Putter reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 288 Reddit reviews across 9 subreddits and 35 posts to rank the best Putter brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/discgolf, r/WalkaboutMiniGolf, r/golftips, r/labgolf, r/golf. Top-rated brands include Dynamic Discs (4.4/5), Innova (4.1/5), Gateway (4.5/5).
Stats
Reviews288
Subreddits9
Posts35
Brands50
Products82
288 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Dynamic Discs
4.4
(39)
"I just got the stock OZ1.i. I just finish a round, and wow. My game improved immediately."
"Probably DF3 is the best atm."
"Love my stock DF3"
"Adding the obligatory link.1 putter that everyone forgets about. I absolutely love it and I've gained 6 strokes per round."
"Reaaaaally liking my DF3"
"It's knocked strokes off my game."
"I putt with wardens, kinda like a p2 shoulder but a smaller actual rim depth."
"Inside circle I putt with the PA3, which is also an amazing putter."
"Pure is an extremely well rounded putting and throwing putter."
"Pure. I use zero softs and they are buttery."
#2
Innova
4.1
(32)
"Innova XT Invader has become an absolute Staple and workhorse in my bag. But as a putter, very underrated"
"I'm back on the Aviar train now and drained a couple C2 putts yesterday."
"Just buy a stack of DX Aviars."
"Invader is so good for this."
"For me, it’s always been an Aviar-x or a GT banger"
"Get an aviar or a discraft jawbreaker roach."
"Aviar - there is a reason Innova is #1."
"Switched to Invaders for better hand feel."
"For putting putter, I’m actually a fan of R-Pro."
"Aviar-X if you like softter putters"
#3
Gateway
4.5
(22)
"Get yours hands on a Gateway Shaman. Those things are suuuuuper shallow to me and fit great in my small hands."
"Warlock or Voodoo. Try em both."
"Try warlocks. Eraser plastic is very firm and tacky."
"The Gateway Wizard super soft is my main ho."
"I’m a fan of deep putters with beads so wizards are my go to."
"Wizard please! Plenty of plastic types, colors, cool stamps, always available online."
"I’m a Wizard guy, myself."
"Gateway Shaman is what you seek."
"Try a shaman."
"Another Gateway Shaman vote here."
#4
MVP
4.4
(20)
"Recently switched to Nomads and had immediate improvement."
"I am a proxy man myself."
"I will put my vote in for the pixel or proxy."
"Try put a pixel, i have one in electron soft and its very floaty."
"I actually suggest the P model S."
"P Model S is great for putting and throwing."
"Proxy, Atom, Envy all use the same core with different overmold."
"MVP Atom Cosmic-Electron Soft."
"My putting putter has been the MVP Ion, as the inside of the disc has a super nice curve that my fingers power grip comfortably into."
"They have a bit more bite at the end."
#5
Discraft
4.2
(18)
"I love my Rhynos. I put with Rhynos and now Yeti instead of KC Aviars."
"I picked up a big z roach the other day and that thing is so money."
"G-Star Aviar ftw."
"Roach is tits."
"Rhyno in either R-Pro or Champion. Champion seems to have a bit more glide and fade, R-Pro beats in to just about dead straight."
"I have tried a lot, but a I keep coming back to the wizard"
"When I practice in the backyard I use a judge, wizard, 2 pilots, and a couple of others just to make my own stack."
"When I practice in the backyard I use a judge, wizard, 2 pilots, and a couple of others just to make my own stack."
"The judge or wizards."
"The judge or wizards."
#6
Streamline
4.3
(11)
"I love my Pilot!"
"Pilot never does me dirty."
"I love my Streamline Pilots."
"When I practice in the backyard I use a judge, wizard, 2 pilots, and a couple of others just to make my own stack."
"Pilot and Pixel are both great glidey discs. Pilot is definitely the glider of the two. It’s great beautiful summer day putter."
"Streamline Pilot"
"Or lower profile is the pilot (this is microbead)"
"Streamline pilot in electric firm. That glide can be really helpful for spinning."
"Strealine Pilot, Aviar, Challenger"
"Streamline Pilot. It does have a rounder edge and a micro bead though."
#7
Discmania
4.5
(10)
"Links are great for any putt. And they're phenomenal throwers as well."
"P2 and it’s not even close."
"I also spush putt with slight hyzer and find that the P2 is super versatile for shaping putts in the woods too."
"P2 is still one of the greats. Absolutely love the firefly."
"I love the Discmania P2."
"Discmania links"
"I use Discmania Logics in Exo Soft."
"Other shallow putters I liked are the Discmania Logic (Exo Soft)..."
"Discmania logic."
"The P2 is essentially an Aviar and has a nice tacky feel in base plastic."
#8
Odyssey
4.1
(10)
"My best putting rounds were with my GOLO 6.2 mid-mallet. Not as pretty as a blade, but it gets the job done. It’s a cheat code."
"Ive had my odyssey for 20 years and it’s the only club I won’t replace, it’s a little heavier but I like that feel vs others."
"Got one used at a golf shop and it's been great. I think I paid a touch over $100 for it but I have zero complaints."
"Odyssey putters are always the best bang for your buck."
