Winter Jacket reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 286 Reddit reviews across 46 subreddits and 71 posts to rank the best Winter Jacket brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/BuyItForLife, r/askTO, r/askvan, r/arcteryx, r/PatagoniaClothing. Top-rated brands include Canada Goose (4.4/5), Patagonia (4.5/5), Carhartt (4.7/5).
Stats
Reviews286
Subreddits46
Posts71
Brands64
Products50
286 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Canada Goose
4.4
(25)
"Canada Goose jackets are as good as it gets!"
"Got a Canada goose from DHGATE. It’s actually soooo warm and high quality."
"Canada Goose is best if one can afford it."
"I have a Canada Goose Emory Parka. I love it. It was expensive, but well worth it."
"I personally have a Canada goose from ten years ago."
"How about Canada goose?"
"Canada Goose. They are expensive (ish) up front but they last forever."
"Canada Goose is popular but it’s significantly warmer than almost all other parkas."
"But even then I would advise some thermal layers and a fleece layer to keep you warm."
"If you’re in colder urban area’s or planning on being outside for extended periods we go out with our canada goose’s."
#2
Patagonia
4.5
(22)
"Workwear Patagonia has some great options, get the thicker puffy coats and they will keep you warm."
"If something breaks on it you can send it back to them and they patch it up / fix it."
"Patagonia down sweaters are worth their price tag"
"Look at mountaineering and outdoor brands for high quality buy it for life jackets. Patagonia, Arcteryx, Feathered Friends, Black Diamond"
"Patagonia nano puff + soft shell. This brand has very good customer service and will repair your gear."
"I swear by the Patagonia Jackson Glacier."
"Based on their warranty/repair policy, they're interested in their customers keeping their products for longer."
"Also seconding for north face and Patagonia, both have been obvious choices for decades for a reason!"
"Buy from the likes of patagonia, I also know Rab does good stuff."
"I have a long zip up down parka for single digits and below... a Patagonia down sweater or two."
#3
Carhartt
4.7
(15)
"On sale now for $119 and is a great jacket and very warm!"
"Carhartt from Fleet Farm or online. Can be had for a relatively low price and should last a while."
"Reasonably priced and will literally last a lifetime."
"Anything Carhartt."
"They’re warm and they’ll last you a lifetime."
"Carhartt and nothing else."
"Carhart makes great stuff for dogs and it doubles as a thunder coat too haha."
"Layering is your friend. Could look at Carhartt of course."
"They are warm and cool looking"
"Carhartt is the way to go"
#4
Arc'teryx
4.4
(16)
"Arc teryx. Light windproof waterproof down feathers"
"Look at mountaineering and outdoor brands for high quality buy it for life jackets. Patagonia, Arcteryx, Feathered Friends, Black Diamond"
"Arcteryx are great quality and very warm for how lightweight they feel on."
"Any sort of outerwear you'll be in good hands with Arcteryx and their lifetime warranty."
"Wore my beta insulated the whole time and it was perfect."
"Beta insulated is my favorite jacket I’ve gotten from Arc’teryx so far."
"Also have an Arcteryx Atom and a Beta shell, not as warm but great for layering and worth every penny."
"Atom heavyweight"
"For northern Canada’s extreme cold, consider brands like Arc'teryx or Mountain Hardwear."
"I'm considering the regular Ralle atm, but the person I'm shopping for doesn't like parkas."
#5
Aritzia
4.8
(12)
"Warm to -40C."
"I have super puff from aritzlizia... I can wear a t shirt with any of these in Vancouver and still be warm."
"My partner loves her super puff and I think its on sale right now."
"I bought the long super puff 4 years ago and every winter I’m so happy and grateful I bought it!"
"Superpuff long is my favourite for the Toronto winter."
"I have the Super Puff (and so does half of Toronto lol) it’s very warm for the price!"
"I agree with the Aritzia superpuff."
"100% Aritzia Super puff."
"Aritzia superpuff!"
"Aritzia"
#6
The North Face
4.5
(11)
"REI has a great winter sale going on right now, just got a north face parka for $175 instead of $450."
"I second the north face parka. I love them."
"I had a North Face parka for 8+ years (daily winter wear as my dog walking coat)."
"Also seconding for north face and Patagonia, both have been obvious choices for decades for a reason!"
"Depends where you live. East end - north face,"
"I’ve had a north face shell and liner for over 20 years."
"The Diablo is longer in the body compared to the Nuptse and you also get one with a proper hood."
"A warm one is good. The North Face makes good ones."
"I have a thick Northface that I use for really cold days."
"If you want an inexpensive but good jacket, go on eBay and look for a North Face or Columbia winter jacket."
#7
Hurtta
4.8
(9)
"They're great quality and fit both my Dogo and Doberman"
"It’s the only brand that fits her properly"
"Second Hurtta! Our Hurtta coats fit perfectly and have lots of options to adjust them properly."
