Diaper Brands reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 251 Reddit reviews across 21 subreddits and 23 posts to rank the best Diaper Brands brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/NewParents, r/Parenting, r/toddlers, r/ZeroWaste, r/pregnant. Top-rated brands include Huggies (4.0/5), Pampers (3.7/5), Kirkland (4.0/5).
Stats
Reviews251
Subreddits21
Posts23
Brands74
Products36
251 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Huggies
4.0
(42)
"Tried Huggies, pampers and Millie moon. Huggies are without a doubt the best. Right valence between soft yet structured."
"Huggies Little Movers shine once they’re rolling/crawling (waistband grips are clutch)."
"We ended up using Huggies diapers because we found they were the best."
"Our favourite is Huggies little movers or snug and dry!"
"Our favourite is Huggies little movers or snug and dry!"
"Huggies have been my favorite for stretch, Sam’s club brand and Kirkland are the next ones."
"Huggies little snugglers! Pampers and Kirkland were subpar, even though Kirkland is made by Huggies I think? The difference is wild. Huggies all the way!"
"I have four kids, only Huggies work for us."
"It's Huggies for us - best fit for our LO - scent-free - often on sale at Walmart and Costco"
"Pampers Baby Dry. Or the Huggies version. They were the ones least likely to make diaper rash worse."
#2
Pampers
3.7
(37)
"I got spoiled with Pampers pure! They don't break out my sensitive eczema kid and they are strong and absorbent."
"We use Pampers Pure. They fit my kids the best."
"Pampers and huggies are the best, with Pampers swaddlers being our #1 diaper of choice."
"Pampers Swaddlers are the go-to for newborns (soft, great absorption)."
"Pampers premium is the best imo. It’s definitely pricey but it’s much safer. My baby was most comfortable in those diapers."
"Pampers premium is the best brand. These are a bit expensive but not more than your babies comfort."
"We use pampers naturals - they used pampers in the NICU and he never had a problem"
"Pampers from newborn to pampers pants now toddllers. Best ever!"
"I will forever swear by pampers baby dry and swaddlers, I’ve never had a leak unless it was SUPER full."
"We love Pampers swaddlers and Pampers pure."
#3
Kirkland
4.0
(26)
"For us, hands down, it was Kirkland. Same with the wet wipes."
"Costco has the best prices and quality. Kirkland diapers are great."
"We also love the costco Kirkland diapers. We have 2 under 2, both of which we use Kirkland diapers with and we have never had an issue with them. Great coverage and great value."
"I used to and then we tried Costco/kirkland brand and honestly they’re better."
"Kirkland. Nothing compares. Huggies is second choice but I still would prefer Kirkland"
"Kirkland lol from Costco. Second is Huggies."
"Costco brand (Kirkland diapers) are the best and economical."
"When he was a newborn it was Kirkland brand, now that he's 2 it's parents choice brand during the day and pampers cruisers for sleep."
"We have been using Kirkland (size 2 for a 14.5 lbs/25 in baby) and they have been sufficie"
"My brother uses the Kirkland brand for his son and they work fine also."
#4
Rascals
4.3
(12)
"Rascals brand at Walmart. So soft and the best price. I won't use anything else."
"Rascals for sure. More soft and comfy, more absorbant, no scents/lotions and cheaper than the other brands."
"Rascal and Friends that the only ones that don't leak or cause a rash, plus prevent blowouts."
"Rascal and Friends!! They are amazing. Can get them at Walmart."
"Really like rascal and friends, been the best for my baby. Absorbent, good fit, no weird chemical smell like huggies(hate them) affordable, and they haven't ever cause a rash for me."
"Little rascals for a fancy splurg or if u can afford- Kirkland as a main reliable."
"I love rascal and friends! Seem to be less toxic, they work well, and they’re affordable at Walmart!"
"We love rascal and friends! LO had sensitive skin as a newborn, so we switched to this which is hypoallergenic."
"The rascal and friends from Walmart are actually just as good if not a little and made by the same company as Millie Moon."
"My second born 1. honest/ 2 choices -hello bello/ rascal and friends. All works really good for him no leaks or blow outs."
#5
Coterie
4.3
(9)
"I use Coterie and love them. Why do they get hate??"
"I have so much love for Coterie!!! This is my favorite reliable AF baby product."
"Coterie, so so worth the cost."
"We like Coterie at home (bc they are simple and clean and don't have that diaper smell) and then pampers for daycare (taking advantage of the cvs sales)"
"Sounds like the good ones are: Coterie"
"I have been trying Coterie and it is very very soft and good for my son’s skin."
