Bakery reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 347 Reddit reviews across 57 subreddits and 67 posts to rank the best Bakery brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/germany, r/pittsburgh, r/HoustonFood, r/kansascity, r/FoodToronto. Top-rated brands include Lidl (4.7/5), Magnol (4.9/5), Aldi (4.3/5).
Stats
Reviews347
Subreddits57
Posts67
Brands97
Products5
347 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Lidl
4.7
(23)
"Lidl 100%💥🔥🔥"
"Hello Americans, in my opinion is the best supermarket bakery ever in the world Lidl."
"Have the best "Apfeltaschen"!"
"Lidl has the best bakery and fresh"
"Lidl"
"Lidl"
"Lidl"
"Lidl bruder"
"Lidl"
"Lidl"
#2
Magnol
4.9
(12)
"MAGNOL, mademoiselle Louise, love croissants, koffeteria, eaDough, Paris baguette, badolina basque cheesecake is to die for."
"Another vote for Magnol! They’re apparently opening up a location in the heights."
"Magnol no contest"
"Magnol, and it’s not even close."
"I’m surprised nobody has mentioned Magnol!"
"Another vote for magnol"
"Magnol for those incredibly buttery and flaky croissants"
"Magnol is amazing! Mademoiselle Louise is also very good!"
"Magnol, no question"
"Magnol"
#3
Aldi
4.3
(12)
"Aldi for sure🧁🧁"
"Aldi always"
"I like Aldi and Lidl."
"Aldi on top."
"Aldi :3"
"For Franzbrötchen it is Aldi, for the rest it is Lidl."
"Gotta go with Aldi on that one! Rewe is fine as well, they got some fancy things (at least at some places)."
"Probably aldi"
"Aldi is always a solid go to imo!"
"Definitely Aldi but not like the bakery with the fresh stuff I mean the stuff out of the Vending machines it’s like haven 😭🤭"
#4
Bloomers
4.8
(9)
"Bloomers!"
"Bloomers donuts are my favorite."
"Their fritters are fantastic too"
"Can't go wrong with Bloomers and Bunner's Bakeshop."
"My strong personal preference is Bloomer's > Bunner's."
"Bloomers is better than bunners for sweets imho"
"Bloomers is well known for their donuts, and they have several locations in the city."
"Bloomers is great."
"Seconding Bloomers though granted I haven’t tried very many vegan bakeries"
#5
McLain's
4.2
(9)
"McLains is legendary for their cookies."
"The lemon bars are truly *chef’s kiss* — my current obsession is the pistachio bread."
"They have the best lemon bars I've ever had in my life, though! And Povitica bread, too."
"They make the best and most consistent cakes in KC."
"McLain’s is the recommendation for custom cakes."
"McLain’s is great for custom cakes."
"Almost positive McLain's can make you a custom cake of those flavors."
"They have a bunch of cake designs to pick from and offer a chocolate cake and a peanut butter buttercream."
"I got a cake from there one time and it was not great. Kind of flavorless, dry."
#6
Publix
4.8
(8)
"They were excellent!"
"Tasted great too."
"My wedding cake from the Lake Eola Publix was perfect!"
"My wedding cake from the Lake Eola Publix was perfect!"
"Yes we got married November 9 of this year and we absolutely loved our cake."
"I had a publix cake for my wedding and it was SO. GOOD."
"Very nice catering team to discuss the cake with also."
"They will typically have fall / Halloween selections out."
#7
Dolce
5.0
(7)
"Dolce has thoroughly impressed me every time I've been there."
"Another vote for Dolce."
"I ordered 2 different birthday cakes from Dolce in April and both times it was a great experience."
"Dolce is absolutely the move."
"Dolce has a chocolate/peanut butter cake I would eat off the floor before any other cake in town."
"Dolce in prairie village has our fam's favorite chocolate cake."
"They’ve done a few of our bdays and our wedding."
#8
Flour Child
4.1
(8)
"By far the best is Flour Child."
"Flour Child in Grand Ledge"
"Flour Child"
"Yeah, Flour Child is what you're looking for."
"Another vote for Flour Child."
"I would recommend Flour Child in Grand Ledge"
"Flour Child in Grand Ledge is great!"
