Diaper Brand reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 372 Reddit reviews across 24 subreddits and 34 posts to rank the best Diaper Brand brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/beyondthebump, r/BabyBumps, r/NewParents, r/ZeroWaste, r/Parenting. Top-rated brands include Huggies (4.0/5), Pampers (3.6/5), Kirkland (4.3/5).
Stats
Reviews372
Subreddits24
Posts34
Brands79
Products32
372 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Huggies
4.0
(61)
"Tried Huggies, pampers and Millie moon. Huggies are without a doubt the best."
"I only used Huggies special delivery. Soft, absorbent, and didn’t irritate her sensitive skin."
"We love Huggies! We tried Pampers first because that’s what the hospital had. My baby had such tiny legs that pee would go out the leg holes. Huggies leg holes just fit her better."
"She’s exclusively Huggies now."
"Huggies all the way"
"We a Huggies family. They fit my little chunk so well!"
"Huggies plus from Costco!"
"Huggies just fit her the best."
"Huggies Plus from Costco are my first choice"
"Them and Lil Snugglers are what I use."
#2
Pampers
3.6
(50)
"There were never any issues with leaks or blowouts either. We used them from birth up to about 18ish months."
"Pampers and oddly enough, target brand diapers are the best ones in my opinion."
"Tried Pampers swaddlers and Huggies on the twins. Pampers fit them both much better and we never looked back."
"Pampers swaddlers has been my favorite so far for my squirmy newborn."
"Pampers swaddlers worked the best for him"
"Pampers FTW!"
"I love Target up&up and Pampers swaddlers."
"Pampers premium protection!! Beats all others."
"If you get the premium protection, works great."
"Pampers premium is the best imo. It’s definitely pricey but it’s much safer. My baby was most comfortable in those diapers."
#3
Kirkland
4.3
(36)
"For us, hands down, it was Kirkland. Same with the wet wipes."
"We loved Kirkland diapers, we're our favorites until we outgrew!"
"Kirkland diapers! Great price, rarely has blowouts in them"
"Kirkland for sure"
"I prefer Kirkland from Costco over the Huggies though because they are the exact same fit but cuter patterns lol"
"Kirkland from Costco!"
"I just love the Costco Kirkland brand so much"
"We’ve stuck with Kirkland brand. 19 months and counting."
"Best bang for our buck has been Kirkland!"
"We also love the costco Kirkland diapers. Great coverage and great value."
#4
Millie Moon
3.9
(32)
"A friend mentioned Millie Moon and they are so amazing. Incredibly soft, no more road burn."
"Millie moon. if I was a baby, I would want to be in millie moon! they are so soft"
"Millie Moon diapers. She is 8 months old now, and that has worked for us so far!!!"
"We LOVE Millie Moon"
"Millie moon!"
"Millie Moon!"
"Millie moon diapers are so soft and are great in holding in everything as long as you have the right size."
"Millie Moon because they are so much softer and more protective of baby’s skin."
"Switched from pampers to Millie moon for our little guy and have absolutely loved them. Sizing & shape are very similar but way better material and absorption"
"I’m having great luck with Millie Moon. No fuzzies, I have had only 1 blowout and zero urine leaks."
#5
Coterie
4.0
(28)
"Coterie 1000%"
"Love Coterie! Kudos gave my daughter a really weird lower back rash that only went away after we swapped to Coterie."
"They’re expensive, but hold a lot, no rashes, no blow outs. Worth it"
"Coterie, if price isn’t a factor."
"I love Coterie. Definitely not a necessity, and the price is nuts, but I won’t lie they’re fantastic for us."
"Coterie, hands down."
"High End - Coterie"
"Coterie!! The absolute softest"
"Coterie wipes and diapers are our favorite."
"I use Coterie and love them."
#6
Honest
3.5
(15)
"We tried 4 other brands before honest and had constant leaks and blowouts. Switched to honest and haven’t had an issue since."
"We’ve been really happy with Honest. My daughter has super sensitive skin. She now wears them only for bedtime, but they hold in everything."
"We love honest. They fit so good. And he hasn’t had a rash since we switched from pampers."
"My girls fit Honest diapers the best and have the fewest blowouts."
"Honest & pampers pure are also fine."
"I love honest because they fit his body shape so nicely."
"Diapers were using the honest company, if those don’t work out we’re gonna use pampers"
"I love honest brand diapers."
"Diaper-wise, we bought Honest diapers exclusively. Never had a problem with other diaper brands and would use them if someone gifted them to us."
"Honest diapers are the brand we use."
