Best eyebrow pencil on Reddit

163 reviews from r/Makeup, r/MakeupAddiction, r/drugstoreMUA and 15 more subreddits

163 reviews from
and
By Brand
/
By Product
#1

NYX

4.3
(20)
"Nyx has a great one."
·
"I use Nyx Lift & Snatch Eyebrow Tint Pen in Ash Brown and Espresso."
·
"I love the NYX microbrow pencil."
·
"Nyx micro brow pencil! Also Rimmel makes a nice clear gel to set them."
·
"NYX is pretty much a dupe for ABH brow wiz!"
·
"NYX micro brow pencil"
·
"NYX has a wonderful micro brow pencil!"
·
"I use the Nyx eyebrow palette, comes with a light and dark powder."
·
"NYX."
·
"I use the nyx and the elf one."
·
#2

Anastasia Beverly Hills

4.6
(13)
"A great eyebrow pencil option is Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in the shade 'Dark Brown' or 'Ebony.'"
·
"The ABH ones are great."
·
"I also love anastasia beverly hills brow pencil."
·
"ABH Brow Wiz in Granite is the best match for me."
·
"The Anastasia Beverly Hills brow products are amazing."
·
"ABH brow wiz in granite. I am about NC25-30 with black hair."
·
"I gave up on pencils years ago and now use Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow in auburn."
·
"I love the Anastasia Beverly Hills brow pencils in ash brown."
·
"ABH Brow Wiz is very soft with a relatively warmer shade range."
·
"It's described as having cool/ash undertones."
·
#3

Elf

4.5
(13)
"I actually really like the ELF instant lift brow pencil."
·
"Elf instant lift brow pencil is my HG, sooooo cheap and soooo good!"
·
"Not a pencil but I’d recommend the elf ‘wow brow’."
·
"Elf is cheap and one of the best, even compared to high end."
·
"I personally recommend Elf's eyebrow pencil."
·
"I use elf instant lift eyebrow pencil and I really like it."
·
"I use the ELF one. ( I originally only bought it for the spoolie because it was so cheap but it actually turned out to be the best thing I've ever used)"
·
"I like ELF to fill in the middle part."
·
"ELF instant lift brow pencil in deep brown."
·
"Elf brow gel isn’t bad - amazing for the price."
·
#4

Benefit

4.7
(12)
"Fenty and Benefit have the best shades imo."
·
"Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra Fine Shape & Define in 4.5 Cool Soft Black-Brown."
·
"Benefit always."
·
"Benefit Gimme Brow Volumizing pencil."
·
"Benefit gimme brow+ pencil."
·
"Benefit precisely my brow or abh brow wiz"
·
"Benefit Precisely My Brow has been my go to for years."
·
"Benefit precisely my brow lasts over a month for me."
·
"I also use Benefits."
·
"The most popular options at Sephora are Benefit Precisely My Brow and ABH Brow Wiz."
·
#5

Maybelline

4.3
(9)
"It lasts all day without smudging."
·
"I used Maybelline Express Brow 2-in-1 Pencil + Powder and it worked great."
·
"The Maybelline ultra slim eyebrow pencil in brown/black is amazing :) very pigmented."
·
"The best thing through all these years has been Maybelline's self-sharpening eyeliners."
·
"I love the maybelline express brow."
·
"The maybelline Express Brow Ultra Slim Pencil is a pretty nice one."
·
"I’m a big fan of the new Maybelline total temptation eyebrow pencil."
·
"It’s more creamy than the ABH and turns out more warm toned on the brows but it’s good for the price."
·
"I love it but that may be the 'meh' one you mentioned?"
#6

Anastasia

4.9
(7)
"Anastasia brow wiz, it’s not too soft so it’s harder to go overboard with it."
·
"I have no complaints. Super quick and easy, and the taupe color is nice and cool on me."
·
"I love the effect - can do both sharp & diffused looks."
·
"I add in some dipbrow."
·
"I need them to look natural and I need it to last!"
·
"My sister is a blonde and she loves the eyebrow pencil."
·
"Lets you draw tiny hair-like lines on your brow."
#7