"Our Hurtta coats fit perfectly and have lots of options to adjust them properly."
"I suggest to try Hurtta."
"Hurtta 100%."
"I really like hurtta. I get the base layer sweatsuit type one piece and the blanket type jacket for extreme weather."
"Hurrta or Kurgo."
"Hurtta have a variety of waterproof options."
#8
Columbia
4.1
(10)
"I got a Columbia jacket for 16k that is doing a great job."
"Jacket from warehouse store for less than $200."
"I’m really leaning toward Columbia at this point, based from some awesome reviews I’ve read!"
"Check out any of the "Interchange" coats from Columbia. They have 2 layers and are super warm."
"They're both excellent and look as good as when I bought them."
"I always had a Columbia jacket growing up in MN, the ones with the two layers."
"I'd vote for Columbia brand. I had one that was great for 15+ years."
"Columbia makes a nice coat they have them at winners or Marshall’s sometimes."
"Columbia makes coats in big and tall sizes that are relatively affordable."
"Works very well it has brought me back to buy more of their products."
#9
Helly Hansen
4.8
(8)
"Helly Hansen jackets are downright amazing for keeping us warm and dry in the winter season."
"Helly Hansen is nice!"
"Huge fan of Helly Hansen gear generally."
"Huge fan of Helly Hansen gear generally. It just works and it lasts."
"The best coat I’ve had is a Helly Hanson jacket."
"Helly Hanson. Almost too warm. They look thick, but you have full mobility."
"Helly Hansen or North Face"
"It’s more of a rain shell, but works great with a sweater or fleece on cold days."
#10
Uniqlo
4.2
(9)
"Uniqlo does a great down parka."
"Been using Uniqlo for years."
"I bought Uniqlo’s Parka jacket before my trip to Hokkaido, and it really came in handy!"
"LI’m be my Uniqlo puffer"
"Uniqlo is probably the cheapest I'd go for a winter coat."
"I usually just wear my Uniqlo PuffTech parka most of the winter. Once it gets near single digits with wind-chill, I'll break out my Uniqlo Hybrid Down."
"Uniqlo"
"Uniqlo down parka. Waterproof, warm and £40."
"Been using Uniqlo for years."
#11
Fjällräven
4.1
(9)
"Just buy a $1000 Fjällräven and be warm."
"Get a down and a fleece. Parka wise, I use fjallraven."
"How about Greenland winter jacket (115g/m^2 Supreme Microloft)? However, a down jacket would be the best choice if you can stay dry."
"It feels robust and more rigid than Skogso. As I only bought it last year, I never washed it in the machine one, and don’t plan anytime soon."
"If you look around, the Nuuk Lite can be found on sale, usually cheaper than the Greenland Down."
"I usually wear my Greenland winter jacket (fleece lined) in the type of weather you described and find it ok as long as I put a ton of wax on it."
"The Nuuk Lite would be a good choice for damp and windy. It’s also still plenty warm for colder temps."
"Take a look at the Nuuk lite. Waterproof and warm, or the regular Nuuk of the lite doesn’t feel warm enough."
"Fjall Raven has some quality winter coats for much cheaper."
#12
Decathlon
4.0
(8)
"I got an amazing waterproof & warm winter coat from Decathlon for £70."
"Go to a sportsshop like voswinkel or decathlon there are the real winterjackets for under 100€"
"Decathlon, wide price range."
"Decathlon has functional wear that does its job."
"Decathlon or TK Maxx"
"Decathlon and uniqlo will do the trick, good price / quality."
"Many people wear decathlon."
"Not BIFL, but Decathlon occasionally has some good gear."
#13
Eddie Bauer
4.6
(7)
"The parkas are pretty long as well and should keep you well insulated."
"Jackets are super warm and priced decently."
"The Eddie Bauer sale that gets you everything half off is the way to go. Got a coat rated to -30 and good boots for way cheaper then I would have else where."
"Eddie Bauer has perfect jackets for our weather."
"They offer petite sizes too :)."
"Eddie Bauer is a good source for coats."
#14
North Face
4.4
(7)
"I’ve had mine for 15 years , and it’s in perfect condition."
"I have a North Face down jacket that held up in -35C in Canada no problem."
"Either a big thicc the north face down jacket."
"Is pretty solid."
"Your puffy winter coat will be fine. Wear layers underneath the coat."
"I have a Down North Face Parka but usually just keep that in the truck for an emergency."
"I have a Down North Face Parka but usually just keep that in the truck for an emergency."
#15
Moose Knuckles
4.1
(7)
"Moose knuckle and woodpecker hands down."
"My teen has a moose knuckles jacket that he got as a gift and I have to say it is very well made."