#7
Luvs
3.1
(12)
"I love Luvs. It isn’t the most expensive brand, it held in their pee all the time."
"Luvs is my favorite too. I feel like it fit our kiddo the best and prevented blowouts best"
"Luvs Ultra Leakguards - Great value, leak protection, and soft."
"We’re in Luvs now and they do the job, only a couple blowouts due to user error on my husbands end lol"
"I personally like Luvs. My baby is always dry."
"Luvs are probably my favorite on brand kind."
"My nephew had an allergic reaction to Huggies, would soak through pampers and the only thing they could get to work was luvs."
"Luvs."
"I do not like Luvs, Parent's Choice, or Huggies."
"Luvs straight to jail."
#8
Rascal and Friends
4.4
(8)
"They're the cheapest and the best."
"Really like rascal and friends, been the best for my baby. Absorbent, good fit, no weird chemical smell like huggies."
"I love rascal and friends! Seem to be less toxic, they work well, and they’re affordable at Walmart!"
"We love rascal and friends! LO had sensitive skin as a newborn, so we switched to this which is hypoallergenic."
"If you prefer walmart try Rascal and Friends! They are super deep/scoopy."
"Rascal and friends works best for us."
"Rascal and friends!"
"Rascal and friends"
#9
Hello Bello
3.6
(9)
"Hello Bello! The subscription is super convenient."
"My favourite by far is Hellobello."
"Hello Bello - Eco-friendly, hypoallergenic."
"We got a hello Bello subscription from my in-laws and love it. The diapers fit well"
"We use Hello Bello and Kirkland and really like them both."
"We love hello bello. They’re not insanely overpriced, and they run a little big it seems, so great for night time especially."
"We use Hello Bello or Rascal and Friends."
"Last place is Hello Bello."
"My god those were the worst."
#10
Up & Up
3.8
(6)
"I love Target up&up and Pampers swaddlers."
"With my son I loved the up&up target brand. As a single parent the sales and quality for the price were amazing."
"Along with the Up & Up diapers from target."
"I prefer them over Pampers."
"We’re an Up and Ip family"
"Didn’t like the up & up brand."
#11
Dyper
3.8
(6)
"Dyper. They are fully compostable and offer a 2x/month pick-up service to take the compostable diapers to a composting facility."
"Dyper- bamboo, sustainable, size inclusive."
"I used Dyper with my first and also used the ReDyper service. I got a free trial and ended up liking it."
"Love the Dyper brand but only the original not the black charcoal ones"
"No chemical smell, no fiber shedding, and decently priced."
"The only one I absolutely hated was Dyper. They smelled SO BAD and weren't soft (like they felt... Recycled papery??)."
#12
Parent's Choice
4.2
(5)
"Parent’s choice have been a game changer for our little guy."
"Parents choice. They’re cheap, absorbent, don’t leak, & don’t have that weird smell."
"Parents choice has definitely become our top runner up based on price, fit, baby’s comfort, and the lack of blow outs."
"We use parent’s choice (walmart) and it works fine, I did notice the fuzz problem on expensive brands, and they irritated my kids, so the cheap stuff it is! I also notice this brand holds leaks and blow outs better too"
"Parent’s Choice - Budget-friendly, solid leak protection."
#13
Healthy Baby
4.8
(4)
"I love healthy baby diapers!"
"I use Healthy Baby. They are the cleanest diapers on the market. EWG verified to have no toxins or harsh chemicals."
"Healthybaby, amazing and the only EWG certified, but expensive"
"Yes they very absorbent are for me! They are thin but very absorbent. We use them at night, no leaks."
#14
Kudos
4.3
(4)
"We love Kudos, great fit for our baby and environmentally friendly."
"Kudos, the only diapers where baby’s bum touches 100% cotton."
"Switched not too long ago from kudos but love em so far"
"Kudos"
#15
Pampers Pure
3.8
(4)
"Love love love pampers pure."
"Pampers Pure has been our favorite."
"We love Pampers Pure, they work so well for us."
"Even Pampers Pure has a weird scent."
#16
BumGenius
5.0
(3)
"I used GroVia and Bum Genius- supplementing with Green Mountain Diaper inserts for overnight/as they got bigger and had higher needs. Loved all of those brands."
"We used cloth diapers 10+ years ago and have zero regrets. We primarily used BumGenius."
"I just bought what they had at BuyBuyBaby . . . Charlie Banana and Bumgenius."
#17
Rascals
5.0
(3)
"Rascals brand at Walmart. So soft and the best price. I won't use anything else."
"Rascals for sure. More soft and comfy, more absorbant, no scents/lotions and cheaper than the other brands."
