Steel Toed Boots reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 246 Reddit reviews across 30 subreddits and 37 posts to rank the best Steel Toed Boots brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Carpentry, r/WorkBoots, r/geologycareers, r/Construction, r/BuyItForLife. Top-rated brands include Red Wing (4.6/5), Thorogood (4.6/5), Timberland Pro (4.4/5).
Stats
Reviews246
Subreddits30
Posts37
Brands66
Products42
246 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Red Wing
4.6
(82)
"Red wings and thorogoods are what I’d buy."
"Red Wing makes several women's steel toe boots, the 2340, 1224, 2459, 2347, 2346. I have no issues recommending them"
"Red Wing 2231."
"I bought great boots at Redwing in North Vancouver."
"If your son doesn't want to wear rubber boots... Red Wings are the way to go."
"I’ve always sported redwings."
"Redwing 4200 (get custom insoles)"
"Redwings and good socks."
"They are very comfortable."
"I’ve been wearing that model of boot for almost 20 years."
#2
Thorogood
4.6
(18)
"I recommend Thorogood, American Heritage moc toe, my boss and his friends swear by them."
"Red wings and thorogoods are what I’d buy."
"I can’t say enough about Thoroughgood boots. Comfortable right out of the box and super durable."
"Love my composite toe thorogood boots. They meet all your needs you've listed."
"I’ve had the 804-4200 Thorogood’s for about 7~ months now with no complaints."
"Definitely Thorogood"
"I got Thorogood with Redwing inserts and I low key wear them even when I’m not going to work."
"The best brand hands down is thorogood."
"Id recommend thorogoods most comfortable boot I've had."
"Thorogoods are great and made in USA."
#3
Timberland Pro
4.4
(13)
"They had a huge selection of sizes."
"Highly recommend, they're pretty true to size."
"Timberland Pro. The expensive ones are about $200 and well worth it. Most comfortable ever."
"I second the guy who said Timberland Pros."
"The most comfortable thing I’ve ever had on my feet."
"Timberland Pro work boots seem to be pretty popular lately they have 3 or 4 women’s models these ones look like a good value"
"Timberland pro boondocks have served me pretty well."
"Timberland pro boondocks Around $350."
"My dad gifted me a pair of timberland pro’s last month and they’re crazy comfortable."
"I like the timberland pro boondocks, I mink oil them to keep them waterproof."
#4
Danner
4.6
(12)
"Look at Danner Boots. They are a PNW company and I wear my work boots pretty much everywhere."
"Danner GTX Comp Toes and Darn Tough socks."
"My girlfriend and I both wear steel toe Marine Corps boots from Danner."
"I have a pair of Danner's that I really like and I know several men on my jobsite that swear by Red Wings."
"Big fan of the danner quarry 8s. They come in a alloy toe and last longer than any other brand i have had."
"I've been happy with Danner and Red Wings."
"I highly recommend them if you can get them."
"Danner boots"
"Danner makes their nicer boots in the PNW, and $450 would put you into their nicer boots."
"Recently I bought a pair of Danner boots that were on sale for 1/3 of what I normally pay for a pair of boots."
#5
Keen
4.3
(11)
"I have been wearing Keen for six years. Oregon based, composite toe and warm."
"I suggest trying out some the Keen brand. I had the Keen Philadelphia, and they were super comfortable."
"Keens are COMFY. Give them a shot."
"On my 3rd pair of composite toed Keens"
"Keen are awesome."
"Keen 6” Cincinnati, top contender."
"Keen makes really good and comfortable boots but they are going to cost more than a Walmart boot."
"Keen is my favorite brand for work and play."
"Keen is my favorite brand for work and play."
"KEEN makes a good Womens sizing steel toed low ankle boot not terribly expensive."
#6
Timberland
4.4
(7)
"If your doing indoor work I swear by the Timberlands Electricians Shoes if you can get away with them."
"I've owned 2 pairs of these and they are wonderful."
"Currently using a pair of Timberland's."
"If you need boots I'd try a Timberland one for sure."
"Ceramic toe timbs lasted me for 7 years."
"I've got a pair of Timbs with some Dr Scholz pads inside. Works great for me."
"I highly recommend timberlands or cats as everyone else has been saying."
#7
Blundstone
4.3
(7)
"If you’re willing to dish a few bucks blundstone steel toes are awesome."
"I wear these day in day out and have done for years. Some of the most comfortable boots Ive worn for workboots tbh."
"I found Blundstones to be the comfiest and supportive for me."
"Most guys I work with in residential construction wear safety toe Blundstones or Redbacks."
"I always rock the steel toe blundstones with the rubber toe. They are comfortable."
"I’ve also had great experiences with Blundstone."
"I've had my blundstones for years now and they still hold up very well."
#8
Carolina
4.5
(6)
"Check out Carolina’s American made boots. They’re more comfortable than some Redwings and Thorogoods."
"I used the Carolinas for mechanic work and they lasted 5+ years."
"Can’t go wrong with some Carolinas."