"Moose knuckle is by far the warmest jacket but they're stiff, fits small and heavy."
"This is one of the brands im browsing... among others were moose knuckle and canada goose."
"Even the mods will suggest you to try Moose Knuckles."
"I ended up going with moose knuckle instead. Almost half the price, just as warm, and way better style/design."
"It’s more stylish than Canada goose."
#16
Barbour
4.5
(6)
"Always classic Barbour Jackets though are 11/10 and are timeless."
"A coat from Barbour."
"Barbour."
"Really nice stuff available in different style and thicknesses."
"Barbour and filson are good, but you need a liner below 20deg."
"Barbour is not a cold weather jacket."
#17
Super Puff
5.0
(5)
"Super puff is amazing. would 100% recommend."
"I will always recommend the super puff."
"The super puff is the warmest I’ve had."
"It’s SO warm. I’ve worn it in -40 in Winnipeg."
"I appreciate that you can unbutton the side slits."
#18
Mountain Warehouse
4.0
(5)
"Hut up mountain warehouse, they have great prices and loads of options available."
"I have a jacket Mountain Warehouse that's layed me a few years."
"Mountain Warehouse at Mayfair had winter jackets on their clearance shelves for $35 - 50."
"Winners or Mountain Warehouse."
"Don’t waste your money on a Patagonia or something expensive like that in the city like Victoria."
#19
Nobis
4.8
(4)
"I like Nobis jackets, they’re as warm as Canada goose but can go in the washer."
"I prefer nobis for extreme temps"
"Nobis is super expensive but its so worth it."
"Of all the luxury brands I like Nobis’s quality most."
#20
Noize
4.8
(4)
"Noize. I have a parka and it is sooo warm."
"I love my Noize parka!"
"I like Noize a lotttt! They’re cruelty free and very affordable and mine have Lasted 4+ winters!!"
"Not cheap but affordable and great quality."
#21
Pajar
4.5
(4)
"I got a Pajar jacket and it was so warm."
"I bought a Pajar instead of a Canada Goose parka and have loved it so far."
"Pajar is another good label like Canada Goose."
"Pajar, a Canadian company, makes great parkas."
#22
Mackage
4.3
(4)
"Mackage xs fits amazing and is amazing quality i’ve had 2 for years"
"I know Mackage is pricey but it’s Canada Goose goes chic lol best brand IMO for extra warm jackets for those icy days."
"Mackage is super warm and high quality."
"Mackage is the most stylish of the three but not quite as warm(marginally) and not quite as durable."
#23
Nano Puff
4.7
(3)
"Agree that the nano puff is probably the best choice."
"Nano puff should be perfect."
"Great for Florida winters (central Florida anyway)"
#24
Fjallraven
4.3
(3)
"All day"
"If you’re somewhere that gets extremely cold (like -30 Celsius and below) I’d suggest choosing a less preppy option. Think Fjallraven."
#25
Rab
4.3
(3)
"They have a fantastic warranty and are a fraction of the cost of CG."
"Rab is another brand that specializes in down and isn’t as well known but just as good."
"Rab Valiance, waterproof and down insulated"
#26
Moncler
3.3
(3)
"Moncler - I've had some for years that are in heavy rotation. Wear well and warm."
"Moncler's warmth falls off a cliff compared to the 3 listed above but it's a fashion item first."
"Moncler is more of a fashion brand these days. The jackets are well made but you pay a premium for the designer label."
#27
Ruffwear
5.0
(2)
"They're waterproof and great for dogs with deep chests."
"Very good quality."
#28
Keis
5.0
(2)
"Heated jacket definitely the way to go. Good choice!"
"Heated Keis Jacket (get the one with sleeves) you'll never look back."
#29
prAna
5.0
(2)
"I got a puffer jacket from Prana and I LOVE it! So so warm and super cute"
"Really love my puffer from prAna. It’s warm and lightweight."
#30
Thorium
5.0
(2)
"Thorium or Atom AR."
"I live in NH and wear my Thorium daily all winter."
#31
66°North
5.0
(2)
"66 North brand is great. Those other brands look like shit. I wouldn't buy those if they were $100."
"66north. Great quality, warm as fuck. The Scandinavians know about the cold. Fit great on wider shoulders too."
#32
Feathered Friends
5.0
(2)
"Look at mountaineering and outdoor brands for high quality buy it for life jackets. Patagonia, Arcteryx, Feathered Friends, Black Diamond"
"You will not regret this purchase!"
#33
Outdoor Survival Canada
5.0
(2)
"Outdoor Survival Canada gets my vote. Have a Quartz and Nobis too. OSC is the warmest."
"Personally I would look into Outdoor Survival Canada as one of your options."
#34
Didriksons
4.5
(2)
"Warm even in -20 with wool sweater."