"Mallet putters are more forgiving on off center putts. I like Titleist, but odyssey would be a close second place."
"Picked up an odyssey rossie for 4 bucks at a thrift store. Gamed it for about 3 years."
"I’d go with odyssey. Just avoid the two ball tech. It kind of ruins you lining up putts."
"Oddsey makes some great putters. Check eBay lots of options under 100 and a decent amount under 50 even"
"I got my odyssey from callaway pre owned for $100 and only had some knicks in the paint."
"I gamed the rossie 2 until I four putted for bogie. Snapped the shaft, threw it in the pond and never looked back."
#9
Axiom
4.5
(8)
"Envy."
"Proton envy :)"
"I usually go firm envy."
"Everyone in my group puts with an electron Proxy."
"Viking rune and Axiom Pixel are my recommendations."
"Pixels"
"I like the envy and proxy as my throwing putters."
"I like the envy and proxy as my throwing putters."
#10
Latitude 64
4.3
(7)
"Latitude 64- Pure."
"For shallow putters I like L64 Pure (zero medium)..."
"Latitude 64 Pure is another option."
"Latitude 64- Pure."
"Tomb, Pure (Opto, opto-x/gold-x)"
"I like the Fierce and the Pure"
"I then switched to the pure which feels amazing in the hand, but in the end it was too US."
#11
DGA
4.3
(7)
"DGA Steady BL in D-Line is a really great putter."
"I have it in their Stone plastic and absolutely love it."
"I switched to the Steady BL a little over a season ago... I’ve genuinely never felt so confident that I’ve found 'my putter'."
"100% recommend the DGA Steady BL."
"Ya definitly try the Steady BL. The Surf is nice too."
"Considering trying out the Steady or the Ion"
"I went from pilots, to dga steady, to dga sonar."
#12
Cleveland
4.0
(6)
"I love the Cleveland SOFT Huntington Beach putters."
"Wilson and Cleveland are really good and the least expensive new putter."
"Cleveland makes a good putter for cheap."
"Cleveland putters are pretty cheap and kind of the same as other brands imo."
"Cleveland Huntington Beach…. Similar price as the Wilson line."
"I have a Cleveland… i bought it to replace my seemore and then bought an artisan to replace it."
#13
Scotty Cameron
4.8
(5)
"If I was going to pick one… just one to game for the next 20 years, I’d pick a phantom 7."
"Right now - Studio Design 3.5. Beautiful shape, great balance, deep sound, pure roll."
"I love how the Newport 2.5 looked and I used my buddy’s for a couple holes and fell in love."
"If you got the money get him a Scotty Cameron or L.A.B those are the premo putters in golf"
"I bought an expensive Scotty Cameron years ago, but can putt equally with a $5 thrift store stick."
#14
Westside
5.0
(4)
"Been my putter for the last 2 years."
"Love, love, love my Maiden."
"Maiden is what I keep coming back to as straight putter that has good glide and isn't too touchy."
"Maiden."
#15
Rhyno
4.5
(4)
"Rhyno! Lots of plastic choices."
"Rhyno."
"If you’re comfortable with the Innova thumb track and like 2 speed putters, the Rhyno is probably a good place to start."
"For me the rhyno and armadillo are my go-to discs for 200ft in."
#16
Prodigy
4.5
(4)
"I specifically like the firm for spin putting."
"PA-3 is the best beaded do it all putter on the market."
"Something pretty stable and dumpy is probably a pa-3"
"Pa3"
#17
Ping
4.5
(4)
"Go to your local play it again sports and pick up a ping anser."
"The original Ping that actually makes the Ping sound when you hit it. The started remaking those in 2014. I bought one for 80 bucks."
"Just buy a really nice older model putter on ebay for about the same price"
"You can get a solid Ping or maybe Evnroll putter with a decent grip"
#18
Labyrinth
4.3
(4)
"Labyrinth by far"
"The labyrinth is the coolest imo with el dorado a close second."
"Labyrinth then the non spiky Myst one"
"Labyrinth one is pure class"
#19
Wilson
4.3
(4)
"Got one, love it. changed out to a really fat SuperStroke and this thing slaps."
"Wilson."
"I'd add Wilson to that too - they're a sleeper brand, good value for the cash."
"Wilson and Cleveland are really good and the least expensive new putter."
#20
Jawbreaker
4.0
(4)
"Ct challenger best putter🤙🏾"
"Challengers are the way"
"Challenger is underrated"
"Jawbreaker challenger crew reporting in."
#21
Luna
4.3
(3)
"Luna or roach fly dead straight! So much glide in them as well."
"I use Luna and Kratos for both putting and throwing putters, both in jawbreaker."
"Luna."
#22
Seagull Stacks
4.3
(3)
"Seagull Stacks. You shall not pass. EVERY TIME."
"I’ve been using the seagull stacks one for years. I’m a basic bitch."
"My favorite is Seagull Stacks, although Journey to the Center of the Earth is a close second."
#23
Links
4.3
(3)
"I bought a stack of EXO hards several years ago. Fantastic putter for spins."