Wet n Wild

4.7
(6)
"C603A Wet and wild pencil. Color simma brown looks most natural."
·
"I really like the wet n wild micro brow pencil."
·
"I haven't tried this one but the Wet'n Wild one is amazing!"
·
"I love Wet n Wild, believe it or not."
·
"I have really been liking the 'wet n wild Ultimate Eyebrow Retractable Definer Pencil' in the color ash brown!"
·
"It's pigmented, stays all day."
#8

Etude House

4.3
(6)
"Etude House drawing eyebrow in gray brown."
·
"I am definitely going to try this!! I am currently using the Etude House brow pencil in 05 grey."
·
"I like the etude house drawing eyebrow pencil!"
·
"The etude house one is my fav."
·
"I like the Etude House gray, and the Anastasia brow wiz in granite."
·
"The one I like using is actually Korean; it's called Etude house drawing eye brow."
#9

L'Oreal

4.3
(6)
"My fave is the loreal brow stylist."
·
"The L’Oréal brow stylist definer in taupe/blonde is amazing!"
·
"I use loreals brow stylist definer in ash brown."
·
"I like L’Oréal micro brow, not too expensive and it pretty much stays on."
·
"It's very very lovely once on!"
·
"This one was more waxy."
#10

Annabelle

4.2
(5)
"Annabelle Skinny Brow Liner! It’s been my cheap go to for ever."
·
"Annabelle has a nice ash brown eyebrow pencil, skinny brow liner in universal taupe."
·
"I use Annabelle Skinny brow liner or NYX Micro Brow Pencil."
·
"I like the Annabelle skinny brow pencils."
·
"Works wonders."
#11

Milani

4.8
(4)
"The milani weekend brow is amazing."
·
"Milani’s slim brow pencil with the spoolie on the end is my current fave!"
·
"I love Milani pencils."
·
"I really like the Milani one."
#12

Charlotte Tilbury

4.5
(4)
"My fav is Charlotte Tilbury Brow Wiz."
·
"Expensive but the Charlotte Tillbury ones are amazing!!"
·
"I quite like the Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat in Natural Brown."
·
"I've been using the Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat and I really like it."
#13

Sephora

4.0
(4)
"My favorite eyebrow pencil is The Sephora eyebrow pencil."
·
"Sephora retractable brow pencil in soft charcoal."
·
"The Sephora collection waterproof brow pencil is sooo underrated."
·
"I have been using the sephora brow pencil as a dupe for ABH."
#14

MAC

3.8
(4)
"MAC was great because it was waterproof, natural-ish looking and not shiny."
·
"MAC eye brows styler it's a very thin pencil."
·
"Try the MAC eyebrow stylizer. It's a liquid tip on one side and powder on the other."
·
"I've only really tried one and it's the MAC mechanical brow pencil - I didn't like it as much at first but I've gotten used to it and now I love it!"
#15

Soap & Glory

4.0
(3)
"The pencil end is actually rubbish, but it is totally worth buying just for the pen."
·
"I used the crayon for general filling in and the pen to draw a few hairs to make it more natural."
·
"It has the pigment at one end and highlighter at the other."
#16

Espoir

5.0
(2)
"Another vote for Espoir The Brow Balance Pencil."
·
"Espoir brow balance pencil. i like how this pencil draws the color evenly."
#17

Glossier

5.0
(2)
"I use Glossier Brow Flick and Boy Brow."
·
"The Glossier brow flick pen is really good. No smudging!"
#18

Kosas

4.5
(2)
"Kosas is amazing!"
·
"I use the Kosas brow pencil and I really like it!"
#19

Clinique

4.5
(2)
"My personal favorite is the Clinique Superfine Liner for brows."
·
"A friend I know who has trich recommended Clinique eyebrow pencil and Benefit eyebrow pencil."
#20

Shu Uemura

4.5
(2)
"The shu uemura hard formula pencil seems expensive up front but lasts FOREVER."
·
"Shu Uemura is a really hard formula, so that lasts a long time."
#21

Colourpop

4.5
(2)
"Their Brow Boss pencil is very affordable and one of my favorites :)"
·
"I use Colourpop’s precision brow pencil daily."
#22

Marcelle

4.5
(2)
"I like Marcelle accent eyebrow crayon."
·
"Marcelle makes a really nice one!"
#23

e.l.f.

