Dress Shirts reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 347 Reddit reviews across 25 subreddits and 41 posts to rank the best Dress Shirts brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/malefashionadvice, r/mensfashion, r/FinancialCareers, r/Austin, r/medicalschool. Top-rated brands include Charles Tyrwhitt (4.4/5), Brooks Brothers (4.0/5), Eton (4.7/5).
Stats
Reviews347
Subreddits25
Posts41
Brands89
Products31
347 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Charles Tyrwhitt
4.4
(64)
"I love CT. I bought a few of their shirts when I first graduated law school in 2014 and they are all still holding up."
"Charles Tyrwhitt in a heart beat"
"I love the CT custom program. By the way, they recently enhanced it and now you can customize to quarter of an inch."
"Charles Tyrwhitt has been my go-to for dress shirts for 20 years."
"I have 1 CT and Eton shirt that I wear weekly because they feel so good, and fit so well!"
"Go for shirts with spread or cutaway collars, they give more space around the neck and balance out the proportions."
"CT dress shirts can be had for$33 regularly as part of the 3 for$99 deal. That is definitely the best value."
"I have a Royal Oxford Non Iron dress shirt from Charles Tyrwhitt and a couple of more casual linen dress shirts and I love them."
"Charles Tyrwhitt is a great option and you can use their custom shirt option if you're willing to spend a little bit more money"
"Another vote/post for Charles Tyrwhitt. I’ve never found a better dress shirt (wrinkle-free or not) with the quality at a $33/shirt (in the US) price."
#2
Brooks Brothers
4.0
(27)
"Brands like Brooks Brothers or Charles Tyrwhitt offer options with larger neck sizes that still look sharp."
"Brooks brothers makes wrinkle resistant shirts"
"Brooks brothers and charles tyrwhitt"
"Brooks Brothers Regent fit shirts. I have a similar build and they fit great."
"I’ve used brands like Brooks Brothers and Charles Tyrwhitt in the past, which have good quality shirts within that price range."
"Another vote for Brooks Brothers too."
"Try Brooks Brothers or Charles Tyrwhitt. Both have great options in that price range and are known for quality."
"I have a supima cooling fabric dress shirt that's my go to due to its comfort from BB"
"Brooks Brothers"
"I am really a fan of Brooks Brothers shirts."
#3
Eton
4.7
(20)
"I've got a closet FULL of Eton shirts (and ties) she's given me over the years."
"Eton."
"I have 1 CT and Eton shirt that I wear weekly because they feel so good, and fit so well!"
"I’ll second the Eton recommendation."
"Charles Tyrwhitt and Eton are solid picks in that range. Good quality, clean fit."
"I can vouch for Eton. Been wearing them for years, only replacing them when the arm pits get too yellow or discolored."
"I’ll also vote for Eton. Not just the best crinkle free but up there as some of the best RTW shirts available."
"Eton's 'Wrinkle Free' are the best I've come across"
"Eton uses a wrinkle treatment without the use of heavy chemicals like formaldehyde. Their treatment is unique to the brand and is way more natural."
"Best? Eton. Best value? CT."
#4
Proper Cloth
4.8
(17)
"Proper Cloth has a ton of options and the measurements are incredibly spe"
"Proper Cloth is the only answer."
"Love Proper Cloth"
"Proper Cloth. A good fit is important for dress shirts."
"Proper Cloth"
"At a certain point it just makes more sense to order MTM from somewhere like Proper Cloth."
"Get fitted at Proper Cloth. You'll thank yourself."
"MTM. Proper Cloth is fantastic!"
"Look into going custom with a company like Proper Cloth."
"The fabrics are great."
#5
Banana Republic
4.0
(12)
"They barely ever require ironing."
"I third banana republic"
"I've also bought from Banana Republic."
"I second Banana Republic."
"Banana Republic. Ralph Lauren. Brooks brothers."
"Banana Republic has a great non tuck slim fit Oxford. Only complain is chest being a bit boxy but quality and length is great."
"Banana Republic has best bang for your buck I think."
"Honestly - just buy white or light blue Banana Republic (or equivalent) non-iron shirts."
