Goalkeeper reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 225 Reddit reviews across 16 subreddits and 47 posts to rank the best Goalkeeper brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/FUTMobile, r/fut, r/EASportsFCMobile, r/EASportsFC, r/eFootball. Top-rated brands include Donnarumma (4.4/5), Van der Sar (4.0/5), Kobel (4.3/5).
Stats
Reviews225
Subreddits16
Posts47
Brands75
Products38
225 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Donnarumma
4.4
(20)
"Has been insane with the saves"
"Donnarumma TOTS 98 was by far the best. He is fantastic at 1v1s he saves a lot of shots."
"Donna TOTS red rank has been the best goalkeeper I've ever used."
"UPDATE: TOTS Donna has been amazing for me so far in H2H better than VDS."
"TOTS Gigi gold rank max lvl 30 is absolutely unstoppable."
"Donna Euro version is a beast he saved me in so many h2h Matches."
"I'm using TOTS Donna rn and I have to say he's amazing."
"Donnaruma is a beast for sure so I guess you can't go wrong with him."
"In this order imo."
"So good in vsa"
#2
Van der Sar
4.0
(12)
"VDS"
"God tier: Van der Sar, Yashin"
"TS Van der Sar is the best keeper i’ve ever used"
"I use VDS; Ive used Buffon, Allison, Sels and several others with better stats but he just seems the most consistent."
"Van der Sar follows closely after them in terms of quality and cost."
"Van Der Sar is a solid choice"
"It's either Van Der Sar or Yashin, but it really comes down to your preference."
"Van de sar"
"I recommend VDS, atleast ranked once."
"Go for tall gk like VDS or Cech. If you can’t buy the 94+ ones then go for 89 rated fully ranked ones."
#3
Kobel
4.3
(11)
"Trust me bro I used UCL kobel for months and he's never dissapointed me especially in vsa he's a nightmare for every opponent"
"I signed Kobel for £37m but in the 2nd season he was rock solid for 5 seasons"
"No doubt"
"Kobel or mamardasvili"
"Kobel Bryan"
"The best gloves made in india are the KOBO ones. Good quality and works well for both ag and real grass."
"Are the best gks imo."
"UCL Kobel or TOTS Donna are the 2 best ones that are tough in both H2H and VSA."
"Probably Kobel from the daily penalty reward."
"Ucl Kobel"
#4
Thibaut Courtois
4.5
(10)
"Courtois 100 for budget and 105 for Unlimited budget. Get gold. He is the best. No question.."
"I have courtois and oh my goodness there was a game that he just saved everything."
"Courtois for sure"
"For gold cards it’s probably Courtois"
"It's Courtouis currently and there's no debate."
"I hear gp courtious is the bees knees"
"Courtois or alisson i’ve found"
"I am constantly switching between Courtois, POTW Donarumma, Emi Martinez and Kobel, POTW Diogo Costa with booster."
#5
Ter Stegen
4.3
(10)
"I have 103 ter stegen rn and he performs amazing"
"I have ballon d'or Ter Stegen so I would recommend him"
"Ter Stegen is currently the best keeper in the game almost objectively"
"Pls choose ter stegen, for me he is the best gk in the game right now. he always makes unexpected 1v1 saves and he will only let tap ins basically."
"TOTW Ter Stegen is another strong contender to consider."
"Elite tier: Courtois, IF Ter Stegen, Alisson"
"IF Ter Stegan."
"Ter Stergen has been pretty good (prefer him over Cech and Casillas)."
"Ter stegen is good too but not this version of him"
"I have IF Ter Stegen but VDS is better for chem"
#6
Gregor Kobel
4.8
(8)
"Is better than my gold Ranked Buffon"
"Kobel all day"
"Kobel is the best one"
"Kobel for 200 shards"
"Kobel and Howard are really good."
#7
Alisson
3.8
(10)
"94 alisson toty"
"Base Allison, super reliable and consistent, leans more on the attacking side of things. Arguable the best gk in the game imo"
"I use alisson he is good tho"
"I'd recommend focusing on these gold options: Courtois, Alisson, and Lloris."
"Elite tier: Courtois, IF Ter Stegen, Alisson"
"Alisson or Neuer"
"Allison seems a really popular choice on the cheap side."
"Been using allison since early on, had ederson but he was garbage for some reason."
"Alisson if you can’t afford vds or cech"
"Alisson"
#8
Courtois
4.1
(9)
"He is sooo good (add him low punt)"
"Gold Courtois was insane for me, only got rid of him because I got lucky and packed TOTY Allison"
"Get retro start courtois."
"I'd recommend focusing on these gold options: Courtois, Alisson, and Lloris."
