New York Pizza reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 154 Reddit reviews across 14 subreddits and 15 posts to rank the best New York Pizza brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/bullcity, r/Louisville, r/longbeach, r/summervillesc, r/denverfood. Top-rated brands include Randy's (4.0/5), King's (5.0/5), Old School (4.6/5).
Stats
Reviews154
Subreddits14
Posts15
Brands93
Products0
154 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Randy's
4.0
(8)
"Randy’s on Miami is by far the best of all their other locations, IMO. Lake Boone and Northgate tie for second."
"Randy's MLK or Hope Valley. They're owned by randy. The other randy's locations are franchises iirc, and theres some quality issues."
"Order Randy's well done."
"Randy’s at Northgate is my everyday take out spot."
"Randy’s!"
"Randy’s (the one closest to the JCC) Single slices are often bigger than from the typical pie you’d order for takeaway"
"Their cheese or pepperoni slices are straight up NY style and really good."
"Randy’s I guess…It used to be better."
#2
King's
5.0
(5)
"Kings on Live Oak Drive or Ladson Road... Hands down the best pizza in the area."
"I like King's on Ladson Rd. Best I've had in that area for NY style."
"The owner is from NY and taught his people how to make them right. I too recommend this place"
"Kng’s on Ladson or Italian Bistro in Knightsville"
"King's pizza off Ladson is amazing imo!"
#3
Old School
4.6
(5)
"Old school is the best NY style in the city."
"Old School in Norton Commons!"
"Old School NY Pizza"
"Old School NY Pizza, Goodfellas, Spinellis. All are decent NY style pizza places."
"Old School NY is my favorite (The Brooklyn Style with whole garlic cloves on it), but it’s expensive."
#4
Goodfellas
4.2
(5)
"Goodfella's is the most like a NY street style slice."
"As a native NY'er (upstate not city) I can tell you it's the closest thing to a taste of home for me."
"Goodfellas if you can get them to reheat the slices. Wheated is phenomenal right out of the oven."
"Goodfellas is my vote."
"Old School NY Pizza, Goodfellas, Spinellis. All are decent NY style pizza places."
#5
Sophia’s
4.0
(5)
"If you want a real authentic Ny pizza go to Sophia’s pizza in Durham in angier ave"
"After that, Hutchins or Sofia’s."
"Sofias in East Durham"
"For "New York" style, Pie Pushers and Sofia's."
"Sophia’s (East Durham) is okay and is more affordable."
#6
New York Pizza Company
4.5
(4)
"New York Pizza Company"
"NY Pizza Company on Frankfort Ave and it was phenomenal in our opinion. Great foldable crust, good flavor."
"New York Pizza Company."
"There is a new place called New York Pizza Co"
#7
Alfredo's
4.3
(4)
"I second Alfredos. Don’t sleep on the subs sandwiches and pasta dishes, too, such as the homemade lasagne and baked ziti. The perfect neighborhood pizza joint."
"Another vote for Alfredo's!"
"Damn good pizzas, too!"
"Alfredo’s (dunno if there’s more than one location, but the one next door to the movie theater in CH is good)"
#8
Slice of New York
4.3
(4)
"They make their own dough and sauce. The slices are proper giant NYC style slices where you gotta fold it and let the grease drip off a little."
"Slice of New York in Seal Beach"
"Slice of New York in seal beach is quite good!"
"Slice of New York Pizza is solid, good eggplant parm as well."
#9
Fat Sully’s
4.3
(4)
"Fat Sullys is the best NY style I’ve had here as well"
"I love Fat Sully’s as a NYC slice."
"Fat Sully’s is a bit closer to a cliche slice, and it’s really good"
"Fat sullys for a pizza by the slice. Best slices IMO"
#10
Schainos
3.8
(4)
"Danos, Schainos, Labrascas, and village idiot"
"Papa gios in irmo or schianos"
"Try Schianos!"
"Closest authentic NY pizza is Danos which is on Rosewood ave, next is Schianos. Don’t expect either of them to actually taste as good as NY pizza."