"Athletic / slim fit"
"The closest thing that would potentially fit is banana republic or Uniqlo."
#6
Uniqlo
4.4
(11)
"Uniqlo"
"Uniqlo Airism shirt sleeve button up"
"Their dress shirts are iron free and have a flex in them which is awesome."
"Absolutely your best bet at this price range."
"Just bought some from uniqlo and the bay on sale."
"I feel like I’m recommending Uniqlo almost every time someone asks for clothing reccs here."
"I do Uniqlo. There are often XS-sized shirts but S is not bad."
"Ive had luck with uniqlo!"
"Uniqlo lmao."
"Uniqlo perfectly fit the description of what you're after."
#7
State & Liberty
4.6
(9)
"State & Liberty is the best in my opinion"
"They are designed and made for athletic build."
"I love my state and liberty dress shirts, they're stretchy (but arent overly tight) and don't wrinkle easily."
"Super comfy. Like Lululemon meets menswear"
"Amazing shirts. Pretty much the only place I shop now"
"I also have one State & Liberty shirt that is incredibly soft and fits well but, in white, it’s too thin."
"I've also bought from State and Liberty."
"Their core product is high-quality stretch/athletic dress shirts."
"State & liberty."
#8
Bonobos
4.4
(9)
"I liked wearing my Bonobos shirts."
"Would recommend bonobos ones, super comfortable and you’ll get away with professionalism."
"Check out Bonobos, custom tailored for you, they have great suits too."
"Their tailored line fits me… well, like I had it tailored!"
"Bonobos offers lots of options."
"I wear bonobos for work. They last a long time."
"For less fancy but still put together Bonobos and League of Rebels."
"Bonobos or howler bros if your office is a little more laid back."
#9
Spier & Mackay
4.1
(7)
"Spier and Mackay’s MTO program. Starts at $78, gives you your choice of collar / placket / cuff with no extra cost."
"Spier and Charles Tyrwhitt Great shirts"
"If you have time go for custom shirts. Studio suits and Spier and Mckay are great."
"Spier & Mackay"
"I have the white poplin from Spier & Mackay. Wore it at a wedding recently with no undershirt and it worked well."
"Spier is better than CT, J Crew, and Brooks."
"The best bet is likely Spier & Mackay. They have great fabrics for the price and their cuts are slim so should be what you like."
#10
Mizzen+Main
4.7
(6)
"I love my mizzen and main. I can leave their shirts in my trunk in a pile and put them on with no wrinkles."
"Makes great performance dress shirts."
"MIZZEN AND MAIN!"
"Mine have already been through ~100 washes, still look good."
"I've also bought from Mizzen and Main."
"Mizzen & Main makes a pretty decent shirt that’s supposed to be untucked."
#11
Indochino
4.5
(6)
"My solution was going made to measure. Indochino, specifically."
"Indochino has provided me with the only shirts that really fit me."
"If there is an Indochino near you, you can get custom fitted dress shirts."
"Custom is great. I like my shirts from Indochino but dunno about the quality compared to high end brands"
"Indochino at the domain."
#12
Kamakura
4.3
(6)
"Can’t speak highly enough of Kamakura in terms of craftsmanship, fabric, and variety of fits especially for shorter and/or slimmer guys."
"The best I’ve found is the Kamakura easy care line. They’re outstanding shirts"
"At that price point - Kamakura. I’m seeing some mall brands in here that I think Kamakura would crush from a value and build quality."
"Kamakura is a good place to start but beyond that getting it made will probably be better value."
"I highly recommend Kamakura, a Japanese brand that does very specific fitting and won't blow your bank."
"High quality for the price."
#13
Nordstrom
4.2
(6)
"Honestly Nordstrom and the bay have personal shoppers."
"You could probably get them to tailor one of their shirts to the exact sleeve length"
"You can get that size in this and other Nordstrom shirts"
"Their own brand are really the best dress shirts out there but the fabrics arent typically stiff"
"Nordstrom rack, their Nordstrom brand stuff is pretty inexpensive and looks decent."