"Perhaps didriksons is worth looking into?"
#35
Jackson Glacier
4.5
(2)
"Jackson Glacier Jacket has been incredible for me."
"Jackson glacier jacket keeps me cozy in Colorado winters."
#36
TFG
4.5
(2)
"It's fantastic. It's extremely lightweight and has kept me warm down to roughly 20 degrees Fahrenheit."
"I like it a lot and it’s decent value when it’s on sale."
#37
Outdoor Research
4.5
(2)
"Excellent puffies that fit the shoulders and pull into the waist."
"I've been very happy with my Outdoor Research winter coat and it has a lifetime guarantee."
#38
Downdrift
4.5
(2)
"I have the downdrift and i love it."
"Look for last year's Downdrift or Jackson Glacier or similar on sale."
#39
Duluth Trading Company
4.5
(2)
"Duluth trading company! Look there 1st and compare."
"As for me, I have a Duluth trading company."
#40
Refrigiwear
4.5
(2)
"See if you can get refrigiwear. Warmest jackets in the world."
"Refrigiwear"
#41
Weatherwool
4.5
(2)
"Check out Weatherwool if you are considering wool."
"Weatherwool but you’ll be on the waiting list for a year before you can get one."
#42
Woods
4.5
(2)
"Woods from Sport Chek."
"Woods has some really great looking and warm products."
#43
Quartz
4.5
(2)
"I got a quartz jacket last year and love it."
"I love my Quartz jacket. Quartz is less expensive than Canada Goose but definitely feels high-quality."
#44
Mountain Hardwear
4.5
(2)
"My personal preference in brands for that is Mountain Hardwear - they are just amazing."
"Their stuff is fantastic."
#45
Lands' End
4.5
(2)
"I got a Lands End waterproof parka off eBay for under $50 and it’s lasted me for years."
"Land's End or Eddy Bauer and layers. Colombia's reflective mid-layers are wonderful."
#46
Big Rays
4.0
(2)
"They seem to do the job quite well."
"Kavik from Big Rays. Designed for Alaska."
#47
Arc'teryx Veilance
4.0
(2)
"Veilance is amazing but most people will pass on it compared to Moncler or Canada Goose because it has no logos on it"
"Arcteryx Veilance if price isn’t too much of a concern."
#48
Soia & Kyo
4.0
(2)
"Soia & Kyo + Arc’teryx both have good options!"
"Soia and Kyo is nice, and they have a big archive sale right now"
#49
Canada Pooch
4.0
(2)
"I got a great jacket from Canada Pooch."
"Check out Canada pooch."
#50
Marmot
4.0
(2)
"Try Marmot. Im 6'7 male but thought I'd chime in."
"Marmot has a good sale on their website right now."
#51
Bosideng
4.0
(2)
"Bosideng is the best one I have, but it was quite expensive."
"Bosideng is good. not cheap, but very good."
#52
Peak Performance
4.0
(2)
"I've been happy with my peak performance helium jacket."
"I've been happy with my peak performance helium jacket."
#53
Filson
4.0
(2)
"Check out Filson."
#54
Pawsome Finds
4.0
(2)
"Www.pawsomefinds.shop got affordable winter jacket for dogs. You can try"
"Www.pawsomefinds.shop got affordable winter jacket for dogs. You can try"
#55
Solano
3.5
(2)
"The solono down would be a good option as well too"
"The Solano is very sleek and mostly waterproof but not for hardcore rain or very cold weather."
#56
WinterGreen
5.0
(1)
"Wintergreen is based in North Minnesota by the Boundary waters. My MIL has had their fleece for decades and it’s usually the only thing she needs in the winter"
#57
Frozen Range
5.0
(1)
"If you can find one, grab a Frozen Range. That thing is tuff!"
#58
Black Diamond
5.0
(1)
"Look at mountaineering and outdoor brands for high quality buy it for life jackets. Patagonia, Arcteryx, Feathered Friends, Black Diamond"
#59
Macpac
5.0
(1)
"By far the warmest jacket I ever owned was a Macpac down jacket from New Zealand, it was also probably one of the cheapest."
#60
Manastash
5.0
(1)
"I have a Manastash Monster and it’s incredible."
#61
Kivak
5.0
(1)
"I’d recommend getting a Kivak parka from Big Ray’s in Anchorage or Fairbanks. Outstanding gear."
#62
Denver Hayes
5.0
(1)
"Denver Hayes water resistant puffer from Mark’s Work warehouse for $107 on black Monday. Aritzia super puff dupe and FANTASTIC for water resistance."
#63
Alpha Industries
5.0
(1)
"Bought new in 2018, use it every winter and only repair has been to replace a zipper in 2023."
#64
Hawke & Co.
5.0
(1)
"I swear by this thing. I’ve also worn it for winter hiking and skiing."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
