Tobacco reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 234 Reddit reviews across 14 subreddits and 41 posts to rank the best Tobacco brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Colognes, r/fragranceclones, r/hookah, r/RYO, r/ScentHeads. Top-rated brands include Tom Ford (4.6/5), Parfums de Marly (4.4/5), Herod (4.8/5).
Stats
Reviews234
Subreddits14
Posts41
Brands88
Products58
234 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Tom Ford
4.6
(31)
"Tom Ford"
"Tobacco Oud"
"I love layering tobacco Vanille with other frags like myrrhe mystere, Oud Wood, Vanille fatale"
"Tobacco Vanille"
"For me it’s the Tom ford, it just has this sweetness that even on a warm evening is so endearing."
"It's one of the 🐐 fragrances for me."
"Tobacco vanille wins easily."
"Best captures the complexity and nuance of tobacco from these options."
"Hoping for Ahmed to release tobacco and vanille."
"Tom Ford"
#2
Parfums de Marly
4.4
(24)
"PDM Herod"
"Herod for sure."
"Wore herod today and absolutely love it."
"Of those, Herod and Tobacco Vanille."
"Hands down Herod but if someone asks in public red tobacco."
"I own Herod and it quickly became my all-time favorite tobacco scent."
"Herod, hands down"
"Herod."
"Herod by far"
"Herod by a large margin"
#3
Herod
4.8
(16)
"Wore herod today and absolutely love it."
"Instantly fell in love with both."
"Herod and Tobacco Vanille."
"My fav of the group you posted."
"The greatest tobacco scent I’ve ever had."
"Herod is the best of the four, all of them are great though."
"I like Herod the best of the four."
"It’s Herod OP. There’s no question it’s Herod."
"Herod."
"Herod, then Triumph of Bacchus or Vanille Havane."
#4
Mancera
4.8
(13)
"Out of all of these I’d say Red Tobacco is my fave tobac"
"Red tobaccco is amazing. Do not blind buy. I love it."
"Red Tobacco is a beast in cold cold weather."
"Red tobacco, dry down is just amazing."
"Herod for sure."
"PDM HEROD wins it for me here."
"Herod is the one where you get the most glorious tobacco scent."
"Herod is by FAR the best scent on this list."
"For the price, mancera red tobacco, worth every $ instead paying 80% of the price for the tf name."
"Red tobacco by Mancera. The drydown is just delicious."
#5
Dolce & Gabbana
4.1
(7)
"The One is the beast, and if you want tobacco games strong, go for red tobacco!!"
"The one esp is easily the best smelling fragrance on this list"
"The one"
"The one."
"D&G The One is my all time favorite smelling fragrance."
"Of those…The One imo."
"The one smells beautiful but the projection on that thing is less than an inch and so weak."
#6
Tobacco Touch
3.5
(8)
"I went with Tobacco Touch and found it to have a bit more clove than TV and Charuto but I like it."
"I have the tobacco touch and I rather like it actually."
"I haven’t tried Charuto. But I always get compliments with Tobacco Touch"
"Gotta be the Tobacco Touch. Charuto was pure honey sweetness. Like honey, no tobacco, no vanilla, just honey."
"Tobacco Touch needs some serious masturbation time. I hated it for the first six months I owned it."
"I have Tobacco Touch. It's heavy on the clove, then a little wet tobacco, but next to no vanilla."
"Tobacco touch has a very synthetic cinnamon/clove baking spice opening until it’s macerated!"
"Tobacco Touch is crazy vanilla and that's it."
#7
Charuto
3.3
(6)
"Charuto places more emphasis on the pipe tobacco smell, it's more so a take on tobacco vanilla then an actual clone"
"Charuto"
"I got charuto it's longevity is amazing but it's kinda linear with a first heavy burst of tobacco leaf then it kinda dries sweet"
"Charuto changed their packaging and it doesn’t look like that anymore. On the first spray, I didn’t like it."
"I have Charuto and like it but can’t compare to others. I wore the OG once and it was probably better but Charuto scratched that itch for me."
