Boxer Briefs reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 421 Reddit reviews across 25 subreddits and 48 posts to rank the best Boxer Briefs brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/malefashionadvice, r/BuyItForLife, r/AskMen, r/bigmenfashionadvice, r/butchlesbians. Top-rated brands include Pair of Thieves (4.6/5), SAXX (4.3/5), Hanes (4.2/5).
Stats
Reviews421
Subreddits25
Posts48
Brands66
Products41
421 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Pair of Thieves
4.6
(33)
"Another vote for pair of thieves simply for price."
"Pair of thieves with the pouch are soooo fire."
"Pair of thieves! V stretchy, comfy."
"They started selling pair of thieves at Walmart I'm a fan."
"Pair of thieves."
"I pretty exclusively buy Pair of Thieves long boxer briefs!"
"I've had great luck with Pair of Thieves."
"Super comfy and don’t roll."
"You can usually get them in target or Amazon."
"I love the boxer briefs at target! “pair of thieves” is one of my favorites."
#2
SAXX
4.3
(30)
"Saxx is the ”if you know you know” of underwear. Nothing else comes close."
"SAXX ftw."
"Highly recommend."
"You can try Saxx."
"I use saxx. Really comfortable and they have held up for years for me."
"I love saxx."
"The Quest and daytripper are my go-to depending on heat."
"Any of those type have been life changing for me. Can’t recommend them enough"
"I like them all for varying reasons."
"Try Saxx."
#3
Hanes
4.2
(25)
"I used to only wear tommy hilfiger, lucky brand, pair of thieves, etc. but i fear hanes are the best."
"Hanes all the way!"
"They are the best. All this fancy posturing. Ladies know you are down for business when you flash that pair of Hanes."
"Hanes boxer briefs. I'd really love someone to show me something better than these because nothing else is close for me."
"Hanes will last a decade"
"Hanes Comfort Flex Fit with gray waist band are the best."
"Switched to these and never looked back."
"Went 13 years without odor or holes before I retired them to rags."
"I love Hanes and Calvin Klein. Fenty has some pretty good ones too."
"I use hanes, but i also have some from transguysupply that are pretty comfortable"
#4
Calvin Klein
4.1
(23)
"Way, way back when, Calvin Klein’s were my goto, and those were as BIFL as could be possible."
"The best briefs were always the Calvin Klein ones"
"I really like these Calvin Klein boxer briefs cause they feel loose like boxers."
"Which are stretchy, breathable and moisture wicking."
"Modal fabric is a GAME CHANGER!"
"Calvin Klein Modal."
"Calvin Klein Modal"
"I found Calvin Klein boxer briefs."
"My Costco has Calvin Kleins that dont have a fly, they're strechy, have a junk pouch"
"Calvin Klein last a long time and are my only pair of underwear I’ll wear."
#5
MeUndies
4.7
(18)
"Me undies. Soft, and wear like iron"
"I am a big fan of Me Undies. Get about 6 years out of a pair."
"+1 on me undies. Love em. Especially the new ball sack."
"MeUndies are the best I’ve found."
"They’re honestly the most comfortable underwear I’ve ever worn."
"MeUndies have been the most comfortable thing I've worn."
"Never had any issues with MeUndies."
"Great customer service and they have fun prints."
"I like meundies cause they’re soft and I haven’t had any rips in 5 years of wear."
"MeUndies!! Are my favorite."
#6
Duluth Trading Co.
4.5
(17)
"Duluth boxer briefs last me a long time and you can wear them in year round no matter how hot or cold"
"I love Deluth Trading."
"Recently switched to Duluth Trading Co. boxer briefs and they are amazing."
"Duluth Trading hands down."
"I own all the versions of the boxer briefs, the run shorts, merino base layers, mtb liners. The are the absolute best."
"I've tried dozens. Duluth Bull Pen is the best. They come in cotton! Honorable mention to WoolX Jazzy No Fly."
"Duluth trading co. They have ones with what they call a “bull pen” My husband won’t wear anything else!"
"Duluth. Like wearing nothing at all."
