Eyeshadow Palettes reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 223 Reddit reviews across 19 subreddits and 51 posts to rank the best Eyeshadow Palettes brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/PaleMUA, r/MakeupAddiction, r/Sephora, r/Makeup, r/muacjdiscussion. Top-rated brands include Anastasia Beverly Hills (4.5/5), ColourPop (4.4/5), Natasha Denona (5.0/5).
Stats
Reviews223
Subreddits19
Posts51
Brands44
Products83
223 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Anastasia Beverly Hills
4.5
(30)
"I love the Anastasia Beverley hills soft glam palette."
"Abh soft glam is rly good and easy to use."
"- abh norvina (original not the big palettes)"
"Any of the Anastasia Beverly Hills Norvina pallets. There are few color stories available and they are all fabulous."
"I quite enjoy the Anastasia Beverly Hills pallets."
"I really enjoy Soft Glam palette from ABH."
"ABH original norvina."
"My all time fave palette is the original ABH Norvina."
"I love my Soft Glam 2 by Anastasia of Beverly Hills."
"I always come back to Soft Glam ABH."
#2
ColourPop
4.4
(30)
"Has many affordable palettes depending on whether you like cooler or warmer tones."
"- colourpop stone cold fox"
"Colourpop, Lorac, and Huda are my favorites."
"Colourpop has many neutral everyday palettes but also very colorful ones."
"My personal fave (pigmented, blendable, and cheap)."
"Colourpop that’s taupe, stone cold fox and off Melrose."
"Finally my chance to get Going Coconuts since I needed an everyday palette."
"Colourpop Stone Cold Fox and Flutterby are two of my favourite ever palettes so highly recommend either of those."
"Colourpop Stone Cold Fox palette."
"Colourpop palettes like stone cold fox."
#3
Natasha Denona
5.0
(22)
"Natasha Denona (great pigmentation)"
"Natasha denona! also really love pat mcgrath"
"Natasha Denona will always be that girl"
"I’ll add Natasha Denona"
"Natasha Denona, Makeup by Mario, Danessa Myricks are the new-er brands which I keep seeing rave reviews for!"
"Also natasha denona."
"10000% her pallets are amazing."
"Natasha Denona midi Xenon - much more versatile than it appears"
"The Natasha Denona Xenon is the best cool toned grey palette I own."
"I actually just got the natasha denona xenon palette and i’m in love with it!!"
#4
Huda Beauty
4.3
(18)
"HUDA Icy Nude palette from their official website!"
"I use nearly every color in the Huda beauty Rose Quartz palette."
"Huda beauty rose quartz is one of my favs."
"Huda Naughty palette is gorgeous, the shades are very rich."
"Huda Beauty Rose Quartz."
"Mercury Retrograde is a really versatile palette."
"Huda beauty mercury retrograde."
"Mercury Retrograde by Huda Beauty!"
"I really love huda beauty new nudes."
"I don't use all the colours together but I've got a noticeable dent in every pan."
#5
Urban Decay
4.5
(15)
"Naked 2 basics palette is such a good cool toned matte palette. You can also use it to contour."
"I love UD’s Naked3, especially if you’re a bit cool-toned."
"The shades are very flattering on light skin tones."
"Urban Decay Naked2 Basics; subtle shades, perfect for everyday use."
"- urban decay naked 3"
"The UD Basics 2 is my most used palette."
"My favorite palettes are: urban decay born to run."
"Urban Decay is still very solid"
"Too Faced and Urban Decay are still very good"
"My go to is Urban Decay WITH their eyeshadow primer applied first."
#6
Juvia's Place
4.8
(13)
"Juvias place!!!!"
"Juvias place is a black owned brand with pigmented products that you may like."
"Juvias place is my go to for affordable, pigmented products. Some palettes I think you'd like would be the nubian ones."
"They have very vibrant colors and deep pigment."
"Juvia’s Place palettes are awesome, especially if you like bright colors!"
"I second Juvias place - the pigmentation will knock your socks off."
"Juvia's Place make highly pigmented palettes."
"I have 4 brand new Juvias place palettes - comes with boxes and packing."
"Definitely Juvia’s Place."
"I recommend juvias place! Extremely good quality, very pigmented!"