"Coterie wipes and diapers are our favorite."
"I love coterie for the absorbency of pee, hit or miss on poop but that’s every diaper! No diaper rashes yet."
"We tried Coterie for overnight when my twins were newborns and they leaked… we contacted the company and they sent us the next size up for free."
#6
Millie Moon
4.2
(9)
"A friend mentioned Millie Moon and they are so amazing. Incredibly soft, no more road burn."
"Love the Millie moons!"
"I love Millie moon but they’re a little more money, I think it’s worth it. It’s also wayy softer than Kirkland."
"For eco-friendly options, Millie Moon (Target) or Honest Company are solid, though pricier."
"I like millie moons"
"They’re more of that “luxury diaper” feel kind of like Millie Moons (which I hear are great) just not as expensive."
"Huggies were our favorite at the beginning, but we had to switch to Millie Moon because they are so much softer and more protective of baby’s skin."
"I want to try Millie Moon or Kirkland as well given the recommendations."
"Millie moon isn’t the worst compared to some."
#7
Luvs
3.9
(8)
"I love Luvs. It isn’t the most expensive brand, it held in their pee all the time and both my kiddos have different body types."
"Luvs is my favorite too. I feel like it fit our kiddo the best and prevented blowouts best"
"Luvs are good too for a cheaper option, they seem thin but they work well imo and hold just as much"
"Luvs Ultra Leakguards - Great value, leak protection, and soft."
"Luvs Ultra Leakguards - Great value, leak protection, and soft."
"Luvs Ultra Leakguards - Great value, leak protection, and soft."
"I personally like Luvs. My baby is always dry."
"Luvs can go fuck itself, I’ve had so many sheets, blankets, and outfits that I needed to wash because they never kept pee and poo in"
#8
Dyper
4.5
(6)
"We've primarily used dyper for all three kids. No complaints at all, even for overnight."
"Dyper. They are fully compostable and offer a 2x/month pick-up service to take the compostable diapers to a composting facility."
"I just switched to Dyper charcoal from Bambo. Loving it so much so far!!!!"
"We use Dyper, which is comparable in per diaper cost to Coterie."
"I use Hello Bello, Dyper, Huggies or Millie Moon now depending"
"We love dyper"
#9
Parent's Choice
3.2
(6)
"Believe it or not parents choice the Walmart brand also did really well for all of them and are well priced"
"Parent’s Choice - Budget-friendly, solid leak protection."
"Parent’s Choice - Budget-friendly, solid leak protection."
"Parent’s Choice Budget-friendly, solid leak protection."
"Kirkland or parents choice!!!!"
"I buy parents choice from Walmart for disposables/ overnight."
#10
Honest
4.3
(4)
"Just went through a box of Honest diapers and they were amazing! No blowouts. Held her pee for the whole night, without leaks."
"Sounds like the good ones are: Honest"
"Overall, our house uses the honest company, or any type of Huggies except the red packaging"
"My second born 1. honest/ 2 choices -hello bello/ rascal and friends. All works really good for him no leaks or blow outs."
#11
Hello Bello
4.3
(4)
"I stopped the pampers and started using Hello Bello and she was fine."
"Hello Bello - Eco-friendly, hypo"
"Hello Bello Eco-friendly, hypo"
"My second born 1. honest/ 2 choices -hello bello/ rascal and friends. All works really good for him no leaks or blow outs."
#12
Kudos
5.0
(3)
"We love kudos! Have been using them for 14 months now."
"Kudos!"
"Kudos, the only diapers where baby’s bum touches 100% cotton."
#13
Thirsties
5.0
(3)
"Thirsties One Size Pocket Diapers worked great in my opinion."
"My favorite for the newborn size was the SIZED Thirsties covers over flats."
"We love Thirsties and Bayrli. Best 2 by far for small babies of what we’ve tried."
#14
Parasol
4.3
(3)
"I ended up trying Parasol and we love them."
"Parasol available at target"
"We started using Parasol. You can get them at target. Worth their price in softness for our baby’s sensitive skin."
#15
AlvaBaby
4.3
(3)
"I used the nbfor my son who was very small. Loved them."
"I recently bought some AlvaBaby diapers from Amazon. My daughter is about 20lbs and the all in one size is great for her and they work as well as a disposable."
"We chose the AlvaBaby newborns and then the MamaKoalas for use from 8lbs and up."
#16
Sam's Club
3.7
(3)
"My toddler was short and chunky so the Sam’s club diapers are great for her and when she was around a year I started using the pampers overnights."
