Steak reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 365 Reddit reviews across 54 subreddits and 63 posts to rank the best Steak brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/denverfood, r/WaltDisneyWorld, r/disneyparks, r/Minneapolis, r/regina. Top-rated brands include Texas Roadhouse (4.4/5), The Keg (4.6/5), Guard and Grace (4.9/5).
Stats
Reviews365
Subreddits54
Posts63
Brands93
Products19
365 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Texas Roadhouse
4.4
(19)
"Texas Roadhouse is the way to go. Hand cut steaks, freshly made sides, and fresh baked bread."
"Texas Roadhouse Odessa is probably the best common-man steakhouse."
"I was shocked how good it was."
"Is the best."
"Texas Roadhouse."
"Enjoy the dinner rolls too!"
"Honestly though for price, options and quality you can’t beat Texas Roadhouse."
"For a great steak at a fantastic value."
"When we want steak, but also don't want to dress up, we hit up Texas Roadhouse."
"Texas Roadhouse and oddly... the filet at Shogun on the Hibachi is some of the most tender flavorful steak around!"
#2
The Keg
4.6
(12)
"The Keg - great service, I recommend Chicago Style."
"I agree that our Keg is the best one I've ever been to."
"The keg here is the best one I've been to ngl."
"The Keg downtown is one of my favourite steak houses."
"The keg is the most consistent."
"I have never had a better filet mignon than at the Keg."
"The Keg is still the best in my opinion."
"Is always a hit when I want to take company to a nice steakhouse."
"The steaks are consistently good"
"Hot take, but for me and the price, it's The Keg."
#3
Guard and Grace
4.9
(11)
"Is fancy and great."
"Is a truly special steakhouse."
"Guard and Grace or Shanahan’s are top tier in Denver."
"Guard and Grace or Shanahan’s."
"Guard & Grace is consistently top tier."
"My personal favorite for high steak house."
"No budget concerns….Guard and Grace."
"It's one of the best steakhouses in the country."
"Would be a much better option."
#4
Shula's
4.8
(10)
"My favorite steak I have ever had on property (and the most expensive) was at Shula's at the Dolphin."
"Shulas."
"Shula’s since you’ve already done Yachtsman."
"My favorites are Shula’s, Yachtsman’s and Flying Fish."
"If you want the best of the best, hit Shula’s."
"Shula's is the best I've had."
"Been a few years but Shulas had the best steak I've ever had anywhere, not just Disney"
"For pure steak quality? Shula’s."
"Shula’s or Yachtsman. There are other places that are good, but these two are a cut above."
"Personally, I’d go to Shula’s or off property."
#5
Old Homestead
5.0
(9)
"Old Homestead is the best one."
"Old homestead has the best ribeye in AC."
"Old Homestead--and to me, it's not close."
"Old homestead by far"
"Old Homestead"
"Two best steaks in Atlantic City 1) Old Homestead Gotham rib chop"
"Old Homestead , no one else comes close"
"The old homestead steak house. We were just there for my birthday... it was fantastic."
"If you want a Peter Luger style steak, Old Homestead at Borgata is your choice"
#6
Capital Grille
4.9
(9)
"Capital Grill is also excellent."
"The food was delicious and the service was awesome."
"Capital and Hyde park are always on point."
"If I had to pick one."
"Capital Grille downtown is fire."
"Never had a bad experience."
"Capital Grille is one of my favorites!"
#7
Ruth's Chris
4.6
(9)
"Not only does ruths chris have much better steaks, their sides are great."
"You’ll get transported to a simpler time when steak was good and servers were passionate."
"Ruth’s Chris! ❤️"
"Ruth’s Chris is the best steakhouse IMO."
"Purist steak style: Ruth Chris's."
"Ruth's Chris is a good option."
"We’ve had River Palm Terrace, but weren’t terribly impressed."
#8
Yachtsman
4.3
(9)
"Strictly looking at Disney resorts, it’s the Yachtsman."
"Yachtsman is by far the best."
"I’m a Yachtsman man, man."
"I think Yachtsman’s has it beat"
"We really liked the steak at Yachstman"
"Yachtsman, Shula’s and Toledo are all vastly better experiences."
"It’s got great steak. Maybe not the best on property."
"Yachtsman is my go to, however, had Turf Club at Saratoga recently and was pleasantly surprised."
