Lip Liner reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 243 Reddit reviews across 15 subreddits and 68 posts to rank the best Lip Liner brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Sephora, r/MakeupAddiction, r/OliveMUA, r/Makeup, r/PaleMUA. Top-rated brands include NYX (4.4/5), MAC (4.6/5), Charlotte Tilbury (4.9/5).
Stats
Reviews243
Subreddits15
Posts68
Brands51
Products79
243 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
NYX
4.4
(49)
"Def my personal holy grail."
"If I'm feeling cool: Nyx lip liner in Brooklyn Thorn."
"If I'm feeling warm: Nyx lip liner in Los Angeles 2.0."
"My go to lip liners are Nyx Nude Truffle and Charlotte Tilbury Foxy Brown."
"👍"
"Works wonders with these lip oils , I’d suggest any brown shade."
"NYX Mauve; Bobbi Brown Pale Mauve."
"It's NOT orange or bright or baby pink or too dark. It's actually my lip color."
"Nyx line loud lasts forever."
"My favorite liners ever are the nyx line loud."
#2
MAC
4.6
(40)
"Mac stone!"
"Love this one"
"This is a very nice brown"
"Glossier and Mac are my two favorite."
"Mac, or makeup forever"
"Another vote for MAC"
"MAC and Lancome."
"MAC but I also love makeup by Mario ones"
"MAC lipliners baby. They are THE BEST. Gorgeous colors to choose from and the formula is perfection."
"Not carried in US Sephora stores, but MAC still has the best, imo."
#3
Charlotte Tilbury
4.9
(31)
"Charlotte tilbury pillow talk with sleepy girl!"
"I love Charlotte tilbury walk of no shame with raspberry jelly"
"Charlotte tilbury lip liners, swatch them in store next to any brands and give them a minute to dry down you won’t be disappointed"
"Pillow Talk by charlotte... just perfect"
"I have CT Iconic nude and can second that recommendation."
"A lot of medium toned olive and tan skin tones look good in a color like Charlotte Tilbury Iconic Nude."
"I love Charlotte tilbury lipliners. My favorite shade is pillowtalk medium."
"Stay on even through meals."
"Of these for a beginner get CT."
"Charlotte tilbury."
#4
Maybelline
4.6
(10)
"Creamy but last well."
"Have you tried the new Maybelline tattoo lip liners?"
"Maybelline lifter liners! Theyre creamy when you apply, then they set down like gel eyeliners and dont budge"
"Sooo creamyy and stays put .. It’s the only lipliner product which I love and use."
"Had great staying power. Wasn’t in that really pink/red and more of a neutral lip for me."
"Maybelline lifter liner. It's brand new and man that stuff stays on better than any liner."
"I just got Maybelline lifter liner in Line leader and I'm liking it so far."
"Maybelline lifter liner."
"Maybelline colorsensational."
"Maybelline Coloursensational (tied with Revlon: creamy, long-lasting, easy to apply."
#5
Rimmel
4.3
(10)
"Rimmel cappuccino, Unearthly Cursed, MUFE endless cacao are ones I have without the orangeyness."
"Rimmel london cappuccino"
"Rimmel Cappuccino is a really nice cool brown."
"Rimmel Cappuccino sheered out?"
"Rimmel cappuccino is a great affordable option!"
"Rimmel’s ‘Cappuccino’ is good as it is a darker, neutral brown."
"Cappuccino from rimmel is cute."
"I use rimmel in cappuccino."
"I use rimmel in cappuccino."
"Some are too hard some are creamier."
#6
Colourpop
4.7
(9)
"Colourpop lip liner and lippie stix in Oh Snap. Perfect pinky mauve nude."
"Colourpop lip liners are very comfortable."
"Colourpop (yes, it requires international shipping, but they're super creamy & just glide on."
"Colourpop has ton of colors and are super creamy."
"I really like ColourPop’s lip liners."
"I just bought the shade julia a few weeks ago and I’m in love with formula and shade."
"Colourpop has good lip liners."