"My baby likes the Sam's club brand diapers. We got pampers from the hospital, but she didn't like them."
"When my son was born in 2023 I loved Kirklands and Sam’s clubs diapers."
#17
Tena
5.0
(2)
"Tena is probably your best bet."
"Tena are an excellent brand."
#18
Smart Bottoms
5.0
(2)
"I only use smart bottoms all-in-ones. They fit once baby was 8/9 pounds. We love smart bottoms and bought them secondhand for a great price."
"The best newborn diapers for them in the early days were Smartbottoms newborn AIOs"
#19
Green Mountain Diapers
5.0
(2)
"For day diapers, we use second hand covers that I got for a song, and I personally replaced all of the leg and back elastics in them by hand so now they work good as new. Because we don't have a dryer, the inners are flats from Green Mountain Diapers."
"All my diaper inners are GMD. I mostly stick with flats because we don't have a dryer and flats dry exponentially faster than anything thicker."
#20
Northshore
4.5
(2)
"Northshore supreme or seni active overnight both can hold a full bladder void at least for me."
"Also the Northshore Supreme line....about the same price as InControl. They seem kinda thin when you first put them on but don't let it fool you. This is also a very absorbent diaper"
#21
Merries
4.5
(2)
"Have you ever tried Japanese diapers like Moony and merries? Buy a bag and you will never go back to Huggies , pampers, Millie moon or rascal and friends."
"Korean brands : Merries, Moony."
#22
Seni
4.5
(2)
"Seni has as good if not better products. The Quatro seems to have more capacity than the Abena M4 and the Seni pull-ups seem to have more capacity than the Abena M3, both at a lower cost."
"If you're looking for something a bit more absorbent than Depends, but without costing too much more, I'd look at ... Seni."
#23
Pura
4.0
(2)
"Pura diapers have worked even better for us than coterie! They are at Walmart and on Amazon, we LOVE them and they’re cheaper than coterie but the same thing pretty much"
"As far as “clean” or cleaner diapers pura, millie moon isn’t the worst compared to some."
#24
Honest Company
4.0
(2)
"My girls fit Honest diapers the best and have the fewest blowouts."
"Diapers were using the honest company, if those don’t work out we’re gonna use pampers."
#25
Mama Bear
4.0
(2)
"I love the mama bear diapers, been using them for months."
"Mama Bear on Amazon is my favorite for wipes. The diapers are pretty reasonable priced and worked well too."
#26
Kiddos by MedPlus
4.0
(2)
"Kiddos by MedPlus is what we have been using. It's pretty good."
"We tried many brands and settled at "kiddos by medplus". It's reasonable comparatively."
#27
InControl
4.0
(2)
"I buy the InControl Elite for my "everyday " diaper."
"The InControl diaper line come out to just pennies over $2 a diaper and they are very absorbent"
#28
Pampers Pure
3.5
(2)
"Pampers Pure has been our favorite."
"I liked pampers pure until baby’s thighs chunked up and we switched to Huggies for a minute"
#29
CVS
3.5
(2)
"Ok hear me out we love CVS brand! Never had a blow out in them in two years!"
"Store brand like ... CVS products."
#30
Assurance
3.5
(2)
"I think the Assurance and Tena brands have stretchy waistbands."
"Store brand like Assurance (Walmart)"
#31
Close Pop-In
5.0
(1)
"Close Pop In newborn size, they are both quite tiny."
#32
NorthShore
5.0
(1)
"Northshore (northshorecare.com) is far superior to anything you’ll find in stores."
#33
Megamax
5.0
(1)
"The most absorbent adult diaper in the world is the Megamax sold by Northshore Care."
#34
Bayrli
5.0
(1)
"We love Thirsties and Bayrli. Best 2 by far for small babies of what we’ve tried."
#35
Diaper Dabbler
5.0
(1)
"There is something called Diaper Dabbler where you can order a sampler pack with a few diapers each from a bunch of different brands, so you can try them all out and see what works best for you. Highly recommend!"
#36
Fuzzi Bunz
5.0
(1)
"I loved fuzzi bunz pocket diapers. They were so easy."
#37
Molicare
5.0
(1)
"Try Molicare Mobile 10. They are the most absorbent normal pull up and hold up quite well, even with heavy leaking."
#38
Lalabye Baby
5.0
(1)
"We've loved Lalabye Baby cloth diapers with my first two kids and plan to use them again for baby #3 due in a few months."
#39
Hoppi
5.0
(1)
"Hoppi: Very soft and thin. I love this very much! I'm using their day diaper."