"Elite tier: Courtois, IF Ter Stegen, Alisson"
"Base Courtois. He can save the titanic"
"You can go for Courtois if you wish"
"Ucl Courtois"
"Courtois"
#9
Neuer
4.1
(8)
"I have Neuer 104 and he's a beast"
"I haven't conceded 1 reddit neuer goal"
"Base neuer all day"
"Neur winter wonderland"
"Neuer. I've used him since the start of December and he's been really solid."
"Alisson or Neuer"
"From this list Naeuer"
"I would choose him over NC Neuer and POTW De Gea"
#10
Schmeichel
4.4
(7)
"Get Schmeichel 105"
"Schmeichel 105 is a beast"
"Best in the game? 104 Courtois then 105 Schmeichel"
"Do Schmeichel SBC he saved me last WL soo much"
"You could opt for Schmeichel since icons offer chemistry advantages."
"I'm perfectly fine with Schmeichel and would only switch to one of those if I pack them."
"For me Schmeichel has been great but some other keepers you could try are Casillas or Van de sar."
#11
Mamardashvili
5.0
(6)
"Still cooks."
"One of the best keepers in the game rn"
"All top players were using him even while 99 rated GKs were available in the Market"
"Max ranked"
"I've been using Mamardashvili at red rank lvl 25 and he saves almost everything."
"97"
#12
Buffon
4.0
(6)
"Buffon is the first iv used that hasn’t been useless he’s won me a few games"
"IMO Buffon base."
"Buffon"
"Buffon"
"I was positively impressed by that Buffon, I’m now using him as my main keeper"
"I would choose him over NC Neuer and POTW De Gea"
#13
Mike Maignan
5.0
(4)
"I had Mike mignon with my Leicester team. He rocked 7.5 every game."
"Mike Maignan helps me win many games I shouldn't."
"Maignan has been an absolute beast."
"Maignan and Kobel the best gk"
#14
West Coast
5.0
(4)
"All of their gloves have removable finger saves as well."
"Third for West Coast turf options."
"Best gloves I have and they hold up wonderfully on turf."
"West Coast is what I use for turf"
#15
Giorgi Mamardashvili
4.8
(4)
"Can’t go wrong with mamardashvili"
"Mamardasvhilli and donnarumma far away."
"Any other answer than Giorgi Mamardashvili is wrong."
"When he is in form i like him best and starts over any other gk pulls off saves pretty well"
#16
Casillas
3.8
(5)
"I’ve seen enough crazy far reach and footwork saves from Casillas to stick with him."
"Toty Casillas has still been mr reliable for me"
"Casillas"
"Crazy how no one is talking about Casillas. He hasn't conceded a goal in so long."
"Some other keepers you could try are Casillas or Van de sar."
#17
Yashin
4.5
(4)
"God tier: Van der Sar, Yashin"
"Yashin, miles ahead of anyone else I've used"
"Yashin offers remarkable performance at a relatively affordable price point."
"It's either Van Der Sar or Yashin, but it really comes down to your preference."
#18
Sels
4.5
(4)
"When I faced Sels, he was insane! He saved everything."
"Sels is insane for me"
"Sels seems just a little better at everything than Casillas and Casillas was solid."
"Sels is pretty solid."
#19
Alisson Becker
4.3
(4)
"Alisson/dudek are the best"
"You could probably get gold rank bdr Alisson who I have since switched to."
"Alison maignan and dudek"
"When I got Alisson I started to win games that I would have lost with Cech."
#20
Petr Čech
5.0
(3)
"Petr Čech is a game-changer. He's affordable and an absolute beast between the posts."
"I packed cech a while ago and have never felt the need to replace him"
"Cech easily by miles"
#21
Gianluigi Donnarumma
4.7
(3)
"Donnarumma is the best one for VSA."
"Definitely donnarumma. got so sick of him saving absolutely everything against me in vsa until I got packed him myself."
"Red rank 97"
#22
Manuel Neuer
4.3
(3)
"Neuer and scchimicheal are the best rn. Followed by Allison and Donna if u want something cheaper"
"Neuer is pretty strong rn"
"Neuer has a unique player id factor performs more than the stats."
#23
Rulli
4.3
(3)
"Rulli has been the best GK I've used in FC25 so far. Very good."
"I use Rulli now. I had Casillas previously but Rulli works better for me"
"Rulli for me. Replaced Casillas."
#24
Čech
4.3
(3)
"TOTY Čech, who's widely regarded as one of the best in the game."
"Peter cech has been insane for me, like for real."
"Go for tall gk like VDS or Cech. If you can’t buy the 94+ ones then go for 89 rated fully ranked ones."
#25
Campos
5.0
(2)
"Campos 🤑🤑goated (he can run)"
"Every campos card is just very good!the diving and reaction is just unimaginable good I totally recommend buying him at red ranked version with 20lv"
#26
VDS
5.0
(2)
"Grab VDS"
"100 VDS he a beast for me."
#27
Dida
4.5
(2)
"Dida, period."
"Dida is the best br gk I have seen"
#28
Diogo Costa
4.5
(2)
"Yeah, Costa is the best choice at this price."
