Liquid Eyeliner reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 340 Reddit reviews across 21 subreddits and 91 posts to rank the best Liquid Eyeliner brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Makeup, r/MakeupAddiction, r/beauty, r/Sephora, r/drugstoreMUA. Top-rated brands include NYX (4.7/5), Stila (4.8/5), Wet n Wild (4.5/5).
Stats
Reviews340
Subreddits21
Posts91
Brands52
Products78
340 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
NYX
4.7
(69)
"Epic Ink Liner. I just replaced by dried out liners with a brown and a black one of each!"
"Nyx epic ink!!!"
"Highly suggest NYX Epic Wear Liquid Liner in Brown!"
"I really like the Nyx Epic Wear waterproof eyeliner."
"Nyx Epic Ink is really good, pigmented, and lasts."
"I have never once found one that compared to NYX Epic Ink."
"NYX epic Ink eyeliner is my go to, usually around £8-9 in boots etc"
"I like the NYX Epic Ink liner in brown."
"NYX epic wear liquid liner! Waterproof, dries matte, and has a really nice pointy brush!"
"NYX INK LINER IS THE ONE YOU NEEED!!!"
#2
Stila
4.8
(49)
"KVD, UD, One Size, and Stila!"
"Stila Stay All Day is great, always pretty high up on the list"
"Stila and KVD are the best I’ve tried."
"The only two that work for me are the stila liquid liner and wet and wild breakup proof eyeliner!"
"I like Stila Stay All Day liquid pen liner."
"I'm a big fan of this guy: https://www.stilacosmetics.com/products/stay-all-day-waterproof-liquid-eye-liner?variant=40020533248103"
"Stila stay all day liquid liner."
"I've been buying stila eyeliner since 2013! It's my ride or die!"
"I've had a lot of luck with Stilla. I apply my wings at 530am and they last my work shift and boxing."
"Stila Stay All Day waterproof liquid eyeliner is a very good one. Can confirm that (once it dries) its waterproof and stays pretty well."
#3
Wet n Wild
4.5
(27)
"The only two that work for me are the stila liquid liner and wet and wild breakup proof eyeliner!"
"The best black was honestly wet and wild in the short fat / conical bottle."
"Wet n wild breakup eyeliner"
"[this eyeliner ](https://www.amazon.com/Wet-Wild-Proof-Liquid-Liner/dp/B01FIL3GRE?ref_=ast_sto_dp&th=1&psc=1) held up!"
"This is my every day eyeliner. It stays put even after being out on the Texas heat sweating for several hours."
"I hear the wet n wild break up proof liner is awesome"
"Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Eyeliner."
"If you're looking for something more expensive, I suggest KVD tattoo liner."
"It stays on, lasts a while in the tube, has a good tip, and is very pigmented."
"Wet n wild breakup proof liquid eyeliner is great."
#4
KVD
4.7
(25)
"That's my HG too, I've tried so many others!!!"
"I’ve been using it since 2015 for 12+ hours pretty much every day and it’s never failed me"
"I really like KVD tattoo liner."
"I’ve been using the KVD tattoo liner for years."
"KVD tattoo liner, no competition."
"My favs are Sephora - Kat Von D liquid liner."
"I swear by KVD tattoo liner."
"I use kvd liquid eyeliner, I am oil skin, and it actually can keep all day."
"It’s a felt tip that applies smooth."
"The KVD liquid liner is my HG."
#5
Physicians Formula
4.4
(16)
"My personal favorite is the physician's formula liquid eyeliner pen."
"Physicians formula makes my favorite eyeliner."
"I really like Physician's Formula. The felt tip is just right. I've been using it for years."
"My favorite is a drugstore eyeliner from physicians formula."
"It is some of the best I've used- makes putting on eyeliner very easy."
"I know that feeling when I finally tried Physicians Formula Waterproof Eyeliner."
"I love that eyeliner!"
"Lasts forever and works well for wings."