"Duluth Trading Company Buck Naked Briefs. Only underwear I'll ever buy again."
"Duluth trading company buck naked."
#7
Tommy John
4.2
(17)
"Tommy John's breathability is top-tier, and they don't ride up."
"Is my favorite for comfort."
"I love Tommy john."
"Tommy John"
"I am actually so passionate about Tommy John lol. They are my favorite."
"Tommy John and it’s not even close."
"I really like TommyJohn (both their modal and cool cotton lines are good). For boxers (not boxer briefs) I like Nicelaundry."
"Tommy John for me. Definitely not Stance."
"Lulu and Tommy John are quite good."
"I pretty much only buy them when they're on sale."
#8
Duluth Trading
4.8
(15)
"I own 10 pairs."
"Super comfortable, and will make you understand why women are willing to spend so much on bras."
"Are hands down the best underwear I’ve ever had."
"Are worth every penny, You’ll thank me later."
"Moisture wicking over cotton."
"Armachillo from Deleuth."
"I bought 7 pairs of Armachillos on above from here."
"Duluth Trading Post “buck naked” underwear is the best."
"Duluth Armachillo Cooling Boxer Briefs thank me later."
"Armachillo from Duluth Trading. They almost never die."
#9
TomboyX
4.5
(15)
"I have a handful of tomboyx boxers that have lasted me 5 years as of right now and have zero signs of wear! They're expensive, but worth every penny."
"Tomboyx. they have a bunch of different styles and they hold up + don’t show under my fitted jeans."
"Personally, I LOVE Tomboyx."
"Love tomboyx!"
"Tomboyx is also great - very comfy, high quality"
"Tomboyx. Fantastic range of sizes and gender inclusive."
"Tomboyx >all"
"They pay their workers a living wage and the quality far surpasses Hanes or any other brand I’ve tried."
"I now only wear boxers from tomboyx and woxer. I’m overall very pleased with both brands and I feel great wearing them, their sizing is true and they have tons of options to pick from."
"I personally still buy my boxer briefs from TomboyX."
#10
Under Armour
4.3
(15)
"Under Armor didn't disappoint."
"I live and die by the underarmor boxer briefs."
"UA Boxerjacks are the way to go for me."
"Do amazing boxer briefs."
"Good support for the boys, thighs don’t ride up."
"I'd say under armour"
"UA is my current wear"
"UnderArmour"
"I really like the ones from UnderArmour."
"Undies are pretty great"
#11
Lululemon
4.5
(13)
"Lulu makes the best boxer shorts hands down."
"Lululemons are my favorite as well. They’re still soft and roomy for hanging out but athletic/stretchy enough for the gym."
"Lululemon hands down."
"Premium product. I do briefs but they are 1000x better than saxx."
"I've been in love with the LuluLemon boxer briefs."
"I fucking SWEAR by Lululemon."
"I recently got a couple of pairs from Arcteryx and I’ve been enjoying them."
"Lululemon"
"Lululemon."
"The most comfortable ones I had."
#12
Uniqlo
4.6
(11)
"Uniqlo is sooo comfortable"
"Airism by Uniqlo is def the best quality and the best price for sure."
"I like the uniqlo airism boxer briefs."
"Uniqlo Airism Boxer Briefs are the best imo."
"I like the Uniqlo boxer briefs."
"Far far far and away uniqlo airsm, I know they are a bit of a meme. But they are insanely good."
"Some of the best I’ve found anywhere."
"Uniqlo airism, the non-cotton one"
"I really like the ones from Uniqlo, I was using the mack Weldon ones but noticed the stretch too much by the end of the day."
"Im a fan of Uniqlo Airism and Bjorn Bjorg performance boxers."
#13
Step One
4.7
(10)
"Step One. Nothing better."
"Buying Step One boxers was one of the best decisions I've ever made."
"Don’t ride up at all, very comfy."
"Step one. I'm short and fat, my cis husband is tall and built like a rugby player."
"The best ones I swear by are 'stepone' true to size, great material and just perfection."
"Not sure your country but in Australia i buy stepone."
