Mid Size Suv reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 333 Reddit reviews across 13 subreddits and 101 posts to rank the best Mid Size Suv brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/whatcarshouldIbuy, r/askcarguys, r/homestead, r/daddit, r/CarsAustralia. Top-rated brands include Mazda (4.4/5), Toyota (4.3/5), Honda (4.4/5).
Stats
Reviews333
Subreddits13
Posts101
Brands41
Products81
333 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Mazda
4.4
(53)
"For our family of 4, we love our Mazda CX-9. You can find low mileage CPO examples for well under $35k, majority under $30k. 2022 was the best year, IMO."
"Mazda cx5 and subaru forester"
"Look into a higher trim CX5 or slightly used X3 with extended warranty."
"CX5."
"Mazda CX50!!"
"EASY MAZDA CX-5"
"Mazda CX-5. Recommend from the biggest boned driver."
"Great safety ratings and it's good value for money."
"I'm partial to the Mazda CX-5, especially with the turbo engine. It's a very nice vehicle with the right amount of comfort, power, and utility for most people."
"I definitely need to test drive the Mazda CX-30 and Mazda CX-5, I’ve heard really good things about them"
#2
Toyota
4.3
(44)
"Add Toyota RAV4 to your list. They are one of the best selling vehicles in the country, so they are not hard to find used."
"Toyota Highlander Hybrid or Crown Signia Hybrid"
"Equivalent to the Corolla Cross and Rav4 for Toyota"
"Equivalent to the Corolla Cross and Rav4 for Toyota"
"Toyota Rav 4s are the best mid-size suv in that price range, in my opinion."
"The best vehicle all around SUV I’ve owned is a Toyota Sequoia..."
"Start with RAV4, as it's the gold standard for compact SUV."
"If you can afford it get a 4runner, they are some of the best built vehicles on the road."
"I bought a 2020 RAV4 LE AWD Hybrid a month ago. Love it."
"We went with a new rav4."
#3
Honda
4.4
(42)
"Latest gen Honda crv which came out in 2023, which I have. Used you can find one for low 30’s. I get high 30’s to 40 mpg with awd."
"Honda CRV Hybrid. I'm 6'2", and it fits me fine. Super quiet, especially in the Sport Turing Trim. Great gas mileage."
"The ones between 2013-2017 (RM series 1 and 2) are really good because they have a traditional automatic (no CVT)..."
"If you’re not like super concerned with fuel economy the Passport is by far my favorite in this segment."
"Honda Pilot."
"Another vote for the CRV."
"Honda pilot"
"Elevate best option."
"Equivalent to the HR-V and CR-V for Honda"
"Equivalent to the HR-V and CR-V for Honda"
#4
Subaru
4.3
(29)
"Subaru Forester or Outback."
"Had a list similar to yours and ended up with a Subaru Crosstrek and it really surprised me."
"Don't overlook the redesigned 2025 Subaru Forester."
"Subaru Ascent is pretty affordable for the class."
"Subaru hands down. They are built for utility and have a lower cost of ownership than VW."
"Subaru Outback, Touring XT (turbo) - Touring XT is the highest trim. $44k new, you can find low mileage used ones for $30k."
"For outdoor stuff and great space hard to beat a Subaru Outback or Forester."
"Friend of mine was involved in an accident and had to total his Corolla. He did extensive research regarding safety and got a 2019 forester. They are pretty safe!"
"I absolutely love my 2019 Forester. I got the limited - but even the base model was nice!"
"Forester is your best bet for height and price tag."
#5
Hyundai
4.2
(24)
"If you're open to the bigger 3rd row options the Hyundai Palisade and Kia Telluride have some very impressive interiors and tech."
"I have a Palisade Calligraphy. We admittedly got it before the 3 SUVs you mention were out, but at the time it was by far the best value for the money."
"New Santa Fe. With Hyundai, the 10-year/100k powertrain warranty only applies to new or certified pre-owned."
"Hyundai palisade, I'm bigger than you and it's great."
"I decided on buying a 2019 Hyundai Santa Fe. It’s the best value and drives just as good."
"You'd probably get more bang for your buck with the Hyundai Santa Fe."
"Hyundai Santa Fe is surprisingly affordable and nice."
"Most affordable is going to be the Hyundai sante fe or Kia sorento but I don’t know if I trust the powertrains long term yet like I would a Toyota Highlander."
"But avoid the white ones, the paint falls off. The diesel ones are fantastic!"
"Go sit in some new Hyundai vehicles."
#6
Kia
4.5
(18)
"If you're open to the bigger 3rd row options the Hyundai Palisade and Kia Telluride have some very impressive interiors and tech."
"The Kia Telluride is at the top of it's class on most review sites."
"Got the 2024 kia sportage ex hybrid 7 months ago. I really cannot imagine there being a better car in the $30k price range"
"I have a friend and family that have purchased Kia Seltos(es?) and really enjoyed them."
"Have you looked into a Sportage? Feels like a better version of a Tucson in my opinion."
"The Kia Telluride is rated highly."
