Deck Box reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 182 Reddit reviews across 13 subreddits and 29 posts to rank the best Deck Box brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/EDH, r/OnePieceTCG, r/pkmntcg, r/mtg, r/TCG. Top-rated brands include Gamegenic (4.6/5), Ultimate Guard (4.5/5), Ultra Pro (4.5/5).
Stats
Reviews182
Subreddits13
Posts29
Brands32
Products84
182 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Gamegenic
4.6
(63)
"I only use Gamegenic Sidekick 100+ XL. All my deck are double sleeved and I absolutely love that deckbox."
"I love love love my Gamegenic Bastions. I bought a bunch to colour code decks by their identity."
"100% recommend the bastion, they can fit an entire double sleeved deck plus a good sized stack of sleeved tokens."
"These are absolutely the best for double sleeved commander decks imo."
"Gamegenic bastion is a slam dunk for double sleeved commander decks, even leaves room for sleeved tokens."
"I love the Squire Plus from Gamegenic, they fit my double sleeves commander decks really well, even with the thick closable inner sleeves"
"Gamegenic Bastion XL. Will fit 100+ thick double sleeves cards and have room for tokens. It's made from hard acrylic and the colours are bomb."
"I use the gamegenic sidekick 100+xl"
"+1 for GameGenic XL deck boxes."
"The Gamegenic Sidekick Pro will house 4-5 snaps and an 80 card double-sleeved deck."
#2
Ultimate Guard
4.5
(42)
"Ultimate guard Sidewinders hands down. They are a little bit on the pricey end, but the quality is second to none."
"And then i got into ultimate guard boulders. and now, i really only want 'em."
"I like Ultimate Guard. I have several Boulder deck boxes."
"I have a couple of Sidewinder deck boxes."
"Been exclusively rocking boulders for years, now. Probably have a dozen or so."
"Ultimate Guard Return to Earth Boulders are my fave."
"Every one of my 8 decks are in a color coded sidewinder. Love those things."
"I like 100+ Boulders, theyve been my go to for years, but I've been really liking the new Quiver Nexus deck boxes."
"I currently have a UG side winder for my double sleeved deck, and UG Boulders for my single sleeved."
"UltimateGuard’s boulder. Barebones but extremely effective, cost, and space efficient. Great if you have many decks you like to travel around with."
#3
Ultra Pro
4.5
(21)
"I just use ultra pro boulders!! They are my go to!!"
"I like Boulders because I feel like I could chuck them through a car window and they would be fine."
"I enjoy how conveniently Boulders pack compared to other deck boxes."
"I've had some of my boulders for over 8 years. Good as new."
"Ultrapro satin tower by far."
"My current travel deckboxes are Ultra-Pro Marble Satin Cube. I bought the one and was satisfied so I bought a 2nd one in another color."
"Ultra Pro Satin Cubes are my personal favorites."
"I like Ultra Pro Satin Cubes."
"Look for the Ultra Pro Satin Tower. It's arguably the best deckbox for the price. It's only real knock is its kinda bulky, but with a double sleeved deck plus tokens and dice, it should be perfect."
"Ultra pro cubes are what I buy. Generally $15ish and couponable."
#4
Dragon Shield
4.3
(7)
"I like dragon shield boulders (100+) in a dragon shield arkhive, comes in 400, 800, 1000 variants."
"Yep I own three DS and two of em are 100ct double sleeved decks, with like 20 tokens and still some space leftover. Cheers."
"I like the Dragonshield deck boxes. They also have enough extra space for a bunch of tokens."
"I generally use the Dragonshield ones. They have space for the deck, tokens and even a playboard."
"I bought some cheap ones off amazon for $15 that do the job. I use dragonshield perfect fits for the inner and the outer is a custom art dragonshield sleeve."
"Dragon shield perfect fit"
"Double shells can hold double sleeved cards and tokens, not sure about the card holder."
#5
BCW
4.1
(7)
"I'm a huge fan of the Spectrum Prism boxes. They're durable, have a sturdy build to them and they sit horizontally which I really like."
"I really like the BCW Spectrum Prisms. They easily fit a double sleeved deck, you can get like 3 to 5 more cards/tokens in inner sleeves."
"They're cheap, sturdy , fit double-sleeved cards and I really like the horizontal orientation. Honestly, I prefer them to boulders."
"BCW Prism, compact and very hard to accidentally open."
"I prefer the BCW Spectrum Prism deck boxes over the boulders. They’re a couple bucks cheaper but for me they’re easier to open and they hold a few more tokens than Boulders."
"I like BCW spectrums. They're cheap and hold my double sleeved decks plus some tokens."
"My beat to shit 300 count bcw box. or any basic cardboard box."
#6
Stanley
4.0
(5)
"They are vastly superior to every single "real" deckbox out there. For the price of a somewhat secure deckbox for 1 deck, you get an incredibly secure, practically indestructible deckbox for 8 decks; plus 2 larger compartments."
"I use a small tool box the professor showcased years ago, never had any problems. You can get it at Home Depot for about $35."
"I've seen a lot of people using a Stanley Deep Pro Organizer for a deck box holder, seems like a good idea and the pricing is about the same as 1 "fancy" deck box."