"Colourpop, they are at 7$ each but they have the bundle on their website."
"I really like Color Pop! It's very affordable and haven't had any issues."
#7
Makeup Forever
4.6
(8)
"Makeup Forever Wherever Walnut — neutral, not too warm, natural pink."
"Lasts all day."
"MUFE lip liner is my holy grail."
"Make up Forever liners are my all time favourite and they glide like butter."
"Nothing beats mac and makeup forever."
"I really like overlining with wherever walnut (makeup forever) and liar (urban decay)."
"I’d go with Makeup Forever in wherever walnut."
"Make up for ever, lip and eye pencils."
#8
Huda Beauty
4.8
(6)
"I use huda beauty lip liners they are smooth and bendable and don't break easily"
"I really like huda beauty lip liners!"
"Huda Beauty lip liner in warm brown🤌🏻🤌🏻."
"I just bought the Huda one and I love it so much."
"I randomly purchased this one day at a Sephora in Spain and I ended up LOVING IT."
"I would avoid rare beauty. I love the shades but the formula is not very long-lasting."
#9
Revlon
4.6
(5)
"And the elf lip oil in jam session- and it’s so so pretty def recommend"
"The Revlon Colourstay liners have great longevity."
"Revlon colorstay lip liner."
"Revlon Colourstay (tie."
"I use Revlon colorstay lip liner. I like the colorstay, maybelline superstay, and L’Oréal infallible collections for lip products."
#10
Rare Beauty
4.5
(4)
"I love the Rare Beauty! So creamy and easy to use."
"Is my favorite out of these."
"Rare beauty is great, a little drying, but good color payout."
"I like rare beauty, morphe, mac"
#11
MAC Lip Liner
5.0
(3)
"Mac lip liners are amazing"
"I like Mac lip liners ❤️❤️"
"Honestly this is gonna sound crazy....but I use Mac lip liner and then set it with a similar shade of eyeshadow."
#12
Press
5.0
(3)
"I’ve been wearing press and sugar cookie non stop since I received it last week!"
"I tried it on with my friends press lip shape and omg it's stunning."
"I bought press for a true pink combo and balance for a more natural pink look!"
#13
Sephora
5.0
(3)
"Sephora lip liners are great! I recommend you try out the following: 32 hot sauce - matte dirty rose or 24 rum raisin - matte mauve brown."
"Sephora or NYX Professional lip liners are the way to go!"
"I really loved the Sephora lipliners in the following colors: Nectarine and Dressed to the 90’s that are definitely nude on me."
#14
MUFE
5.0
(3)
"I like Anywhere Caffeine"
"They have a ton of very nuanced brown shades to choose from."
"A lot of people swear by Endless Cacao"
#15
Wherever
4.3
(3)
"I have wherever walnut and i LOVEEE it!"
"I think wherever walnut looks good with most shades! I use this lip liner with raspberry jelly and it also turns out to be a great combo."
"I’ve seen people using wherever walnut with it :) I’m sure anywhere caffeine would work too"
#16
Sephora Collection
4.3
(3)
"Sephora collection has the best lip liner hands down."
"I’ve been pleasantly surprised by the colors and quality."
"Sephora Collection 01 The Nudiest."
#17
RMS Beauty
4.3
(3)
"Have you looked at Nighttime Nude from rms beauty? That’s pretty spot on what you’re describing."
"I like sunset nude from rms beauty."
"Have you looked at Nighttime Nude from rms beauty?"
#18
Anastasia Beverly Hills
5.0
(2)
"I’m not a lip liner girlie at all but recently got an Anastasia lip liner in a set that I bought and I’ve been converted! They last so long, through eating and drinking all through the night!"
"Also, Anastasia liners are immovable"
#19
Fenty
5.0
(2)
"The Fenty ones last forever."
"Just recently tried the new fenty lip liners."
#20
ColourPop
5.0
(2)
"ColourPop Ashton I'm light olive hella muted and it's the best."
"Try ColourPop Ashton it's my fav."
