Undereye Concealer reviews from Reddit

Summary

We analyzed 219 Reddit reviews across 14 subreddits and 56 posts to rank the best Undereye Concealer brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/MakeupAddiction, r/Sephora, r/Makeup, r/PaleMUA, r/AustralianMakeup. Top-rated brands include NARS (4.6/5), Maybelline (4.2/5), Tarte (4.6/5).

Stats

Reviews219

Subreddits14

Posts56

Brands51

Products89

Top communities

r/MakeupAddiction77 r/Sephora48 r/Makeup34 r/PaleMUA13 r/AustralianMakeup12

219 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

NARS

4.6

(26)

"It is an amazing concealer love it!!"

"I love the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer!"

"Best combo of high enough coverage with the least amount of dryness."

"Nars cafe con leche has an olive undertone too."

"Nars radiant creamy is my HG."

"I use the nars radiant creamy concealer just under my eyes and on spots!"

"I absolutely love the Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer."

"I really like the NARS Radiant Creamy concealer and the Fenty concealer is surprisingly hydrating and creamy too!"

"Either the Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer or Milk Makeups Flex Concealer."

Maybelline

4.2

(25)

"Maybelline Age Rewind concealer is my all time fave."

"I’ve been using Maybelline instant age rewind for years. I like the fact that it covers without being too heavy."

"Maybelline instant age rewind!"

"I recommend Maybelline Fit Me if you can find a shade that works for you."

"Maybelline Age Rewind, either in a shade to match your skintone..."

"My top 3 for undereye are Charlotte Tilbury Retoucher, Maybelline Age Rewind, and Bobbi Brown corrector in the pot."

"I found a really good combo that brightens without creasing is Maybelline Age Rewind."

"The absolute best drugstore concealer I've ever used was Maybelline Instant Age Rewind."

"Fit me concealer is pretty good"

"Maybelline is honestly better in my opinion."

Tarte

4.6

(18)

"Tarte Shape Tape is just by far the best concealer when it comes to undereye darkness."

"Tarte shape tape, maybelline age rewind."

"I love Tartes shape tape."

"I have been loving the Tarte creaseless concealer for exactly this!"

"I absolutely love Tarte Shape Tape!"

"Tarte Shape tape or Nars soft matte creamy concealer!"

"The best one I have come across is the Tarte Shape Tape."

"Shape Tape has become my HG concealer."

"Another vote for the tarte sharp tape."

"So I tried out Tarte shape tape and I love it!"

Benefit

4.5

(13)

"Benefit Boing Creasless Concealer. Best coverage ever - more than shape tape."

"Benefit Boi-ing Hydrating Sheer Concealer (aka Fake Up) - literally the only concealer I've tried that doesn't cake up under my eyes."

"I use Benefit FakeUp. It looks like a lipstick for easy application and I have never had a problem with flaking or creasing."

"I like boi-Ing by benefit. A LOT. The coverage is great and it stays put and doesn't crease or look awful."

"Benefits erase paste!! It's pricey but it last a while and so hydrating!"

"I'm currently loving Benefits erase paste... You only need a little but and I set with powder and good to go all day!"

"Pair the roller up with a concealer like booing from benefit."

"...or Benefit pot color corrector concealer."

"I can recommend a few different products: - Benefit Bo-ing concealer in shade 1"

"I layer Benefit Erase paste in Medium under Mac studio finish Concealer."

Tower 28

5.0

(11)

"My new favorite concealer is Tower 28. It’s great for dry and aging skin."

"I really like my Tower 28 concealer. It is quite moisturizing."

"Glossier & Tower 28"

"Haus labs and tower 28 are the two best from a fellow dry girlie"

"Tower 28 is the best for my sensitive, dry, fine lines undereye"

"I asked the same question a few weeks ago and ended up trying T28 and I’ve been very happy so far!"

"Second Tower 28"

"Tower 28 is so good. I have very sensitive dry under eyes and this concealer doesn’t irritate my eyes."

"It’s a great concealer and I’ve never had any issues with creasing."

"The ones I’ve found that work the best are tower 28, Natasha Denona and for a lighter coverage, glossier stretch concealer."

It Cosmetics

4.8

(11)

"Covers EVERYTHING."

"Working best for me."

"IT cosmetics bye bye undereye is a great concealer with a large shade range."

"...the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye concealer..."

"Bye Bye Under Eye by It Cosmetics is my favorite."

"It Cosmetics makes a concealer called Bye Bye Under Eye which worked wonders for one of my close friends."

"My standard go to is the IT cosmetics bye bye undereye."

"I use and highly recommend It Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye Concealer!"

"It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under eye sounds perfect for you."

"IT cosmetics bye bye under eye!"

MAC

4.4

(12)

"Creamy gives you the full coverage, not at all cakey."

"My MAC Pro Longwear concealer is great and doesn’t dry me out or get crepey."

"Mac prolong wear is excellent for underneath the eyes"

"If I need more coverage I like Mac Pro long wear!"

"NARS Creamy or MAC Prolongwear!"

