Bike Seat reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 160 Reddit reviews across 24 subreddits and 46 posts to rank the best Bike Seat brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/MTB, r/bicycletouring, r/cycling, r/bicycling, r/ladycyclists. Top-rated brands include Brooks (4.2/5), Specialized (4.6/5), Ergon (4.4/5).
Stats
Reviews160
Subreddits24
Posts46
Brands47
Products76
160 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Brooks
4.2
(35)
"I swear by brooks cambium. Just did 100 miles last weekend on it."
"Brooks C-17. Most comfortable saddle I've ever used."
"Brooks Cambium mid width (C15) with the cutout (carved) just works like a miracle for me."
"Saddles are so personal, but I'll add my vote for the Brooks B17. I have it on two bikes, including my touring bike, and it will go on every other bike I ever buy from here on in."
"I've been riding leather for at least 40 years and love it."
"I like the C17 (a lot)."
"For me, it’s a Brooks B-17. Doesn’t mean it’s right for everyone."
"The leather seat made my ride much more comfortable compared to the synergetic seat."
"I use Brooks Conquest and love them!"
"For years, I dismissed these as an anachronistic and overpriced affectation. I was wrong. So wrong."
#2
Specialized
4.6
(15)
"Warning: once you try it you will have to buy it"
"Absolutely the best for me"
"For me (female) the specialized mimic saddles in a narrow size are amazing."
"The S-Works version with the 3D printed mirror is a premium choice."
"Specialized saddles with mimic are highly recommended."
"The Specialized power saddle is perfect for finding the right width for comfort."
"Great option for women with a 30-day return policy."
"Specialized power works great for me."
"I have a saddle from Specialized on my road bike that I love even more."
"Short nose saddles are really popular right now, I always had good luck getting customers on the Specialized Power"
#3
Ergon
4.4
(15)
"I have the ergon SM pro on my three MTBs. A tad more expensive but soooo good"
"I used padded shorts, and now with the Ergon SM Pro I don't even use it anymore."
"Just picked up an Ergon for my SO…game changer! She is so happy and is now riding pain free."
"Ergon, there are no other saddles worth buying."
"Expensive but your ass will thank you for it!"
"Measure your sit bones first because sizing is critical"
"That’s what I run on all my bikes. I size down on my mtb though."
"The Ergon has been great for me, as someone who has struggled previously."
"I think im gonna try the ergon and see how I get on."
"Ergon grips provide excellent comfort and control for handlebars."
#4
WTB
4.1
(13)
"The WTB Volt is the most popular saddle ever. Fits a LOT of people and it’s inexpensive."
"The WTB Volt is the most popular saddle on the planet."
"I find the WTB Volt seat to be particularly comfortable for me and it's not a "cushy" or "soft" seat."
"Bro, everyone's butt is different. You'll have to try them out. I like the WTB Silverado."
"The cheapest version of the WTB Volt is great."
"Measure your sit bones then buy the appropriate WTB Volt"
"My brother has had success with a wtb volt. Um, sqlabs is also highly praised."
"I like the wtb Silverado personally. Titanium is reasonably priced in my opinion and very comfort if you prefer a little extra padding"
"Wtb volt - really liked it but kind of basic"
"Ended up going with an Ergon on all of my bikes."
#5
Selle Italia
4.1
(8)
"Selle Italia SLR Boost TI 316 Superflow for me."
"If I needed a new saddle right now for my bike, I'd buy a Selle Italia SLR Boost."
"A lot of people (including me) love the Selle Italia SLR Boost but saddles are pretty personal."
"It’s a bit trial and error."
"Think im gonna give selle Italia a go. Heard a lot of praise from people in Facebook."
"Novus Boost Gravel Heritage Superflow Saddle"
"I saw some people recommend a noseless saddle or a seat like this but I don't want to spend too much money without knowing if it wi"
"The selle slr boost for example has a wide channel and a lot of people love it, but if I race on it longer than 2 hours it flipping hirts to pee hours later."
#6
Thule
4.5
(6)
"Just wanted to share my experience with the Thule Yepp Maxi. It’s been a game-changer for our family bike rides."
"It feels lightweight and doubles as a stroller too."
"Works absolutely fine. Little one got the handles for her birthday and loves it."
"We've had Thule seats for the last seven years (through two kids, 50km+ days) with no issues."
"I prefer the seat. I don't trust some asshole driver not seeing the trailer. Also, I found trailers cumbersome if you need to get on a sidewalk to lock up your bike."
"The Thule Yepp seat is suitable for larger children but may not be comfortable for long rides."
#7
SQlab
4.6
(5)
"+1 for SQLab, great saddles"
"My ass feels better but even better my lower back feels better."
"Sqlab. Tried brooks, but as they mold to your butt they also mold to your hip dysplasia, haha"
"Big fan of SQlab personally."
#8
Selle Anatomica
4.6
(5)
"LOVE the leather Selle Anatomica."
"Their saddles have a lot more flexibility than any of the Brooks offerings which means no break in."
"Expensive but the best saddle I've ever used, hands down."
"I’ve enjoyed the Selle Anatomica."
"If you want something like the Brooks but a little more flexy/comfy right off the bat, take a look at the saddles Selle Anatomica makes."
#9
Selle
4.6
(5)
"Not the most expensive saddle I’ve owned, but far and away the most comfortable."
"Greatest saddle I have ever used. Its like sitting on a cloud."