#11
Milana's New York Pizzeria
5.0
(3)
"Milanas is the answer."
"Milanas is second to none."
"Milana’s New York Pizzeria in downtown is my favorite New York-style slice in the city by far. Their white pizza is second to none"
#12
Italian Bistro
5.0
(3)
"Italian Bistro is the closest we’ve found to the pizza we always had in Queens!"
"Italian Bistro is also in Sangaree. They operate independently but are the same recioes and food."
"Italian bistro/sangaree pizza next to the food lion on main st is the best"
#13
Italian Pizzeria
4.0
(3)
"Now, if I don't feel like driving to Randy's, I definitely go to Italian Pizzeria on Guess Road. Their salads are amazing, and you get a LOT for the price."
"Italian pizzaria on guess is a mix of smells like oil, dirt, cigarettes and age that take me back to my grandmas house in nj so i love to eat there. Great stuff."
"Italian Pizzeria in Wellons Village. Darn near perfect but don't go after dark..."
#14
Devil's
3.7
(3)
"Devil’s (on 9th St) Ditto on single slice size"
"We like Devil’s Pizzeria on Ninth Street! Good pizza and good wings."
"There isn’t really any good pizza down here but if you had to choose, I’d either go with Devil’s or Sofia’s."
#15
Pizza Wagon of Brooklyn
5.0
(2)
"They’re the closest thing to authentic NYC pizza that I’ve had in LA."
"Pizza wagon of Brooklyn is the closest I've had to a NY style slice in all of Los Angeles."
#16
Prime
5.0
(2)
"Prime Pizza is great NY style pizza. There are a few locations in LA. The closest one is El Segundo."
"Prime in manhattan beach is as close as you can get in California."
#17
Antonio's
5.0
(2)
"Antonios Pizza is #1 in Summerville"
"Famulari's was my go to but now its Antonio's"
#18
Brooklyn South
5.0
(2)
"Hands down the most NY authentic tasting pizza in the area"
"Brooklyn south or Antonio's pizzeria. Ebenezer pizzeria in knights ville was surprisingly delicious also."
#19
Sidewall Pizza
5.0
(2)
"Sidewall, I think it’s better than Tarantino’s"
"Sidewall Pizza is positively *outstanding* if you can get in."
#20
Frascelli
4.5
(2)
"Frascelli's New York Deli and Pizza. It's just a short drive north of Louisville Off of Interstate 71 at Buckner. The owner is from Brooklyn and it's the real deal."
"Frascellis in Buckner"
#21
Little Coyote
4.5
(2)
"Little coyote has the best pizza ever!"
"Little coyote, speak cheesy, Milan’s and there is 4th horseman if you like lots of toppings"
#22
Anthony’s
4.5
(2)
"Anthony’s is always solid especially for here. Best slice I’ve had in this area frankly"
"I’m an Anthony’s guy for the NY Slice. My family is from NY and CT, so I’ve had plenty of slices from the source and to me it’s the closest here."
#23
Grimaldi's
4.5
(2)
"Grimaldis came in second for pepperoni, but their non-pepperoni pizza came in first overall."
"I like Grimaldi’s myself"
#24
Ricky’s
4.5
(2)
"Ricky’s!! They’re in North Durham, up Roxboro. Hands down the best in Durham."
"The answer is and has been Ricky’s off Latta and Roxborro…. This is coming from a fella who grew up south shore LI."
#25
Mimo's
4.0
(2)
"Honestly across the river Mimos. Very surprising"
"If you don't mind crossing the river check out Mimo's in New Albany."
#26
Domino's
4.0
(2)
"Dominos has just added a NY style pizza. They stretch their hand tossed crust bigger and cut into "6 foldable slices""
"Domino's NY style PLAIN cheese comes the closest."
#27
Hutchins
4.0
(2)
"After that, Hutchins or Sofia’s."
"Hutchins grandma pie!"
#28
Danos
3.5
(2)
"Danos, Schainos, Labrascas, and village idiot"
"Closest authentic NY pizza is Danos which is on Rosewood ave, next is Schianos. Don’t expect either of them to actually taste as good as NY pizza."