"Spacious, but drives smaller than it is."
"If it were me, it would be a loaded Kia Telluride in that class."
"Telluride."
"I just got a Seltos S AWD which has all the latest safety tech and gets ~30 mpg."
#7
Ford
4.0
(18)
"Ford Maverick. It’s not an SUV but it feels like one and has a lot of headroom from what I remember."
"Ford Escape hybrid"
"Ford Maverick Hybrid. Low cost, you get a truck with a bed with it which is plenty of truck for 95% of the truck stuff people need. It's 4 inches longer than a Honda Accord. 37 combined MPG."
"Hybrid versions of SUVs are still in short supply for most automakers; Toyota especially. CRV or Escape will be easiest to acquire."
"Ford Maverick hybrid sounds like what you want."
"I really liked the explorer better than most of the others."
"They're pretty comfy and roomy."
"I'm looking at the 2022 Ford Maverick. Its pretty affordable, hybrid, has a small bed and 5 seats."
"Ford Flex."
"How about the Ford Explorer? I have had several and they are super nice and very versatile."
#8
Acura
4.3
(12)
"Look at a CPO MDX type S or MDX a-spec advanced."
"You’d probably like an Acura RDX regular or a-spec."
"We’ve been extremely happy with our 2014 MDX. It’s been bulletproof since we bought it new."
"Acura RDX. By far the most affordable luxury SUV on the market."
"We got a 2020 MDX a year ago for $33k, nice interior, reliable, plenty of space."
"I think the Acura MDX Type-S leases pretty well and is more roomy than the smaller X5/GLE."
"Check out the Lexus UX, Mazda CX-30, CX-5, Volvo XC40, and Acura RDX."
"Wife is roughly your size, drives an Acura MDX."
"Acura RDX V6."
"Used ~2015 Acura RDX may hit your needs well."
#9
Lexus
4.7
(9)
"You can get a 2016-2018 RX 450h for around or under $30K. They’re great cars. My best friend has one and gets an honest 30 MPG in all driving situations."
"Lexus RX series. It's not free, but my Mom has a 2007 hybrid and it's still going strong."
"Rented a ‘22 rx350 for the month while my car was getting worked on, great vehicle"
"You can easily find a 2016+ RX350 for under $30k. Still haven’t had any issues with mine in 15 years."
"Nothing but good things to say about them."
"Lightly used Lexus RX. It'll run forever, too."
"Mid Size: Lexus RX 350h/450h, , Toyota Highlander or Grand Highlander, a high mileage BMW X5e"
"Check out the Lexus UX, Mazda CX-30, CX-5, Volvo XC40, and Acura RDX."
"Lightly used Lexus RX. It'll run forever, too."
#10
BMW
4.4
(9)
"The 40i engine is powerful and reliable (inline 6). For me both cars are the gold standard of compact and midsize SUV."
"The 40i engine is powerful and reliable (inline 6). For me both cars are the gold standard of compact and midsize SUV."
"X1 is hands down the best of that bunch."
"2023 X1 without a doubt. The best option."
"Used BMW X5. Yes actually!"
"Bmw x3 m40i or Bmw x5 40i. 60k for used is a high budget."
"Bmw x3 m40i or Bmw x5 40i. 60k for used is a high budget."
"X5 is a nice car and decent value, especially if you're leasing."
"The BMW X5 is a unicorn."
#11
Volkswagen
4.4
(8)
"Vw atlas with a bench seat in the second row."
"The Atlas is an excellent vehicle."
"I drive a Volkswagen Atlas. I’m 6’7” and over 400 pounds and this is the first car I’ve felt is “me-sized.”"
"My wife likes the VW Atlas."
"Positively cavernous and are a standard pick for tall families."
"Great tech, is offered with Volkswagens famous VR6 motor."
"Might get an Atlas next time."
"Actually looking at a VW Touareg now too, looks like it has lots of towing power."
#12
Nissan
4.1
(8)
"2024 Nissan Pathfinder Rock Creek."
"Nissan Pathfinder might be worth a look"
"That new Pathfinder is genuinely ready nice."
"Of these I would lean toward Pathfinder."
"Look into the 2005-2015 Nissan Xterra. Strong 4 liter V6 with 265 HP..."
"Have you considered a CPO Nissan Murano?"
"Really dig my Murano. Plenty of engine and handles like a dream."
"Look for a Pathfinder or Xterra and do your research on a few of the typical issues."
#13
Chevrolet
4.0
(4)
"I'd recommend full size suv, 250 Suburban, Sequoia, Excursion, Tahoe, Armada."
"I currently lease a chevy blazer 2lt AWD."
"Older Chevy Tahoes, suburbans, yukons."
"Chevy Suburban is always a good choice."
#14
Audi
5.0
(3)
"Audi Q5 45 for sure."
"Try the 2021+ Audi Q5e plug in hybrid. You get 362hp and a 0-60 of 4.5sec and it’s the same size as your Rogue."
"German cars generally. Audi Q5."