#9
Edeka
4.4
(7)
"Edeka and Rewe are top tier"
"Edeka and Rewe are the bakery kings in Germany."
"Without any doubt and without any debate possible edeka."
"Ganz gut ist."
"Definitely a big edeka in my town. It's just a crazy good bakery ya know"
"I think it’s underrated."
"Is hit or miss."
#10
Rewe
4.3
(7)
"Rewe 100%"
"Rewe"
"1. Rewe -> Good for proper bread and bread rolls."
"I would say Rewe"
"Rewe with Meisterbäcker"
"I buy from Rewe, it also sells simit (turkish) in our city."
"I think Lidl is a Little overrated rewe is The best"
#11
Northern Rye
5.0
(6)
"I got a country sourdough loaf, some foccacia, a peanut butter and jam cookie and a cinnamon bun, all delicious."
"For bread I agree with the consensus on Northern Rye."
"It’s categorically northern rye"
"Northern rye is one of the best in the country never mind the toon!"
"Northern Rye by far. FAB does a lot of good stuff but there's always massive holes in their sourdough."
"Northen Rye. Nothing even comes close!"
#12
Kaufland
4.5
(6)
"Kaufland IMO"
"Kaufland"
"If I really had to choose, Kaufland would be my pick"
"Kaufland and Lidl"
"Would be my pick."
"I like the diversity of products especially in summer for grilling."
#13
Isgro
4.2
(6)
"Isgro's!!!"
"I like isgros"
"Isgros"
"Isgro’s"
"Ok Isgros are acceptable"
"I like Isgro, but last time I went there they were out of rainbow (7-layer) cookies."
#14
Porto's
4.6
(5)
"Porto’s. They are a SoCal treat!! They have great everything, don’t forget to try a potato ball while you’re there."
"Porto’s, fat and flour"
"Porto’s"
"What about Porto's?"
"Porto's for Cuban baked goods and food."
#15
Classic Bakery
5.0
(4)
"For most things, Classic Bakery."
"Classic Bakery for sure. I’d always get my birthday cakes from there as a kid."
"Classic bakery. And it’s not even close."
"I live in Pittsburgh now but still think about the cream filled donuts there!"
#16
République
5.0
(4)
"République | Proof Bakery | The Sycamore Kitchen | Lou The French on the Block | Des Croissants Paris | Porto’s | Pascal’s | Artelice Patisserie | Petitgrain Boulangerie"
"Republique, Lou the French on the Bloco, Fleur Et Sel, Paderia, Okayama Kobo, Porto’s, Sarkis Pastry, Paradise Pastry"
"Republique"
"République, Petitgrain Boulangerie, Mr.T, Artelice, Jim’s Bakery, and Sugarbloom Bakery are some of my favorites."
#17
The Pie Fairy
5.0
(4)
"Would do this!!"
"Are good people"
"I order from Pie Fairy and Bubbly Tart."
"The Pie Fairy!! They are so creative and insanely delicious"
#18
Food Glorious Food
5.0
(4)
"In Highland Park on Bryant Street is a smaller bakery but they have excellent cakes, pastries and breakfast offerings!!"
"In highland park!"
"Food Glorious Food in Highland Park is the best!"
"In Highland Park!"
#19
Mademoiselle Louise
5.0
(4)
"I have never been disappointed by anything I have had there."
"LOVE Mademoiselle Louise! It's my Friday stop before work."
"Mademoiselle Louise has been my benchmark for a long time."
"Mademoiselle Louise!"
#20
Proof Bakery
5.0
(4)
"Proof• tartine• fondry• milo and olive• bub and grandmas• republique• just what i kneaded•"
"Proof bakery on glendale blvd is fantastic"
"Highly, highly recommend you go here for breakfast or brunch and then try couple pastries too."
"Proof Bakery in Atwater - and it's worker owned!"
#21
Bricktown Bakery
5.0
(4)
"Bricktown Bakery is amazing."
"Bricktown Bakery in Nevada is worth the trip :) "
"The only correct answer is Bricktown Bakery in Nevada!"
"Bricktown Bakery in Nevada! We get all our cakes from there and they have incredible donuts."
#22
Twisted Croissant
5.0
(4)
"Twisted Croissant ez"
"So far, Twisted is my favorite."
