Pizza Place reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 298 Reddit reviews across 20 subreddits and 20 posts to rank the best Pizza Place brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/jerseycity, r/thousandoaks, r/thewoodlands, r/StLouis, r/tampa. Top-rated brands include Toppers (4.2/5), Slice House (3.5/5), Grimaldi's (3.8/5).
Stats
Reviews298
Subreddits20
Posts20
Brands99
Products3
298 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Toppers
4.2
(10)
"Toppers!!!!"
"Toppers and it’s not close."
"Toppers 😋"
"Toppers is, easily."
"Toppers"
"Toppers for pepperoini or hot sausage, or any of they're specialty pizzas."
"Toppers is all about getting plain cheese with cilantro, imho."
"Toppers or slice house"
"Toppers is for after my toddler's swimming lessons"
"Just disappointed in the flavor (or lack of) especially for the cost."
#2
Slice House
3.5
(11)
"Slicehouse was the last great slice I had - comparable to Apollonia's which is top rated for Los Angeles."
"In order: deninos, slice house, damores."
"I’m gonna say Denino’s. Slice house and fredas after that."
"Parma and slice house are best"
"Slice House"
"Toppers or slice house"
"Ingredients at those places is higher quality. So when toppers is basically the same price point at a fraction of the quality."
"Slice house"
"Slice House is good as well, but hit or miss depending on toppings/crust choices."
"Freda’s NY, Parma’s Detroit. Slice House 3rd place."
#3
Grimaldi's
3.8
(10)
"Grimaldi's is real Brooklyn pizza coal fired fantastic."
"Grimaldis in San Tan is awesome"
"Also Grimaldi's at West shore plaza."
"Grimaldi and RC Pizza are my goto"
"Grimalds Pizzeria-Hot Pizza"
"IMO is Grimaldis"
"Grimaldi’s"
"Grimaldi’s also doesn’t have the best customer service, but they use great ingredients and generally don’t have a bad experience if I sit down and eat there"
"Grimaldis is good! but the service is HORRIBLE"
"Grimaldis, Zanti, Fielding’s and Sorriso are the only decent pizza."
#4
Parma
4.0
(9)
"Parma without question in terms of Detroit style."
"Parma"
"Parma. But if you want to expand your radius, I would try Magma at Moorpark!"
"Freda’s NY, Parma’s Detroit. Slice House 3rd place."
"Parma is good for their Detroit style."
"Parma and slice house are best"
"Parma Pizza - Solid Detroit Style, but it has gotten very expensive."
"Parma"
"Honorable mentions for Parma"
#5
La Pizza
4.9
(7)
"La Pizza is crazy good, but it also isn’t St. Louis style which might be what OP is wanting."
"LaPizza is crazyyyy good."
"LaPizza, they have a new spot on Main Street in St. Charles."
"La pizza is ny style and really good."
"If you eat anywhere but LaPizza you will waste your money."
"La Pizza, no question."
"Katie's or La Pizza if you want something locally trendy."
#6
Pizza Tonight
4.9
(7)
"Pizza Tonight and Brothers are both delicious."
"Pizza Tonight is awesome!"
"Pizza tonight if you want the best delivery"
"For a whole pie (and pepperoni rolls!!) it's pizza tonight for me, specifically the whole schmear"
"Pizza Tonight is INCREDIBLE. XL Italian sausage and pepperoni is goated."
"Another vote for Pizza Tonight! Their calzones are great as well."
"While I prefer Pizza Tonight, every once in a while I’ll do Grimaldi’s and toss in a cannoli."
#7
Pizza Masters
3.8
(8)
"Pizza masters or rizzos :)"
"Pizza masters a solid 2nd"
"JC Heights: Pizza Masters, Gino’s, Rizzo’s"
"Pizza Masters though are my go to."
"Pizza Master’s on Central in the Heights."
"Pizza Master's, Lo Fi for Detroit style"
"I liked it as a kid, but always prefered pizza masters. For me, it was the second call if pizza masters was to busy that night."
"I live right by Pizza Masters - it’s alright."
#8
Razza
5.0
(6)
"Razza, by far."
"Neapolitan - Razza"
"For fancy sit down, Razza downtown is great"
"Downtown: Basille’s, Rustique, Krispy, Las Americas, Razza & Porta for restaurant experience"
"Razza for sit down."
"Razza"
#9
Peppino's
4.0
(7)
"Little Italy and peppinos for me"
"I like Pepinos and DePalmas"
"Pepinos or little Italy!"
