Yogurt reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 219 Reddit reviews across 34 subreddits and 42 posts to rank the best Yogurt brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/moderatelygranolamoms, r/yogurtmaking, r/LowCalFoodFinds, r/chicagovegan, r/comoxvalley. Top-rated brands include Fage (4.5/5), Siggi's (4.4/5), Chobani (4.1/5).
Stats
Reviews219
Subreddits34
Posts42
Brands61
Products67
219 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Fage
4.5
(30)
"Our local Farm Foods has got the Fage ones in; 2 plain for £3 and two flavoured for £4."
"Fage is the best no fat one."
"I just started making my own and I love it. Saves us SO much money since we were going through 2-3 containers a week and we only like FAGE which is $7/container here"
"Fage yogurt is so good! I get the 5% one for my 2yo."
"I've been using whole-milk Fage Greek yogurt and adding maple syrup and vanilla extract to make homemade vanilla yogurt. It's sooo good!"
"We use plain fage. If I have one, I’ll mash part of a banana and mix some yogurt into it."
"I get 5% Fage. My son eats it plain out of a reusable pouch."
"We do Fage plain or Trader Joe's. I add fruit and/or slivered almonds to it, sometimes a tiny bit of maple syrup mixed in."
"We use Fage!"
"Fage."
#2
Siggi's
4.4
(23)
"Siggi's is the best yogurt. Hands down."
"I love the siggis yogurt and the Icelandic provisions yogurt"
"I love Siggi’s!!! The protein content is great and it genuinely tastes good too."
"Siggi’s is delicious but around 190 cals with 10g of protein per serving."
"Sigis is amazing, tastes just like skyr."
"Their product line is so much better than the competitors it's wild."
"Siggi's came out as the top rated product."
"Siggi’s!"
"I eat Siggi’s with blueberries, granola, and honey."
"I love the Chobani Less Sugar and Siggis Skyr."
#3
Chobani
4.1
(19)
"The best flavor of Chobani zero sugar is Oikos Triple Zero"
"Chobani triple zero vanilla and caramel are favorites."
"All the recommendations here have been great so far, but keep your eye out during the next fall season…that’s when they bring out the pumpkin pie flavor. It’s amazing, wish they had it year round!"
"I’d recommend chobani as they have cheesecake, lemon, milk & cookies."
"My favorites are chobani, noosa, or oui."
"I used plain Chobani and it made great yogurt."
"We love the Chobani, fage, and stonyfield yogurts"
"I like pretty much all of them but the strawberry cheesecake flavor is really good!"
"I have to do the Chobani because it’s lactose free"
"I need to do the chobani zero sugar because it’s lactose free"
#4
Oikos
4.3
(16)
"I also recommend oikos triple zero yogurt (15g protein and 90 cal)"
"I usually go for Oikos Triple Zero because it is high in protein and lower in sugar."
"Oikos Triple Zero Greek Yogurt."
"Oikos high protein!"
"I stick to Oikos Triple Zero, Yoplait Protein, and Chobani Zero Sugar."
"I love Oikios Greek yogurt! Flavors are amazing."
"Oikos is mostly lactose free"
"Love the vanilla add some sugar free coffee syrup"
"I prefer Oikos Triple Zero. They use stevia instead of artificial sweetener."
"I do oikos triple 0"
#5
Greek Yogurt
4.8
(12)
"Plain nonfat Greek yogurt. Add fresh fruit and chia seeds or flax."
"I buy non-fat plain Greek yogurt. Useful for creamy salad dressings, baking, etc."
"Whole milk greek yogurt, only ingredient should be whole milk and the good bacteria."
"We just did whole milk Greek yogurt."
"Greek yogurt is also a great substitute for sour cream."
"0% nonfat plain Greek yogurt tastes exactly like sour cream to me."
"When I'm using greek yogurt as a swap for mayo, I go with the higher fat greek yogurt."
"If it’s a recipe where mayo seems VERY important, I’ll cut the portion of mayo in half and swap the other half with the Greek yog."
"I use a meal service and a lot of meals have sour cream, which I always sub for greek yogurt."
"I use more salt, good amount of ghee, and Greek yogurt because it is tangy."
#6
Cocojune
4.6
(8)
"I just recently discovered cocojune and its been my new favorite."
"Both unsweetened."
"Cocojune and Harmless Harvest are my 2 faves."
"I really like coconut yogurt Because of its yogurt taste, but I also eat silk soy milk yogurt which tastes more neutral to me."
"We love Cocojune."
"Cocojune imo. It doesn’t have weird gums and gels."
#7
Nancy's
5.0
(6)
"No thickeners, no fillers. Just high quality yogurt loaded with 41+ billion live probiotics per serving."
"This is the best commercial yogurt I’ve ever purchased. It’s not runny at all even though it’s not Greek yogurt. It’s fantastic."
"Best brands for starter: Nancy's and White Mountain. Far better than all the usual grocery store options. Very strong in live probiotic cultures!"
"We love Nancy’s cream top whole milk yogurts!"
"We’ve been getting a brand called Nancy’s. It’s some of the best yogurt I’ve ever had."
