"Kulfi is very light and I got a sample of the tester from sephira employee too it's light and brightening, doesn't crease much."

"Concealer- Kulfi or Tower28"

"Kulfi, Kosas or colourpop."

#17

Too Faced

4.5

(10)

"The best concealer I’ve used is Too faced."

"Too Faced born this way for higher budget."

"Too faced born this way concealer ! Non comedogenic and full coverage."

"I love the Too Faced concealer for a full coverage concealer that actually lasts all day!"

"This erases them with a few dabs."

"I used to love shape tape but as I aged, it settled into creases a lot more."

"Too faced born this way."

"I use born this way by too faced and I apply it with a brush so it’s not as full on."

"Too faced warm beige."

"I recently got Too Faced Ethereal Light concealer."

#18

LA Girl

4.4

(8)

"I’m a concealer freak and the LA Girl is an iconic product."

"Have you looked into LA girl concealer? A huge shade range, really affordable and high coverage."

"LA pro girl concealer got me through the ages 12-15 when my acne scars HAD to be hidden."

"La pro concealer works wonders and if u want high coverage huda beauty concealer is a amazing..bt it's expensive..after using tht I've stopped using foundation"

"Mao sad na akong dakong prob OP unya itom kaayo sya, naka tabang nako ang LA Girl Pro Concealer (orange)."

"La girl pro concealers in shade fawn or MUR 13.2 flawless filter concealer."

"Surprisingly, la girl pro concealers do the trick."

#19

Tower28

5.0

(5)

"The tower 28 concealer is what I use and really like."

"I use Tower28! Underrated!"

"All their products have been amazing for my very acne prone skin and I actually switched to them after the Kosas concealer made me break out."

"I started using the tower 28 concealer and they work well together!"

"Tower 28"

#20

Kulfi Beauty

4.8

(5)

"Kulfi Cosmetics concealer works great! Full coverage and no creasing."

"Kulfi beauty or the lip bar have good concealers for brown skin."

"My favorite concealer is kulfi beauty."

"Kulfi Beauty concealer"

"Kulfi Beauty concealer."

#21

L'Oreal

4.6

(5)

"Have you tried the L'Oreal infallible concealer, I'm never going back to high end concealer thanks to how awesome it is."

"My absolute favourite new find is L’Oréal infallible concealer."

"If you are in the usa: ELF camo concealer, Wet n Wild incognito concealer, infallible concealer."

"I use the L'Oreal infallible concealer, I think it's probably the most high coverage drugstore concealer there is."

"L'Oreal infallible concealer is great , has been my go to for the last few years."

#22

MAC

4.6

(5)

"Mac Studio radiance concealer in nc5"

"I have genetic dark circles and I never go anywhere without my MAC concealer."

"Mac pro longwear concealer."

"Very minimal creasing and so many shades!"

"Mac's concealers work for me."

#23

iT Cosmetics

4.4

(5)

"The best I’ve found for dark under eyes is the iT cosmetics bye bye undereye concealer."

"I like Bye-Bye Undereye!"

"The iT Cosmetics bye bye undereye concealer!"

"I tend to recommend the 'Bye Bye Undereye, Water proof concealer'."

"I layer it over a very thin application of Bye Bye Undereye."

#24

Mac

4.2

(5)

"An oldy but goody. I found it never creased on me."

"Mac prolongwear"

"I like It CC cream as a base it also does some great concealing on its own."

"I found that MAC didn't give me any itches or outbreaks."

"I've had luck with Mac."

#25

Pat McGrath

5.0

(4)

"It’s a bit pricey but worth the money. I literally sometimes do only concealer based makeup, as it has such a high coverage."

"My favorites are Pat McGrath and YSL Touche Eclat."

"Pat McGrath"

"I would recommend Pat McGrath Sublime concealer. It’s creamy, solid medium coverage, and looks like skin."

#26

Catrice

5.0

(4)

"It’s the best at concealer I’ve ever used."

"So much better than any concealer I've tried!"

"Catrice Under Eye Brightener. You won’t be sorry."

"I like the Catrice under eye brightener a lot."

#27

The Saem

4.8

(4)

"The Saem's Cover Perfection Triple Pot Concealer is so good."

"Is my go to. It’s an affordable cream colour corrector."

"The saem pot concealer"

"The saem pot concealer in 0.5"

#28

Charlotte Tilbury

4.5

(4)

"I mix the Kulfi main match concealer with the Charlotte Tilbury beautiful skin concealer and it gives smooth, pretty dull coverage that does not crease or dry out."

"I actually mix it with Charlotte Tilbury’s beautiful skin concealer and set it with the Huda easy bake loose powder and it’s perfection."

"Charlotte tilbury color corrector"

"Use the charlotte tillbury color corrector then go over with a thin layer of foundation."

#29

Colourpop

4.3

(4)

"Colourpop hasn’t creased on my under eye baggage yet."

"Colourpop concealer in Fair 07c."

"The elf camo concealers and colourpop concealers also apparently have some pretty good olive shades."

"I have a colourpop concealer that is pretty muted."

#30

e.l.f.

4.3

(4)

"The ONLY concealer I’m obsesssed with is elf camo concealer!"

"I like the elf hydrating camo concealer."

"I’ve just started using the ELF Camo concealer."

"I use the elf hydrating camo concealer for my hormonal acne."

#31

Ilia

4.0

(4)

"Ilia is my holy grail for dry and sensitive skin!!"

"Ilia is really good on my dry/mature skin."

"I’ve been having luck with the Ilia serum concealer."

"I tried Ilia, Haus Labs, and Burt’s Bees and had terrible results each time."

#32

Dermablend

5.0

(3)

"Yes, Dermablend. But make sure to set it with powder, ideally also from Dermablend."

"I would recommend Dermablend. I’ve seen other people use it to cover tattoos and I’ve used it to cover scars and birthmarks."

"Dermablend."

#33

Perbelle Cosmetics

4.7

(3)

"It’s super hydrating and gives a nice, smooth finish."

"It is amazing."

"I am using Perbelle Cosmetics cover stick concealer for dry skin. And it works good for me."

#34

Fenty

4.7

(3)

"She turned me on to the Fenty Hydrating concealer. It has so much more pigment and still a really dewy finish."

"I use the fenty hydrating concealer in the shade 100c with it!"

"Been loving the hydrating one by Fenty."

#35

Fiera

4.3

4.0

(2)

"I use benefit boing and sometimes bare minerals powder concealer which won't be great for dry under eyes but maybe try the setting spray tip and see if your best conclealer creases."

"It's working well under my eyes"

#46

Mars

4.0

(2)

"Mars cancel concealer for lower budget."

"Try the Mars cancel concealer I’ve seen great reviews about it."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started