"Mac pro longwear concealer"

"I love the Mac studio fix concealer and nc10 is a really good match."

"My favourites are MAC Pro Longwear, MUFE HD concealer, and Clarins Instant Concealer."

"Mac studio finish is my HG (i have really dark circles)."

"Mac's pro longwear conclear"

NYX

4.2

(10)

"I swear by the nyx bare with me concealer serum."

"Nyx bare with me serum concealer"

"Try NYX serum concealer. Nice texture but lightening enough without being heavy."

"Nyx bare with me >>>>>>>"

"Nyx serum concealer! I use it all the time with my skin tints and it still looks very natural."

"Ive heard NYX bare with me is good"

"Nyx serum concealer and revlon skin awaken 5 in 1 concealer. They are waterbased so its a plus."

"I used the NYX peach under eye colour corrector + Shape Tape because concealer on its own wasn't doing the trick."

"NYX's Dark Circle Concealer sits beautifully on the skin..."

"I really like Nyx's dark circle concealer. It's salmon-colored and has china clay in it."

Glossier

4.1

(7)

"Glossier Stretch Concealer is amazing on the undereye and is definitely natural looking!"

"Glossier Stretch concealer. It's definitely lighter coverage, but it wears so nicely"

"The glossier stretch is so flattering. It’s the only thing I’ll put under my eyes to brighten the area up"

"The ones I’ve found that work the best are tower 28, Natasha Denona and for a lighter coverage, glossier stretch concealer."

"Glossier Stretch Concealer"

"Glossier Stretch Concealer in Light 3"

"I really like the glossier stretch concealer!"

#10

Bobbi Brown

4.5

(6)

"Try Bobbi Brown's color corrector."

"I think it’s the best product and technique I’ve tried."

"My top 3 for undereye are Charlotte Tilbury Retoucher, Maybelline Age Rewind, and Bobbi Brown corrector in the pot."

"I used Bobbi brown corrector for years and just recently switched to Charlotte tilbury corrector."

"I like the Bobbi Brown undereye corrector."

"I'd personally recommend using a primer and then following it with Bobbi Brown's Corrector."

#11

Natasha Denona

4.5

(6)

"Love Natasha denona and ABH"

"Natasha denona hands down"

"The ones I’ve found that work the best are tower 28, Natasha Denona and for a lighter coverage, glossier stretch concealer."

"The Natasha Denona concealer she came out with a year ago"

"I love Natasha Denona’s concealer."

"I just bought a mini and loving it so far."

#12

IT Cosmetics

4.6

(5)

"I like this one as well!!! It works so well for my undereye, and a little truly goes a loooooooooooong way."

"I use it to cover pimple or marks and it is amazing and lasts all day."

"I just bought it on a whim last month for the first time and love it too!"

"But the IT worked best for me for a long time. Just needed the tiniest amount, blended out beautifully."

"It’s not the best for me anymore but that was my go to concealer for many years."

#13

Too Faced

4.6

(5)

"I love the Too Faced Born This Way, it’s a classic."

"All time best coverage concealer for me is too faced born this way concealer."

"I really like the tf born this way."

"Too Faced Born this Way concealer is great for a “your skin but better” look."

"I really like the too faced born this way- good coverage, doesn't crease, looks natural."

#14

Dior

4.8

(4)

"Dior forever skin!!!!"

"Dior forever skin!"

"Dior forever skin correct"

"Dior forever skin correct."

#15

Rimmel

4.3

(4)

"The only one that really has worked for me is Rimmel lasting radiance concealer"

"Rimmel has a liquid under eye concealer that's very smooth and moisturizing (and cheap)."

"If you want a thin hydrating consistency with light-medium coverage, get the Rimmel wake me up concealer."

"Drugstore: rimmel wake me up concealer is great."

#16

Kosas

4.0

(4)

"Kosas is the best for dry under eyes"

"Second the Kosas concealer! Better shade range than Chemist and nice formula all round."

"None was able to cover my hickies except for that kosas and it stayed almost the next day as well. It’s creamy non drying actually."

"I never understand the recommendations of nars, hourglass or kosas for dry under eyes. I found them all to be SO drying."

#17

The Saem

4.7

(3)

"Their concealer in shade brighter is the best pale pink concealer I've found so far."

"I would recommend The Saem Mineralizing Creamy Concealer in #0.5 Snow."

"I really like The Saem concealers. I have a peach beige one that I use under my eyes and I love it."

#18

Huda Beauty

4.3

(3)

"I bought the Huda corrector during the sale and love it so far, very easy to blend."

"Huda’s is pretty good and offers enough coverage for me."

"Huda corrector is good; so is Lancome."

#19

Smashbox

4.3

(3)

"I just bought Smashbox hydrating under eye primer and Smashbox concealer for my eyes."

"The Smashbox Becca one is very brightening, emollient but doesn't crease!"

"I love the Smashbox Hydrating Under Eye Primer, Clarins Instant Light concealer."

#20

e.l.f.

4.0

3.0

(1)

"Check the L'oreal age perfect concealer."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started