Horse Breed reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 303 Reddit reviews across 10 subreddits and 34 posts to rank the best Horse Breed brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Horses, r/StarStable, r/reddeadredemption, r/RedDeadOnline, r/RDR2. Top-rated brands include Mustang (4.4/5), Arabian (4.3/5), Quarter Horse (4.3/5).
Stats
Reviews303
Subreddits10
Posts34
Brands79
Products25
303 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Mustang
4.4
(27)
"Mustang."
"Mustang, but I'm biased."
"For me it's the mustang. Looks good in English and western tack. Not big, but also not small. Great agility stats and cute little animations."
"I also really recommend the mustangs (also a fun animation and they are GORGEOUS) and the appaloosa"
"I had the occasion to ride a mustang mare on a cattle drive. They paid Nevada correctional $350.00 for her and she was amazing."
"There's actually not much difference between horses but the definitely best is the mustang."
"Mustangs, Kladruber og Missouri Fox Trotter has the best stats."
"I just got a Mustang and I’m in love with how fast it is. Stamina is really good too."
"The mustangs are the only breed in the game so far that I can ride without having to be annoyed by its animations!"
"I came across the wild striped mustang and I fell in love with her. Great stamina, stomps wolves and snakes, and she doesn't drop me when there's a cougar or a bear nearby."
#2
Arabian
4.3
(23)
"Endurance bred Arabians are the best for this type of job."
"1. Arabians"
"I recommend the same because its whiteness is unique and you bond with her so much which is important in the game since bonding improves the horse stats."
"I fell in love with a young green Arabian and got to be part of the training process, which was wonderful."
"I think the White Arabian is the best girl, while the Silver Turkoman is the best boy."
"Best all around is the rose bay gray arabian. Best stats."
"Just go get the White Arabian. It’s a legendary animal and starts with amazing stats."
"I just got a arabian! i love her sm!!"
"My favourite horse is my Arabian, she's the only one I've maxed out so far."
"Gem3 Arabian, Percheron, English Troughblood"
#3
Quarter Horse
4.3
(15)
"I suggest (just my opinion) -Quarter horse -Appaloosa -Morgan -Paint"
"Quarter horses are great, but they are all individuals. Take your time and work with a trusted trainer to find the right fit."
"Quarter horses are usually pretty mild tempered, can come in 16hh+, and depending on breeding can be pretty speedy as well."
"My 14.2 ranch bred qh is the best darn horse I’ve ever ridden. He’s fast, can turn on a dime, has hooves that could crack boulders and has never once spooked me off of him."
"Quarter horse. That's the only answer."
"I’d say QH or Appendix QH if you’re asking for a specific breed."
"QHs tend to be good, but drafts can be a rough time."
"Quarter horses and draft type horses make really great beginner horses."
"The quarter horse technically has the best racing stats as it's the only one with both 3 agility and 3 discipline."
"The best stats i have are on my QH, idk why."
#4
Andalusian
4.5
(13)
"Andalusian, its the only horse that i have two of."
"My main ride is an Andalusian named ‘Pie Oh My.” Great steed!"
"I love the Andalusians and the Mustangs."
"It maxes out on health at lv 4, has 8 stamina which means it will never get tired."
"That’s what you want to hold you over until 'Horse Flesh For Dinner' when you can get the Dark Bay Turkoman."
"I have perlino andalusian and being a war horse he is fast, has stamina and wont buck you off immediately"
"Seconding Andalusians."
"Andalusians tend to be favored with that kind of thing."
"I'll say the Dark Bay Andalusian from the Strawberry stables."
"If you want a nostalgia horse, then any remaining gen1, for me personally the gen1 andalusians."
#5
Morgan
4.7
(12)
"For beginners or first time horse owners I recommend: Morgan horse, Quarter horse or Paint horse"
"I suggest (just my opinion) -Quarter horse -Appaloosa -Morgan -Paint"
"There are some Morgans that fit your bill. Some types don’t get too tall and are strong, sturdy, and have a good work ethic."