#29
Pizzeria Toro
3.5
(2)
"Pizzeria Torro and Ponysarus are both Neapolitan style, but they’re the best pizzas in Durham IMHO."
"Pizzeria Toro — it’s decent Neapolitan pizza, but it’s a bit pricy."
#30
Famularis
5.0
(1)
"Famularis is awesome"
#31
King's Pizza Express by Buontempo
5.0
(1)
"Kings Pizza Express by Buontempo in Moncks Corner is well worth the drive."
#32
Speak Cheezy
5.0
(1)
"I love Speak Cheezy’s sourdough crust"
#33
Bonnelo's
5.0
(1)
"Bonnelo's in San Pedro. So FREAKING good!"
#34
Secret Pizza
5.0
(1)
"If you can make the trip out there, Secret Pizza"
#35
Pietrini Pizza Napoletana
5.0
(1)
"Specializing in traditional 12” Neopolitan-style and 18” NY-style pizza, cheers!"
#36
Noble Funk Brewery
5.0
(1)
"Noble Funk Brewery. Fantastic coal oven pizza"
#37
Hops n Pie
5.0
(1)
"Best NY I’ve had in Denver"
#38
Cosmo’s
5.0
(1)
"Being from NY, Cosmo’s is going to be your best bet for an authentic pizza."
#39
Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage
5.0
(1)
"Audrey Jane’s Pizza Garage in Boulder is my favorite NY slice style"
#40
Mozza
5.0
(1)
"Best New York style pizza if you're going pepperoni is Mozza."
#41
Pulcinella’s
5.0
(1)
"Don’t sleep on Pulcinella’s! I’m from NJ originally & a pizza asshole for sure. I’ve tried most of the places listed, but find myself regularly going back to Pulcinella’s. Half the price of Randy’s, always ready within 15-20 minutes, staff is great and pizza is awesome."
#42
Vici
5.0
(1)
"Vici near southpoint is the best NY style in Durham. Both the regular NY style and the grandma pie."
#43
Sal's
5.0
(1)
"Sal’s on 55. The best!"
#44
Alfredo's Pizza Villa
5.0
(1)
"Alfredo's Pizza Villa in Chapel Hill is my favorite pizza right now. Perfectly crispy underside, never chewy crust, just a delicious pizza."
#45
Bocci
5.0
(1)
"Bocci. My Brooklyn born father cried tears of joy when we went there."
#46
Pizza Kovatchi
5.0
(1)
"Pizza Kovatchi in Lexington is New York style pizza done right."
#47
Mario's
5.0
(1)
"When was in college there was a great place called Marios right across from the honeycombs. Fabulous place!"
#48
Altar Society
4.0
(1)
"Altar society out there—which imo is very solidly east coast ny style pizza but ironically not the tastiest out of all the other suggestions."
#49
Village Road Pizzeria
4.0
(1)
"Village Road Pizzeria."
#50
Flippin Pizza
4.0
(1)
"Flippin pizza on spring is the closest to joes in nyc imo"
#51
Lamonica's
4.0
(1)
"Take a trip to Westwood for Lamonica’s!"
#52
Vinny's
4.0
(1)
"I second Vinny’s and sangaree"
#53
Rosmarino's
4.0
(1)
"Check out Rosmarino's on Ladson near Dorchester."
#54
Vinny's Goose Creek, NY Pizzeria
4.0
(1)
"Vinny's Goose Creek, NY Pizzeria (on Rivers, sketch location but legit pizza), Sabatinos downtown."
#55
Labrasca's
4.0
(1)
"Danos, Schainos, Labrascas, and village idiot"
#56
Papa Gio's
4.0
(1)
"Papa gios in irmo or schianos"
#57
Sarah n Geo's
4.0
(1)
"Sarah n Geos in Ridgeway has a good pie."
#58
Magic John's
4.0
(1)
"Magic John’s is another fantastic spot in Berlin for New York-style pizza! Located in Mitte, they serve up classic, oversized slices with that authentic thin, foldable crust you're craving."
