Pizza reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 591 Reddit reviews across 96 subreddits and 105 posts to rank the best Pizza brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/SeattleWA, r/askTO, r/Upperwestside, r/Charlotte, r/missoula. Top-rated brands include Pizza Rock (4.6/5), pizza (5.0/5), Grimaldi's (4.4/5).
Stats
Reviews591
Subreddits96
Posts105
Brands100
Products2
591 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Pizza Rock
4.6
(14)
"Pizza rock, good pie, solamente (new) brooklyns best, old school!"
"Pizza Rock downtown. Tony Two Times pizza is great."
"Pizza Rock. Order the "Hot Honey"."
"Pizza Rock has been the best I’ve tried."
"Pizza Rock"
"Pizza Rock for sure."
"Pizza Rock and it aint even close"
"I fucking love pizza rock."
"Pizza rock downtown if ya near there.. tell make it crispy for ya too....."
"Pizza Rock, so many good options."
#2
pizza
5.0
(13)
"Epic Pizza in Enmore is honestly fuckin delicious."
"Lil Franky in Tempe"
"Bsp’eria in Maroubra Junction (newly opened) is the best I’ve had"
"2 Bridges pizza Neutral Bay. God level. 🍕"
"Giovannis in Cammeray (also Mosman but haven’t been to that one)"
"One of the best pizza places in the country. highly recommend!"
"Pizza boccone in potts point is tasty and a bonus for their chilli oil"
"Almalfi in San Marcos"
"They make an AMAZING pizza."
"Corner pizza"
#3
Grimaldi's
4.4
(13)
"Also Grimaldi's at West shore plaza."
"I prefer Grimaldis but both places are excellent."
"So good."
"I was always a huge fan of Grimaldis."
"Another vote for Grimaldi’s."
"Toss-up between this and the Grimaldi's in westshore. It's a chain but even in NY it's considered one of the best."
"Grimaldis in the Bell Tower Shops"
"Grimaldi's at Stadium Trace in Hoover."
"Grimaldi’s WDM"
"Grimaldi’s"
#4
Byrne Dairy
4.7
(12)
"Byrne-ordered and made fresh is actually awesome"
"Byrne. Literally everyone who has tried it, has raved about it."
"A guy i work with has brought it in a handful of times and it's fantastic. Great crust"
"Bryne is absolutely the best there’s no comparison"
"Byrne breakfast pizza is insanely good for a "gas station"."
"I love Byrne Dairy breakfast pizza"
"Honestly I was gonna come here to say Byrne Dairy!! I second this as my vote too, OP!"
"Byrne Dairy is definitely the best."
"Byrne dairy is hit and miss but by far wins the day."
"Between Byrne Dairy and Fastrac both are decent but Byrne is the better of the two."
#5
Biga
4.8
(11)
"Biga."
"My ranking: 1. Biga (by a mile)"
"Still my go to."
"Biga all day."
"Biga is my favorite. The maple bacon chipotle pizza might be the best pie I’ve ever had."
"Biga is my favorite all around."
"Biga is the best and it's not even close."
"Biga > Pie Hole > The Bridge."
"Biga has amazing sauce."
"He makes a damn good pizza."
#6
Tony's
4.6
(11)
"It's Tony's."
"Tonys in SF."
"Tony's or Golden Boy."
"Tony’s."
"Tony's and Gioia are my fav by the slice spots."
"Tony's is the best one I've had."
"The clam pie at Tony’s in SF is phenomenal."
"Tony’s is good for so many types and I love their neopolotan."
"It definitely sounds like you need some Tony's pizza."
"For a good street slice I highly recommend Tony's."
#7
Modern
4.8
(10)
"Modern!!!"
"Modern has the best crust and the crust is everything IMO."
"Modern, Zuppardi’s, Ernie’s"
"Modern 4 life"
"Then we tried Modern, they loved it. So I’d go with Modern first"
"Modern for me, hands down."
"As others have said, Modern and Bar would be my first choices."
"Modern."
"I would go to modern pizza first and then Zuppardis next."
"Modern or BAR."
#8
Justine's
4.9
(9)
"Justine’s."
"Justine's, no contest."
"Justine's, no contest."
"Justine’s down the road a mile is the best in town."