"Yesss morgans 100%!!"
"I agree with a Morgan! Huge desire to please, fun personalities, love doing things where they have a “job"."
"Morgans! Size can vary, but a lot of them are between 14-15hh, and super personable."
"I'm a biased farrier in charge of a few."
"I love haflingers or Norwegian fjords....But I have a Morgan and I would 10000% recommend a Morgan."
"I had a 14.2 hand Morgan/QH and she was full of personality. I miss her!"
"The $15 Morgan at the Valentine stable is the one."
#6
Haflinger
4.7
(11)
"Haflinger!!"
"I second Haflinger!"
"Came here to recommend Haflingers too, they are great & very versatile."
"Haflingers are awesome things! I’ve met a few and they’re always such sweet, hardworking and forward ponies."
"Haffy. They’re so versatile and have the Instagram cool factor."
"Get a haflinger! they have very clear Arabian influence and there are some super sporty ones 😊"
"Haflingers are awesome for first-time owners."
"My haflinger and bwb are my personal favorites!"
"In Germany we call them Edelblut Haflinger ;-). But be aware you‘ll get a incredible smart horse which is also stubborn and extremely sensible at the same time!"
"Halflingers are so fun so are pony sized quarter horses."
#7
Turkoman
4.3
(11)
"Dark bay turkoman is my fav horse, one of the best horses statistically and it looks really good, other good ones are mustang and andalusian."
"Turkoman has always been the most beautiful and well proportioned choice for me."
"Turkoman is the best overall, but honestly it doesn’t make a big difference"
"Dark Bay Turkoman! Can be taken for free from the Braithwraite stables during the "Horse Flesh for dinner" Mission in ch.3 through a glitch"
"I always default to the turkoman from the story mode in act3 that you steal from the braithwaits or whatever they are called. Just a great horse all around and my current one I call him kelpie."
"I’m happy with my black Turkoman"
"But try the Turkomans, they have a good reputation."
"I prefer the *Turkoman* over the *Arabian* because it’s far less skittish."
"I'd say the Turkoman breed. Mixture of Race and War horses."
"I think the Turkomens and Missouri Fox Trotters are probably your best bet."
#8
Shire
4.5
(10)
"Shire horse for life."
"Shire ( Only Raven Black Coat )"
"The most recent gen shire!! my favourite"
"I LOVE the shires id love one in every color 😂"
"Personally speaking, the Gen2 Shires. They look better and have more personality than the recent Gen3 ones"
"1. Black Shire from Hosea."
"I personally either like to keep the shire that Hosea gives you."
"I always keep the big boy shire, the one hosea gives you. He’s a good boah"
"The shire is nice to have. It’s the biggest horse in the game"
"Not enough shire comments here T_T
def them or the belgians"
#9
Dutch Warmblood
4.5
(10)
"Dutch Warmblood. They're steady, big (but not giant), and to top it off, they have hands down the fanciest trot."
"The Dutch Warmblood is incredibly resilient, very brave."
"Found in Valentine Stable is my favourite"
"Dutch warmblood next week"
"The dutch warmblood comes out coming wednesday! maybe see if you like one of those :D"
"By the lake there is a gold panner and he had a Dutch warm blood that looks good."
"Chocolate Roan Dutch Warmblood. Available at the Valentine stable."
"I’m really fond of the gold panner’s horse."
"I like the Dutch Warmblood horses and Hungarian Halfbreds"
"Dutch Warmbloods imo. They have good health and excellent stamina."
#10
Icelandic
4.7
(9)
"Icelandic horses! They’re tiny but they’re super strong"
"My Icelandic gelding is very competitive and speedy, and super smooth."
"Icelandic"
"Icelandics! Gaited so very smooth but very forward and fast to ride. They're fantastic trail horses but very gentle on the ground."
"Icelandic all day, everyday"
"Icelandics!"
"Right now my Icelandic is my favorite. The special move is adorable and so well animated."