"A cheaper option is Physicians Formula eyeliner. It’s a great alternative in my experience."
"I liked PF better than KVD."
#6
Maybelline
4.5
(13)
"I swear on Maybelline!"
"Maybelline tattoo linner."
"Is really great! Plus affordable!"
"I love it. I was a KVD tattoo liner fan... the only one to compare is the maybelline one imo."
"It's really good. Dark black and stays long."
"My holy grail eyeliner is the Maybelline Hyper Easy and it's like $10."
"My holy grail eyeliner is Maybelline Hyper Easy."
"Try the maybelline tattoo liner, it’s not liquid so it won’t crack or flake."
"I use Maybelline HyperSharp for black and KVD tattoo liner for brown."
"Maybelline colossal eyeliner- slightly shiny but brush is very good for making a wing."
#7
Fenty
5.0
(10)
"I like the Fenty fly liner. It’s super pigmented and long lasting."
"I really like Fenty's Flyliner!"
"Fenty fly liner is awesome!"
"Fenty fly liner!"
"Y’all should try Fenty Flyliner if you have oily eyelids like me."
"Fenty flyliner is my go-to just because I find it the most user-friendly."
"I have oily eyelids too and my favorites are the Fenty flyliner."
"Fenty Flyliner!"
"Flyliner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner by Fenty."
"Both are wonderful and don’t smudge and stay put."
#8
e.l.f.
4.4
(9)
"Tbh elf liquid eyeliner has been my fave"
"I like the elf expert liquid liner, it’s only $3US !!!"
"The elf liquid eyeliner is my fav and it’s only $3."
"Elf has a really good pitch black liquid eyeliner!"
"Elf have a great one!"
"I just got an e.l.f. one yesterday and it’s really fine and soft"
"I like the brushes because It gives me a lot more control."
"I actually got the ELF liquid eyeliner and it’s pretty good, and very comparable to the Nyx one!"
"Elf expert liquid eyeliner in jet black."
#9
Elf
4.4
(7)
"I’ve been using the elf liquid liner for years and it’s always worked great for me."
"I've been using Elf Liquid Liner for so many years."
"Super cheap and can get amazing sharp wings!"
"One of my fave liquid liners is the elf liquid liner."
"I like the ELF liquid liner and the nyx matte waterproof liner."
"The elf ones that come in a little pot are great and super cheap."
"Elf makes a cheap, smooth and very pigmented one for $2 or $3 bucks."
#10
Benefit
4.8
(6)
"Benefit Roller Liner! Seriously I’ve tried more than ten liquid liners in the last three years."
"I really like benefits roller liner."
"I've been using the Benefit Roller Liner since it came out, and I haven't looked back since."
"The black really pops out and I have used both Kvd and stilla."
"Benefit’s Roller Liner! I’ve tried KVD, Stila, Marc Jacobs, and the Flyliner from fenty, and this outperforms all of them."
"It’s really really good and it’s sold at Sephora."
#11
Kat Von D
4.8
(6)
"KVD Tattoo still holds up."
"Stila and KVD are the best I’ve tried."
"KVD beauty tattoo"
"Kat von D Tatoo Liner in brown. That stuff stays on and on and on."
"I find I have better control with a shorter tube. It’s very pigmented for brown."
"KVD, UD, One Size, and Stila!"
#12
Heroine Make
4.3
(6)
"Korean and Japanese liners are the best. I like Heroine Make(Japanese) and Clio Superproof Brush or Pen tip (Korean)."
"Its called the herione makesmooth liquid eyeliner, its waterproof"
"Ultra thin brush tip, once it dries it won't budge."
"Isehan (the heroine make line in particular) is a very good brand"
"Kiss me heroine. It's made for Asian hooded eyes so more budge proof."
"Heroine make is good and popular too but it itches my eyes."
#13
Inglot
5.0
(5)
"I mix powder eyeshadow with Inglot's Duraline or Makeup Forever's Aqua Seal to make my own liquid eyeliner!"