"Justine’s is my favorite in Loveland."
"I'd take Justine's over Arte's 100 times out of 100."
"Without a doubt, Justine 's."
"1. Justine’s
2. JJ’s Wood Fired (Fort Collins)
3. GFL (Truck)
4. Rolling Stone (Truck)
5. Slyce (Fort Collins)
6. Anthony’s (Fort Collins)
7. Arté (Loveland)
8. Pizza Street (Loveland)"
"* Justine’s - best takeout pizza if they don’t have a 1+ wait.."
#9
North of Brooklyn
4.6
(9)
"Killer Bee from North of Brooklyn."
"North of Brooklyn on avenue rd"
"Try North of Brooklyn or Makers"
"Seriously underrated? La Famiglia (especially their selection of ready slices)"
"Is sooo good"
"North of Brooklyn, Sol Pizza"
"I love North of Brooklyn, Beast for a sit in dinner."
"North of brooklyn."
"North of Brooklyn...until I started making my own."
#10
Pizza Time
4.4
(9)
"Pizza Time without a doubt"
"I'd take pizza time over any other spot in Bellingham eight out of ten times. It's the best."
"Pizza Time!! They’re the best non-fancy-ass pizza in town by *FAR*"
"Pizza time is also really good."
"For cheap and decent food I go with Pizza Time or cheese bread and cinnamon twisty sticks from McKay’s."
"Pizza Time is so good when you’re in the mood for that type of pizza."
"For typical greasy cheap pizzas can’t stay away from Pizza time."
"I've always loved them and its a decent price"
"Pizza time is good."
#11
Due Amici
4.4
(9)
"Due Amici for sure!"
"Due amici - only answer 💯"
"Due Amici. It reminds me of the pizza places near my apartment in Brooklyn."
"Had it recently and thought it was excellent."
"Is pretty great."
"For NY style, Due amici is solid."
"I would suggest Due Amici, Giacomos, Slice House."
"Due Amici and Portofino’s"
#12
Badiali
4.3
(9)
"Best pizza: Badiali."
"I like Badiali, Fresca, Frank Ranalli's Pizza and Gigi"
"Badiali, Bar Sugo and North of Brooklyn. End of story."
"Badiali, King Slice and Bitondos are my go-tos"
"Badiali. Bar Sugo is also really good."
"Badiali really is the best pie in town."
"But not the individual slices, the fresh pre-ordered whole pizza."
"Badialis is the obvious choice."
"Badiali is the Chick-fil-A of pizza, overrated."
#13
Market Street Pizza
4.9
(8)
"Market Street Pizza and Mr. J's pizza"
"Market street pizza (the og one on market) is absolutely delicious with super funky topping options."
"Market Street is bomb and Pizza Pipeline is the best for OG delivery pizza"
"Market street, Peace pie, and perry street, and ofc pizza rita <3"
"Market Street!! Expensive but sooooo good. Their wings are great too."
"Market Street will give you the heartiest and arguably best pizza in town."
"Hands down."
"Market Street Pizza is an underrated gem"
#14
Salamone's
4.8
(8)
"I still haven't been to camp clovis but I want to"
"Best pizza I've personally tried so far in Tacoma."
"I like Salamone’s (not UP) and Camp Colvos"
"Salamones."
"Is truly the stuff"
"Is probably the best, followed by PSP downtown."
"My only two suggestions Salamones and Bar Rosa."
"Salamone’s in Tacoma hands down the best I’ve had."
#15
Brooklyn Brothers
4.8
(8)
"Brooklyn Bro. Pizzeria in Mukilteo is really good."
"Brooklyn bros hands down."
"Brooklyn Brothers is good pizza."
"Brooklyn Bros is the answer"
"Brooklyn Brothers in Mukilteo in Millcreek."
"Their NY slice is excellent."
"Brooklyn brothers (any location) or Moto Pizza in Edmonds."
"Brooklyn Bros is great."
#16
Sparta's
4.5
(8)
"Spartas for sure!"
"I always took my friends and special guests to Spartas."
"Sparta's is the bomb."
"Long time local business with solid pies."
"Sparta's, Uncle Peteza, and Elliot Bay Pizza are our go-to places."
"...I'd have to say Sparta's on 99."
"Spartas."