"I wear Step One."
"Still prefer lululemon but step one are not far behind in terms of comfort and quality."
"Step One are great quality but pricey."
"I’m a fan of Step One."
#14
Duluth
4.9
(8)
"I only wear their undies now."
"I really enjoy em. Don’t ride up and they aren’t lying; they are exceptionally soft."
"Duluth Buck Naked is the best boxer briefs money can buy and they run sales all the time."
"Duluth Buck Naked is the best for me."
"I have Duluth 'Dang Soft' boxer briefs."
"Duluth Buck Naked. Best I've found."
"Is underrated. Interesting material, but very comfortable."
#15
Woxer
4.6
(8)
"I second Woxer! I have large thighs too."
"I really like my Woxer boxer briefs."
"I have had a lot of great luck with Woxer brand."
"Also recommend Woxer"
"I love Woxer."
"They work really well to prevent chafing."
"I’ve slowly been switching over from Duluth boxers."
"Have great-fitting boxers."
#16
Exofficio
4.5
(8)
"My favorite I’ve ever used."
"I’ve converted fully to Ex Officio."
"I like exofficio give-n-go boxer briefs. They can take a beating and I’ve found them to be flexible enough to not pull."
"Ex Officio give n go boxer briefs are the best."
"ExOfficio get recommended a lot with hikers."
"For every day wearing the Ex Officio are nice."
"I think they strike the right balance of being fitted, but not too tight."
"ExOfficio"
#17
2UNDR
4.5
(8)
"2Undr are by far my favourite."
"I love 2under. Material is nice and comfortable."
"2Undr boxer briefs are the best I've ever tried."
"I highly recommend 2undr."
"2UNDR"
"2Under. Pouch for your boys, don’t ride up the legs, durable."
"Different cuts will fit better for different people, but I like Saxx and 2under."
"2UNDR."
#18
Mack Weldon
4.5
(8)
"Huge fan of Mack Weldon AirKnit"
"There is nothing else as durable."
"Mack Weldon Airknit."
"Pricey but it’ll be your last pair"
"I like Mack Weldon."
"Mack Weldon."
"Mack weldon airknit if you live where it's warm."
"Mack Weldon has served me very well for several years."
#19
David Archy
4.6
(7)
"I LOVE my David Archy boxer briefs. The fit is unlike anything I've had in the past."
"David Archy, you won’t regret it."
"I've really been enjoying my David Archy."
"I've been using these same 4 pairs from David Archy for the past 4 years and haven't had any issues."
"I've been only wearing David Archy underwear from Amazon."
"David archy are the best."
"David Archy"
#20
American Eagle
4.4
(7)
"I rock American eagle boxer briefs as they come with a 9” inseam."
"Never let me down."
"Their fabric doesn't ride up and they have lasted me well over 8 years."
"American eagle, they are my second favorite and have no fly."
"I like American Eagle's boxer briefs in a 2X or 3X depending on fit."
"I usually wear American Eagle or Ethika boxer briefs."
"American Eagle. They have a lot of different options to choose from."
#21
Woxers
4.8
(6)
"I LOVE woxers. best boxers. they are so comfortable, don’t ride up on your thighs and are good for those who get yeast infections easily/breathable."
"My partner and I both have a very large collection of Woxers and we love them!! What a game changer for real!!"
"My absolute favorites are woxer, but they can be pricy. Soft, breathable fabric and a waistband that doesn't roll."
"Woxers are super comfy. The material is soft and they hold their shape throughout the day. They have a wide range of colors and style choices."
"I got woxers, and immediately said “why have I ever worn anything else”. Cons- they are expensive. Pros- they are comfortable, they dont do the stretched out leg thing."
"Woxer is so soft and comfy, perfect fit, and don't roll up or get huge. The Downside is they're not very well made."
#22
Kirkland
4.1
(7)
"Kirkland (yes the costco brand) boxer briefs are super comfy"
"Just buy the 100% cotton kirkland ones at costco"
"Nothing comes close to the comfort of Kirkland."
