Crib Mattress reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 162 Reddit reviews across 15 subreddits and 39 posts to rank the best Crib Mattress brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/BabyBumps, r/NewParents, r/BabyBumpsCanada, r/moderatelygranolamoms, r/beyondthebump. Top-rated brands include Newton (4.7/5), Naturepedic (4.4/5), Ikea (4.3/5).
Stats
Reviews162
Subreddits15
Posts39
Brands42
Products68
162 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Newton
4.7
(59)
"I second the the Newton, I think it is comfy, firm, and keeps its shape."
"It’s 100% worth it especially when flu, norovirus/rotavirus, etc hits the household."
"Our baby LOVES her Newton mattress!"
"Newton, easily. It’s waterproof. You’ll have to google it to see what I mean. It’s also insanely comfy."
"Newton"
"Love our Newton!!!"
"We have the Newton washable one and it’s amazing. So airy and comfy for my son."
"Loved our Newton Crib Mattress! My daughter is 3 now and so she has the Twin Mattress."
"We have the newton mattress and I love it."
"Mommyhood101 says the Newton mattress is best."
#2
Naturepedic
4.4
(12)
"Naturpedic!"
"Naturepedic I think is the commonly recommended option."
"I got a Naturepedic because I love how firm it is."
"Is SO firm, and keeps that firmness."
"Naturepedic crib mattress"
"Our Naturepedic mattress fits perfectly (it’s the two sided mattress)"
"We did Naturepedic in the mini. No issues at all with the mattress."
"Naturepedic or Avocado."
"I got the naturpedic organic mattress."
"Naturepedic or brentwood home. Avocado is a bit ridiculous $$$$$."
#3
Ikea
4.3
(7)
"I love the Jattetrott"
"We have an Ikea foam mattress that is still going strong almost 3yrs later."
"IKEA, sometimes Costco has good options online"
"IKEA :)"
"If you have an Ikea crib get the Ikea mattress."
"I am also planning to go for the Ikea crib and I think I will buy the mattress there as well."
"Mine was about $32 at IKEA, and I believe there was another one cheaper."
#4
Graco
3.8
(8)
"We got the Graco premium foam toddler/baby mattress from Amazon!"
"Ended up going with the Graco cause a friend had it and said her son slept super well on it. No complaints, seems comfy but firm."
"My sister recommended it, it has plenty of good reviews, and I remember seeing elsewhere on Reddit that someone said it fit perfectly in the SNIGLAR."
"I chose the Graco mattress, it’s affordable, it’s well known brand that is reliable and issues recalls when necessary, and it’s a firm mattress."
"Graco is a VERY well known, reputable, safe brand."
"We like it. It’s the right size for growing into, and comes with a water resistant (removable) cover."
"Graco from Walmart. I think they’re like 80$?"
"I am personally considering the Graco 2 sided one."
#5
Sealy
3.8
(8)
"They absorb the liquid and require washing (and air drying) after an accident."
"We got ours at Costco, they were even on sale it was sealy I believe. Kids are almost a year and a half and no issues."
"It's a good, firm yet comfy mattress."
"I chose it because it said firm and had great ratings."
"I bought mine on Amazon for about $150.00 - the sealy cotton bliss 2."
"I have either a Sealy or Simmons one.. can’t remember which brand it was. But it works fine."
"Any of the sealy/Serta crib mattress will do just fine. You don’t need to spend $200."
"LO seems to like it when she naps on it."
#6
IKEA
4.3
(6)
"We’re on year four of our ikea crib mattress and it’s now with our second child and still looks and feels like it’s new."
"Ikea krummelur is tested really good in the Netherlands on safety and a bargain at 40 euro."
"LO typically runs hot and doesn’t seem to sweat when sleeping on it. Also, no funky smells or off gassing from the mattress."
"We’ve been using an IKEA mattress from the get go and baby/toddler has always found it comfortable."
"Yeah, we've been perfectly happy with our $80 IKEA crib mattress."
"Our baby has been using it for about 9 months now and it has held up well and she seems to like it."
#7
Halo
4.2
(6)
"A comparable breathable mattress to Newton would be Halos version. I believe it’s half the price of a Newton. Our little one has been sleeping in theirs since he was two months old and we absolutely love it!"
"The Halo has the same tech and features as the Newton and it's cheaper."
"The halo dreamwave is a dupe for the Newton mattress."
"We have the Halo mattress, which is *slightly* cheaper than the Newton but not by much. Our baby loves it though."
"Halo"
"I went with the Halo Dreamweave after reading the comparison with Newton."
#8
Babyletto
4.0
(6)
"We got the Babyletto pure core mattress. It's not made of natural materials, but it doesn't contain flame retardants."
"We got the Babyletto one and like it."
"We have the Babyletto mini crib mattress and like it a lot."
"We've got the babyletto pure core and really like it."
"I got the babyletto pure core mattress with hybrid cover."
"It's 2-sided and seems comfortable and not noisy."