"Honestly inglot duraline is the shit. and it goes a long way for quite some time."
"Just buy a bottle of inglot duraline and a liner brush."
"It's a clear liquid that you can turn your eyeshadows into liquid liners with."
"I use Inglot's Duraline and mix it with gel liners and... it works really well"
#14
Tarte
4.6
(5)
"Tarte is my all time favorite."
"The tarte one is really easy for me to apply."
"Tarte Sex kitten is also great."
"Tarte! One side is liquid the other is pencil."
"Tarte has a good one!"
#15
MAC
4.8
(4)
"MAC Liquidlast."
"I recommend MAC Liquidlast or NYX Matte Liquid Liner."
"I can not recommend the MAC liquid eyeliner enough!!!"
"The Mac liquid last is good but it’s very runny and it’s easy to get some in your eye, that burns!"
#16
Essence
4.8
(4)
"Essence liquid ink! Super pigmented and doesnt budge"
"My favorite is Essence liquid liner (waterproof version)."
"Super cheap and better than any other liner I tried."
"Try essence. Their mascaras are holy grail as well."
#17
Colourpop
4.5
(4)
"I picked up the Colourpop BFF liner at Ulta and omg it's perfect."
"I think Colourpop BFF liner is the best."
"I like the colour pop ones"
"I like Colourpop! It's $8 and it stays on."
#18
Clinique
4.5
(4)
"Its the best I’ve tried and absolutely foolproof to apply."
"Is great"
"In black."
"I actually love the Clinique one!"
#19
L'Oréal
4.5
(4)
"L’Oréal lineur intense. I when very oily lids and have been using this for 30 years."
"The L’Oréal Paris liquid eyeliner is the one I use. The fine felt tip delivers a razor sharp wing and lasts all day and night on me."
"I just finished the L'Oréal superliner. Now I'm using the Sephora brand one. Both pretty good and with good staying power."
"L’Oreal lineur Intense is great but it doesn’t dry quickly."
#20
Too Faced
4.5
(4)
"Exactly nothing better than the Too Faced eyeliner, Kat Von D, and Stila that is my top pick."
"My fave is the Too Faced Better Than Sex liner."
"The top faced eyeliner is much easier to use AND is more durable."
"I absolutely LOVE the Better than Sex liner which is surprising to me."
#21
Clio
4.3
(4)
"My friend dislocated her arm went to hospital and her eyeliner was still perfect."
"Korean liquid eyeliners - clio and bbia"
"I also like Clio's l, they don't transfer on my eyes at least."
"I use the Clio kill black and it’s the best I’ve ever used."
#22
Liquid Eyeliner
4.0
(4)
"Judydoll probably has one in dark brown."
"If you have access to Indonesian beauty brands, I enjoy the one by BLP Beauty."
"Eccentric Cosmetics carries colorful indie liquid liners."
"Milani liquid eye. Super black, glides on easily and does not budge."
#23
One Size
4.7
(3)
"My favorite liquid eyeliner is the One Size Point Made."
"My two favorites are the point made by one size and huda beauty!"
"Relevant products used: One size point made, busty brown"
#24
K-Palette
4.7
(3)
"Try the K-Palette eyeliners!"
"If you have access to K-Palette, their liquid eyeliners are great!"
"Lately I’ve been using K-palette eyeliner. It’s quite good."
#25
Morphe
4.7
(3)
"Morphe liquid liner is sooo good & waterproof!"
"I recently discovered the Morphe liquid liner and my God."
"The morphe one has been the closest match to it."
#26
Milani
5.0
(2)
"Milani liquid eyeliner will always be the GREATEST in my book."
"Milani! Super cheap and it stays on for so many hours."
#27
Lakmé
5.0
(2)
"I’ve bought a shit load of expensive eyeliners and always come back to the Lakmé one. It’s the best I’ve found so far."