"Peppino's but I did just have a fabulous Philly Cheesesteak pizza at the Eastside DePalma's so you got options."
"Peppinos. Two BIG slices and a drink for like $8."
"Peppinos, although owned by the same people, actually makes a decent pizza."
"I love Peppino's, but I also like Emmy Squared"
#10
Cappy's
4.3
(6)
"Cappy’s 100%"
"Cappy’s
This is the truth, they're SO good they only open for 4 hours Mon-Thurs"
"Of my 3 favorites, I like Three Brothers the best."
"#1 Lee's Grocery and tied at #2 Cappy's & Sally O'Neals"
"Cappys or Sally o Neal’s"
"If you want Tampa proper Cappys and Sally O’Neals are the OG"
#11
Freda's
3.4
(7)
"Freda's is my all around favorite in the area"
"Freda’s, and honorable mention mention to D’Amores"
"Fredas, Magma, or Two Doughs"
"I’m gonna say Denino’s. Slice house and fredas after that."
"Freda’s"
"Frieda's hot garbage"
"Friedas hot garbage"
#12
Faraci's
4.8
(5)
"Faraci's!! Closer to Chesterfield than these other spots and authentic St. Louis style pizza."
"If you are in Chesterfield, then you want Faraci's which is on Manchester Road."
"Faraci’s is so damn good!"
"Faraci’s isn’t too far from chesterfield, easily the best pizza in the St. Louis Region."
"Faraci’s if you want St. Louis style"
#13
Killer Crust
4.8
(5)
"Killer Crust again last weekend and it fired on all cylinders."
"Try killer crust!!!! it’s on oconee connector !"
"Killer krust out on Epps Bridge is really good."
"Killer Crust Pizza is the one pizzeria that has had me in a chokehold"
"Krust is pretty good"
#14
RC's
3.8
(6)
"RC’s is the best in our area hands down."
"RC's and Pizza Tonight."
"RC’s, Pizza Tonight, or Jet’s."
"RC's is great."
"RC’s tends to have terribly long waits and mediocre at best customer service but it’s good pizza."
"RC is hit or miss. Exactly half of the time, it's great. The other half of the time, it's been horrible."
#15
Pizzeria Da Gloria
5.0
(4)
"Pizzeria Da Gloria is the best pizza in St. Louis! Fresh woodfired pizza, ingredients from Itay, handmade, absolutely delicious!"
"Pizzeria de Gloria has really authentic taste. That would be my next choice"
"Pizzeria da gloria"
"If you’re willing to drive, Pizzeria da Gloria - but hurry"
#16
Domino's
2.7
(7)
"Kuch na ho toh dominos he best hai"
"Dominos hi accha lgta h mujhe pizza ke mamle mein"
"Then you can go with Domino's atleast they serve decent pizzas when there's no option available"
"Jab koi aur option na ho toh atleast dominos serves better than Pizza hut"
"Domino's ( personal opinion)"
"Dominons. all these cafés bars aint cook food for shit"
"Would rather have dominos"
#17
Denino's
3.8
(5)
"Deninos has the best pepperoni period. Thick and flavorful."
"Denino’s, although they have been “temporarily” closed for a while now."
"In order: deninos, slice house, damores."
"I’m gonna say Denino’s. Slice house and fredas after that."
"Denino's is good but I don't pay that much for pizza"
#18
Basile's
3.8
(5)
"Basile's (Hoboken location is a step up from the JC location) for traditional pizza and slices."
"Downtown: Basille’s, Rustique, Krispy, Las Americas, Razza & Porta for restaurant experience"
"Basille's, Two Boots for late night drunk slices."
"Basilles Delivery"
"You can do Basile's in a pinch."
#19
Brothers Pizza
3.8
(5)
"Brothers off grogans mill is my fav."
"Brothers Pizza for NYC thin slice cheese. Crust Pizza for specialty toppings."
"Brother’s is generally good, but I find their pizzas greasy."
"Brothers Pizza , but the service is hit or miss."
"Brothers used to be"
#20
Rizzo's
4.5
(4)
"Pizza by the slice: Rizzos in the Heights is a clear #1"
"My favorite slice is from Rizzos on Central Ave"
"Pizza masters or rizzos :)"
"JC Heights: Pizza Masters, Gino’s, Rizzo’s"
#21
Piesanos
4.3
(4)
"Piesanos has been the best for pizza"
"Piesanos for pizza/Italian"
"VALID takes on piesanos and Linda vista"
"Peisanos is good for pizza."