"It’s what I use on every bike."
"I have a lot of issues with soft tissue pain and ended up with a Selle SMP that seems to be working out quite well."
"I’m a fan of selle but everyone is built differently."
#10
Cloud 9
5.0
(4)
"I love the Cloud-9 seat I have on my e-bike."
"I really like my Cloud 9 seat."
"I really like my Cloud 9 Seat."
"I use the Cloud 9 Cruiser Gel Saddle seat on my Aventure. It works very well and comfortable."
#11
Chromag
4.7
(3)
"Chromag Trailmaster is one of my favorites."
"Chromag trail master"
"The Trailmaster is their plusher model."
#12
Terry
4.3
(3)
"I am a huge fan of Terry products, so I run a terry topo on my full suspension."
"I have always switched the little bike seat with one that was wide. They are fairly common and easy to find at most stores."
"The men's Liberty series have worked with long hours on the bike for me."
#13
Selle SMP
4.0
(3)
"I'm partial to selle smp. But they (subjectively) look kind of weird and are (objectively) really expensive."
"Selle SMP TRK Gel (it's a saddle)"
"Would a Selle SMP or SLR be of benefit?"
#14
Shotgun Seat
5.0
(2)
"He loves it now. We can ride for a good 4-5 miles no issue."
"My kiddo loves the shotgun seat and can ride 10km on gentle singletrack."
#15
cycling shorts
5.0
(2)
"Do you wear cycling shorts already, with the padding in it? They’re a game changer."
"Do you wear bike shorts. Because a halfway decent set of bike shorts will do more for you than any saddle upgrade."
#16
Fabric
4.5
(2)
"Fabric scoop! I have been using it for 2 years, havent looked back!"
"Fabric scoop - good saddle and flexes but not great for 2hrs+"
#17
Selle Royal
4.5
(2)
"I just replaced my bike seat with a Selle Royal Respiro and I love it! It’s designed for women."
"Try selle royal respiro or Fizik Aliante for extra comfort without the bulk."
#18
SDG
4.5
(2)
"This saddle is the best I’ve ever rode on."
"I've had about three or four SDG saddles over the years. They've always help up and been very comfy."
#19
Fizik
4.0
(2)
"I love my Fizik Argo R1."
"Fizik Terra Argo 160mm"
#20
Sqlabs
5.0
(1)
"The Sqlabs 6Ox was a total revelation. 0 discomfort or numbness after 2h on the trainer."
#21
BiSaddle
5.0
(1)
"I stumbled onto the BiSaddle, now have them on 2 road bikes and a mountain bike."
#22
Hamax
5.0
(1)
"I’ve had the Hamax Caress for a few months now, and I couldn’t be happier."
#23
Pro
5.0
(1)
#24
Hamax Caress
5.0
(1)
"Both have been great."
#25
Thule Yepp
5.0
(1)
"Been very happy with the Thule yepp."
#26
Burley Encore X
5.0
(1)
"We've really enjoyed our time with it."
#27
iBert Seat
5.0
(1)
"I can’t recommend highly enough the iBert seat for little kiddos."
#28
WeeHoo Trailer
5.0
(1)
"We love the WeeHoo, super comfortable for long rides."
#29
Bontrager
4.0
(1)
"Bontrager verse - another very good saddle but my bike got stolen with it, would recommend highly"
#30
Nukeproof
4.0
(1)
"Only saddle besides ergon I've ran that didn't require padded shorts and was/is comfy over 4+ hour rides is a Nukeproof Enduro saddle."
#31
Serfas
4.0
(1)
"Serfas makes several bike seats with a little cushion that might help."
#32
Topeak
4.0
(1)
"We’ve been using the Topeak BabySeat II, and it’s been fantastic."
#33
SQ Lab
4.0
(1)
"My recommendations- If you want a modern seat, SQ lab online."
#34
The Bike Seat
4.0
(1)
"Something like this although I dont know where the feet go."
#35
Terry Bicycles
4.0
(1)
"Have her choose."
#36
Brooke
4.0
(1)
"Brooke saddles are nice. They take a while to work in though."
#37
Hobson
4.0
(1)
"Hobson easyseat."
#38
Terry Liberator Y
4.0
(1)
"For me, it's a Terry Liberator Y. For you? You need to take every recommendation you can find, buy one, and try them until you find the right one for you."
#39
Terry Saddle
4.0
(1)
"I also switched over to a Terry saddle designed/cut for women which made a difference for me."
#40
Pearl Izumi
4.0
(1)
"Pearl Izumi on Amazon will be fine for your needs."
#41
Infinity
4.0
(1)
"Infinity saddles, looks wierd but lots of long distance riders swear on it."
#42
Ergon, WTB, Selle Italia, Terry
4.0
(1)
"Ergon, WTB and Selle Italia/Terry are all decent brands to check out."
#43
Büchel
4.0
(1)
"I swapped the Peloton seat for this on the recommendation of my osteo."
#44
ISM
4.0
(1)
"A mate of mine rides an ISM noseless saddle, not sure if it would suit you, but may be an option."
#45
OKbaby
4.0
(1)
"I have a back seat from OKbaby, and it's great."
#46
Georgina Terry
4.0
(1)
"If you are a female Georgina Terry, makes saddles, for women’s anatomy."
#47
Charge Ladle Saddle
4.0
(1)
"It's slightly shorter and wider than a road saddle."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