"I read that Charuto is good but I can’t f with that bottle design"
#8
Serbetli
4.8
(4)
"Depends wear you live for me by far the best in no particular order are : Jibiar, Eternal smoke and serbetli."
"I’m a huge huge fan of serbetli, our lounge got rid of al-fakher and replaced it with that."
"To me my go to that is always great and top tier are Serbetli and Element."
"Heard good things about Serbetli as well but dont have it in my country."
#9
Holster
4.3
(4)
"German guy here. I love Holster, Fuck your Life / Law, 7Days and Shades."
"I think the best ones are OS and holster right now."
"I like the ice flavours from Holster, Watermelon, GRP 2.0, Wildberry and Quiwi."
"All the flavours are pretty good."
#10
Guerlain
4.3
(4)
"Guerlain Tobacco Honey is phenomenal."
"The one not listed - Tobacco Honey by Guerlain"
"Ive heard guerlain tobacco honey is a good tobacco scent"
"Tobacco Honey by Guerlain is quite realistic."
#11
Reyane Tradition
4.0
(4)
"An excellent A*Men Pure Havane by Thierry Mugler tribute act."
"Very good performance and an okay alternative to the - discontinued - Pure Havane from Thierry Mugler."
"Insurrection 2 Wild - Reyane Traditions"
"Reyane Insurrection II Wild is great! It's super affordable and high quality."
#12
Amouage
5.0
(3)
"The best tobacco by a decent margin is Amouage Royal Tobacco. It’s pricy, but the smell and performance are insane and well worth it if you love tobacco scents."
"Amouage Royal Tobacco"
"My favorites; **Amouage Royal Tobacco**"
#13
JiBiar
4.7
(3)
"Depends wear you live for me by far the best in no particular order are : Jibiar, Eternal smoke and serbetli."
"JiBiar - Sweet Watermelon"
"Ive heard good things about Jibiar, maybe can try it."
#14
Diptyque
4.7
(3)
"Diptyque Narguile."
"Diptyque’s Narguile, which is tobacco and honey."
"Diptyque Narguile sound like what you’re looking for."
#15
Daniel Josier
4.7
(3)
"Ambre Tabac by Daniel Josier."
"Favorite tobacco vanilla: Ambre Tabac 👌🏾."
"Ambre Tabac by Daniel Josier."
#16
BUOY
4.0
(3)
"Speaking as a former Marlboro red and black smoker."
"It's a thin cut and doesn't have a lot of trash in it."
"My favourites are BUOY, Cheyenne and Privateer."
#17
PF Candle Co
4.0
(3)
"P.F. Candle Co Teakwood and tobacco works too."
"Teakwood and Tobacco by PF Candle Co and Narguile by Diptyque."
"I really love P.F. Candle Co's Teakwood and Tobacco."
#18
Two Timer
5.0
(2)
"I've only tried one; 'Two Timer.' I can say that it's a fantastic blend."
"For flavor, Windsail platinum and 2 timer mixed is pretty awesome."
#19
whole leaf tobacco
5.0
(2)
"My favorite has got to be blends of whole leaf tobacco"
"Is legit a completely different experience imo."
#20
Pueblo
3.3
(3)
"I've been hooked for ages with pueblo, the yellow one"
"Pueblo (thin strip cut, dry, drying out quickly)"
"Pueblo yellow"
#21
Replica
4.5
(2)
"My personal favorite so far is replica jazz club."
"Jazz Club"
#22
Royal Tobacco
4.5
(2)
"Royal tobacco - one of the best i've sniffed so far."
"You should give Royal Tobacco a try."
#23
Amber Oud
4.5
(2)
"Amber Oud Tobacco Edition is the one with the best longevity I’ve tried so far."
"That is the one I have been using for years. Love it, but would like to try something else also similar"
#24
Dior
4.5
(2)
"Dior - Tobacolor easily the best."
"Dior- Tobacolor."