"Rascals are my favorite name brand diaper. They’re soft and super duper absorbent"
#18
Green Mountain Diapers
5.0
(3)
"Because we don't have a dryer, the inners are flats from Green Mountain Diapers."
"All my diaper inners are GMD."
"GMD has nice flats and is overall a company I would trust."
#19
Parasol
4.3
(3)
"I ended up trying Parasol and we love them."
"Parasol"
"Parasol! Runner up Millie moon"
#20
AlvaBaby
4.0
(3)
"I recently bought some AlvaBaby diapers from Amazon. My daughter is about 20lbs and the all in one size is great for her and they work as well as a disposable."
"We chose the AlvaBaby newborns and then the MamaKoalas for use from 8lbs and up."
"I've used Alvababy."
#21
HEB
5.0
(2)
"If you happen to live in Texas near an HEB, the HEB overnight diapers are the BEST."
"I tried all kinds of diapers and he’d wake every morning leaked. Until I found these. They work the best."
#22
Kirkland Diapers
5.0
(2)
"We have used Kirkland on our last two kids and will for this one too."
"Kirkland (Costco) they are made in the same factory as Huggies. Very soft, cost effective."
#23
Smart Bottoms
5.0
(2)
"I only use smart bottoms all-in-ones."
"I liked smart bottoms."
#24
Cloth Diapers
4.5
(2)
"Cloth WORKS so much better. I would “handle” way more poop with disposable blowouts ... than just throwing cloth diapers directly in the wash"
"You can save a lot of $ and landfill by using cloth diapers."
#25
Lalabye Baby
4.5
(2)
"We've loved Lalabye Baby cloth diapers with my first two kids and plan to use them again for baby #3."
"I use lalabye baby for my newborn and really like them!"
#26
AdultClothDiaper.com
4.5
(2)
"Adultclothdiaper.com is where I got all mine from. Great diapers that really last."
"I usually wear the covers from Rearz and adultclothdiaper.com."
#27
NorthShore
4.5
(2)
"Northshore (northshorecare.com) is far superior to anything you’ll find in stores."
"Northshore supreme or seni active overnight both can hold a full bladder void at least for me."
#28
Kiddos by MedPlus
4.0
(2)
"Kiddos by MedPlus is what we have been using. It's pretty good."
"We tried many brands and settled at "kiddos by medplus". It's reasonable comparatively and available at medplus stores."
#29
Charlie Banana
4.0
(2)
"I've used Charlie Banana."
"I just bought what they had at BuyBuyBaby . . . Charlie Banana and Bumgenius."
#30
Mama Bear
4.0
(2)
"Amazon Mama Bear once they are solid."
"Mama Bear on Amazon is my favorite for wipes. The diapers are pretty reasonable priced and worked well too."
#31
Aldi
4.0
(2)
"Aldi diaps are pretty solid."
"The ones they sell at Aldi!"
#32
Babykins
4.0
(2)
"I like and use ones from Rearz, adult baby pants ( baby-pants.com) yes despite the name are adult items, babykins,omutsu for overnight."
"I like both Leakmaster and Babykins."
#33
Thirsties
4.0
(2)
"Thirsties One Size Pocket Diapers worked great in my opinion."
"Thirsties."
#34
Bambo
3.5
(2)
"I think I like the Bamboo better so far. Both are unscented."
"I switch between bambo brand and coterie."
#35
Always Discreet
3.5
(2)
"Always Discreet Boutique."
"I bought always discreet and used them a couple of times but they irritated my c section scar."
#36
Member's Mark
3.0
(2)
"We've liked the Member's Mark diapers from Sam's Club."
"Members Mark (Sam's club) had the most leakage."
#37
Pull-Ups
3.0
(2)
"If you want the absorbency of a diaper, then agreed that Pull Ups are what you should try."
"Pull ups. They’re only 2.5 they’re probably just not ready yet."
#38
Amazon
3.0
(2)
"I use the Amazon brand overnights sometimes when they run out of the Tena's that I use. I usually have to change myself in the middle of the night but they're decent for cheap ones."
"I use the Amazon Brand."
#39
FuzziBunz
5.0
(1)
"I loved fuzzi bunz pocket diapers. They were so easy."
#40
Pampers, Huggies
5.0
(1)
"Pampers and huggies are the best, with Pampers swaddlers being our #1 diaper of choice."
#41
Molicare
5.0
(1)
"They are the most absorbent normal pull up and hold up quite well, even with heavy leaking."