#22
Ameci's
4.3
(4)
"Seconding NP Amecis. Doug is great"
"The Ameci in Newbury Park is the best one I've ever been to by a million miles."
"Ameci's for work lunch calzone"
"When I’m in the mood for cheap, ameci pizza"
#23
Rustique
4.3
(4)
"Margherita - Rustique"
"Rustique"
"Downtown: Basille’s, Rustique, Krispy, Las Americas, Razza & Porta for restaurant experience"
"I like Rustique and Two Boots for delivery."
#24
Venezia's
4.3
(4)
"Absolutely, love Venezias!"
"Venenzias pizza by faaaaar the best for NY style."
"Love Venezias. If you want a sit down place, Grimaldis in San Tan is awesome"
"Venezia’s is fine hangout pizza, but never seems worth mentioning in a “best of” context."
#25
D'Amores
4.0
(4)
"Damores is the most consistent lightly well. Perfect imo."
"Honorable mention mention to D’Amores, esp the stromboli"
"I really have enjoyed the stuff I've gotten from D'Amores. Not saying it's the best but it's good and has good non-pizza stuff."
"In order: deninos, slice house, damores."
#26
Gino's
4.0
(4)
"JC Heights: Pizza Masters, Gino’s, Rizzo’s"
"Gino’s"
"My favorite is Gino’s in the Heights for a good NY slice."
"Gino’s"
#27
Sal's
4.7
(3)
"Just had Sals tonight. Excellent pizza."
"Surprised nobody has mentioned Sal's in Gilbert yet. Lots of solid recommendations here, but to me they are by far the best."
"You tried Sals in Gilbert? He’s from ny. I haven’t been there in years but it used to be very good."
#28
Lo Fi
4.7
(3)
"Lo-Fi is a very good Detroit Style with a nice cocktail list"
"Lo Fi for Detroit style"
"For NY's revenge on Detroit for what Dominos did to NY pizza, Lo Fi."
#29
Sally O'Neals
4.3
(3)
"Sally’s O’neals on south Howard - thank me later"
"#1 Lee's Grocery and tied at #2 Cappy's & Sally O'Neals"
"Cappys or Sally o Neal’s"
#30
Two Doughs
4.0
(3)
"Honorable mentions for Two Doughs (Agoura)"
"Fredas, Magma, or Two Doughs"
"Two Dough"
#31
Porta
4.0
(3)
"Porta is also quite good."
"Downtown: Basille’s, Rustique, Krispy, Las Americas, Razza & Porta for restaurant experience"
"Porta"
#32
Nona's
4.0
(3)
"Nona’s and Santoro’s"
"Nona's"
"Enjoyed that review. Will be trying Nona's soon."
#33
Little Italy
4.0
(3)
"Little Italy and peppinos for me"
"Little Italy hands down"
"Little Italy is usually pretty decent"
#34
Krispy
3.7
(3)
"Krispy has great square pies"
"Downtown: Basille’s, Rustique, Krispy, Las Americas, Razza & Porta for restaurant experience"
"Kristy is good, but only for individual slices."
#35
Little Caesar's
3.7
(3)
"Little Ceasars"
"Little Caesar’s stuffed pretzel crust."
"Little Caesar’s: It’s hot and ready."
#36
Magma
5.0
(2)
"Magma pizza in moorpark also rocks."
"Agree with your list but would add Magma in Moorpark for an excellent Napoli style."
#37
Otto's
5.0
(2)
"Otto's is genuinely good."
"Ottos pizza. End of discussion, it is by far the best gluten free pizza in Portland."
#38
Peppinos
5.0
(2)
"Peppinos for pizza (+ tiramisu!!!)"
"Peppinos for pizza. But only pizza. They have the best NY pie in town"
#39
Barros
5.0
(2)
"Our favorite Barros pizza is their Kona."
"Barros is my kids favorite, humble pie too, they do this honey under the crust that’s 🤤."
#40
Pizza Kat
5.0
(2)
"Pizza Kat!"
"Pizza Kat is my go to for gluten free. It’s amazing."
#41
Pagliai's pizza
5.0
(2)
"Pagliai's pizza in downtown Mankato uses a ton of cheese. In my opinion they are one of the best pizza joints in MN."