"My favorite brands are Nancy’s or Bellwether Farms!"
#8
Dannon
3.8
(6)
"Dannon is my first choice for starter. Been using it sucessfully for 40 years in various locations and conditions. Plain, full fat."
"I have used Dannon for starter many times."
"I would just buy a big container of Dannon ('cause I love it)"
"Dannon is better if looking for similar calories than Chobani zero option."
"I like the Dannon Light & Fit strawberry and cherry flavors."
"The Dannon L&F are more at my grocery store. There must be several varients then?"
#9
Two Good
4.6
(5)
"I do too good yogurt (2 g sugar, 12 G protein, plus very civic minded)."
"I like Two Good yogurt."
"I prefer Two Good Yogurt."
"Apparently Two Good has just released a zero sugar variety that, per their website, is lactose-free."
"I like the Two Good brand meyer lemon flavor. It does have 80 kcal and 2g sugar- but it doesn’t have an aftertaste of Chobani, IMO."
#10
Kefir
4.2
(5)
"I replaced all my yogurt intake with kefir. it suits my gut flora much better :)"
"Just wanted to mention that you may like kefir."
"But i would recommend trying kefir."
"Maybe kefir."
"I have mixed plain kefir with flavored to cut the sugar a but"
#11
Luvele
4.8
(4)
"I have to say it is brilliant... has made wonderful yoghurts"
"I eventually got a Luvele and love it. It’s not the cheapest, but I think it’s the best."
"Luvele all the way. Easy to use, can monitor the process visually."
"I'm really happy with my Levele and their exceptional service."
#12
Yeo Valley
4.8
(4)
"I got some yeo valley greek yogurt 2 yrs ago and used it to make my own literally so easy and the tang of yogurt is much more mellow plus never ending yogurt."
"We get the little Yeo yoghurts- no added sugar and come in tiny pots, so good for self feeding with a spoon."
"I buy raspberry or strawberry Yeo valley and then add in extra fruit depending on what I’ve got in."
"I buy the Littles Yeo Valley ones, I checked and the sugars were around 6/7g per 100g which was the lowest ones in the aisle."
#13
Icelandic Provisions
4.3
(4)
"We love Icelandic Skyr!"
"I like icelandic yogurt (skyr) lots of protein not as tart as greek."
"I bought myself Icelandic Provisions and my daughter started snatching them from the fridge."
"Icelandic Provisions has some really good vegan skyr too with good protein content."
#14
Kirkland
5.0
(3)
"Costco just started selling a 0% fat Organic Kirkland brand greek yogurt that fits your description! It's in a round 1.36 kilogram container. Just bought it for the first time and loving it."
"Add some honey and you are in business - I eat it everyday"
"I've been happy with Kirkland Greek yogurt."
#15
Noosa
4.7
(3)
"Is my absolute favorite by far."
"I like the Noosa with lemon curd."
"Have you tried Noosa? I really like their lemon curd."
#16
Epigamia
4.3
(3)
"Epigamia is rlly good if you want an all natural greek yogurt brand"
"Almost every supermarket stock the 50g packs of greek yogurt and its flavored versions. For example, that’s the best option I’ve found at The More supermarket near GH."
"The best I had was from epigamia ,but its expensive."
#17
Skyr
4.3
(3)
"I highly recommend you try Skyr if you ha"
"I like flavored Skyr and will share that with our little when I'm eating it but prefer to give her plain so she isn't used to the sweetened."
"Skyr is an icelandic yogurt."
#18
Milky Mist
4.3
(3)
"Milky mist pure greek yogurt is available in lulu mall . Other yogurts are flavoured and I recommend to avoid them because they are loaded with sugar."
"Skyr from Milky Mist"
"Milky Mist is available in most supermarkets. They also have a skyr , if that is your thing"
#19
Activia
4.0
(3)
"I always ended up going back to Activia! It was good stuff!"
"I like Activia but making it is easy too."
"I do think the activia yogurt works well for me."
#20
Tree Island
4.0
(3)
"I like tree island yogurt, especially the Greek one"
"Tree island (local!) Greek yogurt."
"I'm loving Tree Island's (full fat) Greek yogurt. Admittedly it's not low fat, high protein like many other "Greek" yogurts, but the taste is heavenly."
#21
Goat Yogurt
5.0
(2)
"Goat milk yogurt is what was recommended to me. I bought it at a health food store and my dog goes crazy over it."
"The brand of goat yogurt I like is Capretta. The Rich & creamy version tastes like plain yogurt."
#22
Ratio
5.0
(2)
"I eat Ratio yogurt with added protein."
"Ratio yogurt is really good and has 25g protein."
#23
Instant Pot
5.0
(2)
"I make my own greek yogurt with my instant pot."
"I love my Instant Pot for this."
#24
Brown Cow
4.5
(2)
"Brown Cow the best."
"Brown Cow has some gems."
#25
Lifeway
4.5
(2)
"My favorite is Lifeway Kefir. The flavors are delicious!"
"Try Lifeway Kefir"
#26
White Mustache
4.5
(2)
"Hands down White Mustache if you're in an area where you can get it."
"White moustache is our favorite!"