"It’s a tie between Twisted Croissant and Ken’s Artisan Bakery"
"Twisted Croissant is hard to beat."
#23
Five Points
5.0
(4)
"Others have mentioned Five Points but to be more specific, get the chocolate rye cookies. Best cookie I’ve had."
"Five Points, Jak’s, 350 degrees bakery."
"In Squirrel Hill."
"Five points - best croissants in town"
#24
Tous les Jours
4.8
(4)
"Tous Les Jour. End of search."
"It was tasty and very pretty."
"In East Liberty."
"Tous les jours"
#25
Gluten-Free Gem
4.5
(4)
"Gluten Free Gem and New Cascadia are both phenomenal."
"Gluten free gem is my go to."
"Slightly-distant thirds might be Gluten-Free Gem."
"Gluten Free Gem has always served me well."
#26
Muddy's Bake Shop
4.3
(4)
"Muddy’s Bake Shop ftw"
"I'm a huge Muddy's fan!"
"Muddy's or Sweet Lala's"
"Muddy's or Frost Bakery."
#27
Bam Bam
4.3
(4)
"Bam Bam - their patisserie range is amazing."
"Bam bam."
"Places like Bam Bam, Tarte, Paddock and Custard Canteen will be the most popular."
"Bam Bam."
#28
Bakers Hill
3.2
(5)
"You couldn't have a more perfect place name for a bakery."
"The chances are it's excellent."
"Not as good anymore, changed owners or something."
"I don't rate bakers hill very much at all."
#29
Varallo
4.0
(4)
"Varallo’s!"
"Varallo's."
"Varallo"
"Also Varallos on 10th and morris"
#30
Bakeri
5.0
(3)
"Bakeri has amazing sourdough, best in the area."
"Is a total vibe."
"Bakeri is amazing."
#31
Fortunato
5.0
(3)
"Fortunatos don't even look elsewhere"
"Great Italian bakery and I just checked they deliver via ChowNow"
"If you want a great sourdough bread, Fortunato Brothers has a very delicious one!"
#32
Delectable
5.0
(3)
"Check Delectable. Great bakery."
"Delectable bakery is THE way to go for local, custom, and delicious."
"Delectable or doodles dough"
#33
Big Sky Bread
5.0
(3)
"Friendly staff and delicious treats!"
"A staple for everybody I know"
"Everything is delicious"
#34
Homestead
5.0
(3)
"Homestead all the way!"
"Their home page outlines that they do exactly what you're looking for."
"Homestead all the way!"
#35
Kringel
5.0
(3)
"Their pastries are vegan but you’ll love them even if you’re not one"
"I think it has the best pastries in Tallinn."
"Great pastries in Tallinn."
#36
Torrance Bakery
5.0
(3)
"All of my kids' birthday cakes have come from Torrance Bakery on Western."
"Torrance bakery or kings Hawaiian"
"Is this a trick question? Torrance Bakery in old Torrance."
#37
Spread the Loaves
5.0
(3)
"Spread the Loaves in the Shops at Old Town Helotes. I go at least once a week."
"Spread the Loaves!!!"
"Are all great!"
#38
Goodside Pastry
5.0
(3)
"GoodSide Pastry"
"Goodside Pastry House 100%"
"Goodside Pastry House every time."
#39
Sugar Plum
5.0
(3)
"Sugar Plum - tasty, local (not a chain), customizable."
"Sugar Plum is amazing and delicious!"
"Jamie's Bakeshop or Sugar Plum!"
#40
Buttercooky
5.0
(3)
"Buttercooky for something that looks great"
"Can’t say enough positive things about the bakery and the quality of the pastries and cakes"
"Buttercooky for sure!"
#41
Goodside
5.0
(3)
"Goodside comes in 1st 2nd and 3rd. There is no other answer"
"Goodside"
"The staff were super lovely, too. I'm glad we got a bakery like Goodside in Victoria"
#42
Parisi
5.0
(3)
"For sure."
"Parisi for sure."
"We’ve gifted cookies from Parisi and everyone has loved them."
#43
Mr. Baker
5.0
(3)
"Mr baker is our “go-to-cake” their chocolate and vanilla is amazing."