#9
Moonlight Slumber
4.3
(4)
"Moonlight slumber dual sided crib mattress."
"I went with the Moonlight Slumber - which is not natural fibers, but is Greenguard Gold certified."
"I got the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer mattress because it can be wiped clean."
"Baby is sleeping on it already and it seems nice."
#10
Amazon
4.0
(4)
"Absolute love it, and I want to get an adult mattress for husband and me next."
"I just got one off Amazon, I think it was like $30? Worked just fine, definitely recommend and mattress protector or two!"
"I got one off amazon for about $50 and used my 15% registry completion on it."
"I went the complete opposite direction and bought cheapo waterproof mattresses on Amazon."
#11
Lucie's List
5.0
(3)
"Lucie’s List has some great recommendations."
"Lucie’s List has some great recommendations."
"Lucie’s List is where I go for all gear recommendations."
#12
Newton Baby
4.7
(3)
"We love it!! We love that it's waterproof especially."
"I’d recommend the Newton Baby crib mattress. It’s made specially so that it’s super breathable, even if baby somehow ends up face down in it."
"I got a newton baby cfib mattress for a lot of reasons. It is green guard certified."
#13
Serta
4.0
(2)
"We have a $75 Serta one from Target. My son has been sleeping on it 2+ years."
"We went to target and got whatever Serta crib mattress they had."
#14
Simmons Beautyrest
4.0
(2)
"It’s very nice and I’m looking forward to having my baby use it once she arrives in May"
"I bought this one as its budget friendly, no VOCs, flame retardants etc."
#15
Simmons
4.0
(2)
"We got the Simmons tencel one from West Coast Kids."
"The simmons one came well recommended"
#16
Avocado
4.0
(2)
"Another vote for Avocado."
"We have all avocado mattresses in our house and like them."
#17
Milliard
3.5
(2)
"Super comfy, can be used as an infant and toddler mattress and has a waterproof cover."
"I heard good things about the milliard. 100 on Amazon."
#18
Mothercare
3.0
(2)
"I've lay on it myself and it's super comfy."
"I do not recommend the Mothercare one that is £90."
#19
Newton Mattress
5.0
(1)
"I love the Newton Mattress, and it fits very well!"
#20
Newton Baby Mini Crib Mattress
5.0
(1)
"For a non-toxic, breathable mini crib mattress, I highly recommend the Newton Baby Mini Crib Mattress"
#21
L.A. Baby
5.0
(1)
"I found the item linked below. You can push your face into it and still breathe like normal."
#22
Obasan
5.0
(1)
"Organic natural tree rubber."
#23
Little Green Sheep
5.0
(1)
"We went for this one. It's really nice."
#24
Ecobaby
5.0
(1)
"I highly recommend the Ecobaby Nova Crib mattress!"
#25
Nook
5.0
(1)
"We purchased a nook mini crib mattress. Expensive but imo very worth it!"
#26
Bundle of Dreams
5.0
(1)
"Bundle of dreams mini crib mattress! My LO has slept on it for 18 months and it’s still holding up great."
#27
Lullaby Earth
4.0
(1)
"It's not organic, but we decided to go with Lullaby Earth's Breeze Breathable 2- Stage crib mattress as it's GREENGUARD Gold certified and is chemical/ flame retardant free."
#28
Serta Crib Mattress
4.0
(1)
"I think there’s a Serta on Amazon for about that price"
#29
Newton Mini
4.0
(1)
"The Newton mini is good and fits babyletto well."
#30
Foam Crib Mattress
4.0
(1)
"Mine likes foam better than innerspring."
#31
Target
4.0
(1)
"I will say, my baby is a side and stomach sleeper. BUT we roomed in for the first 6.5 months then she moved to her room."
#32
Etsy Vendor
4.0
(1)
"We got the Stokke crib which is oval shaped, and this vendor had that size (although they also will do custom sizes)."
#33
Walmart
4.0
(1)
"$50 spring mattress from walmart never sagged. My daughter used it until she was 2.5."
#34
SleepEZ
4.0
(1)
"[This one](https://sleepez.com/products/crib-natural-latex-mattress/) is $300. It and of itself is not waterproof."
#35
Pottery Barn
4.0
(1)
"That has lasted us for two kids so far."
#36
My Green Mattress
4.0
(1)
"Switched to my green mattress emily mattress and baby loves it!"
#37
Dream On Me
4.0
(1)
"It’s going on 2 years of use, and will go into a toddler bed when he transitions."
#38
Kolcraft
4.0
(1)
"Over 2 years and still in excellent condition!"
#39
Safety 1st
4.0
(1)
"We went with Safety 1st mattress and have no complaints."
#40
Dream on Me
4.0
(1)
"We have the Dream on Me Holly one from Amazon. Less than $30."
#41
Davinci
4.0
(1)
"I ordered the Davinci complete slumber mini crib mattress from bed bath beyond."
#42
Wool
3.0
(1)
"I’ve seen ads for wool crib mattresses but I’m not sure if they pass the safety standards."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