"They’re my family’s go to."
#17
Alberto's
5.0
(7)
"Albertos"
"Alberto's has my heart 💖 pero if sosyalan kay lami jd sa Tavolata."
"Albertos fordawin jud hahaha lami na affordable pa ."
"Lami man sad Mamitas, sa Cubana sad pero lahi rajud ang Albertos."
"Albertos, affordable pa"
"Alberto's, Angels Pizza and Handuraw"
"Albertos in foodpanda"
#18
Inferno
5.0
(7)
"That’s my favorite."
"Our go to's on the east mountain are Inferno and Rymal Pizza."
"Definitely Inferno imo. good reason there’s people lined up for their dinner service every time I go for pickup."
"Inferno!"
"Inferno in Gaithersburg."
"Inferno."
"Inferno."
#19
Da Nino
5.0
(7)
"Da Nino for sure"
"Da Nino ist quite good."
"Da Nino for sure"
"Da Nino"
"Da nino (the vegan ones are not good tho)"
"Da Nino or Piazza Vittoria"
"Da nino, can get (very) busy tho, especially in summer"
#20
GoldenRoy
4.7
(7)
"They do free home deliveries when you hit a certain amount."
"GoldenRoy and Lino’s"
"Got hooked during my company’s christmas party and fell in love with it!"
"Im a believer"
"Any other halal option besides Goldenroy?"
#21
Mama Mia's
4.7
(7)
"Pizza and any of their pastas 🤌🏽 I love how they bury the pepperoni under the cheese."
"I’m hooked on the pesto."
"Good pizza + good Italian dishes , homestyle Italian none of that cardboard franchise tasting pizza. Mama Mia’s is a must!"
"Mama Mia Pizza on Front St on route to the airport."
"Mamma Mia’s!"
"I like Mama Mia’s, and Stefanos."
"Mama Mia’s is really good for something simple."
#22
Moto Pizza
4.6
(7)
"MOTO Pizza in Mashpee: The chicken and waffle pizza is astounding."
"Moto Pizza in Edmonds."
"Moto Pizza though is the best pizza in the city."
"One word - Moto pizza. Actually two words"
"Moto Pizza, though not traditional is pretty damn good."
"Moto Pizza, Rocco’s, Tutta Bella."
"Moto Pizza is pretty good."
#23
Fat Jimmy's
5.0
(6)
"Fat Jimmys.....Middletown."
"Another vote for Fat Jimmy’s."
"It’s definitely Fat Jimmy’s these days."
"Fat Jimmy’s easily"
"Fat Jimmy’s"
"Fat jimmys is the correct answer."
#24
Mama's Too
5.0
(6)
"Bruschetta from mamas too is amazing"
"Mama’s Too is so good."
"Mama's Too for a fruffy newdangled facegramtok slice."
"Mamas too every day"
"Mamas Too is my favorite pie in NYC"
"There’s plenty of good ones but these ones have been consistently good for me. I am a pizza person"
#25
Pagliacci
5.0
(6)
"Pagliaci"
"Pagliacci."
"I just went into Pagliacci last night to grab a few slices."
"I have a soft spot for Pagliacci."
"Pagliacci is a crowd-pleaser."
"I like pagliacci in bellevue"
#26
Santarpio's
5.0
(6)
"Lynwood’s or Santarpio’s."
"Santarpios in East Boston"
"Santarpios in East Boston"
"Santarpios in East Boston"
"Santarpios East Boston"
"Santarpio’s in East Boston!"
#27
Stefano's
4.8
(6)
"Stefano's has a superior margherita pizza!"
"Stefanos in Pharr!"
"Stefano’s is the closest to an authentic experience…"
"Stefano’s is definitely up there."
"Stefano's~!!! 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🍕🍕🍕"
"I also like Pizza Patron's fresh jalapeño pizzas."
#28
Capri Pizza
4.8
(6)
"Capri pizza is my favorite."
"Capri is awesome......"
"Trust me when I say it’s well worth the 15 minute drive out there."
"The best pizza is in Amherstview, and it's worth the trip."
"Capri in Amherstview.."
"Toss up Between Capri and Big Bob's."
#29
Fresca
4.8
(6)
"Still a big fan of Fresca on college"
"Nothing beats Fresca imo!"