#21
Natasha Denona
5.0
(2)
"I’m obsessed with their shades, lots of neutrals."
"It’s just amazing."
#22
Makeup by Mario
4.5
(2)
"MAC but I also love makeup by Mario ones"
"Makeup by Mario has a lot of good colors too but they don’t last nearly as long."
#23
Tarte
4.5
(2)
"Tarte, PMG, and Peripera are my longest-lasting liners."
"Toofaced & Tarte FTW!"
#24
Elf
4.5
(2)
"The new elf lip liners are super cheap and in my opinion are way better than nyx."
"Elf lip liners."
#25
Kylie
4.5
(2)
"Kylie lip kit! works for her works for me, might work for you."
"I’ve had good results with the lip liner in the Kylie lip kit and also NYX Line Loud."
#26
Glossier
4.5
(2)
"Glossier and Mac are my two favorite."
"Glossier is pretty good too"
#27
L.A. Girl
4.5
(2)
"😍"
"For super creamy non drying lip liner I quite like the La Girls shockwave lip liners."
#28
Make Up For Ever
4.5
(2)
"The extreme makeupforever ones and the fenty ones don’t budge."
"Makeup forever Endless line"
#29
Milani
4.0
(2)
"Milani spice."
"Milani Spice might work."
#30
Mac
4.0
(2)
"Mac half-red matches pretty well"
"MAC Half-Red"
#31
Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat
4.0
(2)
"Never tried it myself but I was thinking Charlotte Tilbury lip cheat in savage rose?"
"My everyday lip is Burt’s hibiscus with charlotte tilbury lip cheat in pillow talk."
#32
NYX Suede Matte Lip Liner
4.0
(2)
"Something more affordable: nyx suede matte lip liner"
"Nyx cosmetics suede matte lip liner"
#33
Essence
4.0
(2)
"If you’ve never tried one before I would first try a super cheap one! Like a $3 essence or LA girl product (ulta)"
"Check out Essence and la girl lip liners 😌"
#34
Morphe
5.0
(1)
"They're so creamy they literally just glide on smoothly."
#35
Urban Decay
5.0
(1)
"I can't believe no one is mentioning urban decay they're literally so smooth and won't come off!"
#36
Dior
5.0
(1)
"It's designed to work with Dior lipsticks, providing long-lasting wear and helps to prevent feathering."
#37
Rhode Lip Liners
5.0
(1)
"Alsooo i believe rhode plans on launching lip liners soon :)"
#38
Endless
5.0
(1)
"I’m fair neutral tone and I love endless cacao with it! Wherever walnut is good too!"
#39
Tower 28
5.0
(1)
"**Tower 28** has liners, gloss, and other lip products that are AMAZING for sensitive skin."
#40
Peripera
5.0
(1)
"Tarte, PMG, and Peripera are my longest-lasting liners."
#41
PMG
5.0
(1)
"Tarte, PMG, and Peripera are my longest-lasting liners."
#42
Annabelle
5.0
(1)
"LITERALLY NEVER MOVE and work perfectly with the Elf lip oils!"
#43
Haus Labs
5.0
(1)
"I line with the Haus Labs Lip Crayon sometimes and it lasts forever."
#44
Bobbi Brown
5.0
(1)
"I really recommend Bobbi Brown pale mauve."
#45
Lisa Eldridge
5.0
(1)
"Lisa Eldridge Sculpt and Shade Lip Liner in 1C. Everything else is orange or brown on me!"
#46
Jones Road
5.0
(1)
"If you like mauves - Jones Road make a great one."
#47
lilybyred
4.0
(1)
"The cool shade from lilybyred swatched on others too and that also looks like something that you might like."
#48
Unleashia
4.0
(1)
"I bought the Unleashia one and it was too light for me but it might work for you."
#49
Kylie Cosmetics
4.0
(1)
"It’s a lot warmer than stone while still be decidedly cool toned."
#50
LA Colors
4.0
(1)
"Iced coral from la colors has a similar look"
#51
Colour Pop
4.0
(1)
"Colour pop has a color for every occasion"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