#7
Makeup by Mario
4.6
(9)
"I second Makeup by Mario palettes. Goes on clean, stays all day."
"I mostly reach for makeup by mario palettes. Any would be a great investment."
"Very flattering and versatile!"
"I love Makeup by Mario Master Mattes"
"The Makeup by Mario Matte palette is great for the base so highly recommend."
"Makeup by Mario neutrals"
"I’m tempted to get the makeup by Mario master mattes tho."
"I really like the master mattes by makeup by Mario."
"The Makeup by Mario Matte palette is great for the base so highly recommend."
#8
Too Faced
4.1
(7)
"Yes, all of them. I refuse to buy a palette with a single shade I wouldn't use."
"Too Faced and Urban Decay are still very good"
"Of the old cult faves I still like Toofaced"
"Bh and Too Faced are my personal favorites."
"I enjoy most all Too Faced palettes."
"Too Faced palettes have a lot of peach undertones which would look nice with hazel eyes."
"I love cool neutrals and they’re great workhorses for all occasions."
#9
Colourpop
4.0
(6)
"I’d also recommend the Colourpop Aurora Struck. It’s a beautiful muted, cooler toned color story."
"Try blowin' smoke from Colour Pop. It's available on their website."
"Colourpop Gone Metal, its at Target."
"Colour Pop Matte about Hue"
"Fade into hue or matte about hue $35"
"I did just order a custom eyeshadow palette from Colourpop and I basically stalked every shade on the website."
#10
Tarte
4.6
(5)
"I love it, it’s my go to palette 90 percent of the time."
"The eyeshadows don't smudge and blend incredibly."
"The one that I own where I use basically every shade."
"My favorites are the Tarte In Bloom palette."
"A great beginner palette is Tarte In Bloom."
#11
Viseart
4.4
(5)
"Viseart has excellent cool and neutral, all matte palettes. I use one or both literally every day."
"I have the Viseart Theory palette in Minx and I love it and have used all the shades regularly."
"Viseart Cool Mattes is also lovely but not all grey."
"I do use them all."
"Viseart Dark Mattes, and Natural Mattes."
#12
Danessa Myricks
5.0
(4)
"Danessa Myricks palettes are TOP TIER! The blooming romance & defining neutrals have powder & cream shadows in them & are soo versatile!"
"They blend so well and last so long. Love them. Worth the money."
"Her shades stayed in place. No fallout under my eyes, no flaking into my contacts. Just beautiful all day shimmer."
"This palette is CARRYING my kit rn. Danessa Myricks Groundwork Defining Neutrals."
#13
Milani
4.0
(5)
"Milani gilded mini in whiskey business"
"I love Milani’s Soft&Sultry which is now out of production."
"Milani Soft & Sultry."
"Milani most loved mattes."
"I wear it just about every day."
#14
Dior
4.8
(4)
"- Dior backstage cool neutrals"
"I’m obsessed with the Dior Backstage cool neutrals palette."
"I’m obsessed with the Dior Backstage cool neutrals palette."
"Dior Backstage (softer looks)"
#15
BH Cosmetics
3.8
(5)
"BH Cosmetics Take Me Back to Brazil palette."
"I also enjoy BH cosmetic eyeshadow palettes."
"BH cosmetics have a store in Germany so if you're in the EU you can get it locally."
"I love BH cosmetics' palettes! Great colors and no fallout."
"I think the closest thing I have is the BH Cosmetics Take Me Back to Brazil palette."
#16
Tom Ford
4.8
(4)
"- Tom ford nude dip"
"Tom Ford Honeymoon Quad (out of 6 Viseart and 7 PMG palettes, this is the only one I use all 4 shades)."
"I definitely use every shade in my Tom Ford Pretty Baby quad."
"I have a neutral eye shadow palette: Tom Ford Nude Dip Eyeshadow Quad."
#17
Revolution
4.7
(3)
"Do amazing ones and they do dupes of other high end palettes."
"I personally LOVE Revolution eyeshadow, they're pigmented and the only eyeshadow I've tried so far that doesn't crease at all."
"I have the Revolution Festive Allure eyeshadow palette. I personally love it! It is a lot of purples/greys though."