"Try Nordstrom. They have good tailors too"
#14
Nordstrom Rack
4.8
(5)
"Nordstrom rack"
"Nordstrom rack"
"Nordstrom Rack!"
"Nordstrom rack baby"
"Nordstrom Rack."
#15
T.M. Lewin
4.2
(5)
"TM Lewin are superb"
"TM Lewin"
"Search "TM Lewin" shirts in Google and you'll get the ad for 3 for 99 from CM."
"I can second the T.M. Lewin ones, they have been my go to for a few years now and have not had any quality drop off after a number of washes."
"I also own quite a few from T.M. Lewin called 'Non Iron' that are generally almost wrinkle free"
#16
Lululemon
4.0
(5)
"My work is super casual business casual and I wear the Lululemon new venture shirt untucked there"
"Lululemon and Banana Republic."
"I bought dress shirt and pants super stretchy and you can’t tell."
"I would either go with a second shirt or Lululemon."
"They have stretch capability and have odour managing materials."
#17
Untuckit
4.0
(5)
"Untuckit is a good one"
"Untuck it is a good one"
"I’m a huge fan of the brand Untuckit. Tons of color and patterns to choose from. Great sizing from a slim fit, to reg, and certainly many materials are wrinkle free"
"Untuckit may be a solution."
"Untuckit @ domain."
#18
Turnbull & Asser
4.5
(4)
"I decided to check out a common suggestion among the comments in this thread, that being Turnbull & Asser."
"Are all really good."
"Is both durable and about the most comfortable shirt I have ever worn."
"Best brand? Turnbull & Asser, but they’re like three times your budget."
#19
Spier and Mackay
4.3
(4)
"Spier & Mackay"
"Spier and Mackay Contemporary cut is designed for muscular, athletic builds."
"Spier and Mackay has good value dress shirts in a variety of sizes."
"Is good quality for the price."
#20
Twillory
4.0
(4)
"My favorites and best fits in my closet are Tailored Athlete (by far), then Twillory."
"Big fan of twillory shirts"
"Twillory is awesome and offer several fit options."
"4 for $260."
#21
Ledbury
3.8
(4)
"Ledbury"
"Budget? Ledbury."
"Ledbury is also good. Especially if you work in a no tie place."
"Ledbury used to be luxurious and fashionable."
#22
Ralph Lauren
3.8
(4)
"+ Massimo Dutti Ralph Lauren featherweight mesh shirt"
"Banana Republic. Ralph Lauren. Brooks brothers."
"Ralph Lauren & Madewell."
"Brooks Brothers, RL - for the first, you can find decent prices at outlet malls"
#23
Ministry of Supply
5.0
(3)
"Ministry of Supply makes great dress shirts"
"Ministry of Supply makes some super nice stuff, I don’t personally wear any of their stuff because I dress like a bum, but my wife loves them!"
"Ministry of Supply makes some super nice stuff."
#24
Calvin Klein
3.5
(4)
"Calvin Klein dress shirt was usually $80 but I got it for either $24 or $34. Great quality and there’s an okay selection too."
"Calvin Klein at the Round Rock outlets."
"Not the best, but the best quality for your buck."
"Mens warehouse I got 5 dress shirts for $110 4 Calvin Klein, down side is they are thin and after awhile can rip on elbows"
#25
Long Tall Sally
4.7
(3)
"I've gotten really nice ones from Long Tall Sally."
"I buy all of my semi formal and formal gear from Long Tall Sally."
"Specializes in clothing for tall women."
#26
Tapered Menswear
4.3
(3)
"Try Tapered Menswear, theres is the best fit Ive tried off the rack"
"I buy mine from Tapered Menswear."
"Have you tried the brand Tapered Menswear? Their cuts are exactly what you're looking for."
#27
Costco
4.0
(3)
"Costco lol"
"Costco"
"Costco."
#28
RW&Co
4.0
(3)
"RW and Co also had great shirts that often go on sale."
"RW&Co and Banana Republic always worked well for me."
"Has an athletic fit that really works for my partner"
#29
Suitsupply
4.0
(3)
"Suit Supply"
"Suitsupply."