"Pagliai's pizza in downtown Mankato uses a ton of cheese. In my opinion they are one of the best pizza joints in MN."
#42
Fully Loaded
5.0
(2)
"I love Fully Loaded."
"Fully Loaded!"
#43
Toasted Pizza Co
5.0
(2)
"Also love Toasted pizza for Detroit style."
"Toasted Pizza Co out in Magnolia is also amazing."
#44
Pizzeria Bianco
5.0
(2)
"Pizzeria Bianco is outstanding."
"Pizza bianco"
#45
Bread and Salt
4.5
(2)
"Bread and Salt in the heights does a very good Roman Style."
"Bread and Salt
Overpriced Plain but a bit different - 10th St"
#46
Leonardo's
4.5
(2)
"Leonardo’s, Satchels and O sole Mio have fantastic pizza."
"Satchels/blue highway/leonardos for pizza"
#47
Satchels
4.5
(2)
"Leonardo’s, Satchels and O sole Mio have fantastic pizza."
"Satchels/blue highway/leonardos for pizza"
#48
Stadium Pizza
4.5
(2)
"Stadium Pizza down on rt 440 next to the old Kmart soon to be new Target."
"Stadium pizza."
#49
Butler's
4.5
(2)
"Thanks for putting Butler's (my current favorite) on your list."
"Honorable mentions for Butler’s"
#50
Pequods
4.5
(2)
"If you can , do the Pequads in MG , I feel the quality is better at the original."
"Pequods is good."
#51
Andy's
4.5
(2)
"Andy’s is the best in my opinion."
"Andy’s"
#52
Ruin House
4.5
(2)
"Ruin house serves the best pizza. And pro tip - there is live band on Wednesdays and no cover entry charges."
"Don’t expect much, but they do a decent job. The Ruin house is also one."
#53
Lee's Grocery
4.5
(2)
"#1 Lee's Grocery and tied at #2 Cappy's & Sally O'Neals"
"Lee’s Grocery"
#54
Toscano
4.5
(2)
"The fungi e cipolla beats everything else"
"Toscano"
#55
Renato's
4.5
(2)
"Renato Pizza Masters in the Heights is the best traditional pizza pizza in Jersey City."
"Renato’s"
#56
Rizzo's Bakery
4.5
(2)
"Rizzo’s Bakery though: that’s the good stuff. The pizza is damn good too."
"Rizzo. Bakery in front, pizza in back."
#57
Sally O’Neals
4.5
(2)
"Sally O’Neals!"
"If you want Tampa proper Cappys and Sally O’Neals are the OG"
#58
Tony's
4.5
(2)
"If you like cheap, New York style, pizza there’s no replacement for Tony’s in Newbury Park."
"Tonys"
#59
Pizza Hut
2.7
(3)
"I think Pizza Hut off Lima delivers that far"
"Yeah true kabhi psnd nahi aaya Pizza hut"
"Pizza hut ka crust bahut mota aur maida maida lagta hai"
#60
Napoli Bros
4.0
(2)
"Napoli bros if you want to stay close."
"Napoli Bros"
#61
2 Amys
4.0
(2)
"2 Amys is great Neapolitan but they sometimes crowd that oven way too much."
"2 Amys is the place to go in Cathedral Heights."
#62
Valentino's
4.0
(2)
"Valentino’s for just a classic, Friday night pizza"
"Valentinos! D’Amores is good but IMO expensive."
#63
Carmine's
4.0
(2)
"Carmines"
"Carmine's"
#64
Las Americas
4.0
(2)
"A step down from that is Las Americas"
"Downtown: Basille’s, Rustique, Krispy, Las Americas, Razza & Porta for restaurant experience"
#65
Pizzarelli's
4.0
(2)
"Get pizzarellis in Ellisville."
"Everyone is always sleeping on Pizzarelli’s and it upsets me."
#66
Katie's
4.0
(2)
"Katie's at Clayton and 141 is a good place. Somewhat upscale pizza and pasta."
"Katie's or La Pizza if you want something locally trendy."
#67
Mellow Mushroom
4.0
(2)
"Mellow Mushroom definitely deserves a shout, much better than most places people are naming"
"Napoli or Mellow Mushroom if you want to stay near your hotel and overpay for something you can get in any other biggish city."
#68
East Coast Pizza
4.0
(2)
"East Coast Pizza"
"East Coast Pizza"
#69
Crust Pizza
4.0
(2)
"Crust also solid if you want wings as well."