"It's super reasonable and easy to use."
#28
Physician's Formula
5.0
(2)
"I love the physicians formula eye booster! Both the black and brown are excellent, better than NYx imo."
"Dries quick, can be built up for intense color, has great staying power."
#29
Anastasia Beverly Hills
5.0
(2)
"My ride or die is ABH. Lasts forever."
"I like the ABH one a lot, the one in a purple container."
#30
Canmake
5.0
(2)
"Japanese liquid liners are the best for oily lids
DUP, flowfushi UZU, canmake lasting liquid."
"I have oily hooded monolids and i napped in this and cried."
#31
PYT
5.0
(2)
"I have a lot of their other makeup and love it."
"I have been super impressed with their mascara! It’s now my HG!"
#32
Sephora
5.0
(2)
"I swear by the sephora brand liquid eyeliner. It literally does not transfer and stays put for a full workday."
"My favourite is the Sephora brand liquid eyeliner."
#33
Palladio
5.0
(2)
"I use Palladio brand (from Sally beauty or Amazon) they have nice colors and it applies and lasts like a dream."
"I just discovered palladio and i love it."
#34
MQNY
4.5
(2)
"Highly recommend the MQNY Macqueen liquid liner - I get it on Amazon. There are two shades of brown, and they’re both excellent at staying put."
"I've always liked the MacQueen liner pens."
#35
Revlon
4.5
(2)
"Revlon colourstay has never let me down"
"I have been using revlon color stay since I was in high school... it’s not waterproof but... it has stayed mostly in place."
#36
CLIO
4.5
(2)
"I love the clio kill eyeliner!"
"I'm pretty torn between the CLIO kill eyeliner and the Kiss Me Heroine one."
#37
Rare Beauty
4.5
(2)
"...I’ve been using Rare Beauty and Pat McGrath’s liquid liners and haven’t had them break down on me."
"The Rare Beauty liner is the only liquid liner I've found that truly dries matte."
#38
Judy Doll
4.5
(2)
"This in #02 is what I'm using. It has a super fine pen but is really easy to use."
"From other ones I really liked is Judy Doll extra slim liners, they are brush tip pen"
#39
Love Liner
4.5
(2)
"And I love it!"
"Love Liner (it’s Korean). I also liked KVD brown liquid liner when I used it in the past."
#40
Lancôme
4.5
(2)
"I’ve never been let down by Lancôme artliner which I have been using for 10 years."
"Lancòme ArtLiner"
#41
Lakme
4.0
(2)
"I recently purchased Lakme eyeconic liquid eyeliner."
"Maybe try the Lakme eyeconic liquid eye liner"
#42
Dollywink
4.0
(2)
"Dollywink! I find heroine make too fine/thin of liner."
"If you have trouble with your eye liner smudging, these might work for you."
#43
Haus Labs
4.0
(2)
"For waterproof liner I’d suggest Haus Lab liquid eye liner."
"Haus labs liquid eyeliner by Lady Gaga I find to be pretty good."
#44
Judydoll
4.0
(2)
"China- judydoll"
"I'm currently trying the Judydoll liner"
#45
Joah
5.0
(1)
"This eyeliner is still working… and it’s my favorite lol"
#46
WET N WILD
5.0
(1)
"I personally use WET N WILD multi stick in burning bridges as a eyeliner."
#47
Lisa Eldridge
5.0
(1)
"Lisa Eldridge kitten eyeliner"
#48
SHEIN
4.0
(1)
"I restocked like +10 times on it."
#49
Mac
4.0
(1)
"Mac gel pencil liner sick tat bro."
#50
rom&nd
4.0
(1)
"Rom&nd is a very good brand"
#51
Surreal Makeup
4.0
(1)
"I have been using Surreal Makeup's Satin Liquid Eyeshadow."
#52
Bbia
4.0
(1)
"Korean liquid eyeliners - clio and bbia"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