"Fresca, in the original massimo’s spot is the best."
"Fresca."
"Fresca, hands down if you get a slice in person."
"Fresca!"
#30
Domino's
3.5
(8)
"Dominos is your best bet."
"Dominos!"
"Am I the only one that really likes dominos? The hand tossed is just amazing."
"IMO it’s dominos"
"Something about Domino's hits different"
"Dominos."
"Oh and let me stop fucking around DOMINO'S sausage and gr"
"There is only Domino's in my country and they are pretty mid"
#31
Jet's Pizza
4.7
(6)
"Jet's pizza with turbo crust is amazing."
"Jets pizza is better than all"
"The best pizza in Seattle is Jet’s Pizza in Lynnwood"
"Jet’s Pizza is so good."
"Jets Pizza on Graham Rd has good NY style."
"Jets Pizza in Cuyahoga Falls is a chain but they make pretty good Detroit style pizza."
#32
Made in New York
3.9
(7)
"Brought some friends from Germany here and they said it’s the best slice of pizza they’ve ever had."
"I still haven't tried Made in NY pizza, but after seeing all the mentions here, I need to give them a shot!"
"Made in New York, Marinara, La Traviatta"
"Made in NY for a solid everyday slice."
"Made in New York for traditional and Motorino’s for Neapolitan"
"Made in New York is pretty good"
"It's very overrated imo"
#33
Costco
4.3
(6)
"I’d murder everyone in Southampton for Costco pizza slice."
"Best cheese pizza. Costco."
"Costco pizza"
"Costco"
"£10 for 18 inches. What a steal."
"They're extremely underrated."
#34
Little Caesars
2.8
(9)
"It’s the pizza for the people."
"Little Caesar’s"
"If we want *good* cheap, we get Little Caesars"
"Little Caesar’s: It’s hot and ready."
"Little Caesars."
"Little Caesars is probably 2nd to Cosco."
"Little Caesars because of the crazy puffs."
"Little Caesar or Costco for me"
"7-Eleven pizza and Little Caesars Pretzel crust some of the worst I've tried"
#35
Pizzeria Posto
5.0
(5)
"Rhinebeck: Pizzeria Posto (wood-fired)"
"Pizzeria Posto in Rhinebeck. Bar none."
"Pizzeria Posto in Rhinebeck"
"Best for me, pizzeria posto and hudson & packard."
"Pizzeria Posto in Rhinebeck."
#36
Vic's
5.0
(5)
"Vic's, Old School, and Wicked Pies are my top three!"
"Vics pizza is where I'm going tonight!"
"Vic's all the way and I've never even been there!!!"
"Vic's is a nice alternative--especially if it's just grown ups."
"Vic's is awesome."
#37
Valentino
5.0
(5)
"If you want a crispy, no flop bottom and a chewy crust on the edge, get Valentino."
"Valentino’s, Capo Pazzo, RomanSQ. Different styles but all fantastic."
"Valentino!"
"Valentinos UTC and or Origin"
"Delicious"
#38
Empire
5.0
(5)
"Empire, Oak City, Sauced, and my personal fav, Fairweather Friend."
"NY Style - Empire, Dado's."
"Empire, Sauced on Paseo (cool retro vibes and cool bar), the wedge (always high quality imo), Hideaway (try the Stillwater original if you’re ever up there), Halls (higher end), Falcones (more simple but it’s amazing)."
"Empire is the closest you will get to NY style pizza."
"Empire is our choice."
#39
Pizza Grace
5.0
(5)
"Pizza Grace - hands down. There is no other answer."
"For me it’s: 1. Pizza Grace 2. Slims 3. Troup’s."
"Pizza Grace, Capella's and Uncle G's are my top 3."
"Pizza Grace is really nailing it these days."
"Pizza Grace"
#40
Doeb's
5.0
(5)
"Doebs!"
"Doebs."
"Doebs or or Hops downtown."
"Doebs for Detroit style."
"Doeb’s in Holland!"
#41
Petrino's
5.0
(5)
"Petrinos on 16th and Vitales in Zeeland are both really good."
"I’m a fan of Petrino’s on 16th for NY style pizza."
"Patrinos, the owner is legitimately from italy so he knows his stuff when is comes to pizza."