#59
Zola's Pizzeria
4.0
(1)
"Zola's Pizzeria While they're more known for Neapolitan-style pizza, they also have a solid New York slice! Their wood-fired oven ensures that perfect balance of chew and crisp."
#60
Standard Serious Pizza
4.0
(1)
"Standard Serious Pizza Located in Prenzlauer Berg, they serve up some of the best pizzas in Berlin, and their New York-style slices are top-notch."
#61
Boombozz
4.0
(1)
"Boombozz NY style add sausage is amazing."
#62
Spinelli's
4.0
(1)
"Old School NY Pizza, Goodfellas, Spinellis. All are decent NY style pizza places."
#63
Pop’s Backdoor
4.0
(1)
"I like Pop’s Backdoor! It’s not super close to NY but it scratches the itch."
#64
Georgina’s
4.0
(1)
"Georgina’s in Morrisville is great too."
#65
Toro
4.0
(1)
"Toro comes closest."
#66
Franks
4.0
(1)
"Franks in Raleigh. Really none in Durham"
#67
Pie Pushers
4.0
(1)
"For "New York" style, Pie Pushers and Sofia's. Used to love Randy's years ago but they are very bland and overly greasy these days."
#68
West Hillsborough Pizzeria
4.0
(1)
"Go one town over and hit West Hillsborough Pizzeria. Beats anything you'll find in Durham."
#69
John’s Pizzeria
4.0
(1)
"I would probably recommend John’s Pizzeria on 44th. It's pretty good NY style pizza, sit down, and serves wine."
#70
Benny Blanco’s
4.0
(1)
"Probably the closest I’ve had to anything back home in NY, honestly kinda reminds me of a spot my aunt used to take us to"
#71
Rosalee’s
4.0
(1)
"If you want New York pizza you go to Longmont and eat at Rosalee’s"
#72
Marquis
4.0
(1)
"Marquis was always my favorite NY style slice in Denver."
#73
Johnny’s
4.0
(1)
"Last NY slice I tried was Johnny’s. Twas pretty good"
#74
Johnny’s New York
4.0
(1)
"Johnnys New York on Wadsworth or Brooklyns Finest on S Broadway scratches that itch"
#75
Redeemer
4.0
(1)
"I recommend Redeemer, but it’s not quite 100% NY style"
#76
Big Bill's NY Pizza
4.0
(1)
"It's called: Big Bill's NY Pizza"
#77
Colombo's
4.0
(1)
"Colombo’s. Original owners were actually from NY."
#78
Galicanos
4.0
(1)
"Galicanos. He’s from NY."
#79
Pizzarito
4.0
(1)
"Pizzarito in the Marina Marketplace has a good NY thin crust, and they deliver."
#80
COOP Pizza
4.0
(1)
"COOP pizza in Palms fits the NY style pizza bill"
#81
Gino’s
4.0
(1)
"Not Durham but Gino’s in Raleigh in the shopping center at pleasant valley rd and glenwood. Owners from the Bronx or Bk I don’t remember."
#82
Di Fara
4.0
(1)
"It’s a little bit of a trek, but Di Fara or the Original NY Pizza in Cary."
#83
Emmy Squared
4.0
(1)
"Emmy Squared is Detroit style, and it’s also very good."
#84
Cugino Forno
4.0
(1)
"I think the best New York style is Cugino Forno."
#85
Roma
4.0
(1)
"Roma on Sherron in the Food Lion strip. Almost perfect."
#86
Donisi
4.0
(1)
"Donisi"
#87
DiOrios
4.0
(1)
"DiOrios"
#88
Wheated
4.0
(1)
"Wheated on Bardstown Rd."
#89
Papalinos
4.0
(1)
"Papalinos"
#90
Joe's
4.0
(1)
"Joe's in Sherman Oaks"
#91
Liberty Pizza
3.0
(1)
"Liberty Pizza."
#92
Famous J’s
3.0
(1)
"Famous J’s or Fat Sullys"
#93
The 4th Horseman
1.0
(1)
"The 4th horseman is hot trash. It smells and tastes like Chuck E. Cheese."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