"Duradero, Carolina, would be two good options."
"Carolina Amp"
"I typically burn through my main field boots once per year. I like Carolinas."
#9
Wolverine
4.3
(6)
"I got a pair of wolverines, I wouldn't get rid of if they fell apart."
"I got a pair of Wolverines for just over $100."
"Depends. I prefer Wolverine. The ones without laces"
"I’ve always found Wolverine to be a good cheaper brand"
"I can vouch for the wolverine brand, I have had my pair resoled 1x after a year of daily use."
"Wolverine composite toe. Comfy for me."
#10
Irish Setter
4.2
(6)
"I would highly recommend them, very comfortable."
"I'm a woman who wears 9-9.5 and ordered my size 7 men's irish setters on Amazon for under $100 4 years ago. Amazing boots."
"Irish Setter Ashby"
"I like Irish Setter. If I was going somewhere fancy id buy a nice pair of redwings."
"Irish setter, it's an off shoot of redwing."
"I wear Irish Setter steel toes with a couple pairs of wool socks... After that I’m not worried about steel toes and I’m in insulated Muck Boots and I’m fine."
#11
Ariat
4.0
(5)
"Ariat sells the dreaded cowboy boots in a composite toe. Super easy to slip on and off, fit in the stirrups, not clunky."
"My GF has Ariats and likes them a lot."
"The most comfortable ones (at least from what customers said) were Ariat laced up or pull ons."
"Ariats seem more comfortable than redwings but redwings seem to last longer imo"
"I like Ariats."
#12
Canada West
5.0
(4)
"I bought the Canada West Rigger boots. So far 3 years and still going strong. Like I said I used to buy redwings. I am so glad I made the switch to these boots."
"I bought the Canada West Rigger boots. So far 3 years and still going strong. Like I said I used to buy redwings. I am so glad I made the switch to these boots."
"I bought the Canada West Rigger boots. So far 3 years and still going strong. Like I said I used to buy redwings. I am so glad I made the switch to these boots."
"I used to buy Red Wing boots, however, my last pair I purchased was Canada West! They are hand made in Canada, and IMO way more comfortable than my redwings were."
#13
Caterpillar
4.3
(3)
"My top would be caterpillar(believe it or not!) brand boots. Crazy comfortable and they last me quite a while."
"Caterpillars aren’t bad if you want something cheap and quick. I’ve had mine for a summer and they are lighter than you’d think and fairly stylish."
"My SO loves her Caterpillar boots."
#14
Dr. Martens
4.3
(3)
"Dr Martens sells women steel toe boots."
"Dr. Martens. I’ve had mine for 4 years. Manage a wallpaper factory. They were one of the only companies that has women’s sizes."
"I actually have a pair of Dr. Martens steel toes that are both functional and fashionable."
#15
Suadex
4.0
(3)
"Suadex steel toed shoes are fucking awesome. Looks like a casual sneaker but protects your toes. Very light unlike steel toed boots. And they are super breathable"
"I wear Suadex steel toes shoes about 60% of the time. They are light, fairly durable and super comfy."
"I got the Suadex ones off of Amazon for my internship."
#16
White's
5.0
(2)
"If you can get white’s to ship to you do that!"
"I've been wearing White's for the last 10 years, and I can't say enough about them."
#17
Redbacks
5.0
(2)
"Recently switched from Haix to Redbacks & couldn’t be happier."
"I have a pair of Redbacks, similar to the Blundstones but I found them to be much more comfortable."
#18
Steel Blue
4.5
(2)
"Steel Blue Hobart wheat color with toe cap."
"Steel Blue are good dunno if you can get in the States though."
#19
Dunlop
4.0
(2)
"Tough, comfortable, and they'll keep your feet dry."
"They're relatively light, very comfortable with a decent insole."
#20
Dakota
4.0
(2)
"My dakotas outlast them."
"Dakota makes great boots."
#21
Reebok
4.0
(2)
"They're just Reeboks, coyote tan high tops. I got them for my job because we regularly need to hand lift things together that weigh hundreds of pounds and are made of aluminum and steel."
"I wear Reebok duty boots, SWATs are supposed to be good."
#22
Georgia
4.0
(2)
"Georgia 6342"
"I've used Georgia Boots for years and never had any problems."
#23
Walmart
3.5
(2)
"His dad got him a pair from walmart"
"You might be able to find some cheapo’s at Walmart or if you have an Atwood’s or tractor supply local they should have some decent steel toes."
#24
Skechers
3.5
(2)
"I got a pair of sketchers steel toed boots with oil resistant shoes a few years back."
"Don’t laugh y’all... Skechers. I know, I know. I’m impressed with the fit and they broke in quick. They are very not waterproof, by Florida standards not much really is."
#25
Red Wing Heritage
5.0
(1)
"Red Wing Heritage Iron Ranger."
#26
Redhartt
5.0
(1)
"Redhartt also has a great selection of steel toed and/or Goodyear welted boots. I’ve also been pleased with their service and prices."