"Don Petrinos on Riley is the best Hands down."
"I like Petrinos."
#42
King Dough
5.0
(5)
"I loooove the chicken Caesar salad from King Dough."
"King Dough!"
"King Dough is near by and amazing. The Gabba Ghoul and their truffle fries make the world a better place."
"King Dough is the best"
#43
Delfino's
5.0
(5)
"Delfinos in UW district has excellent Chicago style pizza."
"Delfinos at University Village."
"Delfinos U village for thick crust."
"Delfino’s in U Village!"
"Delfinos in U village is my fav."
#44
Antonio's
5.0
(5)
"But if you want REAL pizza, go to Antonio’s in Estes Park."
"The best pizza on my way home- Antonio’s in Rosendale!"
"Antonio’s in Amherst chicken bacon ranch is sex level."
"Antonio's in Amherst and Belchertown."
"No one will know this but Antonio's pizza from Estes park, Colorado."
#45
Home Slice
5.0
(5)
"Home Slice is the best pizza in Austin!"
"Home Slice, Pedrosos, Little Deli, Jets for Detroit atyle"
"Homeslice, Toss, Sammataro."
"If you’re not mentioning Home Slice, you’re trying too hard"
#46
Zorch
5.0
(5)
"Another vote for zorch."
"Zorch!"
"Zorch is what you want for a cheat meal for sure."
"Zorch is is peak."
"Zorch is my favorite; I love the variety of different styles they have."
#47
Arte
4.0
(6)
"Arte is really good and really consistent."
"Arte has always been our fav for over 20 years."
"Arte is still the best place with a store."
"Arte's has great pizza for takeout but downtown (Urban Field and Slice and Roll) get bumped up for vibe."
"Arte is the spot."
"Arte and Justine's are the only places worth your time."
#48
Bufalina
4.8
(5)
"Had bufalina last night. Straight gas"
"Bufalina all day"
"Is my favorite in the city"
"3. bufalina"
"But also go to Bufalina in Guilford for some amazing unique pizzas."
#49
Pizza Pete's
4.8
(5)
"Pizza Pete’s if I can have the garlic knots too"
"Pizza Pete's is a favorite."
"Pizza Pete’s"
"PIZZA PETE’S!"
"Pizza Pete’s (no frills delicious slice)"
#50
Patsy's
4.8
(5)
"Patsy's for fancy sit-down pizza."
"Patsys for sureeeeeeeeee"
"Patsy’s pizza - amazing Italian food and pizza."
"I loved Patsy’s in NR"
"Patsys in Wappingers"
#51
Fricano's
4.8
(5)
"Fricano’s"
"Fricanos for sure!!"
"Fricano’s in Holland!"
"Fricano’s"
"Fricano's Too, or Skiles are the best."
#52
Red Swan
4.8
(5)
"Crust is not too thick to be gooey, and the sesame whatever it is they do makes it marvellous."
"Red Swan Pizza. Love the sesame seeds on the crust."
"I feel like I’m the only one here who’s obsessed with Red Swan?? That shii is goooood."
"Red Swan if you want interesting pizzas, all delicious."
"My current favorite is Red Swan."
#53
Pizza Tascio
4.8
(5)
"Pizza Tascio is my new obsession."
"Pizza Tascio (several diff locations) is good too."
"Pizza tasico and providence pizza are far and away the most authentic ny style in kc."
"I’m a big fan of Pizza Tascio myself."
"Is really good but expensive."
#54
Big Mario's
4.8
(5)
"Big Mario’s, Delancy, Supreme, Pagliacci"
"Big Mario’s, enough said. Best location is cap hill"
"Big Mario's on Capitol."
"Especially if you order a whole pie fresh!"
"I’m surprised, they’re my go-to for a slice!"
#55
Pungo Pizza
4.8
(5)
"Pungo Pizza a close second. For garlic knots it’s Pungo Pizza all the way!!"
"Pungo Pizza 4af"
"Pungo Pizza was the best pizza I've ever had in my life"
"It's got to be Pungo Pizza for me. It's a bit out of the way, but quality toppings and the garlic knots are fantastic."
"Pungo Pizza and Ice Cream."
#56
Pizza Hut
3.8
(6)
"I love Pizza Hut. They make cheese crusts and I’m crazy about it."
