Under Eye Concealer reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 456 Reddit reviews across 22 subreddits and 96 posts to rank the best Under Eye Concealer brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Makeup, r/Sephora, r/MakeupAddiction, r/30PlusSkinCare, r/Ulta. Top-rated brands include Maybelline (4.3/5), Tarte (4.6/5), NARS (4.5/5).
Stats
Reviews456
Subreddits22
Posts96
Brands41
Products87
456 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Maybelline
4.3
(49)
"Maybelline’s Instant Age Rewind Concealer, with the sponge tip. Let me tell you, it is wonderful."
"Maybelline age rewind concealer is the top notch one"
"Maybelline Age Rewind is the best undereye concealer I've come across"
"The only under eye concealer I have ever loved is the maybelline age rewind."
"The Maybelline Age Rewind in Brightening is my holy grail."
"I've had excellent results with the pink Maybelline Age Rewind concealer (160 Brightener)."
"100% dupe for the Nars concealer! Why has no one mentioned this?! I've been using it for 7 years religiously!"
"Maybelline eraser(pretty sure it has different names uk/us) but it has a sponge on top."
"Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circles Treatment Multi-Use Concealer."
"Maybelline Age Rewind, Nyx Bare with Me, Elf Hydrating Camo (for dry skin)"
#2
Tarte
4.6
(44)
"Tarte shape tape is a gem"
"I use tarte shape tape concealer."
"I’ve been using Tarte Shape Tape Concealer."
"I use Tarte’s maracuja creaseless concealer and haven’t found anything better. It’s good coverage but it doesn’t look or feel heavy."
"Tarte shape tape!"
"Tarte is the best ever."
"Tarte cc clay undereye corrector!! It looks like skin and doesn't crease."
"Tarte cc clay undereye corrector, been using this for over a decade, nothing comes close"
"I use tarte’s shape tape."
"Shape tape works great but let it dry for a few minutes."
#3
NARS
4.5
(39)
"NARS radiant creamy concealer will never let me down."
"My two favorite concealers are the NARS Rasiant creamy, and the Natasha Denona Hy Glam concealer."
"Just tap lightly using your fingers"
"The Nars soft matte concealer in the little pot jars is amazing for under eyes!"
"Nars is the only concealer that can cover my dark circles."
"NARS radiant creamy concealer!"
"My favorite concealers coverage wise are hourglass vanish, Nars soft matte and hauslabs."
"I always go for the nars radiant creamy concealer."
"My favorites are the Nars soft matte and Dior."
"I love Nars radiant creamy concealer!! Makes me look away and it's not dry at all!!"
#4
Dior
4.8
(28)
"Dior forever is my HG. Just be sure to prep the under eye first."
"The Dior Forever Skin Correct has been great for my creases. It seems to last forever too."
"I’d say go with the Dior forever skin correct."
"Dior! I’ve been a tarte shape tape fan but Dior is another level."
"My personal favorites are Dior Forever Skin Correct."
"Dior Backstage concealer. I have super dry under eyes and this doesn’t flake."
"I like Dior forever skin correct the best out of all the concealers I’ve tried."
"My new holy grail is the Dior Forever concealer if you want more coverage."
"Has been incredible."
"Dior forever. The most beautiful concealer I have ever used."
#5
NYX
4.4
(30)
"Nyx serum concealer."
"All my high end concealers have been wasting away in the drawer since I got the NYX serum concealer."
"I love the NYX Bare with Me Serum Concealer."
"NYX bare with me serum concealer!"
"Nyx bare with me serum concealer! Honestly the best one I've tried and it's the only concealer I buy now, plus it's affordable!"
"The NYX bare with me serum Concealer is the best for what you're looking"
"I always use the Nyx Bare With Me serum concealer."
"I love the NYX bare with me serum concealer for under my eyes, it’s not cakey and doesn’t dry my skin out"
"Literally the nyx bare w me is the best drugstore concealer I’ve ever used imo."
"The nyx serum concealer with the pink clear cap works so good."
#6
Glossier
4.2
(26)
"Stretch concealer by Glossier is my fave. Doesn’t go dry and cakey at all."
"Glossier stretch is my holy grail."
"Glossier Stretch Concealer is PERFECT for dry skin."
"Glossier stretch and Armani luminous silk."
"The glossier concealer is actually great for dry skin."
"It looks and feels fantastic when I’m going through a dry spell!"
"I’m pretty dry and like the glossier stretch concealer!"
"I love that it is so buildable as well."
"Glossier takes a bit to dry down, if I’m in a hurry I can use a tiny little bit of powder, and it’s really like my skin."