"Icelandic has cool gaits and it looks super cute"
"Icelandic Horse Gen 2 - Shire Gen 2 & 3, Mustangs Gen 2 & 3 and The Jorvik Wild Horses!"
#11
Missouri Fox Trotter
4.1
(10)
"My pony is a Missouri Fox Trotter...super strong, super fast, super smart, super sassy"
"I think I’ve decided it’s the MFT"
"I love my blue roan missouri foxtrotter, he’s pretty speedy and brave"
"My go-to's are the Missouri Fox Trotter and the Hungarian Halfbred. I also like the Turkoman."
"I like Missouri Fox Trotter (MFT) imho it has great speed and stamina and is quite brave."
"Can get Missouri Fox trotter as early as chapter 2 if u know how."
"I like the Missouri Fox Trotter but you probably won’t get that very early in the game."
"I like the MFT you can buy in chapter 4. Currently my fav horse."
"If you like a larger horse or a less jumpy one then I recommend Missouri Fox Trotter."
"Missouri Fox Trotter is my fave. Great speed and alright health."
#12
Thoroughbred
3.9
(10)
"A draft x thoroughbred would be your best bet. or just a large tb, warmblood, qh.."
"2. Thoroughbred (more english based)"
"You can get a beautiful Blood bay thoroughbred."
"I really like the Thoroughbred."
"Ultimate edition thoroughbred is pretty good"
"Give me a thoroughbred or a Appaloosa and I place nearly every time."
"Thoroughbreds and warmbloods would definitely be my suggestion based on the description OP gave of what she wants out of a horse."
"Never wanted a TB or OTTB. Wouldn’t even consider them. Bought one anyway and we’re a great team."
"Thoroughbred."
"Thoroughbreds are the most common racing breed today I believe."
#13
Connemara
4.8
(8)
"I have connemara ponies and they are amazing! They're clever and generally sensible, sure footed and made for bad weather and rough terrain."
"No more “jack hammer” trot, plus you get the speed AND a gentle nature!"
"I had a friend who had an incredible Connemara, and also did archery with her!"
"Connemara - I have one and he is the best ever!! Goes anywhere, does anything with a smile on his face."
"Connemara pony sounds like it would be a perfect fit!"
"Connemaras! I love them, they're my favourite."
"Y’all out here suggesting Connemaras like they are a dime a dozen….. there are very few registered annually and easily go for 5 figures as babies lol"
"Once you have earned a Connemara’s trust they are right there wi"
#14
Percheron
4.4
(7)
"I LOVE the percherons. Their gates are gorgeous and smooth, their coat colors are adorable, the character fits them well."
"Perchies!!"
"Yes🙏🏼 i love the percherons so much"
"Any draft or draft cross will be cool-headed and do well in cold temperatures."
"Agree about the big ones. A draft cross maybe, or if you just want a husband horse, a calm Percheron for trails."
"The percherons are cute if you don’t mind their mane and tail looking like rope, and right now they are the fastest horses in game."
"That would be my suggestion for Ella for her size and environment."
#15
Tennessee Walking Horse
4.7
(6)
"I’m a life long Tennessee Walking Horse and Spotted Saddle Horse enthusiast, so I’d recommend you look into gaited breeds."
"I’m in love with the Tennessee walker"
"I’ve played through multiple times and have hundreds of hours with a Dappled Bay Tennessee Walker. For some reason, it’s my favorite horse."
"The very first horse I learned to ride in real life was a TWH so I had to get one in the game."
"One of the best horses in the game is the one almost everyone immediately discounts: the starter Mahogany Bay Tennessee Walker."
"Tennesse walker. Without a doubt."
#16
Appaloosa
4.3
(6)
"I suggest (just my opinion) -Quarter horse -Appaloosa -Morgan -Paint"
"The appaloosa (doesn't get much more western than a cute "moldy" horse:D)"
"I'm bias towards the old lined Appaloosa, but would second the Mustang as a very close second."