"Pizza Hut pan and Chanellos will always be dear to me."
"I love pizza hut.. i think its the sauce."
"It will always be my favorite."
"Pizza Hut papa johns domino's because those are the only chains I've had."
"Nobody out pizzas The Hut"
#57
Cappy's
3.8
(6)
"Cappy’s 100%."
"Cappy’s. They're SO good they only open for 4 hours Mon-Thurs."
"Cappy's, Nona Slice House (Safety Harbor), Three Brothers (Lutz). Of my 3 favorites, I like Three Brothers the best."
"Cappys or Sally o Neal’s"
"Cappy's is only notable for the novelty of the deep dish, it's traditional pie is good but incredibly standard."
"Not understanding the love for Cappy's, the pizza is decidedly mid."
#58
Benny's
3.8
(6)
"Zorch seems to be the local fave, it seems."
"It’s definitely benny’s the first one was in Blacksburg so it’s as local as it gets"
"Probably your best bet for foldable cheese pizza."
"Benny's, it's a small chain in the Mid-Atlantic US"
"Benny's and Avellino's have been mostly good, sometimes a miss."
"Benny's. I use to love avellinos but it came out soggy once and never went back"
#59
Angelo's
4.6
(5)
"Never been disappointed by one of their pizzas!"
"Angelo's in SSP. They have the best sausage and the salads are big and delicious."
"Angelos in South St. Paul (next to WSP)."
"Very popular, very busy."
"You won’t be disappointed if you got to Angelos in Lakewood either."
#60
Joe's
4.6
(5)
"Joe's on higgins"
"Joe's in Dale City (12" for $10)"
"Best ny pizza ive had in the valley."
"With a New Yorker, just go to Joe's in Harvard."
"Good NY/italian pizza."
#61
Rocco's
4.6
(5)
"Checkout Roccos for Deep dish."
"Rocco’s is the answer."
"Rocco’s!"
"Rocco’s in Esco is great!"
"We like both Rocco’s and Michael’s!"
#62
Via 313
4.6
(5)
"Via 313. I live north of SLC and drive down to Lehi for this pizza."
"Is FIRE and the chicago style crust is so good."
"Via 313 is also much better than jets"
"Via 313 is up there. Make sure to get the Detroit style pizza."
#63
Emmy Squared
4.6
(5)
"Emmy Squared & Cugino Forno 🤌🏾."
"Is amazing."
"Emmy Squared; Pizzeria Stella; Square Pie."
"Emmy Squared is great for a very different type of pizza."
"My dad and I both loved Emmy Squared"
#64
Slice
4.4
(5)
"Slice!!!"
"But “The Lakeshore” at Slice is my current favorite pie."
"Slice, Remos, The Bronx House, Mario The Baker are all strong choices."
"Slice or Grigg Street (Greenwich)."
"Slice"
#65
Johnny's
4.4
(5)
"Johnny’s in Mount Vernon. Not open on Sundays nor Mondays. Highly rated."
"Johnny's in Mt Vernon (3rd generation owners, cash only, no slices)."
"Johnny’s is good"
"Johnnys mainly because they have so many options."
"I like Johnny's"
#66
Ponte
4.4
(5)
"I love Ponte, there Green Goddess is literally my favorite pizza ever"
"Pizza Ponte is just so darn good."
"Oakland pizza scene has developed so much. Lucky to have some of the best in the bay just minutes away. Ponte and Mama’s boy has been my go to."
"The buffalo chicken pizza smacks tho, especially with their sauce they give you."
"Of the four I’ve only had Ponte and Mama’s Boy and can certainly vouch for both! Ponte was more elegant and nuanced in taste."
#67
Village Pizza
4.2
(5)
"Upside down pie at Village Pizza in Mamaroneck is sublime"
"Village pizza in the center of Red Hook."
"Village Pizza in Goshen"
"Village Pizza. 16in pizza for $15."
"Village Pizza on N Penn and Hefner"
#68
Deano's
4.2
(5)
"My personal favorite is the Ragin Cajun from Deano's"
"I like Deano's"
"Deano’s is awesome but always makes me sick."
"Deano’s, BJ’s, Pizza Village."