"The Stanley box, though... the Stanley box gets the job done. Thing is, it's not a one-deck box, it's a twelve-deck carry case. It's cheaper than a lot of single-deck solutions but there are also going to be times you don't want the size and weight"
"I did find a Cube/Gamegenix (sp?) box but it was too big and the cards moved around inside too much. I am probably going to opt for one of those Stanley Steel "yellow construction suitcases" with the pointy cornered interiors."
#7
Quiver
4.5
(4)
"Quiver cases are fucking bomb!"
"I started using Quiver Nexus boxes a few months ago and I love them. They’re super solid, easy to open, and stackable!"
"I love quiver you can get like 5 for 25 they are super sturdy."
"I recommend the Quiver Bolt. It fits nicely in a backpack and is water resistant."
#8
DEX Protection
4.3
(3)
"DEX Protection Creation line small is by far my favorite deck box. Ample room for a double sleeve commander deck and a few dozen tokens. Strong magnets for closure, nice textured exterior, red velvet interior."
"DEX protection Creation line Medium is the way to go because it allows you to upgrade your outer sleeve to KMC character-guard mids in case you want to protect some nice graphic sleeves."
"DEX Protection has nice boxes. The safari line has faux snakeskin and alligator."
#9
3D Printed
5.0
(2)
"I just 3d print them for $1-2 worth of material. They are nicer than some that I see ppl buying for top dollar, have magnetic closures, and I can fully customize them."
"If you have access to a 3d printer, these! 120+ double sleeved and you can gasket it to make it water proof."
#10
Satin
5.0
(2)
"I love the satin cube/tower deck boxes. 100 double sleeved cards + a handful of tokens will fit in there so tight that it corrects curling."
"Satin tower for me. 100 double sleeved cards pack in there nice and tight, and it locks shut very securely."
#11
Dueling Guard
4.5
(2)
"I have 4 dueling guard boxes. I like them mostly because the magnets are strong."
"If you want to go fancy.. Dueling Guard XL deck boxes work perfectly."
#12
Jeixynik
4.0
(2)
"Recommend Amazon - Jeixynik MTG deck box"
"The lining can protect the deck very well. It has a split design."
#13
Amazon
4.0
(2)
"I find these random deck boxes on Amazon to be more functional than any of the "nicer" ones from Gamegenic or UltraPro. It has a separate compartment for tokens, and a second drawer-style compartment."
"Honestly Amazon has a bunch of no-name generic deck boxes that are really good. Nice material, good magnets, stretched edges."
#14
Temu
3.5
(2)
"Temu flip tops with display window for that sweet Art Series card you wanna rep your deck."
"Temu windowed boxes or they’re on Amazon too for like $15 like 8 on Temu"
#15
Arcane Fortress
5.0
(1)
"I really like these, they fit 100 double sleeved cards and have some extra room for tokens and an attached box for dice/tokens"
#16
Mage Tech
5.0
(1)
"Mage tech deck box fits my double sleeved deck comfortably. Love the style, and strength of the box itself. Would recommend."
#17
Venssu
5.0
(1)
"Venssu makes great deck boxes with a display (so I know which deck it contains, without having to open it). I also really like Vault X and UAONO."
#18
Reily TCG
5.0
(1)
"I have one from reily tcg, the quality is great imo and i really like it."
#19
Ultrapro
4.0
(1)
"I like both the ultrapto satin cubes and the gamegenic bastion XL."
#20
Aaron Cain
4.0
(1)
"Aaron Cain can make something custom sized if you know the thickness of everything. Tolarian Community college deck box can fit that and more."
#21
Channel Fireball
4.0
(1)
"The Channel Fireball branded deck boxes they handed out like candy at GP and other big events back before 2019."
#22
Gem Accessories
4.0
(1)
"My personal favorite are the Gem Accessories ones. Great quality. But on the pricier side."
#23
Uaono
4.0
(1)
"Uaono makes good shit at a decent price imo."
#24
Harbor Freight
4.0
(1)
"Harbor Freight made a good one, too, same size. After using two for storage for a board game called Gloomhaven, I knew it would be perfect for Magic."
#25
Xvault
4.0
(1)
"Xvault has a great product for the price."
#26
Card Guard
4.0
(1)
"I tend to just buy the generic plastic Card Guard boxes from like Walmart. They’re super cheap AND they can actually fit a double sleeved deck comfortably."
#27
Stanley Pro Series Deep 10 Compartment Organiser
4.0
(1)
"This is good if you can get it for $25"
#28
Pokemon Center
4.0
(1)
"Japanese boxes from Pokemon Center can perfect fit a 65ds deck + divider."
#29
Manamoon
4.0
(1)
"Manamoon boxes are nice too but theres usually a long wait time due to how production works."
#30
Gemtech
4.0
(1)
"Gemtech boxes are also nice if you arent looking for OP specific designs, but again, wait times."
#31
Armored Corgi
4.0
(1)
"Armored Corgi has nice magnetic claps deck boxes and are decently priced."
#32
Gamegenic and Ultra Pro
3.0
(1)
"Gamegenic and Ultrapro Tower."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