#18
Lethal Cosmetics
4.3
(3)
"Make your own palette from Lethal Cosmetics."
"A favorite of mine are Lethal Cosmetics, you can definitely make some neutral palettes with their selection."
"There's a brand ed Lethal Cosmetics, and you can make your own palettes from the singles they have."
#19
Dasique
4.3
(3)
"It's a muted mauve cashmere sweater type palette."
"I have Dasique Muted Nuts... The matte formula is fantastic and the matte pearl is also quite good."
"Best neutral nude palette for daytime smokey eyes"
#20
Morphe
4.3
(3)
"Morphe has a cool toned Matte palette that I love."
"I still use the Morphe Jaclyn Hill palette from 2018"
"Meredith $34"
#21
Patrick Ta
5.0
(2)
"Patrick ta major dimension 3 is my fav neutrals palette."
"I really like the Patrick Ta Major Dimension III eyeshadow palette. The top row is warm and the bottom row is cool."
#22
Sydney Grace
4.5
(2)
"My top choices are Sydney Grace, Give Me Glow, Devinah Cosmetics."
"I've made my own travel palette with pressed eyeshadows from Sydney Grace and Fyrinnae."
#23
Elf
4.0
(2)
"Elf mad for matte in nude mood"
"Elf mad for matte nude mood palette, it’s pretty much all I use."
#24
Wet n Wild
4.0
(2)
"Wet N Wild"
"Wet n Wild and Rimmel has some great drugstore dupes."
#25
Romand
4.0
(2)
"Plus to Romnd Dusty Fog Garden."
"Romand has one called Dusty Fog Garden, it’s great but what I don’t like about it is that it’s all-matte."
#26
Profusion
5.0
(1)
"Profusion I just picked up at Meijer is amazing for $5.47."
#27
Lunar Beauty
5.0
(1)
"Lunar beauty eye shadow palettes are so amazing, great colour stories and formulas. I have 3 different ones and they’re all 10/10"
#28
Cosmic Brushes
5.0
(1)
"Another cool toned that I love and own is the Cosmic Brushes Cooltrals palette."
#29
Devinah Cosmetics
5.0
(1)
"Devinah Cosmetics Eternal Night - the best all matte grayscale color story ever made"
#30
Blend Bunny
5.0
(1)
"In my 20+ years of using makeup... I’m not sure if I’ve ever been this impressed by an eyeshadow formula. Their mattes are fkin gorgeous and their shimmers/duo and multichromes are stunning with little to no fallout."
#31
Pat McGrath
5.0
(1)
"I am satisfied with Pat McGrath - mothership, moonlit seduction."
#32
Beauty Bay
5.0
(1)
"I just picked up the Beauty Bay Smoky 42 pan the other day when they had the £10 palette sale... I was like screw it, I’m getting it!"
#33
Melt
5.0
(1)
"The melt Gemini palette. It’s stunning."
#34
Charlotte Tilbury
5.0
(1)
"Charlotte Tilbury quads are curated really nicely and I use every single shade in them."
#35
Glamlite
4.0
(1)
"I like Glamlite’s monochromatic red ICEE palette."
#36
YSL
4.0
(1)
"I like my YSL a lot"
#37
Clio, Dasique, Wakemake, Lilybyred
4.0
(1)
"Clio dasique wakemake and lilybyred all have neutral palettes, and some decent cool toned ones too!"
#38
Essence
4.0
(1)
"This palette isn’t chalky at all!! i would start with this one tbh"
#39
Clio
4.0
(1)
"For kbeauty, i really like the clio palettes! their matte formula is very smooth and not crazy pigmented, it’s best for that wash of color effect"
#40
Makeup Revolution
4.0
(1)
"Makeup Revolution’s Reloaded Mattes are on sale for $2"
#41
Jeffree Star
4.0
(1)
"Have you tried Jeffrey Star’s Weirdo Pallete?"
#42
Laura Mercier
4.0
(1)
"I do come close with the Laura Mercier Eye Art Artist's Palette, which has a large selection of very wearable shades."
#43
NYX
4.0
(1)
"NYX I Know That’s Bright $8"
#44
Nyx
3.0
(1)
"Be warned this palette catches mould very easily in monsoon season"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