"* Mustang * Appaloosa * Tennessee Walker * American Paint Horse * Belgian Warmblood"
"My first horse was an "old-style " Appaloosa. You have to really dig around to find them, but they are there."
"Appaloosas and Halflinger are an amazing option"
#17
Dalmatian
5.0
(5)
"Dalmatians were purposefully bred to work with horses. Their job was to run with the coaches and protect them from thieves."
"Dalmatians were literally bred to follow horse drawn carts, so a dal from a good breeder would be a great choice."
"Dalmatian they are the best coach dogs"
"Dalmatian."
"I had two trained Dals, did great around horses and on trails."
#18
Standardbred
4.0
(5)
"I really like the Black Standardbred you can catch in the wild."
"Standardbreds aren't like other lighter-gaited breeds. They will relax their head down with proper training."
"I agree that standard breds have a good reputation but many QH are dog gentle."
"There are barrel racing and roping and hunter jumper Standardbreds."
"I recommend Standardbreds. They are far calmer in disposition that QH are now bred to be."
#19
Norfolk Roadster
4.8
(4)
"I’d recommend the Norfolk roadster. I’m pretty sure if u get the right color/coat for it (requires lvl.20 moonshiner) its actually outranks the black Arabian by 1 point and the MFT by 2…"
"I think the norfolk roadster has the highest stats if that’s what you’re after"
"If I had to pick the bravest one, it would be the Norfolk Roadster."
"I usually swap between the norfolk roadster and the arabian."
#20
Belgian Warmblood
4.8
(4)
"I have to always always always recommend my favorite sso (and irl!) breed of all time: the BELGIAN WARMBLOOD!!!!"
"Belgian warmblood is my favourite! I adore their animations and the model."
"My top faves are the belgian warmbloods"
"* Mustang * Appaloosa * Tennessee Walker * American Paint Horse * Belgian Warmblood"
#21
Fjord
4.3
(4)
"Fjords are great."
"Fjords, if you can find one"
"A close second are the fjord horses."
"Fjord gen 1 forever in my heart."
#22
Hungarian Halfbred
4.0
(4)
"Hungarian halfbreds are VERY underrated."
"Hungarian half bread is a good one"
"I used a Hungarian Halfbred for all but one playthrough. You could find it early in the wild, it was large but had decent speed."
"Hungarian halfbred does pretty good."
#23
Quarab
5.0
(3)
"Highly recommend quarabs! My quarab is almost exactly what you're describing."
"Quarabs can be registered under AHA as half Arabian! My beloved most special horse in all my life is a quarab and he's registered."
"Sounds like you might need a half-Arab, something crossed with a Morgan or a QH. Like you, I’ve currently got an amazing 14H Quarab with a smooth-ass trot, beauty, brains, and terrific feet."
#24
Friesian
3.5
(4)
"I love friesians! they’re so beautiful."
"My breed of choice for being wonderful, is friesian, but most are not beginner type horses."
"Friesians and Warlanders would fit too."
"I wouldn't go for a friesian. The aren't bred for riding and it Shows."
#25
Paso Fino
4.7
(3)
"Paso Fino- incredibly brave, willing, and eager to please. Very much comparable to an Arab with the sensitivity and showiness but far less spooky."
"Have you looked at Paso Finos? I love riding my little rocket."
"The lusitanos are very pretty but rather old and stiff. So I'd say either a paso, lippy or JW."
#26
Clydesdale
4.7
(3)
"I ADORE the clydesdales!! They’re also one of my favourites!"
"I’m talking one of those Clydesdales or shire horses that is so huge."
"I used to have a Clydesdale/Hackney cross and knew about a dozen of her siblings and nieces/nephews well"
#27
Gypsy Vanner
4.3
(3)
"Gypsy vanner!"
"I know lots of people who ride Gypsy vanners for mounted archery and they are much faster than I would ever imagine"
"I think ella needs a percheron."