"Mr. Baker"
"Chocolate gnache from Mr.Baker"
#44
Fritz
5.0
(3)
"#2 is Fritz. They do everything well."
"Fritz’s is goated."
"Fritz's makes a cherry crumb pie."
#45
Sweet Magnolias
4.7
(3)
"Would love to get that order!"
"Absolutely hilarious/borderline inappropriate bday cake."
"Sweet Magnolias. I think ordering ends this Friday"
#46
Fry's
4.7
(3)
"Fry’s or Goodside"
"Fry’s bakery, hands down"
"I went to Fry's yesterday and their cakes look delicious."
#47
Costco
4.7
(3)
"I love Costco cakes they always do a good job and I love the way they taste!"
"I'm recommending Costco. I really love their cakes!"
"If you go to Costco, you won’t be disappointed"
#48
Mimi's Bakehouse
4.7
(3)
"Mimi’s hands down! They have lots of options and have delivery/collection across 3 sites in the city."
"We got our wedding cake from Mimi's bakehouse, the carrot cake, they delivered it to the city-centre restaurant where we had our reception and it was delish."
"Mimi's is a lovely family business. They have a couple of vegan cakes available."
#49
101 Bakery
4.7
(3)
"I always go for 101 Bakery or Pastry Section for custom birthday cakes."
"The Sicilian pastry shop and 101 bakery both allow you to order full cakes and are both amazing"
"101 bakery 🙂"
#50
Bunner's
4.3
(3)
"Bunner’s is wonderful, great vegan soft serve too!"
"Yes bunner's."
"Bunner's in Kensington Market. They're still there, and they have some decent baked goods."
#51
Val's Bakery
4.3
(3)
"Incredible"
"Val’s might not have much left if you get there too late."
"Val’s Bakery - downtown Dayton."
#52
Paris Baguette
4.3
(3)
"Paris Baguette is on Church Street."
"Paris baquette, there are multiple locations, but we frequent the one in Katy Asia town"
"Any of the Asian bakeries will do sheet cakes. JJ Bakery, 85 degrees, Paris Baguette, Cake Kobo, Nagomi."
#53
Copenhagen
4.3
(3)
"Copenhagen in Northport has the best strawberry shortcake."
"Copenhagen for reliably good cakes"
"Copenhagen"
#54
My Vegan Sweet Tooth
4.0
(3)
"Ton of Gluten free options."
"Entire gluten free section."
"Vegan treats"
#55
Little Sugar
5.0
(2)
"If you want decorative cakes, little sugar, if you want high quality cakes , then diamond."
"Specially their fresh fruits cake is very good."
#56
Prantl’s
5.0
(2)
"They have a burnt almond torte that was voted best cake in the US."
"It was even our wedding cake!"
#57
Lune
5.0
(2)
"Lune has amazing croissants and great coffee; but they don’t have seating."
"Lune in South Brisbane, Christian Jacques in Kangaroo Point are both great (from a bakery point of view)"
#58
Bushwick Bakery
5.0
(2)
"Run by a baker from Marseille."
"For Croissants, Chocolate Croissants and baguettes."
#59
AngelBaked
5.0
(2)
"Made some cookies for me over the summer and they were so good."
"Made some cookies for me over the summer and they were so good."
#60
Moio’s
5.0
(2)
"Moio’s. They have so many great flavors."
"In Monroeville"
#61
Bavarian Bakery
5.0
(2)
"Bavarian Bakery!"
"Bavarian Bakery"
#62
Moio's
5.0
(2)
"In Monroeville!"
"Those cannolis are the TITS."
#63
Crustum
5.0
(2)
#64
Breadpoint
5.0
(2)
"Shoutout to the person who mentioned Breadpoint, which is a truly fantastic (and very well-priced) Chinese bakery."
"Breadpoint on Low Friar Street"
#65
Beloved's
5.0
(2)
"For bakery, by far."
"Easily best bakery."
#66
Jean Marc
5.0
(2)
"My favorite cake around here is the lemon raspberry from jean marc."
"In millvale"
#67
Villani
5.0
(2)
"I used Villani and it was a huge hit!"
"Villani hands down"
#68
HeB
5.0
(2)
"We've done HeB a couple times for bdays and the chocolate cakes were so moist and delish."