4.0
(2)
"I use elf brown pencils. I don't know if they work for you but the neutral brown was the only pencil I could find that didn't have a lot of red tones."
·
"I would recommend something inexpensive while you're getting the hang of it, something like this: http://www.eyeslipsface.com/studio/eyes/eyebrows/eyebrow_kit."
#24

LA Girl

4.0
(2)
"La girl shady slim."
·
"The LA Girl Shady Slim pencil is really nice!"
#25

Dior

5.0
(1)
"I use the brow liner from this Dior palette and I absolutely love it."
#26

IT Cosmetics

5.0
(1)
"I use IT cosmetics brow power in universal taupe."
#27

Essence

5.0
(1)
"Essence brow pencil in blonde."
#28

It Cosmetics

5.0
(1)
"“It” cosmetics universal taupe brow pencil."
#29

Too Faced

5.0
(1)
"Too Faced pomade brow is so good and long lasting."
#30

Fiona Stiles

5.0
(1)
"It's the perfect cool blonde shade and lasts me all day with no smudging."
#31

Sigma Beauty

5.0
(1)
"I love the sigma beauty mechanical brow pencil and you can get it on beauty bay for really cheap."
#32

Innisfree

5.0
(1)
"I have had the most luck with grey eyebrow pencils from Korean brands like Innisfree."
#33

Jane Iredale

5.0
(1)
"I've seen great results with jane iredale's Eyebrow Pencil."
#34

Daiso

5.0
(1)
"Daiso and miniso have amazing brow pencils in dark grey that I love!"
#35

Thrive

5.0
(1)
"I wear their brow pencil and even when I would sweat a lot at work it didn’t budge."
#36

Suqqu

5.0
(1)
"It creates such a subtle effect as you can draw on strokes of realistic hairs."
#37

Hourglass

5.0
(1)
"It's very creamy and natural looking."
#38

Tarte

5.0
(1)
"I'm super impressed with how well it stays on through the day."
#39

Miss A

5.0
(1)
"A steal for $1 & even has a soft spoolie at the other end."
#40

Wakemake

4.0
(1)
"Wakemake has a hard brow pencil that’s very similar to Shu Uemura’s."
#41

L'Oréal

4.0
(1)
"L'Oréal Brow Stylist Definer in Light Blonde is not harsh & *not orange*!"
#42

Almay

4.0
(1)
"Almay makes a great brow pencil with the twist up product and a spoolie."
#43

Tom Ford

4.0
(1)
"I quite like the Tom Ford brow pencil but other than that, my favourite is the Suqqu brow pen."
#44

Estée Lauder

4.0
(1)
"My go to is Estée Lauder in soft brown :)"
#45

Missha

4.0
(1)
"My current favorite is the Missha wood brow, from Yesstyle."
#46

Banila Co

4.0
(1)
"I use Banila co smudge out detail brow pencil, it is long lasting easy to use!"
#47

L'Oreal Paris

4.0
(1)
"L’Oreal Paris Perfect Brow Stylist."
#48

Avon

4.0
(1)
"I adore avon's blond glimmerstick."
#49

Revlon

4.0
(1)
"Revelon Colorstay Brow Creator."
#50

CoverGirl

4.0
(1)
"My brows hold up well all day and even when I go to the beach/ swimming."
#51

Bare Minerals

4.0
(1)
"Would recommend as a dupe for the ABH brow wiz."
#52

Rimmel

4.0
(1)
"Its got a good consistency whereas some of the cheap ones can be a bit smudgy."
#53

NYC

4.0
(1)
"I really like the formula and colour."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your first customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.

Tell me more
Get started
Audience Research