"Kirkland boxer briefs. They last for ages and are dirt cheap."
"Feel just as good at the end of the day."
"Use used Costco Kirkland brand over here"
"These are comfortable but the stitching on mine fell apart after a few washes. The first time Kirkland failed me"
#23
Jockey
4.0
(7)
"Jockey with the comfort pouch. Pretty much every one of their materials is comfy and fit me perfect."
"Try jockey.com they have longer, dry fit and no fly"
"I've had good ones from Jockey"
"They really are awesome."
"Jockey from Target."
"I wear primarily jockey, calvin klein, and underarmour and they work fine for me."
"Jockey"
#24
Separatec
4.7
(6)
"I've since thrown away _all_ of my boxers and boxer briefs and switched entirely to Separatec."
"Separatec or David Archy (same thing, different branding). Trust me on this one."
"Separatec briefs are amazing. Very breathable."
"It's the only thing I wear now."
"Separatec"
"Separatec. everybody has their own space."
#25
Skims
4.4
(5)
"Kim Kardashian’s brand Skims! Best underwear ever."
"I don’t think I’ll be buying anything else."
"Skims or Uniqlo Airism."
"Skims."
"Skims"
#26
Fruit of the Loom
4.2
(5)
"They feel fantastic and no issues."
"Fruit of the Loom is also great if you don’t like the spandex-like material and want something with more cotton and thickness."
"Fruit of the Loom have ones with the covered waistband, they’re comfortable and the legs don’t really stretch during the day."
"Amazon fruit of the loom bro trust me."
"Basic but they extremely work for me."
#27
Reebok
3.3
(6)
"Reebok has been good, but they do stretch quicker than other brands."
"I use Reebox 9 in, And 1 long length."
"My favorite have been the Reebok brand ones."
"I’ve had a really good experience with the reeboks hard to Imagine walmart quality can get even better."
"Walmart reeboks all the way"
"Walmart reeboks are absolutely awful quality. I had high hopes but they started to fray and come apart after only a couple months."
#28
All Citizens
5.0
(4)
"All Citizens is great as well."
"All Citizens. I replaced my entire drawer with em."
"Big fan of allcitizens."
"All Citizens offers some really premium boxer briefs."
#29
Shinesty
4.5
(4)
"Fun prints and very comfortable."
"Shinesty. The ball hammock is legit and they last longer than most."
"I've had a few pairs of Shinesty for about 3 years now. They've been very comfortable."
"Shinesty makes good ones."
#30
Ethika
4.3
(4)
"I swear by ethika"
"I only wear Ethika. Pricey but worth it and stylish."
"Any that are long - I like Ethika."
"I wear ethikas and they hold up great."
#31
Adidas
4.3
(4)
"I'm a big fan of my regular Adidas boxer briefs. They're stretchy, snug, lightweight, comfy, and I've had them for idk how many years, 5?"
"Best brands are Adidas, MeUndies or Gildan"
"I got some adidas boxer briefs that were fairly cheap and really comfortable."
"Adidas is always on sale at Fred Meyer... I have found to fit best."
#33
Smartwool
4.7
(3)
"Smart wool. Wool is the superior material for all things sweaty."
"The best - even then you can usually find them on a slight discount."
"I like the smart wool ones"
#34
Nike
4.7
(3)
"Going with Nikes - f*cking loved them"
"The bay has a sale on 3 pack nike ones for stupid cheap right now."
"Nike is nice, great quality."
#35
BN3TH
4.7
(3)
"I find they hold up much longer and are better quality than Saxx."
"BN3TH HS a nice pouch for the twig’n’berries and their legs don’t ride up either."
#36
Champion
4.0
(3)
"I like Champion, they have a good amount of elasticity."
"Good for traveling because they quick dry. But I prefer Champion."
"Champions- got at Costco."
#37
Wool & Prince
5.0
(2)
"Very durable."
"It's the best decision I’ve ever made."
#38
New Balance
5.0
(2)
"I like New Balance boxer briefs."
"I swear by them."