"Heb! They’re so good."
#69
Starter Bakery
5.0
(2)
"Starter Bakery by TJs! Also, Arizmendi (other location)"
"Amazing croissants and I have to guess bread as well."
#70
Boosalis
5.0
(2)
"Boosalie."
"[Boosalis] at Crosspoint in Centerville/Washington Township."
#71
Crossroads
5.0
(2)
"Came here to rec Crossroads pies!"
"Crossroads in Doylestown has a delicious cherry almond pie."
#72
Delvecchios
5.0
(2)
"Delvecchios in Snow Hill and Baked in Berlin are both very good."
"DelVecchios in Snow Hill!"
#73
Rocco's
5.0
(2)
"Rocco’s has some amazing peanut butter cookies."
"Rocco's pizza makes big ass old school recipe peanut butter cookies."
#74
Cramers
5.0
(2)
"Cramer’s, but surprisingly, Acme in Newtown has a great CV bakery."
"Ask Cramers in Yardley. Best bakery in the county."
#75
Bake Affair
5.0
(2)
"* Bake Affair is the best out of all in terms of quality."
"Bake affair is the best out of all in terms of quality."
#76
Cutie Pie
5.0
(2)
"It was a really tasty cake."
"Totally worth it."
#77
Dutch Oven
5.0
(2)
"Dutch Oven is generally considered best in the area."
"Dutch oven bakery on duff by the train tracks! Great coffee and sandwiches, but their pastries are to die for."
#78
Sweet Frostings
5.0
(2)
"Sweet frostings is SO good."
"Sweet Frostings for their cup"
#79
Globus
5.0
(2)
"Globus 100 pro"
"Globus"
#80
Chap's
5.0
(2)
"I love Chap's baked goods"
"Chaps, best bakery/desserts and breakfast spot."
#81
Gutsies
4.5
(2)
"100% go to Gutsies"
"Gutsies brings its pastries in from L’Artisan Délices in Montreal."
#82
Party Cake
4.5
(2)
"Brookline."
"Party Cake in Brookline is good"
#83
Batch House
4.5
(2)
"Another one that hasnt been mentioned yet."
"Is expensive but delicious."
#84
Lincoln Bakery
4.5
(2)
"In Bellevue"
"Lincoln Bakery in Bellevue 15202."
#85
Lucy J
4.5
(2)
"Have used Lucy J for multiple special event cakes and they have all turned out great!"
"Perhaps try Lucy J’S at Crosstown"
#86
Weil's
4.5
(2)
"Someone brought a box of cookies from Weil’s to an event last week."
"Some good ones right now!"
#87
Arizmendi
4.5
(2)
"Arizmendi."
"Arizmendi, Forma, and La Farine are my officially Oakland choices"
#88
Auntie Em's
4.5
(2)
"Auntie Em's has some delicious baked goods"
"Seconding auntie em’s and bad attitude!"
#89
Yukis
4.5
(2)
"Yukis and Old German Bakery are by far the best ones in Hoboken!"
"Yukis"
#90
The Bakery
4.5
(2)
"Everything else is at least one tier lower than most bakeries."
"The Bakery has a great selection!"
#91
Settepani
4.5
(2)
"On Lorimer."
"Or Settepani."
#92
Babettes
4.0
(2)
"Babettes in town or Dry Storage in Boulder"
"Probably Babettes or head to Lyons/Boulder for Moxie"
#93
Bert's Bakery
4.0
(2)
"Usually use Bert's since it's closer but Victorian uses higher quality ingredients."
"Berts bakery on westnedge and Kilgore is our go to."
#94
Funny Face Bakery
4.0
(2)
"Funny face bakery"
"Funny Face Bakery is my go-to for custom cookies."
#95
Bakingo
4.0
(2)
"Very affordable prices & good items."
"Their prices are quite very affordable and their pastries are good."
#96
French Gourmet Bakery
4.0
(2)
"The French Gourmet Bakery on Westheimer near Kirby."
"French Gourmet Bakery (and Magnol too)"
#97
Sinful Confections
4.0
(2)
"Slightly-distant thirds might be Sinful Confections."
"I love sinful confections and you can order through DoorDash for delivery!"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