"I think that was a mistake…"
#9
Mancini's
4.5
(8)
"Mancini's!!! Totally reasonable, absolutely delicious, and old school supper club vibes."
"Mancini’s!"
"I'd go there without question if you haven't already tried this spot."
"Mancini’s is such a gem. The food is so good and I love the atmosphere."
"My family enjoyed Mancini's and I think it was a fair price for a pretty good steak."
"I like their steak and lobster."
"Cheaper options : Mancini's or Bennett's in St Paul"
"For on a tighter budget, Mancini's is great"
#10
Le Cellier
4.4
(8)
"Le Cellier, Canada pavilion at Epcot."
"I love Le Cellier too, best in park."
"Le Cellier was the best steak I’ve ever had in my life."
"Le Cellier."
"Le Cellier and Toledo."
"Le Cellier! We also love the Yachtsman."
"I do love me some Le Cellier."
"I like Le Cellier all around best because I think their sides are so good."
#11
The Cottage
5.0
(7)
"All the best steaks I've had in my life have been from The Cottage."
"The cottage. Hands down."
"Haven't regretted a Cottage steak."
"I’ve never had a less than phenomenal meal there."
"The cottage is the most underrated steakhouse in Regina."
"The cottage is really good."
"The Cottage this past week and thought it was outstanding."
#12
Bessie
5.0
(7)
"In town I've enjoyed Bessie"
"Bessie, Jaba, 5th street. Bloody mary's has dropped off IMHO."
"Bessie is great, Bloody Mary’s is ok but the sides are average."
"Bessie is our favourite. Not as good value as Jabba but good for a special occasion."
"Bessie"
"Bessie #1"
"Off to Bessie later this month. Not cheap but meant to be good."
#13
Cut
4.8
(6)
"Amazing steak, sides (including the free bread haha) and service."
"Chi Spacco Melrose, South Beverly Grill in BH."
"Quality is phenomenal and the service is great"
"By far"
"Cut by Wolfgang puck"
#14
A5
4.7
(6)
"Been twice and great both times."
"A5 is amazing."
"Get the bavette."
"A5 - great happy hour too."
"A5… he will love it!"
"A5, as mentioned, Elway's sucks."
#15
Steak 48
4.7
(6)
"Steak 48 in Beverly Hills and Taylor’s in Ktown."
"Amazing food (portions/quality), service and ambiance"
"An amazing spot with amazing service"
"Steak 48 and Pappas has been my top 2 so far."
"Really enjoyed Steak 48."
"Steak 48 is my fave."
#16
Murray's
4.7
(6)
"It takes something like a month of careful monitoring and care to produce a Murrays steak."
"Murrays its not even close"
"Definitely Murray’s. Old steak house. So good."
"If Im not going to cook my own steak, Its Murrays"
"Best peppercorn steak I ever had was at Murray’s!"
"For classic, I love Murray's."
#17
Mastro's
4.7
(6)
"Certified to serve Tajima A5 Kobe Beef"
"My favorite is Mastro’s in Malibu"
"Love the view in the Malibu Location."
"Hands down."
"My two favorites overall are Mastro’s BH and Arroyo Chop House."
"Mastro’s and Steak 48 are my usual spots."
#18
River Palm
4.5
(6)
"River Palm is the best."
"I've been to Dino and Harrys & The River Palm - River Palm is a better steakhouse."
"River Palm and its not even closeeeeee."
"River Palm, Rare, Black Bull, Prime 94, Rails."
"River Palm, River Palm, and River Palm are some of my favorites."
"River palm by far most overrated stake house."
#19
Houston's
4.3
(6)
"Best blow you mind single steak… that Hawaiian ribeye from Houston’s"
"Big fan of the Hawaiian Ribeye at Houston’s."
"I like Houston’s over chop house."
"Houston’s or Arroyo Chop House are your best bets."
"Houston’s, or The Derby in Arcadia"
"Honestly it’s between Houstons and arroyo chophouse."
#20
Argentinian
4.6
(5)
"But their steaks are goddam good everywhere I went."
"Honestly, yes. I love argentinian steak!!"
"The thing is our average day to day meat is excellent quality."
"In Argentina you can find great grass fed meat everywhere and for a low price."
"I agree that Argentines make the best steaks."
#21
El Gaucho
4.4
(5)
"El Gaucho is very good and reasonably priced!"