#39
Ralph Lauren
4.5
(2)
"I did a whole deep dive on this recently and settled on Ralph Lauren. Got a 5 pack for $60. I love em."
"I started off with CK but they started to lose its shape badly. RL is superior."
#40
32 Degrees
4.5
(2)
"Hands down the best."
"“32 Degrees” or “Pair of Thieves”. 32 Degrees is cheap but very good for the price."
#41
Saxx
4.5
(2)
"Except winter with tights then generally saxx"
"I have a lot of saxx boxers, very comfortable but they do end up riding up the legs"
#42
Fruit Of The Loom
4.5
(2)
"They’re the most comfortable."
"But honestly, I love Fruit Of The Loom from Amazon."
#43
PSD
4.5
(2)
"I like PSD, they are comfortable, don’t ride up your legs and have a bunch of designs"
"PSD. They are super comfortable, and have fun designs. Price point is solid."
#44
Lulu
4.5
(2)
"Lulu are great, worth the investment."
"Lulu and Tommy John are quite good."
#45
Stance
4.5
(2)
"They have a pouch for your twig and berries."
"Try stance underwear"
#46
AsWeMove
4.5
(2)
"Aswemove. tried many different brands, this definitely super comfortable and stretches over your skin and molds to your body."
"AsWeMove"
#47
Manmade
4.5
(2)
"10/10 am recommending."
"My cousin swears by Manmade"
#48
Commando
4.5
(2)
"Commando is best."
"Commando but if I wear long pants Calvin Klein boxers."
#49
Express
4.5
(2)
"My express boxers have lasted me like…. 7 years at least, it’s almost crazy."
"Express has great options."
#50
tomboyx
4.5
(2)
"For me I'm really liking tomboyx bit expensive sometimes but I try to look for sales. Really comfy. Has a lot of size options. I really like the 4.5 trunks they do."
"Tomboyx! I get the 4.5” modal trunks. I’ve tried Woxer but didn’t like how close/tight the fabric was."
#51
Sunspel
4.5
(2)
"By far the most comfortable pair of underwear."
"Motherfucking Sunspel. They’re pricey but very good"
#52
And1
4.5
(2)
"I like the And1s from Walmart. I get the long leg ones. Soo comfy!"
"Ok hear me out... And1 from walmart"
#53
Costco
4.5
(2)
"Highly recommend"
"Has a damn comfortable set for sale lately."
#54
Puma
4.0
(2)
"Ive Bern wearing Puma for the better part of my adult life now. They're very comfi"
"I like the Puma ones, but I’m also not a sweaty person."
#55
Stafford
4.0
(2)
"I like the Stafford brand from JCPenney’s"
"I like the Stafford brand from JCP."
#56
Ex Officio
4.0
(2)
"They are really comfortable and great in the summer."
"I wear ex officio and REI brand boxer briefs."
#57
Cocksox
4.0
(2)
"Cocksox"
"Cocksox. No, really cocksox, look them up."
#58
Ball Caddy
5.0
(1)
"Recently started upgrading all my pairs to the ball caddy ones after 6 years."
#59
Nads
5.0
(1)
"Nads is wonderful. They for perfectly"
#60
And1 Platinum
5.0
(1)
"On the other hand, i bought And1 platinum (also at walmart)and they have held up perfectly for the last 12 months"
#61
Merz b. Schwanen
5.0
(1)
"Recently got some merz b schwanen, best I’ve ever owned worth the price point"
#62
Shaping New Tomorrow
5.0
(1)
"Replaced my entire wardrobe with SNT. Never been more comfortable."
#63
B3NTH
5.0
(1)
"B3NTH have been fantastic for me."
#64
ExOfficio
5.0
(1)
"ExOficio boxer briefs are amazing. A little pricey but you can get deals from REI clearance sometimes."
#65
Comfyballs
5.0
(1)
"Https://www.comfyballs.com, literally. Highly recommended, and they got something for all occasions."
#66
Oddballs
5.0
(1)
"Oddballs have been a gamechanger for me. Snug but not too tight or small, really comfortable, not sweaty and they donate a fair whack of money to charity too."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