"Glossier stretch concealer! Maybe a color corrector underneath if you need it"
#7
Kosas
4.4
(23)
"Natasha denona and Kosas have great ones"
"This covers up my bags."
"The Kosas concealer has been my saving grace."
"I love the Kosas one! Hydrating, medium coverage, creamy."
"I have the Kosas and I really like it! It’s hydrating and looks better than any other concealer that I’ve tried as far as not settling into creases and stuff like that."
"Check out the Kosas Revealer Concealer, it sounds exactly like what you're looking for"
"Kosas Revealer Concealer or Make Up Forever Self Setting are my go tos."
"I just bought the kosas concealer in the sale and have been really enjoying it! It is super creamy, matches me perfectly and doesn’t crease!"
"Top three I can think of recently that have gotten a lot of attention."
"I use the kosas one and I like it."
#8
IT Cosmetics
4.8
(18)
"It cosmetics bye bye undereye!!!"
"I like IT cosmetics bye bye under-eye - a little tiny bit goes a long way but it’s def full coverage but much more moisturizing than shape tape."
"Or try Bye Bye Undereye … it is very heavy coverage."
"It cosmetics bye bye undereye. Only one that covers my dark cucles with a tiny amount."
"Or if I need a little extra coverage some days I use it cosmetics bye bye under eye - omg it is INSANE so much coverage and a great formula"
"I apply a few dots directly on my dark lines."
"It’s my go to concealer with full coverage."
"I really love It cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye."
"I like the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye."
"I really like the IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye."
#9
Haus Labs
4.5
(19)
"Haus labs concealer is fantastic for my dry/maturing undereyes."
"I layer a color corrector + the Haus labs concealer."
"Haus labs!!!! Omg life changing"
"Another vote for Haus Labs! It's creamy and brightening."
"Great coverage and minimal creasing. I ditched Lancome and It Cosmetics concealers for Haus Labs."
"LOVE hauz labs concealer too!"
"This works fantastically and doesn't dry my skin."
"Haus Labs concealer is fantastic for very dry/maturing skin and is my current favorite."
"I tried a sample of Haus Labs and I swear my eyes have never looked that good before."
"I really enjoy the Haus Labs Concealer!"
#10
Natasha Denona
4.9
(15)
"I’ve heard that Natasha Denona’s Hyglam concealer is great for reducing under eye creasing."
"Natasha Denona. Put a small amount on your the top of your hand and dip finger or brush tap lightly where you need it, working in thin layers."
"Natasha denona concealer!"
"The Natasha Denona Hy-Glam Concealer is unbeatable in my opinion."
"The best one iv tried is the natasha denona one. It's highly highly pigmented and incredibly light."
"Natasha denona and Kosas have great ones"
"Natasha hands down."
"Natasha Denona!"
"The Natasha Denona concealer is super thin and VERY full coverage. one of my favorites!!!!"
"Try the Natasha Denona one. Delightful."
#11
It Cosmetics
4.5
(16)
"It cosmetics bye bye under eye"
"I like IT cosmetics Bye Bye undereye."
"The it cosmetics bye bye undereye concealer is the best hands down."
"Hands Down, It Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye Concealer."
"I’ve been using the it cosmetics bye bye under eye and it LOVE IT"
"It's not a super hyped/popular concealer but after trying over 25 concealers it's the most reliable product for dry under eyes."
"IT Cosmetics Bye bye under eye, love it!"
"Very moisturizing, full coverage, huge shade range."
"I use IT bye bye under eye concealed."
"I remember trying It cosmetics concealer and found it similar to Keramask"
#12
Tower 28
4.8
(13)
"I love Tower 28 concealer. I’m older and it doesn’t settle into lines/creases."
"The tower 28 concealer is what I use and really like."
"I’ve switched to Tower 28’s serum concealer and absolutely love it."
"Total game changer. For reference, I use Tower28 (it’s my holy grail)."
"I like the Tower 28."
"Is my go to for no makeup makeup days"
"I also love tower28."
"Tower 28! I actually wear this alone without foundation 80% of the time."
"I like tower 28!"
"I got the Tower 28 this week and have loved it so far."
#13
Kulfi
4.5
(13)
"The only concealer that has ever worked for me is the Kulfi main match. I actually mix it with Charlotte Tilbury’s beautiful skin concealer and set it with the Huda easy bake loose powder and it’s perfection."
"The only concealer that has ever worked for me is the Kulfi main match. I actually mix it with Charlotte Tilbury’s beautiful skin concealer and set it with the Huda easy bake loose powder and it’s perfection."
"I have dry under eyes and really like the kulfi concealer. I have found it creases less than any of the others I’ve tried."
"Kulfi concealer is my winner for the past 2-3 years."
