Edh reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 140 Reddit reviews across 6 subreddits and 19 posts to rank the best Edh brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/EDH, r/magicTCG, r/mtg, r/CompetitiveEDH, r/EDHBrews. Top-rated brands include Magic: The Gathering (4.1/5), Ultimate Guard (4.4/5), Dragon Shield (4.4/5).
Stats
Reviews140
Subreddits6
Posts19
Brands7
Products99
140 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Magic: The Gathering
4.1
(115)
"Explorers of the deep is really insane"
"[[Henzie]] is an absolute beast, surely one of the strongest precon out of the box.
[[Obuun]] and [[Valgavoth]] are also really good"
"The new sultai is one of the strongest i’ve seen in a long time, a friend have bought it and it’s really strong and solid"
"The free ones: Force of Will, Force of Negation, Flare of Denial, Fierce Guardianship, Pact of Negation"
"Brago is the premier bounce commander"
"Seconding this recommendation. All the colors you need, and provides a built-in way to *actually* close out the game"
"Baldur's Gate was effectively a perfect representation of the way I like Commander to be, and the draft experience was excellent."
"Double masters 2022. It’s INSANE how many good cards are in that set."
"We found a really good deal on baldurs gate play booster boxes during black friday and ended up getting two!"
"I just opened one from my LGS and loved it. Some great cards, anime art, and I was lucky enough to pull a rhystic study four packs in!"
#2
Ultimate Guard
4.4
(8)
"I now use Ultimate Guard Katana sleeves which feel so much better than DS ever has."
"UG Boulder 100+ deck boxes are perfect."
"I love the ultimate guard boulder deck boxes."
"I put decks in basic 3-4$ deckboxes (they are all same anyway) since I dont throw it around."
"I prefer the shuffle feel of the Katana's, personally"
"Deck Box: UltimateGuard 100+ Boulders, generally. I like having my decks feel like secur"
"The main deck box I use is the ultimate guard boulder"
"I keep 4 in the ultimate guard arkhive which can also jus hold unsleeved decks."
#3
Dragon Shield
4.4
(8)
"Yep I own three DS and two of em are 100ct double sleeved decks, with like 20 tokens and still some space leftover."
"Dragon shield matte sleeves are my favorite."
"I’m a big fan of Dragon Shield sleeves with Dragon Shield sealable inner sleeves"
"I just got these and they look and fit double sleeved decks easily with a removable token "drawer""
"Double shells can hold double sleeved cards and tokens, not sure about the card holder."
"I do like my Dragon Shields."
"I tend to use Dragon Shield Mattes (classic, reliable quality)"
"I personally like either dragon shield or ultra pro eclipse for outers and dragon shield inner if I double sleeve."
#4
Gamegenic
4.0
(5)
"I have a gamegenic sidekick pro +100 XL, currently has 106 thick doublesleeved with the resealable dragonshield inners and dual matte sleeves and 9 other tokens with resealable inners"
"I love the Bastion XL, but I wouldn’t be sure about it holding much more than a double sleeved deck comfortably."
"Gamegenic Bastion XL"
"I believe that the gamegenic sidekick pro xl or the gamegenic squire plus xl should both work."
"I would recommend the academic from gamegenic instead of an unknown company."
#5
Ultra Pro
2.5
(2)
"Then I go for Satin Towers or the $4 deck boxes from Ultra Pro that are single colored."
"I really dislike ultra pro sleeves. The feel, the look."
#6
KMC
4.0
(1)
"I swapped to KMC inners since they're slightly thinner"
#7
Winota and Magda
4.0
(1)
"Winota and magda can be built sub 100 and be lethal. Magda will be faster."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