"Get some shirts darted or whatever customizations you need."
#30
Stafford
4.0
(3)
"I’m a huge fan of the Stafford branded travel dress shirts."
"My husband absolutely loves the stafford brand from jcpenney."
"Stafford from JCPennys. And they're almost always on sale."
#31
DXL
3.7
(3)
"Go to a DXL if there’s one near you and try some shirts on, find a brand you like."
"DXL might. I’m 6’3 245 with 37.5” and 18 neck. They have them there for me."
"DXL. Big and Tall store. I rather tall and large."
#32
Mizzen and Main
5.0
(2)
"Mizzen and Main are the best dress shorts I’ve found that still give the same look as a nice dress shirt."
"Mizzen and Main."
#33
Stantt
5.0
(2)
"Easiest way to get a custom fit shirt at a reasonable price - starting at $100."
"Easiest way to get a custom fit shirt at a reasonable price - starting at $100."
#34
Rhône
5.0
(2)
"Is better than lululemon venture for dress shirts."
"Incredibly comfortable and breathable in the heat."
#35
Brioni
5.0
(2)
"For best fabric quality."
"Brioni or Kiton for direct promotion to VP after year 1"
#36
Kiton
5.0
(2)
"Kiton, especially its royal oxford cloth."
"Brioni or Kiton for direct promotion to VP after year 1"
#37
Lands' End
4.5
(2)
"Lands' End has a great "No Iron Supima" dress shirt. I bought like 6 of them over 5 years ago and they still look brand new."
"I’ve had really good luck lately with Lands End."
#38
OTAA
4.5
(2)
"But lately, I’ve been wearing OTAA, and I’ve been really happy with their fit and fabric quality."
"Check out OTAA’s easy-care shirts.... solid choice for wrinkle-free and comfy fits."
#39
Rhone
4.5
(2)
"I could see myself buying their whole line."
"Rhone."
#40
David Donahue
4.5
(2)
"Best shirts I’ve ever bought."
"David Donahue"
#41
J.Crew
4.0
(2)
"JCrew"
"J Crew offers untucked versions of some of their dress shirts"
#42
Hugo Boss
4.0
(2)
"I have some from both of Hugo Boss brands and so far they are fantastic"
"Hugo Boss"
#43
Tommy Hilfiger
4.0
(2)
"I've had good luck with Tommy Hilfiger shirts, they fit me well and have held up well."
"That have held up really well."
#44
Massimo Dutti
4.0
(2)
"+ Massimo Dutti Ralph Lauren featherweight mesh shirt"
"They fit well, IMO look nicer than CT and are better quality."
#45
Amazon
4.0
(2)
"Amazon"
"Amazon. Return policy is awesome, find the right fit and buy a couple."
#46
J.Crew Factory
4.0
(2)
"I second J.Crew Factory as a value pick."
"I’ve had the best luck with J.Crew’s, and I’ve found even their Factory options to be surprisingly good if you find the right sale."
#47
Men's Wearhouse
4.0
(2)
"Mens Wearhouse when they do their annual sales."
"Men's Wear House looks like they have clearance shirts for $15 online."
#48
Kojo Fit
4.0
(2)
"I have some Kojo fit shirts that are pretty stretchy."
"I have a few from Kojo fit. I like them."
#49
Tip Top
4.0
(2)
"Tip Top. Sign up for their loyalty program, they always have great deals."
"A store like Tip Top with a good salesman and tailor could sell you a shirt that fits the top and alter it to get a good fit."
#50
Untucked
3.5
(2)
"If he doesn’t have to tuck for dress code, 'untucked' is a good brand."
"Untucked shirts would be mostly casual, sold in places like Macy’s, or online."
#51
Club Ride
3.0
(2)
"Have you looked into club ride apparel?"
"Have you looked into club ride apparel?"
#52
State and Liberty
2.5
(2)
"State and Liberty is great."
"Very very disappointed with the shirts I bought from State and Liberty."
#53
Mercer and Sons
5.0
(1)
"Mercer and Sons are very, very generously cut and they're nearly bulletproof."