#25
Le Labo
4.5
(2)
"**Le Labo Tabac 28**"
"Tabac 28 Le Labo"
#26
Xerjoff
4.5
(2)
"Xerjoff Naxos and TfTV as well as Kiste by slumberhouse. Peach and tobacco."
"Xerjoff Naxos."
#27
Ormonde Jayne
4.5
(2)
"Best fresh tobacco on the market, totally different vibe from these cold weather beasts."
"Ormonde Jayne Montabaco Intensivo."
#28
Maison Alhambra
4.5
(2)
"I will never buy TF TV as long as this is available."
"A very good Tom Ford tribute act."
#29
Trifecta
4.5
(2)
"My go to blonde leaf in the US is Trifecta blonde."
"Trifecta is the least hard hitting nicotine wise."
#30
Good Stuff
4.0
(2)
"I've been mixing the good stuff gold and gambler or 4 aces Turkish."
"The tobacco I’ve been using good stuff red with a little gambler mix"
#31
Criss Cross
4.0
(2)
"Seems to tick the boxes."
"It's as close as I have come to a daily."
#32
Maison Margiela
4.0
(2)
"For me it’s the Tom ford, it just has this sweetness that even on a warm evening is so endearing."
"Jazz Club (the only tobacco cologne I own)."
#33
Tobacco Vanille
4.0
(2)
"Tobacco Vanille smells like Christmas in a bottle and lasts fairly long enough."
"Tobacco Vanille has a prominent tobacco note that makes it stand apart from the others."
#34
Tobacco
4.0
(2)
"I'm aging my Tobacco now for minimum one year. Everything is labeled as either Volado, Seco, Viso or Ligeiro in storage for blending later."
"I grow for cigarettes and I isolate the bottom leaves and the tips from the rest of the plant because bottom dirt leaves have almost no nicotine and the tips have a lot."
#35
Social Smoke
4.0
(2)
"Social smoke watermelon chill & cucumber chill still work amazing for me in mixes."
"A more expensive one here in Ger is Social Smoke from the USA."
#36
Maya
4.0
(2)
"Cheap, pretty good tabaco. Might even switch over from american spirit"
"Maya Both the brown one and the blue one are really good!"
#37
Element
3.5
(2)
"To me my go to that is always great and top tier are Serbetli and Element."
"I wouldn't suggest it."
#38
pueblo
3.5
(2)
"I like pueblo blue."
"Pueblo Blue"
#39
Drum
3.5
(2)
"Drum Dark blue (crude cut)"
"Drum light Blue (crude cut)"
#40
Al Fakher
2.5
(2)
"Al Fakher probably isn't even sold there anymore, because it doesn't suit people."
"Al-fakher to me is the McDonald's of the burger world."
#41
American Club
5.0
(1)
"If I could only buy one bag and had to start over I’d definitely go with American Club."
#42
Pure Perique
5.0
(1)
"Pure Perique!"
#43
Apocalypse
5.0
(1)
"Apocalypse is great. I'm in the US."
#44
Ubercigar
5.0
(1)
"The single best option is Ubercigar as they have a good range and the best prices, fast shipping that's free over $150."
#45
Eternal Smoke
5.0
(1)
"Depends wear you live for me by far the best in no particular order are : Jibiar, Eternal smoke and serbetli."
#46
Al Haramain
5.0
(1)
"Absolutely id go with al haramain for sure. I have it and it's awesome"
#47
GRP
5.0
(1)
"I think you would like GRP 2.0 too. You can mix it with like everything."
#48
Carter Hall
5.0
(1)
"Carter hall is super smooth."
#49
Bubbly
5.0
(1)
"My personal favourite is Bubbly shisha."
#50
Naxos
5.0
(1)
"I still prefer Naxos over these, as tobacco fragrance in general."
#51
4aces
5.0
(1)
"I primarily smoke 4aces it's cheap and tastes great I love it."
#52
Montecristo
5.0
(1)
"Montecristo Nº4 is said to have leaves from all the 'floors' of the plant."
#53
Windsail
5.0
(1)
"For flavor, Windsail platinum and 2 timer mixed is pretty awesome."