#27
Aldi
4.5
(2)
"We get the big full fat tub from Aldi. Sometimes we jazz it up with a bit of fruit purée, honey, peanut butter, desiccated coconut, cheerios."
"So is the one from Aldi!"
#28
Maple Hill
4.0
(2)
"The maple hill i got is from a store in my town."
"Maple Hill makes good stuff"
#29
Silk
4.0
(2)
"I like the silk greek, but wish it was sold in large containers."
"The blueberry and strawberry flavors are good."
#30
Ultimate Yogurt Maker
4.0
(2)
"I use the Ultimate Yogurt Maker from Amazon. Like $40 and makes 2 one qt bowls."
"I was thinking of getting a Ultimate Yogurt Maker from Amazon as it's on sale for 60$ compared to it being 80$ just to try it out."
#31
Trader Joe's
4.0
(2)
"We like the Trader Joe’s one too, also Fage since it’s not super sour."
"For some reason I don’t like the Trader Joe’s yogurt cultures- I like their yogurt fine but when I use it as a culture I don’t like it as much as the others."
#32
Red Mango
4.0
(2)
#33
Light & Fit
4.0
(2)
"Light and fit zero sugar flavors are 11g protein and 50 calories if you can find them"
"I like the light + fit zero sugar vanilla sm better"
#34
Kite Hill
2.3
(3)
"Kite hill has a bit of a weird flavor if you eat it alone but has really good macros."
"I didn’t love it at first but when you add some fruit it’s pretty good."
"I've only tried the Kite Hall one...which was awful :<"
#35
Plain Whole Milk Yogurt
5.0
(1)
"Plain whole milk yogurt mixed with natural peanut butter is honestly delicious and could get you to similar protein levels as Greek yogurt!"
#36
Dan Active
5.0
(1)
"Dan Active is my favorite to use form commercial yogurts"
#37
The Collective
5.0
(1)
"Yep same or the collective (brand) - real yoghurt with good bacteria and no added sugar!"
#38
Bio-Kult
5.0
(1)
"Most reliable starter for me are 2 bio kult capsules emptied in cooled down milk."
#39
Cremberie
5.0
(1)
"Cremberie is good one"
#40
Epigamia, Cremberie
5.0
(1)
"I regularly purchase epigamia greek yoghurt from Spring. By quality epigamia is by far the best when it comes to greek yoghurt, for plain yoghurt Cremberie is my choice."
#41
Yeo valley, Sainsbury's
5.0
(1)
"Our baby hated greek yogurt at first but absolutely loved Yeo valley natural yogurt and now loves greek yogurt. Sainsbury's does little pots of greek yogurt for kids."
#42
Aldi, M&S
5.0
(1)
"Mine prefers unsweetened plain Greek yogurt above all. Try it!! He eats any brand from Aldi to M&S lol"
#43
Plant Warrior
5.0
(1)
"It consistently produces creamy, delicious yogurt."
#44
Kite Hill Vegan Greek Yogurt
5.0
(1)
"Kite Hill makes a vegan Greek yogurt that has pretty good macros."
#45
Costco
5.0
(1)
"Costco A2 grassfed yogurt is top notch"
#46
Carbmaster
5.0
(1)
"Their Carbmaster yogurt is delicious and lactose free."
#47
Hidden Valley Ranch Seasoning
5.0
(1)
"Try Greek yogurt mixed with Hidden Valley ranch seasoning packet!"
#48
Taco Bell Quesadilla Sauce
5.0
(1)
"Look up copycat Taco Bell quesadilla sauce and use Greek yogurt instead of mayo and sour cream."
#49
Ultimate Probiotic
5.0
(1)
"I love my Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker. It makes 2 quarts at a time and has adjustable time/temp controls."
#50
VonShef
5.0
(1)
"I bought a VonShef yogurt maker here in the UK, nice and compact."
#51
Premier Protein
4.0
(1)
"Premier Protein Vanilla milkshake powder. Doesn't matter how much, just find a good balance depending on how much yogurt you're eating so it doesn't ruin the flavor or texture."
#52
Little Yeos organics, Rachel's Organics
4.0
(1)
"We sometimes get the Little Yeos organics kids or Rachel's Organics Kids yogurts."
#53
Local Water Buffalo
4.0
(1)
"Have you tried the local water buffalo yogurt? You can get it at Thrifty’s or the farmer’s market. It’s really good!"
#54
Natural Pastures
4.0
(1)
"They make Water Buffalo yogurt and might also make cow greek yogurt too."
#55
Coolinario
4.0
(1)
"I bought a starter culture on Amazon and it turned out pretty great. They are cheap too."
#56
Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker
4.0
(1)
"It has been great thus far!"
#57
Straus
4.0
(1)
"I have been liking Straus after moving to the west coast!"
#58
Wallaby
4.0
(1)
"Wallaby is the best low fat one."
#59
Alexander
4.0
(1)
"I like Alexander whole milk yogurt."
#60
Plant Yogurt
4.0
(1)
"With the plant yogurts it's a real mixed bag on the protein content."
#61
Muralya
3.0
(1)
"Muralya"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