#27
Pit Boss
5.0
(1)
"I would definitely recommend the pit bosses."
#28
Marks Work Warehouse
5.0
(1)
"Marks Work Warehouse."
#29
JK Boots
5.0
(1)
"I got my current pair from Jk boots, that said I paid $950 for them."
#30
Royer
5.0
(1)
"I like Royer lately, specifically the 8920RT. They're Canadian, very well built, super comfortable."
#31
Terra
5.0
(1)
"I’ve been wearing Terra boots for 6-7 years now and they’re fantastic, hold up well."
#32
Murphy Gear
5.0
(1)
"I use Murphy gear. Mention the company name and possibly get a discount."
#33
Steel Toes
5.0
(1)
"Steel toes saved me a few times. If the cow twists its hoof with its weight on your toe, steel toes will save your nail."
#34
Composite Toe Boots
5.0
(1)
"Steel toe boots are very heavy. I wear composite toe boots and my feet have been safe for 15 years!"
#35
Wesco
5.0
(1)
"Go for Wesco and have them rebuilt every couple of years. They will be a little over your price range, but are the closest thing to a lifetime boot you’ll find."
#36
Carhartt
5.0
(1)
"Carhartt hiker composite toe boots. Just as safe as steel toe boots (they have to pass the same tests) but 50% lighter."
#37
Royers
5.0
(1)
"Royers are amazing. I’ve had mine for 8 years."
#38
Baffin
4.0
(1)
"I have these and wear them all winter long. They're great as long as you keep your socks dry."
#39
Shoes For Crews
4.0
(1)
"My fiance got his steel toed boots for work from Shoes For Crews."
#40
Gripfast
4.0
(1)
"I love my Gripfasts but they have to be ordered online. The shipping is surprisingly fast considering they come from England."
#41
Carolinas
4.0
(1)
"I like Carolinas, I have gotten more wear out of them than Red wings."
#42
Aggressor
4.0
(1)
"They are comfy. They are relatively light. And the soles, stitching, and everything else lasts even with sparks dropping."
#43
Angry Itch
4.0
(1)
"Angry Itch. Small brand but very good shoes."
#44
Justin's
4.0
(1)
"Sad to say Justin's have lasted me the longest. The camo uppers and theyre waterproof. About $150ish at academy. Lasted twice as long as wolverines."
#45
New Balance
4.0
(1)
"New Balance makes a composite toe too."
#46
Red Wing, Danner, Blundstone, Timberland
4.0
(1)
"Red Wing,Danner,Blundstones. Actually had a pair of TimberLands that did well in urban work for a year or so."
#47
Kodiak
4.0
(1)
"I bought a pair of Kodiak boots for around $320 Canadian that were of high quality."
#48
Redwing, Chippewa, Carhartt, Ariat, Georgia, Wolverine, Merrell
4.0
(1)
"Redwing, chippewa, carhartt, ariat, georgia,wolverine, merrell. All exceptional boots."
#49
Muck, Xtratuf
4.0
(1)
"For that type of work I'd recommend a pair of Muck or Xtratuf boots."
#50
French's Boots
4.0
(1)
"French's Boots. They're known for cowboy boots but they also have work and equestrian boots."
#51
Vegan Victory Shoes
4.0
(1)
"Also from the UK: Vegan Victory Shoes with steel noses."
#52
Duradero
4.0
(1)
"Duradero, Carolina, would be two good options."
#53
Birks
4.0
(1)
"Good boot and less than $100."
#54
Composite
4.0
(1)
"I've worn mainly composite for 20 years and it's always come through."
#55
STC
4.0
(1)
"I only buy STC boots."
#56
She Wear
4.0
(1)
"Google "She Wear". Hope that helps"
#57
NORTIV 8
4.0
(1)
"I really don’t think you need to spend $300 for a decent pair of steel-toed boots. Just look at something like the NORTIV 8 Steel Toe Boots for under $100."
#58
Birkenstock
4.0
(1)
"I wear Birks Defender, they are composite toe though so not sure if that works for you."
#59
Composite Toe
4.0
(1)
"Get him a pair of composites, his toes will thank you for it. Pricier than standard steel, but more comfortable."
#60
Xena
4.0
(1)
"I have some friends who love Xena boots. They're definitely cuter than most of the ones I've seen elsewhere."
#61
Marks WorkWarehouse
4.0
(1)
"Marks WorkWarehouse. Lots of selection and different styles and safety classes."
#62
Rocky
4.0
(1)
"Rocky alpha forces."
#63
Zappos
4.0
(1)
"Try Zappos. Free shipping and returns."
#64
Walmart Steel Toed Boots
3.0
(1)
"Walmart caries steel toes, you might have to wear a mens size."
#65
Chuck Taylor
3.0
(1)
"Amazon.com has steel toe sneakers on they're website."
#66
Steel Toe
1.0
(1)
"Don’t buy steel toes they are ancient technology. Carbon/composite is the way to go."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