#54
Armaf
4.0
(1)
"I have Armaf Hunter Killer. It's a slightly fresher take on Red Tobacco with a fresh green apple in the opening."
#55
Privateer
4.0
(1)
"Privateer Natural and Buoy Yellow are quality tobacco I have used and I like."
#56
Golden Virginia
4.0
(1)
"Strong Tabbaco: Golden Virginia (normal cut)"
#57
Parisienne
4.0
(1)
"Soft tabacco: Parisienne (normal cut)"
#58
Montage
4.0
(1)
"Montage tobac vanille.Really enjoyed it in winter"
#59
Adalaya
4.0
(1)
"Adalaya orange mint is one of the best if you want more real tasting."
#60
MA
4.0
(1)
"I like the most MA Tabaco Touch i dont get clove at all!"
#61
TF
4.0
(1)
"I have TF Tobacco Vanille, Xerjoff Naxos and Jazz Club, if I have to keep one it'd easily be Jazz Club."
#62
Louis Vuitton
4.0
(1)
"Louis Vuitton ombre nomad"
#63
Cuba
4.0
(1)
"Cuba Red"
#64
Triumph of Bacchus
4.0
(1)
"Triumph of bachus is worth a try too"
#65
Initio
4.0
(1)
"Try Initio Narcotic Delight. It’s not tobacco forward, but it’s definitely there with the cognac and cherry."
#66
Blueberry London
4.0
(1)
"Not a clone but a really good cheapie, try finding a tester of Blueberry London for Man, a softer sweeter tobacco more along the lines of Herod and TV."
#67
TV
4.0
(1)
"I like TV but prefer Herod, the real kicker here is that a 50ml bottle of TV is priced the same as a 125ml bottle of Herod where I live."
#68
Adalya
4.0
(1)
"Adalya is one of my favourites."
#69
Shag Tobacco
4.0
(1)
"For UK folks, try shag tobacco its taxed as pipe tobacco but is dryer than pipe tobacco and goes into tubes well."
#70
Jade Liqueurs
4.0
(1)
"Jade Liqueurs makes a perique liqueur that's very good."
#71
Perique
4.0
(1)
"You can get Perique cigars and pipe tobacco."
#72
American Spirits
4.0
(1)
"American Spirits Black"
#73
Cigarbox
4.0
(1)
"Cigarbox or the Index are also good options though."
#74
Fragrance World
4.0
(1)
"A very good Red Tobacco by Mancera tribute act."
#75
Rasasi
4.0
(1)
"Rasasi Shuhrah, or Al Haramain Oud Tobacco edition (TF T Vanille dupe)"
#76
Lattafa
4.0
(1)
"Lattafa khamrah."
#77
Daughters
4.0
(1)
"I've been smoking Daughters Ryan Two Timer Gold & Venegeur lately."
#78
Baraonda
4.0
(1)
"Baraonda by Nasomatto."
#79
3 Sails
4.0
(1)
"The 3 sails tobacco is not for the flavor, but locks the pipe tobacco in the tube."
#80
Prince Albert
4.0
(1)
"Prince Albert is also supposed to be a cigarette/pipe tobacco."
#81
Wajood
4.0
(1)
"Not sweet, cool, leathery. Doesnt project crazy or stay for days but its clean and manly."
#82
Tangiers
4.0
(1)
"I mix 80% bubbly with 20% tangiers."
#83
Musthave
4.0
(1)
"I prefer musthave as a brand a looot more than element."
#84
Indo
4.0
(1)
"Use indo tobaccos."
#85
Fred Jaune
4.0
(1)
"I find it to be a more pleasant and milder to smoke."
#86
Canteros
3.0
(1)
"This is the largest selection in the country, but NZ prices are terrible."
#87
Taif
3.0
(1)
"Initial impressions [here](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A7ZYWYLW4Dw) I love the One though, but can’t get over the weak performance."
#88
Marlboro
2.0
(1)
"Sorry, but nothing is gonna taste just like Marlboro."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