#40
Lil Helper
5.0
(1)
"I do have a brand I like called Lil Helper. They make a few different products, including menstrual pads, diapers, as well as waterproof mats."
#41
GroVia
5.0
(1)
"I used GroVia and Bum Genius- supplementing with Green Mountain Diaper inserts for overnight/as they got bigger and had higher needs. Loved all of those brands."
#42
BumGenius
5.0
(1)
"We used cloth diapers 10+ years ago and have zero regrets. We primarily used BumGenius."
#43
Simplehuman
5.0
(1)
"I've used Charlie Banana, Mama Koala, Alvababy, and Simple Human. They were all fine but the Simple Humans are my favorite because they have double gussets on the leg part and the snaps are nicely spaced."
#44
Moony
5.0
(1)
"Have you ever tried Japanese diapers like Moony and merries? Buy a bag and you will never go back to Huggies , pampers, Millie moon or rascal and friends."
#45
Apple Crumby
2.0
(2)
"I started with applecrumby. Along the way they changed and so many leaks."
"Apple Crumby: Most expensive. I won't go for this unless your baby has very sensitive skin."
#46
Mamamia
4.0
(1)
"We're finding that the Aldi "Mamamia" brand are pretty damn good. Size 1 pack of 24 for 85p. Bargain and they actually do a good job."
#47
Better than Kirkland
4.0
(1)
"Way better than Kirkland !"
#48
Amazon Brand
4.0
(1)
"I use the Amazon Brand."
#49
Tranquility
4.0
(1)
"If you're looking for something a bit more absorbent than Depends, but without costing too much more, I'd look at Tranquility"
#50
Happy Flute
4.0
(1)
"I bought some cheap happy flute newborn covers from aliexpress."
#51
Allter
4.0
(1)
"Allter because it's Bamboo based diapers..and extremely good absorbant"
#52
Buttons
4.0
(1)
"We had great luck with Buttons covers and prefolds."
#53
Amazon
4.0
(1)
"I used these for my little girl pup."
#54
Top Paw
4.0
(1)
"I like the velcro so they’re more adjustable."
#55
Pet Parents
4.0
(1)
"I've used the Pet Parents brand, bought on Amazon."
#56
Depend
4.0
(1)
"I personally like the "Depend Night Defense Adult Incontinence Underwear for Men, Overnight, S/M, Grey, 16Ct" from Wal-Mart.com."
#57
Berkeley & Jensen
4.0
(1)
"We use BJs brand, Berkeley & Jensen, diapers and wipes, have used them for several kiddos and they work great for us."
#58
Mamypoko
4.0
(1)
"Mamypoko: Thick and feel secure. No leakage. I'm using their night diaper."
#59
Himalaya
4.0
(1)
"I always used Himalaya diapers Good price at dmart"
#60
Littles
4.0
(1)
"Littles diapers. Available online. Quite cheap, but pretty good."
#61
Up & Up
4.0
(1)
"The Target brand Up & Up are good diapers/wipes and cheaper than pampers and whatnot."
#62
Binge Outs
4.0
(1)
"Binge outs are the ones we started with and were very happy. They have multiple kinds of pocket diapers and frankly the cheaper line is just as good as the more expensive ones."
#63
Blueberry
4.0
(1)
"I liked blueberry a lot, and smart bottoms. I found them all to be high quality but it’s been 6+ years since I have purchased any."
#64
Charlie Banana
4.0
(1)
"I just bought what they had at BuyBuyBaby . . . Charlie Banana and Bumgenius."
#65
Cozycove
4.0
(1)
"So far I think Cozycove and Peekaboo are good."
#66
Peekaboo
4.0
(1)
"So far I think Cozycove and Peekaboo are good."
#67
gbaby
4.0
(1)
"I like the gbaby diapers. They are bigger than others."
#68
Pampers Sensitive Wipes
4.0
(1)
"Same with wipes, pampers sensitive seems to be the best for us."
#69
Drypers
3.0
(1)
"Before huggies tried so many others like drypers, hoppy, and few others I cant recall."
#70
Cuddles and Little Angels
3.0
(1)
"Cuddles and little angles are available at dmart at under 8/diaper"
#71
Certainty
3.0
(1)
"Store brand like ... Certainty (Walgreens)"
#72
Esembly
2.0
(1)
"We really struggle with Esembly. Too many leaks and blow outs."
#73
Member's Mark
2.0
(1)
"Members Mark (Sam's club) had the most leakage."
#74
Thank U Mom
1.0
(1)
"A brand I would stay away from Is thank u mom or something like that they didn't work for us."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