"My current favorite concealers when I want good coverage is the Kulfi one."
"Kulfi concealer or Urban Decay Quickie"
"I’ve been having luck with the Main Match Crease-Proof Long-Wear Hydrating Concealer by Kulfi."
"I like hourglass, kulfi, and the lip bar concealers."
"I also own kulfi and it’s great if you’re looking for a concealer with a thinner consistency."
"Kulfi is the most hydrating and does not crease on me."
#14
Huda Beauty
4.5
(11)
"Huda Faux Filter Concealer. My Holy Grail for aging skin with horrible dark circles"
"Thin and pigmented and wears well without creasing is Huda Beauty Fauxfilter concealer hands down the best and exactly what you are looking for."
"I’m a Panda girl too and I can help you out. I’ve tried so many concealers but the huda faux filter one is the best."
"Game changer for me!"
"I like huda beauty under eye corrector first. Let it dry and then a touch of concealer."
"The rosiest by far."
"Huda beauty does not crease but it can be drying overtime."
"Haus labs and huda are very thin and liquid, medium to full coverage and have self-setting quality."
"You may want to look into Huda Beauty's Glowish concealer in porcelain."
"I like the Huda Glowish concealer as it's the only one I've tried that settles the least."
#15
Too Faced
4.3
(11)
"Just blend well"
"It’s lighter and more hydrating than other concealers."
"Too Faced 'Born This Way' concealer has been a game changer for me!"
"The too faced born this way concealer is amazing!"
"Perfect coverage, blends beautifully, doesn’t settle into fine lines, and doesn’t crease."
"I somehow still was able to find my match in too faced and love that as well"
"I like too faced born this way light illuminating smoothing concealer."
"Try the too faced ethereal light concealer it’s a medium coverage with a skin like finish"
"I use the too faced born this way concealer and it’s great!"
"It's not a full coverage concealer, but it gives around medium with a very natural finish."
#16
Hourglass
4.7
(10)
"Hour glass always!! And for drugstore Nyx!"
"I really like the Hourglass concealer, I haven’t had issues with it creasing."
"It’s water based/hydrating and creamy. Didn’t exaggerate my under eye lines like others do."
"Hands down hourglass concealer. Full coverage, no creasing."
"The only concealer that works for me is the hourglass concealer."
"I love hourglass vanish concealer for under eyes."
"Provides great coverage and looks so skin like and is illuminating."
"I add Glossier Concealer or Tower 28 or Hourglass."
"I like hourglass, kulfi, and the lip bar concealers."
"I love the hourglass one."
#17
Bobbi Brown
4.6
(8)
"As someone in their 40s as well, I find the Bobbi Brown undereye corrector to be really good."
"My favorites - Bobbi Brown Undereye Corrector."
"A little goes a long way"
"You might like the Bobbi Brown undereye color corrector?"
"The Bobbi Brown Under Eye Corrector is my go-to! It’s got the right amount of coverage to conceal/correct but still blends in if you’re not wearing foundation."
"If you want something full coverage then I’d try Bobbi Brown or Nars."
"If you want something full coverage then I’d try Bobbi Brown or Nars."
#18
e.l.f.
4.0
(8)
"I recommend the elf hydrating camo concealer."
"Elf hydrating camo concealer."
"You may enjoy the elf hydrating camo concealer!"
"The ELF hydrating concealer is really nice! It doesn't emphasize any dryness and has good coverage."
"I'm wanting to try the elf hydrating one."
"I really like the Elf hydrating concealer for drugstore choices."
"I go on top with either cover girl trublend undercover concealer or the elf hydrating camo concealer."
"Going to go against the grain here and not recommend the ELF ones."
#19
MAC
4.5
(6)
"Another good one is the MAC prolong wear concealer in NC20 or NC25"
"Try a full coverage liquid concealer like MAC Pro Longwear."
"MAC Pro Longwear!"
"Mac prolongwear."
"Mac Pro Long Wear concealer"
"I have the Mac Pro Longwear concealer and I love it."
#20
JOAH
4.8
(5)
"JOAH Eye Serum Concealer is the best and it really doesnt crease and looks like skin."
"The only one that isn't dry, doesn't crack or crease is Joah Eye Serum Concealer from CVS."
"Joah eye serum concealer from CVS."
"Joah eye serum concealer is awesome."
"Drugstore option is Joah Eye Serum concealer."
#21
YSL
4.6
(5)
"I use YSL Touché Eclat"
"YSL Touche Eclat followed by Laura Mercier setting powder is 👩🍳’s 💋!"
"Ysl touché eclat always works for me with no foundation. Handy for touch ups too"
"Maybe try a 'brightener' - like YSL Touche Éclat in 'Luminous Radiance'."