"Deanos and Pizza Artista cajun pizzas are 🔥🔥"
#69
Mellow Mushroom
4.2
(5)
"Mellow Mushroom."
"Mellow Mushroom is my go-to when I want more unusual toppings."
"Mellow Mushrooms !!"
"Holy Shitake pizza at Mellow Mushroom."
"I think Mellow Mushroom is a wonderful pie compared to some of the others listed."
#70
Grandma's
3.3
(6)
"Second Grandmas. Soooo good"
"The pizza doesn’t taste the same, but it’s still pretty good pizza. That being said, it’s still our favorite pizza spot."
"Grandmas"
"Grandma’s"
"The one time I ate at Gramdma's it tasted like the same quality as bowling alley pizza."
"Grandmas has made me so sick both times I've ate there"
#71
Christian's
3.3
(6)
"I tried Christian’s Pizza in downtown this past weekend, I liked it and would go again."
"I like Christian's slices."
"I really like the Christian's Pizza in the village, it's my favorite."
"Christian's is good at 3am after the bar, but that's about it"
"Christian’s has majorly downgraded in the last year or two"
"Christian’s is overrated (the Cville chapters, anyway)."
#72
Luigi's
4.0
(5)
"Luigi's is good."
"Luigi’s on High Ridge."
"All the following are different and individually great."
"Luigi's is really good and reasonably priced."
"Luigi's (Tryon or Steele Creek) is owned by former New Yorkers."
#73
Franco Manca
4.0
(5)
"For me."
"Quite good."
"Popsis is amazing but Franco Mancas is also really good."
"The pizzaiolo is 100% Italian and knows his stuff."
"Franco Manca is pretty decent."
#74
DHOP
5.0
(4)
"Dhop is so good"
"DHOP is amazing."
"Count me in on team DHOP"
"DHOP and Uncle Rico’s."
#75
Red Tomato Pie
5.0
(4)
"Yeah, Red Tomato Pie is definitely the leader."
"Red tomato 🍅 Pie is by far the best I say this as an Italian who make amazing pizza recipe that goes back to Italy from my nonna."
"Red tomatoe pie for sure if not there I really like red swan as well"
"Red Tomato Pie IMO."
#76
Antoneta's
5.0
(4)
"The flavor of that pizza is amazing and has had me eating one a week for the last 3 y"
"I’ve enjoyed their pizza as a new convert to NY style pizza and their oven cooks everything so quickly and evenly."
"Definitely! We always order from them for work and the pizza and pricing is soo good!"
"Now with the new owners, it’s great!"
#77
Looco's
5.0
(4)
"They aren't stingy with their toppings."
"Loved them garlic breads too."
"It's hands down the best I've had."
"Looco’s for sure!!! Don’t forget to try their Garlic bread too."
#78
Totsy's
5.0
(4)
"Tried everything here in CDO and Totsy's is the best."
"Definitely totsy’s croissant pizza."
"Totsy's."
"Totsy’s! Try their croissant pizza."
#79
Bella Napoli
4.8
(4)
"Bella Napoli followed by a tie of Providence and Tascio."
"Bella Napoli on Roselle rd and 90. Spectacular thun neopolitan pizza."
"Bella Napoli."
"Bella Napoli in Latham and Troy has pretty good dough."
#80
Sarrica's
4.8
(4)
"If you want to try an amazing Neapolitan style pizza, head to Sarrica’s."
"Sarrica's or Cajun Saucer"
"It's Sarrica's for me easy."
"If you want a Nice dough pizza, I’d go for Sarricas, Antonis, or Central."
#81
Providence Pizza
4.8
(4)
"Providence Pizza in Grandview is good - by-the-slice NY style pizza."
"Your best bets are Providence Pizza in Grandview."
"Providence Pizza in Parlor"
"I'm a fan of Providence Pizza personally."
#82
Ozzy's
4.8
(4)
"Ozzy’s is incredible."
"Definitely Ozzys"
"Ozzy's is king rn in Glendale"
"Ozzy's and Little Goat are both great in city limits."
#83
Bacco
4.8
(4)
"Baccos is the best rn."
"Bacco’s is the best."
"I like Bacco. Also enjoy Franks in Aberdeen."
"Bacco for that deeper dish, almost Detroit."