#28
Paint
4.3
(3)
"My top faves are the paints"
"Paint or Belgian Warmblood for me"
"Paint horses"
#29
Belgian
4.3
(3)
"The top three are Belgian and French breeds."
"Belgian or Dutch Warmblood for me 🙏🏻 but I also love appy, aph, Percheron and Arab :)"
"Belgians, appaloosas, mustangs. all very nice horses that I enjoy riding the most."
#30
Belgian Draft
4.3
(3)
"Ella's needs a Belgian Draft horse like the Amish use to plow fields."
"Belgian draft chestnut. Can see a long way from all the way up here boi."
"Belgian Draft or a Morgan. I'm Belgian so i'm biased, and Morgan just cuz Arthur Morgan."
#31
Nokota
4.0
(3)
"Hands down the Nokota is the best, aka the 4x4 of the equine world."
"I really like the blue roan Nokota or grullo dun Mustang."
"It's pretty easily agitated at level 1 bonding, but it gets a lot better."
#32
Palomino
5.0
(2)
"I think it’s gonna end up being the palomino sabino because I love palominos."
"I have the palomino sabino and i really want the seal brown pinto! Highly recommend any colour tbh, they’re all SO cute!!"
#33
APH
5.0
(2)
"I love the APH and the JWH. Both their trots are adorable and I love the APH’s canter."
"I love the APH. It really represents the type of stock horse I enjoy."
#34
PRE
5.0
(2)
"My girl is 7/8th PRE, love her to death! Brave, great mind, and willing."
"I have a PRE. They’re super, but bigger than 14hh but you can get them small, mine is 15.2 and is the smallest horse I’ve ever had."
#35
Klad
5.0
(2)
"The Klad is a great horse."
"I pulled the trigger on the Klad, it has been treating me well."
#36
Gypsy Cob
4.5
(2)
"...but just fun to run in and knock like 3-4 bandits at once and highly likely one shot them, is a shire."
"Gypsy Cob I just think they’re neat."
#37
Paint Horse
4.5
(2)
"I suggest (just my opinion) -Quarter horse -Appaloosa -Morgan -Paint"
"* Mustang * Appaloosa * Tennessee Walker * American Paint Horse * Belgian Warmblood"
#38
Irish Cob
4.5
(2)
"Irish Cob. Sweet, steady, family oriented, smart. Not too big but not too small and don't need alot of feed."
"Also irish cob. scrolling thru the comments made me realize i forgot a main lol"
#39
American Paint Horse
4.5
(2)
"I LOVE the american paint horse in western tack the most"
"Love me an american paint horse."
#40
Saddlebred
4.0
(2)
"Saddlebred. its the first "show" quality horse in game and as an ex show girly i fell in love with it."
"Wait for the saddlebreds or check the spoilers."
#41
American Standardbred
4.0
(2)
"My last 2 that I tamed and the 2 I'm switching between atm are the all black American Standardbred and a brown with white face Thoroughbred both purely because I like their aesthetic."
"American standard bred and Mustangs are great."
#42
Gaited Horse
4.0
(2)
"I agree that our gaited horses are pretty problem free."
"Really any gaited breed is a good place to start IMO."
#43
Ardennes
4.0
(2)
"Bought the Bay Roan Ardennes from the stables which I love to death, one of the best-looking horses in the game IMO."
"Available through a glitch similar to the 'biscuit' glitch."
#44
Tennessee Walker
3.5
(2)
"* Mustang * Appaloosa * Tennessee Walker * American Paint Horse * Belgian Warmblood"
"I bought the cheapest 'nice' horse I could. Which I believe was a Tennessee Walker."
#45
Zangersheide
5.0
(1)
"The top three studbooks in terms of results are Zangersheide, BWP and SF."
#46
Collector Horse
5.0
(1)
"The collector one has the best stats if memory serves me correctly."
#47
Bounty Hunter Horse
5.0
(1)
"I'm really digging the level 20 Bounty Hunter horse. It sounds mean."