#22
LA Girl
4.2
(5)
"L.A. Girl Pro Conceal - you can buy it on PrincessPolly."
"LA girl. I’m 45 😊"
"I often wear LA Girls Pro Conceal without foundation."
"I like la girl and shape tape."
"I find la girl pro conceal is lovely if applied thinly!"
#23
Rare Beauty
4.2
(5)
"The Haus Labs is my favorite."
"Rare Beauty Concealer"
"I know it’s kinda expensive but the rare beauty concealer."
"Rare beauty under eye brightener!!"
"I really like the Rare Beauty concealer! I find it hydrating and it doesn’t crease bad under my eyes."
#24
The Saem
4.8
(4)
"The Saem Concealer! It's the best."
"It’s like a dupe for shape tape but less than $10."
"I swear by The Saem Perfect Tip Concealer."
"I use the Saem concealer in brightened (the shady is light pink and cancels out the darkness)."
#25
Urban Decay
4.5
(4)
"It's full coverage and it blends out so easily."
"It has amazing full coverage and the lightest shade is perfect."
"I use the urban decay concealer and it works well for me!"
"I apply it with a slightly damp beauty blender, and it has nice coverage."
#26
Makeup Revolution
4.5
(4)
"My HG concealer is Revolution Beauty Conceal and Define."
"Makeup revolution, you can get it at Ulta and it’s $7."
"Makeup Revolution Conceal and Define concealer is great in my opinion."
"Makeup Revolution and Colourpop both have great concealers."
#27
Elf
4.0
(4)
"Elf hydro camo concealer"
"Pat McGrath and Elf Hydrating"
"I use the ELF hydrating camp concealer."
"I use the ELF hydrating camo concealer applied with a sponge."
#28
Benefit
5.0
(3)
"I'm an Erase Paste fan for life."
"I use Benefit's Erase Paste to correct my extreme under-eye darkness."
"I use benefit's erase paste."
#29
Pat McGrath
4.7
(3)
"I’ve been through 3 Pat McGrath sublime concealers. It’s so so good."
"I have used the Lancôme, kulfi and Pat McGrath. All three are a solid medium coverage in my opinion."
#30
Armani
4.7
(3)
"Armani’s luminous silk was a game changer for me."
"Armani Luminous"
#31
Becca
4.3
(3)
"This is my favorite, I’ll put a lil of this on my eye bags and then throw some foundation or concealer over it."
"I like the Becca under eye brightening corrector with the glossier stretch concealer."
"Applying a colour corrector with luminescence (Becca under eye brightening corrector) on inner corners with finger"
#32
Lancôme
3.7
(3)
"Angie of hot and flashy reviews concealers for mature under eyes that might be worth checking out! I believe she likes the lancome one."
"I got some of the Lâncome during the Ulta sale and I'm really liking it. It's thin but has good coverage."
"I have used the Lancôme, kulfi and Pat McGrath. All three are a solid medium coverage in my opinion."
#33
Nars
5.0
(2)
"I also love Nars radiant color corrector!"
"I have really dark circles and I use Nars radiant colour corrector first."
#34
Charlotte Tilbury
5.0
(2)
"Favorite concealers are the Charlotte Tilbury Magic Vanish."
"I like to use a color corrector under any concealer for undereye area (I have been using Charlotte Tilbury Magic Vanish for this)."
#35
Chanel
5.0
(2)
"I will always recommend the Chanel le correcteur in peach"
"I use the Chanel le correcteur. It’s always been my favorite for dry skin."
#36
Colourpop
5.0
(2)
"I find Colourpop No Filter concealer set with a light pressing of powder on a brush works well for me."
"I freakin love the stuff."
#37
Winky Lux
4.5
(2)
"I LOVE the Winky Lux Peeper Perfect Under-Eye Concealer. Went on a long search for a moisturizing, long lasting concealer that didn't set into my creases."
"I also like Winky Lux perfect peeper."
#38
L'Oreal Paris
4.5
(2)
"L'oreal True Match Hyaluronic Radiant Serum Concealer is my holy grail."
"L'Oreal Paris True Match Radiant Serum Concealer with Hyaluronic Acid"
#39
Catrice
4.5
(2)
"Catrice under eye brightener!! So much better than any concealer I've tried! Does not settle into creases at all"
"Catrice under eye brightener"
#40
Dermablend
4.5
(2)
"Dermablend concealer works really well."
"Dermablend is a brand that’s available at Ulta. I haven’t tried it myself, but I understand it’s designed to cover up discoloration."
#41
Laura Mercier
4.0
(2)
"My favorite is the one by Laura Mercier!"
"I'm a fan of the Laura Mercier concealer."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