#84
The Pizza Joint
4.8
(4)
"The Pizza Joint is my favorite, they’ve got really good salads and wings too."
"The pizza joint!"
"The Pizza Joint 10/10"
"The Pizza Joint for new York style slices and pies."
#85
Gino's
4.5
(4)
"Can’t go wrong with Gino’s"
"Definitely Gino's near Ocean Lakes"
"Gino’s on general booth."
"I love Ginos in Tonawanda."
#86
Mario's
4.5
(4)
"Mario’s is the best suburban pie I’ve had in the area."
"My fave is Mario's."
"Mario’s or Reno’s."
"Mario’s has always been my go to slice place."
#87
Volturno
4.5
(4)
"Top 5 within city limits: Volturno, Olo, I Love Frankie, Palace Pizza, Blue Jeans."
"Is everyone insane? Volturno! BOGO on Monday and Tuesday too."
"Volturno"
"Volturno, Olo’s, Rail Trail in Hudson."
#88
Brooklyn Pizza
4.5
(4)
"Brooklyn Pizza in the food court at One Liberty Place is very good."
"Best I’ve had in a long time."
"I just recently tried Brooklyn pizza in chatsworth I believe and I thought it was pretty good"
"Brooklyn Pizza at Colony Crossing does a good, well, Brooklyn pizza."
#89
Pizzeria Da Moreno
4.5
(4)
"Pizzeria Da Moreno in Koh Kaew is the correct answer!"
"🤌🏽🤌🏽🤌🏽"
"Da Moreno in Phuket is nice. Half Italian and half thai but the pizza is like in Naples."
#90
Jet's
3.4
(5)
"I second Jets for Detroit style. I like Lucci’s Place for New York style."
"Is my fave."
"Jets is good but so overpriced!"
"Jets is fine IMO, the turbo crust is quite delicious."
"Jet’s!"
#91
Blue Pan
4.3
(4)
"Blue Pan is great for Detroit style."
"Blue Pan for Detroit."
"If you love Detroit, you def need to have Blue Pan. It is much better than Jets quality wise."
"Blue Pan and Hops and Pie for Detroit style"
#92
Cart Driver
4.3
(4)
"Cart driver in lohi you get the real experience, real sourdough, good appetizers great atmosphere."
"Marco’s coal fired, joy hill, cart driver, redeemer, all great choices"
"Cart driver for NE"
"Cart driver and Benzina for brick oven Neapolitan style"
#93
For Pizza
4.3
(4)
"My current fave is the Amore Italia pizza from For Pizza."
"Here to say we’re being fans of For Pizza and Semolina at our house."
"For Pizza and Semolina in Medford."
"For Pizza is excellent 90% of the time."
#94
Big Bob's
4.3
(4)
"Big bob’s best pizza in oceanside."
"We are regular big bobs."
"Same with Big Bob’s."
"Big Bob’s, Mama Mia, or (out of town but worth the drive) capris."
#95
Pizza Village
4.0
(4)
"Landry special from pizza village is my all time favorite pizza."
"Pizza Village in Hopewell Junction"
"Pizza Village"
"Pizza village the dupe special."
#96
Buontempo
4.0
(4)
"Back in the Buontempos, but they’ve fallen off recently."
"Buontempo is good if you're in the mood for that."
"My top 3 at the moment are Buontempos, Garibaldis, and Italian Sensation."
"Buentempo’s is a close third."
#97
Pizzakid
4.0
(4)
"TRY PIZZAKID!!"
"Just tried Pizzakid. Lami ang Meaty Supreme."
"Na fave na dayon nko sya."
"Di na worth it"
#98
Pizzeria Sapienza
4.0
(4)
"Sapienza"
"Pizzeria Sapeinsa!"
"Pizzeria Sapienza or Geno Ds, both Uptown."
"My goto is Pizzeria Sapienza, really good NYC style pizza."
#99
Pie Hole
3.8
(4)
"Pie hole."
"Pie hole is great."
"I suggest the trademark potato bacon."
"Pie Hole just tastes like wet cardboard."
#100
Round Table
3.8
(4)
"Round table does not use soy in aspect of making their pizzas."
"-Round Table"
"Round Table."
"I’m not a big pizza guy but ig round table"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