"Wife and I will occasionally share a Tuscan from Crust. Different but very good."
#70
New York New York
4.0
(2)
"New York New York pizza the best of the best."
"Beats Eddy and Sam's and New York New York."
#71
Papa John's
4.0
(2)
"Out of big name brand offerings, our papa John’s is really great. Fastest delivery, pizza is always good, etc."
"Papa John's east side rules, actually."
#72
Amici
4.0
(2)
"Otherwise I’ve had good pies from Amici"
"Amici, formerly buonos"
#73
Wood Fired Pizza
4.0
(2)
"More wood fire pizza keep them coming thanks brother"
"Wood Fired Pizza Wine Bar"
#74
Pompei
4.0
(2)
"2nd Pompei.. good crust to cheese/sauce ratio"
"Pompei on WSA is solid."
#75
Ted's
4.0
(2)
"No one said it’s truly amazing but it’s the best in this town. Ted’s is good too."
"I also enjoy Ted’s most best personally"
#76
Tino's
2.0
(3)
"Tino's Artisan is on my list to try but haven't yet"
"Skip, unless you're a transplant: Tino's"
"Tino's is an easy pass. The dough was sus and the sauce was tinny."
#77
Wise Guys
3.0
(2)
"Wise Guys definitely changed and isn’t as good. It’s still better than like 80% of other places though."
"Honorable mention to Slice&Pie on 14th St."
#78
Jimmy's
3.0
(2)
"Jimmy’s ,on Pulaski ( daytime only )."
"Skip, unless you're a transplant: Jimmy's"
#79
Two Boots
2.5
(2)
"Rustique and Two Boots for delivery. Basille's, Two Boots for late night drunk slices."
"Skip, unless you're a transplant: Two Boots."
#80
Taste Budz
2.5
(2)
"TasteBudz, got the Meaty Pizza. Was it the worst? No. The best? No. Would I order from there again? Probably"
"Taste budz pizza tends to be dry and thick"
#81
Igloo Fired Pizza
2.5
(2)
"There is place called Igloo wood fired pizza in Lalpur."
"Well igloo fired isn't any good tried on 27th March it was no good"
#82
Bake House
5.0
(1)
"Most authentic Neopolitan Pizza you’ll get in city but its pure veg"
#83
Clockwork Pizza
5.0
(1)
"Clockwork pizza in Tempe!"
#84
Lou Malnati's
5.0
(1)
"If you like Chicago style, Lou Malnati's or Nellos"
#85
Bella Pizza and Pasta
5.0
(1)
"Bella pizza and pasta on ellsworth. Moved here from NY 4 years ago and it took me 3 years to find my pizza place."
#86
La Pinoz
2.0
(2)
"I have a really bad experience with La Pinoz dude"
"Naaahh there pizza base is like real bread not good....my opinion"
#87
Spacca Napoli
4.0
(1)
"I like Spacca Napoli a lot."
#88
Gus's New York Pizza
4.0
(1)
"Gus’s New York Pizza and Venezia’s are my fave delivery"
#89
Brooklyn New York Pizza
4.0
(1)
"I like Brooklyn New York Pizza at Brown/Recker. Favorite pizza just depends on what type."
#90
Nello's
4.0
(1)
"Nello’s is its own thing, seemingly. Takes cues from a couple different sources, but not like any deep dish I’ve seen"
#91
Master Pizza
4.0
(1)
"Place off of Baseline and Dobson which used to be called Rocky’s and looks to be called Master Pizza now."
#92
Pizza J
4.0
(1)
"Pizza j is run by one of the best dudes in the industry"
#93
Buddy's
4.0
(1)
"I would say buddy's for chicago deep dish."
#94
Pizzicato, Rudy’s
4.0
(1)
"Pizzicato or Rudy’s"
#95
Assembly
4.0
(1)
"Assembly also has housemade GF dough but they sometimes run out so call ahead if you're aiming for Detroit-style."
#96
New Cascadia
4.0
(1)
"New Cascadia Decent pizza, and it's a dedicated GF bakery so people with celiac dont have to worry about cross contamination"
#97
Mississippi Pizza
4.0
(1)
"Mississippi Pizza never gets on any best pizza lists but they make totally fine pizzas. They have many vegan pies as well."
#98
Apulia
4.0
(1)
"Apulia"
#99
10th St
3.0
(1)
"Overpriced Plain but a bit different - 10th St"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