"El Guacho Argentinian steakhouse in Sukhumvit. Epic."
"Made the 3rd best steak I ever had in a restaurant anywhere."
"El gaucho (classic)."
"El Gauchos is excellent."
#22
Bowery Meat Company
5.0
(4)
"Bowery Meat Company is great."
"I like Bowery."
"Bowery Meat Company or Carne Mare."
"Bowery Meat Co."
#23
Steakhouse 10
5.0
(4)
"Have loved them ever since."
"It was phenomenal!"
"Steakhouse 10 in Englewood. Reliably excellent."
#24
Le Jardin
5.0
(4)
"Le Jardin - aged on site....expensive !!"
"Le Jardin has been the best steak experience we’ve had in the city."
"If you're looking for the best steak and experience in town and can pay for it... It's beautiful inside, too."
"Le Jardin is the best in town as far as I’m concerned."
#25
Bistecca
4.8
(4)
"Bistecca / Wolfgang (not cut) / CUT / Luke’s chophouse."
"Bistecca is our go-to when in syd."
"Bistecca."
"Bistecca."
#26
Del Frisco's
4.8
(4)
"Get a tomahawk."
"Del Friscos, cap grille , Hyde park."
"This is the best one."
#27
Jiko
4.8
(4)
"There’s a reason the Walt Disney executives have their corporate dinners there."
"Jiko has the best steak at Disney World."
"Jiko was unbelievable. 60 dollars for a NY Strip seems absurd."
"Jiko before their chef left for California Grill was consistently the best steak on property."
#28
Carne Mare
4.8
(4)
"The gorgonzola aged wagyu at Carne Mare is arguably the best steak in the city."
"Carne Mare and Bowery Meat are both excellent."
"Carne Mare is excellent."
"Carne Mare is great."
#29
Yachtsman Steakhouse
4.8
(4)
"Yachtsman would be my go to."
"Yachtsman, Flying Fish, Le Cellier in no particular order."
"Yachtsman Steakhouse is my personal pick. Great food, always had great service there."
"Yachtsman Steakhouse."
#30
Grekos
4.8
(4)
"Get the rib eye!"
"Greko’s! Went there for our anniversary, everything was fantastic."
"Grekos!"
"Only one person has said.... Greko's. Great steak, big meals, friendly staff."
#31
Niku
4.5
(4)
"Niku, followed by Harris."
"Hands down."
"Niku for me."
"I buy my steak at the butcher attached to Niku."
#32
Chop
4.5
(4)
"Chop has never made a bad steak for me."
"CHOP. My whole family including myself have never had a less than perfectly cooked steak from them."
"I find they are consistently good."
"I am a fan of Chop."
#33
Steakhouse 71
4.5
(4)
"Loved Steakhouse 71 so much last year."
"Recently really enjoyed the steak at Steakhouse 71."
"Steakhouse 71 is SUPER underrated."
"Steakhouse 71 🏃♀️🏃♀️"
#34
Bastien's
3.4
(5)
"If you like the 60s vibe and a good martini but are willing to compromise ever-so-slightly on the steak: Bastiens."
"Bastiens is good too and a good value."
"Agree with others here - Bastiens is great value."
"For old school"
"Don’t go there."
#35
Meritage
5.0
(3)
"Steak Frites or Steak au Poivre at Meritage are both excellent."
"Meritage for the all around great steak and seafood."
"The steak au proivre at Meritage is incredible"
#36
Chester Arms
5.0
(3)
"The Chester (Arms) does an incredible steak platter for 2 or 3 people, big portion for a very good price."
"There is only one answer here and that is The Chester Arms."
"Chester Arms or The Porterhouse"
#37
Capa
5.0
(3)
"It has a Michelin star for a reason!"
"Capa at the top of the four seasons has amazing steaks."
"Capa at the Four Seasons in Golden Oak."
#38
Pimiento
5.0
(3)
"Pimiento old town. The service is also excellent!"
"Pimiento for sure."
"Pimiento."
#39
Shanahan's
5.0
(3)
"Top 3 steaks I’ve had in my LIFE."
"Man was it fantastic."
"Is my favorite steak house in Colorado."
#40
Cultivar
5.0
(3)
"There’s a good NY at cultivar with the best chimichuri."
"Cultivar has one of the best steaks i’ve EVER had"
"Has one of the best steaks i’ve EVER had."