#15
Mazda CX-5
5.0
(3)
"The pleasures of heated seats and no repairs has made life so pleasurable."
"Mazda CX-5 the Ford Bronco Sport should hit dealers soon and could be interesting."
"As a young adult, I can't recommend the cx-5 enough."
#16
Volvo
4.3
(3)
"Volvo XC40 is the most fun to drive."
"Volvo XC60 with the T8 engine (turbo, supercharger, and a hybrid component)."
"Check out the Lexus UX, Mazda CX-30, CX-5, Volvo XC40, and Acura RDX."
#17
Toyota RAV4
4.0
(3)
"We are looking at a RAV4 in the Adventure or Off road trim and a hitch."
"A Toyota RAV4 07-12 with the V6 and 4WD would be a decent candidate."
"I love my RAV4, but why are you leasing?"
#18
Toyota Highlander
4.0
(3)
"Midsize would be like a Toyota Highlander or Honda pilot, Hyundai palisade, Kia telluride, etc."
"Toyota Highlander, Lexus RX, 2006+ Honda Pilot, Acura MDX."
"Any interest in the next class up in size? Pilot/Highlander/CX-9? Because I think the CX-9 is great."
#19
Jeep
4.0
(3)
"I know these are love or hate but I have pretty good luck with Jeep Cherokees."
"As an owner of a 98 Grand Cherokee, I'd recommend that over basically anything else."
"My lady just bought a 2014 Jeep Patriot, it's an awesome car."
#20
GMC
2.8
(4)
"I have a GMC Acadia, I like it a lot and it has good room."
"A GMC Terrain w/ V6 and towing package will serve you well."
"Steer clear of the Acadia (garbage)."
"Steer clear of the Acadia (garbage)."
#21
Honda CR-V
5.0
(2)
"Honda CR-V 6, it just came out and it appears to be a really nice vehicle."
"Runs great, no issues at ALL!"
#22
Genesis
5.0
(2)
"I went with the GV70. Loving it."
"The genesis gv80 is an amazing suv for the price!"
#23
Mazda CX-9
4.5
(2)
"CX-9 Signature trim ticks all those boxes. We have one and love it."
"Any interest in the next class up in size? Pilot/Highlander/CX-9? Because I think the CX-9 is great."
#24
Honda Odyssey
4.5
(2)
"I like our Sportage but there is not room between the two car seats to sit another person."
"The Honda Odyssey ;)"
#25
BMW X5
4.5
(2)
"I drive a used BMW X5."
"Second vote for the BMW X5. I had a 2010 diesel that was bar none the most comfortable ride."
#26
Toyota 4Runner
4.5
(2)
"4 runner with a 6x12 utility trailer should do the job."
"The 4Runner is reliable for sure, my uncle in Kimberley BC has 560k km on his 2007 V8 SR5 and the drivetrain has never once been apart."
#27
Honda Pilot
4.0
(2)
"Midsize would be like a Toyota Highlander or Honda pilot, Hyundai palisade, Kia telluride, etc."
"Any interest in the next class up in size? Pilot/Highlander/CX-9? Because I think the CX-9 is great."
#28
Honda Passport
4.0
(2)
"Honda PassPort is a good car you can buy."
"The Passport might be a better option than the Pilot for your situation."
#29
Chrysler Pacifica
4.0
(2)
"I would consider... the Dodge Durango, Jeep Grand Cherokee L, and Jeep Wagoneer L."
"I have also driven rental Chrysler Pacifica minivans."
#30
Hyundai Tucson
4.0
(2)
"Tucson should fit your bill."
"New Tucson looks spectacular."
#31
Kia Sorento
4.0
(2)
"Instead of the new Hyundai Sante Fe go for the Kia Sorento Hybrid."
"I think the Kia Sorento would be a good buy for you."
#32
Buick
4.0
(2)
"Buick Envision is probably your best choice."
"Buick Enclave. Easy to get in and out of. Has a lot of nice touches inside."
#33
Mitsubishi Outlander
4.0
(1)
"Mitsubishi Outlander (not the sport). I had one for 5 years and I'd go back."
#34
Mitsubishi Outlander Sport
4.0
(1)
"Mitsubishi Outlander Sport under 50k miles. They're extremely underrated SUVs."
#35
Acura RDX
4.0
(1)
"First generation Acura RDX. With low miles it's a great deal."
#36
Infiniti
4.0
(1)
"Infiniti FX35 ('10+), Acura RDX, Mazda CX-5."
#37
Dodge
4.0
(1)
"Dodge Durango as well. Both fun."
#38
Suzuki Grand Vitara
4.0
(1)
"Suzuki Grand Vitara, under 5k, will haul as well if not better than a Subaru."
#39
Mitsubishi
4.0
(1)
"Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV is probably your best bet. Even if you don’t have your own garage to install a plug, it has various drive modes and can still operate as a regular hybrid."
#40
Lincoln
4.0
(1)
"I like the Corsair and that would be my top choice from your list"
#41
Hyundai RAV4
3.0
(1)
"The Hyundai's have improved over the last few years."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