#42
Diaper Dabbler
5.0
(1)
"There is something called Diaper Dabbler where you can order a sampler pack with a few diapers each from a bunch of different brands, so you can try them all out and see what works best for you."
#43
Lil Helper
5.0
(1)
"I’ve loved the products I purchased, and their cloth diapering system is intriguing!"
#44
GroVia
5.0
(1)
"I used GroVia and Bum Genius- supplementing with Green Mountain Diaper inserts for overnight/as they got bigger and had higher needs. Loved all of those brands."
#45
Simplehuman
5.0
(1)
"Simple Humans are my favorite because they have double gussets on the leg part and the snaps are nicely spaced."
#46
Little Rascals
5.0
(1)
"Little rascals for a fancy splurg or if u can afford- Kirkland as a main reliable."
#47
Pura
5.0
(1)
"Pura diapers have worked even better for us than coterie! They are at Walmart and on Amazon, we LOVE them."
#48
Walgreens
5.0
(1)
"The Walgreens brand has been amazing, surprisingly! My mom peed 3 times one night and it didn’t leak at all."
#49
Teva
5.0
(1)
"The brand teva is excellent."
#50
Top Paw
5.0
(1)
"I like the velcro so they’re more adjustable."
#51
Depends
5.0
(1)
"I got Depends Silhouette and they were great!"
#52
Knix
5.0
(1)
"Knix leakproof dream shorts. Buy 4 or 5 pairs and then just wash them after use."
#53
Frida
5.0
(1)
"I used Frida disposable underwear with always overnight super pads."
#54
Pet Parents
5.0
(1)
"I've used the Pet Parents brand, bought on Amazon."
#55
Huggies Special Delivery
5.0
(1)
"We use Huggies Special Delivery! Pampers and other Huggies gave her rashes."
#56
Abena
4.0
(1)
"The slip M4 I use is $1.5 Canadian per diaper from Amazon...decent diaper for the price."
#57
Huggies, Pampers
4.0
(1)
"Pampers never quite fit right. Ended up going with Huggies little snugglers for most of the years."
#58
Applecrumby, Huggies, Drypers, Hoppy
4.0
(1)
"My son is 3 now, hes wearing huggies airsoft. Before huggies tried so many others like drypers, hoppy."
#59
BJs brand, Berkeley & Jensen
4.0
(1)
"We use BJs brand, Berkeley & Jensen, diapers and wipes, have used them for several kiddos and they work great for us."
#60
Hoppi, Mamypoko, Huggies, Apple Crumby
4.0
(1)
"I have a 7.5 months baby and I've tried several brands: Hoppi, Mamypoko, Huggies, Apple Crumby."
#61
Millie Moon, Honest
4.0
(1)
"My baby’s skin is super sensitive and we only use the Millie moon brand from target! We also really liked the newborn honests ones but the bigger sizes do not hold blow outs!"
#62
Seni
4.0
(1)
"Seni has as good if not better products. The Quatro seems to have more capacity than the Abena M4 and the Seni pull-ups seem to have more capacity than the Abena M3, both at a lower cost."
#63
Diaper Stork
4.0
(1)
"I am not who you asked, but we are using diaper stork."
#64
Binge Outs
4.0
(1)
"Binge outs are the ones we started with and were very happy."
#65
Blueberry
4.0
(1)
"I liked blueberry a lot."
#66
Mama Koala
4.0
(1)
"I've used Mama Koala."
#67
Mamamia
4.0
(1)
"We're finding that the Aldi "Mamamia" brand are pretty damn good."
#68
Merries
4.0
(1)
"Korean brands : Merries, Moony."
#69
Moony
4.0
(1)
"Korean brands : Merries, Moony."
#70
Sam's Club
4.0
(1)
"My baby likes the Sam's club brand diapers."
#71
Better than Kirkland
4.0
(1)
"Way better than Kirkland !"
#72
Dry Direct
4.0
(1)
"Dry Direct from Amazon work pretty well for the budget friendly option."
#73
Tena
4.0
(1)
"Tena is probably your best bet."
#74
Huggies Diapers
4.0
(1)
"Huggies or Pampers"
#75
Pampers Diapers
4.0
(1)
"Huggies or Pampers"
#76
Huggies, Honest
3.0
(1)
"We started with Huggies. Loved them. Tried Honest bc I got them as gift and they didn’t not work at all for us."
#77
Mama Bear, Honest
3.0
(1)
"We used Mama Bear Amazon brand and then Honest at size 4."
#78
Ecoriginals
3.0
(1)
"Ecoriginals."
#79
Always
3.0
(1)
"I tried the always ones. They aren't the best if you are in the taller side."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