#41
Capital Grill
5.0
(3)
"Top spots in and around Denver."
"Served one of the best steaks I've ever eaten."
"Capital grill westbury (i know it’s a chain but they are fucking awesome)"
#42
Marbled & Fin
5.0
(3)
"You won't regret going to Marbled & Fin."
"It was a fantastic experience."
"I've been to MF three times now and it has been excellent every time."
#43
Bryant and Cooper
5.0
(3)
"I always drop in to recommend Bryant and Cooper in Roslyn"
"Bryant and cooper."
"Bryant and Cooper."
#44
STK
3.5
(4)
"Loved STK."
"STK has a solid steak."
"I like STK and Mastros the best."
"If so. He will love STK. If not go anywhere else this sub recommends"
#45
Cowboy Star
3.5
(4)
"Can never go wrong with Cowboy Star."
"Cowboy Star."
"Cowboy Star."
"Cowboy Star for me. Famous did not impress."
#46
Boathouse
4.7
(3)
"I love the filet at the Boathouse in Disney Springs!"
"Boathouse is my pick."
"I enjoyed the steak I got at The BoatHouse in Disney Springs."
#47
Alexander's
4.7
(3)
"Alexander’s in Pasadena is fantastic."
"Best traditional steaks… Arroyo Chophouse and Alexander’s"
"Not saying it’s the best but Alexander’s in pasadena is pretty good!"
#48
Flying Fish
4.7
(3)
"Flying fish was better."
"Don't sleep on Flying Fish."
"Filet at Flying Fish."
#49
Keens
4.7
(3)
"Keens is great."
"I would do Keens."
"My picks: Keen's, Smith and Wollensky, Quality Meats, Porter House Grill"
#50
801 Chophouse
4.7
(3)
"I had a wonderful experience at 801 Chophouse."
"In terms of steak though, my favorite is 801 Chophouse."
"801 is a close runner up"
#51
Golden Steer
4.7
(3)
"You are in Vegas so you need a Vegas unique restaurant. That’s Golden Steer. Amazing old Vegas vibes, good meat, good food."
"Golden Steer. Classic old Vegas opulence and service."
"Golden Steer"
#52
Manny's
4.7
(3)
"Manny's is my absolute favorite."
"Manny's is #1"
"Mannies in the Foshay Building in Minneapolis."
#53
Bavette
4.7
(3)
"Bavettes is my favorite on strip."
"Bavettes in park mgm."
"Super cheap but imo, I'd rather eat it than ribeye."
#54
Arroyo Chophouse
4.3
(3)
"Best traditional steaks… Arroyo Chophouse and Alexander’s"
"Arroyo Chophouse and Alexander’s."
"Honestly it’s between Houstons and arroyo chophouse."
#55
Morton's
4.3
(3)
"Mortons and Killens are my go to."
"We’ve had River Palm Terrace, but weren’t terribly impressed."
#56
Pappas
4.3
(3)
"Pappas Westheimer is my #1."
"Pappas for side bitch."
"Pappas on Westheimer is my go to."
#57
Taste of Texas
5.0
(2)
"TASTE OF TEXAS… they don’t charge $20 for your side dish."
"Taste of Texas is fantastic."
#58
Ruth's Chris Steak House
5.0
(2)
"Ruth’s Chris Steak House."
"Ruth Chris on the Berlin turnpike"
#59
Vaca Argentina
5.0
(2)
"Vaca Argentina is FANTASTIC!"
"Vaca Argentina is my go to."
#60
Wolfgang's Steakhouse
5.0
(2)
"Nothing beats Wolfgang steakhouse!"
"Wolfgang's steakhouse"
#61
Miners & Stockman’s
5.0
(2)
"None of them come close to the Steak at Miners and Stockmen's steakhouse."
"World class steak."
#62
J. Gilbert’s
5.0
(2)
"J Gilbert’s is the best in the area."
"J Gilbert’s continues to be great!"
#63
Musso & Frank
5.0
(2)
"Classic old Hollywood and great steaks."
"My two fav so far."
#64
Bull and Bear
5.0
(2)
"I've heard that the Bull and Bear at the Bonnet Creek Waldorf Astoria is the best steak on property."
"Bull and Bear at the Waldorf Astoria Orlando."
#65
Fia Steak
5.0
(2)
"Super tasty and and small and intimate."