"I died to love the links, nomads from MVP feel similar too"
"I used to putt with links. I loved the lumen soft"
#24
Nomad
4.0
(3)
"Nomads. I feel like pixel’s have a microbead that I really like but I’ve seen some thoughts to the contrary."
"Nomad, Or lower profile is the pilot (this is microbead)"
"Nomad"
#25
20,000 Leagues
4.0
(3)
"My favorite is the 20000 leagues putter. I don't like busy putters, especially close to my hands, and this one is also my two favorite colors."
"20,000 Leagues (I’m obsessed with kraken/cephalopods) or Shangri-la."
"I like the the putters from Myst and 20000 leagues under the sea."
#26
Taco
4.0
(3)
"Taco putter is the best because it is the most visible when the putter is inside walls/objects."
"Yes the taco putter is awesome, and it's not as distracting as you think it would be."
"Taco putter and the Raindow putter are my current favoritea."
#27
Gothic
3.7
(3)
"Gothic is the best. All others are too busy for me"
"I’ve always liked the wrought iron putter from Gothic, but my go to is the Cirrus putter from Myst."
"That and the Gothic one are my most played with."
#28
LAB
5.0
(2)
"Lab putter is the only way. Actually makes putting easy."
"Buy the lab putter you like and just never worry about this subject again."
#29
EV-7
5.0
(2)
"Best putter I’ve found so far."
"Has a very reliable fade at the end of my putt!"
#30
L.A.B
5.0
(2)
"L.A.B DF3!!!! Best putter for all! EXPENSIVE but worth it if you are serious about your game."
"If you’re getting a high end putter, LAB is the way to go. They’re just in Eugene and they have the friendliest staff plus i believe they just installed a brand new indoor putting surface in their headquarters for fitting."
#31
AGL
5.0
(2)
"As a spin putter, I’ve been using an AGL Madrone (micro bead) for 4-5 seasons now and love them."
"I spin putt with the AGL Acacia I love it cause it has lots of glide and just sails to the basket with less effort."
#32
Gardens of Babylon
4.5
(2)
"Imo, the best putter by a LONG shot is from the Gardens of Babylon. It's classy looking--not too sparsely or too densely decorated--and it has the best guiding line in the game."
"My fav is the Gardens of Babylon."
#33
Stokely
4.5
(2)
"I have really been digging Stokely's Wren. The plastic feels great."
"I’ve also been enjoying another “W” beadless putter recently- the Stokely Wren"
#34
Viking
4.5
(2)
"Absolutely love the thing. Got one in a mystery box and thought I'd hate it compared to the Keystones I had been throwing."
"Viking discs knife is a pretty solid beadless putter with some bite to it."
#35
Glitch
4.5
(2)
"Glitch was the putter of 2023, pretty sure it outsold every other disc."
"I like the glitch and the banger gt, and the otter, and the harp, and the fierce, and all for different reasons."
#36
Cobra
4.5
(2)
"I just bought the supernova model as a 6 month golfer and I think it’s great."
"I have a Cobra Supernova putter with the SIK face tech and I really like it."
#37
Kratos
4.5
(2)
"Kratos is my favorite putter I’ve tried in the 3 years I’ve been playing."
"I use Luna and Kratos for both putting and throwing putters, both in jawbreaker."
#38
Atlantis
4.5
(2)
"The Atlantis putter is my goat. It has stripes on it, which help me aim"
"Honorable mention to the Atlantis putter for being a trident skewering a hunk of salmon."
#39
Logic
4.0
(2)
"Blunt wing like a P2."
"Logic I prefer the Cosmic fury version."
#40
KC Pro
4.0
(2)
"Kc pro aviar or wizard"
"Kc pro aviar, challenger, nomad, dagger, whale, haven't tried Kratos but seems good too"
#41
Christmas
4.0
(2)
"Thd Christmas putter and the blue book myst putter are my go to"
"El Dorado, 8 Bit lair, Taco cat & the Christmas one are my favorites"
#42
Trash Panda
4.0
(2)
"Trash panda inner core base plastic."
"Trash Panda, Inner Core."
#43
Reko
4.0
(2)
"Envy is my approach. Reko X my putter."
"Reko X!"
#44
TacoCat
4.0
(2)
"My go to is TacoCat"
"El Dorado, 8 Bit lair, Taco cat & the Christmas one are my favorites"
#45
8 Bit Lair
4.0
(2)
"El Dorado, 8 Bit lair, Taco cat & the Christmas one are my favorites"
"I’m digging the 8 bit lair putter myself"
#46
Upside Town
4.0
(2)
"I really like the upside town putter. Pretty cool antigravity effect on it."
"Upside Town is pretty great"
#47
Myst
4.0
(2)
"I love the Myst one, and it's very simple."
"I like the the putters from Myst and 20000 leagues under the sea."
#48
Shangri-La
3.5
(2)
"Shangri-La is a favourite."
"20,000 Leagues (I’m obsessed with kraken/cephalopods) or Shangri-la."
#49
Zenergy
4.0
(1)
"Zenergy 5.0 is the widest I know of."
#50
TSA
4.0
(1)
"TSA Altar. Nerve plastic is good too."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