#48
Black Horse
5.0
(1)
"If you didn't keep the black horse you were given to sell from Chapter 1, you already missed out on the best horse."
#49
Kladruber
5.0
(1)
"I love my Kladruber!!"
#50
Haflinger, Connemara
4.0
(1)
"I would suggest a Halflinger! Sounds perfect if you want that stocky feel. A couple people have suggested Connemaras. I have two of them, they are absolutely fabulous horses but they are a sporting breed and can have more challenging temperaments."
#51
Pony of the Americas
4.0
(1)
"Pony of the Americas! Very underrated breed in my opinion."
#52
Quarter Horse, Paint, Icelandic
4.0
(1)
"You can find lots of sturdy 14hh grade Quarter horses and paints these days. Also Icelandics are lovely if you’re into gaited horses."
#53
Connemara, Pony of the Americas, Cob
4.0
(1)
"Agree about a connie, or a pony of the americas. Probably something cob-like."
#54
Criollo, Nokota, Brindle Thoroughbred
4.0
(1)
"I've great experience with the criollo recently. Beautiful coats, great health and stamina stats, and great speed."
#55
Missouri Fox Trotter, Norfolk Roadster
4.0
(1)
"Missouri Fox Trotters or Norfolk Roadsters"
#56
Arabian, Norfolk Roadster
4.0
(1)
"Best horses are black Arabian, Norfolk roadster and the collector role horse"
#57
American Paint
4.0
(1)
"American paint Overo or Tobiano. The Pearlino Andalusian the white and chestnut Arabian are all found in the wild from chapter 2."
#58
JWH
4.0
(1)
"I've used my JWH in champs multiple times and done really well."
#59
Akhal-Teke
4.0
(1)
"Akhal-Teke - they’re sturdy, extremely intelligent and sociable."
#60
Pinto
4.0
(1)
"I have the red roan pinto!"
#61
Warmblood
4.0
(1)
"Certain lines of warmblood horses (Dutch, Swedish, German, etc) as well as Thoroughbreds."
#62
MFT
4.0
(1)
"You can get the Silver Dapple MFT in Chapter 2."
#63
American Standard
4.0
(1)
"Can be purchased from the stable in Valentine during the hunting mission with Hosea."
#64
English Thoroughbred
4.0
(1)
"I’ve gotten my best high scores with mine. Plus I absolutely just love them."
#65
Hungarian Half Bred
4.0
(1)
"His Hungarian Half Bred is also pretty good and resilient."
#66
Fresian
4.0
(1)
"Fresian id go with, maybe arabian."
#67
Jorvik Wild Horses
4.0
(1)
"They are a fictional breed unique to Jorvik."
#68
Cob
4.0
(1)
"If you like the thick and hairy breeds, try a cob/Vanner."
#69
Cerberus
4.0
(1)
"Cerberus! I wish the brand stayed on him, but yes. Definitely a fine horse."
#70
Kentucky Saddler
4.0
(1)
"My kentucky saddlers is best girl."
#71
Nakota
4.0
(1)
"Nakota"
#72
Missouri Foxtrotter
4.0
(1)
"My favorite horse breed has got to be the Missouri Foxtrotter."
#73
Dutch Thoroughbred
4.0
(1)
"Dutch thoroughbred pleasantly surprised me"
#74
Appendix (QH/TB mix)
4.0
(1)
"Appendix (qh/tb mix) they’re gorgeous, athletic, and known for their compatibility and intelligence"
#75
Gaited horses
4.0
(1)
"I’ve been really loving riding the gaited horses at the ranch I work at."
#76
Buell
3.0
(1)
"There's some horses you might want to look out for though because they're pretty good, like Buell or the Braithwraite horses in Ch. 3"
#77
Breton
3.0
(1)
"Just got a Breton and a kladruber and the Breton is so fussy."
#78
Warlander
3.0
(1)
"Friesians and Warlanders would fit too."
#79
Draught Crosses
3.0
(1)
"Draught Crosses are pretty cool."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