"In Santa Monica"
#66
David Burke Prime
5.0
(2)
"The best steak in the area is at David Burke Prime in Foxwoods."
"I would go to David Burke Prime at Foxwoods if you want a good steak."
#67
Ribeye
5.0
(2)
"You want a ribeye."
"Tried and true is ribeye."
#68
Argentine Meat
5.0
(2)
"I usually eat other things when visiting Brazil, Argentina and Uruguay have very good meat."
"If there's one thing I really think is excellent, it's Argentine meat."
#69
The Diplomat
5.0
(2)
"Personally I've only had amazing steaks at The Diplomat."
"They have incredible service and are a bedrock of Regina’s restaurant history."
#70
Darcys
5.0
(2)
"Can't stress how good Darcys is for the price, easily one of the best places in Belfast."
"Always hits the spot for me."
#71
Alfie's
4.5
(2)
"The steak was seriously good, and the drinks were also very well done."
"Alfie's is good for short notice."
#72
Marble by MLS
4.5
(2)
"Marbl is incredible - amazing food and service and won’t break the bank."
"Marble by MLS"
#73
Mekelburgs
4.5
(2)
"Mekelburgs' in Williamsburg is top notch"
"Mekelburgs is better than most if not any I've had in Philly."
#74
Pappas Bros
4.5
(2)
"Pappa Bros hands down."
"Pappas bros is the most consistently great steak you can have in Houston."
#75
Toledo
4.5
(2)
"Went to Toledo for the first time this year and it was to die for."
"I've heard the bone in ribeye at Toledo at Coronado Springs is excellent."
#76
Cítricos
4.5
(2)
"I had a great steak at Cítricos at Grand Flo."
"Filet at Citricos."
#77
Wine Bar George
4.5
(2)
"Ok an unusual one I found was the steak at Wine Bar George. It was fantastic."
"Wine Bar George has the best ribeye you'll find on property."
#78
Ricottis
4.5
(2)
"Ricottis on mineral spring, North End Pizzeria in Portsmouth, sax's. North end is my personal favorite"
"Ricottis on mineral spring in north providence"
#79
Raoul's
4.5
(2)
"Raouls or Minetta Tavern"
#80
Porterhouse
4.5
(2)
"Porterhouse in Little Canada is great!"
"If you want a special occasion Steak, try the Porterhouse."
#81
Gwen
4.5
(2)
"Gwen is the best steakhouse"
"Gwen is a good choice, they have Dry Age and Wagyu."
#82
Jordan's
4.5
(2)
"Jordan’s. Hands down. Been there multiple times, incredible place."
"Jordan's is the best steak at Mohegan."
#83
Harry's
4.5
(2)
"My vote is Harry’s .. hands down."
"Only been to Harrys and enjoyed their tomahawk."
#84
Ed Red
4.5
(2)
"Ed Red is the best."
"Ed red is really great but not pimiento level."
#85
Seagar's
4.5
(2)
"Can’t beat it."
"Beach Walk is also quite good and has a nice view."
#86
Gus Gus
4.5
(2)
"There is an herb butter ribeye at Gus Gus that's delicious."
"Gus Gus"
#87
Lexington
4.5
(2)
"Second Lexington specifically for the au poivre"
"I think Lexington does a nice au poivre if you want that old supper club sort of vibe."
#88
Bedrock
4.0
(2)
"Bedrock bar and grill for value for money."
#89
Longhorn
4.0
(2)
"Longhorn in Clarksville, Torino’s in Springfield, Eddie V’s, and Bourbon Steak in Nashville."
"It's a chain but never had a bad steak from longhorn."
#90
Sax's
4.0
(2)
"As others mentioned, Sax’s in EPVD is good."
"I like Sax's in East Providence, although I am sure there are different preferences out there."
#91
Jax Cafe
4.0
(2)
"Jax Cafe, only place I'll pay for a steak"
"I recently tried Jax in NE and was impressed"
#92
Cork Wine Bar
4.0
(2)
"The hanger steak at Cork Wine Bar on 14th Street. Always delish, if slightly understated."
"Always stellar and understated hanger steak at Cork Wine Bar on 14th."
#93
Dan Tana's
4.0
(2)
"That 50 yo grill and quality is a sleeper."
"Get the Dabney slab a Dan Tana's"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