#54
Wills
5.0
(1)
"I’ve been super happy with Wills wrinkle free linen shirts"
#55
Anton Alexander
5.0
(1)
"Fully custom dress shirts made in the USA and shipped in just 1 day. No extra charge for custom fit or design either."
#56
Wool&
5.0
(1)
"Wool& has some. I did their challenge a few years ago."
#57
ENRO
5.0
(1)
"ENRO. Case closed."
#58
OneBone
5.0
(1)
"OneBone’s Smart Dress shirt has fake buttons going down starting around mid chest."
#59
Local Tailor
5.0
(1)
"If you have the budget for it, I would try (at least one) MTM shirt from a local tailor."
#60
Tailored Athlete
5.0
(1)
"My favorites and best fits in my closet are Tailored Athlete (by far), then Twillory."
#61
TruWear
5.0
(1)
"I just tried Truwear shirts, they are high quality!"
#62
Local Suit Shop
5.0
(1)
"I got one fitted for me one time and it was amazing how good it felt."
#63
Maxwell's Clothiers
5.0
(1)
"When you have more time to get stuff, consider these guys."
#64
Wide the Brand
5.0
(1)
"Check out the dress shirts from Wide the Brand. They're sewn from the 4th upper button but still have the look of button down shirts."
#65
Dillard's
5.0
(1)
"Best advice I can say is DILLARD’S. Hop online they’re having a huge blowout clearance on most of their “basic” dress shirts."
#66
Charvet
5.0
(1)
"Get a Charvet on eBay and have it tailored."
#67
Chaps
5.0
(1)
"I recently buy Chaps "elastic" from Walmart, $20 and they are amazing."
#68
Ibex
4.0
(1)
"The original Ibex merino made several button front merino shirts."
#69
LL Bean
4.0
(1)
"LL Bean pinpoint oxfords, have the waist taken in."
#70
Paul Fredrick
4.0
(1)
"Paul Fredrick has a pretty fantastic sale going on right now. Worth a look."
#71
Goodfellow & Co.
4.0
(1)
"Two of my favorites are actually from Goodfellow, which is the Target brand."
#72
Huckberry
4.0
(1)
"Taylor Stitch, Buck Mason, Huckberry"
#73
Buck Mason
4.0
(1)
"Taylor Stitch, Buck Mason, Huckberry"
#74
Torrid
4.0
(1)
"I've had good luck at Torrid, surprisingly."
#75
Club Monaco
4.0
(1)
"Club Monaco."
#76
Taylor Stitch
4.0
(1)
"Taylor Stitch, Buck Mason, Huckberry"
#77
Goodwill
4.0
(1)
"Goodwill"
#78
Austin Pets Alive Thrift Stores
4.0
(1)
"Austin Pets Alive Thrift Stores have a wonderful and affordable selection!"
#79
Sonoma
4.0
(1)
"Sonoma perfect length, try them on at kohls"
#80
Second Looks
4.0
(1)
"Second Looks has(had?) a good selection of good quality ‘used’ clothes."
#81
Zegna
4.0
(1)
"Zegna"
#82
Van Laack
4.0
(1)
"Eton,Van Laack"
#83
Orvis
4.0
(1)
"I wear Orvis Charles F. Orvis signature dress shirts. They seem to always be long enough."
#84
5.11
4.0
(1)
"If casual is acceptable, pick busy pattern, so the printing will not be as pronounced. 5.11 sells such shirts."
#85
Theory
4.0
(1)
"I’ve had really good luck with Theory. Surprised no one mentioned it."
#86
G. Inglesse, Charvet, Brioni, 100 Hands, Ascot Chang
4.0
(1)
"Look at G. Inglesse, Charvet, Brioni, 100 Hands, Ascot Chang."
#87
Cotton Linen Blend
4.0
(1)
"Cotton linen blend dress shirts."
#88
Alpkit
4.0
(1)
"Ultra light and pretty smart. Still sweat but dry fast and don't stink."
#89
Polo Ralph Lauren
4.0
(1)
"I’m about your size and those are a brand of dress shirt I can wear without issue."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