"Diogo Costa has been very solid for me."
#29
van der Sar
4.5
(2)
"Base van der sar"
"I’ve used base VDS since I’ve pulled him and never thought of changing."
#30
Adidas
4.5
(2)
"Neuer is better"
"Using de gea, neuer is better"
#31
Marc-André ter Stegen
4.0
(2)
"Ter Stegen Potw."
#32
Aaron Ramsdale
4.0
(2)
"I got Ramsdale cheap. Contributes to the registration rules too."
"Ramsdale"
#33
Peter Schmeichel
4.0
(2)
"I’ve schmeichel in my team and he’s so good"
"Schmeichel has been great for me. I also like Cech and 92-VDS."
#34
Emiliano Martínez
4.0
(2)
"It would be Martinez and Alisson"
"Emiliano Martinez"
#35
Günok
4.0
(2)
"Dude is pretty solid"
"He is exceptional in both short range and long range shots. He is also cheap."
#36
Savic
4.0
(2)
"Savic is really good but you need to upgrade him to at least red rank,he makes insane saves for me"
"I have been rocking Vanja Savic at Red ranked. He is a beast."
#37
Mamardasvili
4.0
(2)
"I currently use mamardasvili he's good too but kobel is a bit better imo"
"With your budget mamardasvili or savic, if you magically get 900mil get that 103 kobel his no joke :p"
#38
Mignolet
5.0
(1)
"He is a beast"
#39
Script
5.0
(1)
"I highly recommend the Script."
#40
Edwin van der Sar
5.0
(1)
"Van der Sar is the best gk by far in the entire game."
#41
Jerzy Dudek
5.0
(1)
"East or west Dudek is the best."
#42
Lena Schiechel
5.0
(1)
"Schiechel 100 percent the best option."
#43
Filip Jörgensen
5.0
(1)
"I bought on United but not first season Filip Jörgensen and so happy he is so good."
#44
Jane Campbell
5.0
(1)
"Honestly, Jane Campbell."
#45
POTW
5.0
(1)
"POTW purple Neuer is insane."
#46
Ef23
5.0
(1)
"Ef23 neuer"
#47
TOTY
5.0
(1)
"TOTY Maignan **MAX RANK**"
#48
AKB
5.0
(1)
"AKB without a doubt, but that is just my opinion."
#49
Kailen Sheridan
5.0
(1)
"I feel too strongly towards Kailen Sheridan to give a rational answer."
#50
Casey Murphy
5.0
(1)
"Casey Murphy for consist strong performances"
#51
De Gea
5.0
(1)
"For me degea is the best"
#52
Marcos
4.0
(1)
"Marcos 2002, and also Rogerio Ceni for his goal scoring capabilities."
#53
Tim Howard
4.0
(1)
"Save up, MAYBE try to get 103 howard or 104 neuer from the event."
#54
Cech
4.0
(1)
"How about you try Cech or Donna."
#55
Szczęsny
4.0
(1)
"I am using UTOTS Szczęsny he is good, and reliable."
#56
Bounou
4.0
(1)
"Switched Donna for Bounou and it’s been good."
#57
Robert Sánchez
4.0
(1)
"I bought Robert Sanchez the other day"
#58
Szczesny
4.0
(1)
"I preferred him over the 99 Schmeichel whom I use now"
#59
Joe Gauci
4.0
(1)
"Look for joe gauci, he’s an australian keeper"
#60
Nick Pope
4.0
(1)
"N. Pope is 1.98m and sometimes get good potw cards"
#61
Ederson
4.0
(1)
"Ederson and Courtois"
#62
Christiane Endler
4.0
(1)
"Endler for me but I hate playing against Ederson and Alisson."
#63
Iker Casillas
4.0
(1)
"I have Casillas(red ranked) and he is good."
#64
Munich
4.0
(1)
"Munich gresca or prisma"
#65
André Onana
4.0
(1)
"Villareal bought me Onana with that money in same window so kinda cheap."
#66
Olivier Giroud
4.0
(1)
"Giroud."
#67
Luis Campos
4.0
(1)
"Campos."
#68
Virgil van Dijk
4.0
(1)
"Are good for me performance wise"
#70
Jan Oblak
4.0
(1)
"For me oblak and donna tots clear everyone else."
#71
Eintracht Frankfurt
4.0
(1)
"Kaua Santos— frankfurt un genç kalecisi"
#72
Leeds United
4.0
(1)
"Imma big fan of this kid for some reason, and he is almost impossible to convince, but Ilian Meslier."
#73
Olympiacos
4.0
(1)
"The gk of olympiacos was very impressive. also young."
#74
Liverpool
4.0
(1)
"Caoimhin Kelleher (current Ireland no 1, Liverpool no 2) only started playing in goal at 14."
#75
David De Gea
1.0
(1)
"De gea is trash"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
