Best peanut butter on Reddit

216 reviews from r/PeanutButter, r/filipinofood, r/newzealand and 14 more subreddits

216 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

Jif

4.6

(50)

"For me it's Jif."

"JIF. All the way. Always and forever. 😋"

"Jif"

"I love Jif more than anything so I’ve never tried the other."

"Jif by a landslide but justin’s is way better for you without the hydrogenized shit"

"Jif, no palm oil."

"Jif."

"I will stick with the classic!!! Jif."

"This is a matter of opinion, but in my opinion, JIF is the best."

Justin's

4.7

(23)

"Justin's Honey Peanut butter"

"Neither, Justin’s with honey."

"Justin’s is pretty damn good!!! And they make a great peanut butter cup."

"Justin’s. We just started using it and won’t go back"

"Justin's all the way!"

"Justin’s is healthier"

"Justin’s. Jif is at least 50% crisco."

"Just switched to Justin’s and it's really good!"

"Justin’s for sure. And if you’re also a fan of almond butter I 100% recommend Justin’s almond butter that comes sweetened with honey."

"Justin’s for me personally, but no hate to Jif."

Skippy

4.5

(22)

"Skippy is the king, stop this nonsense train."

"Skippy."

"Skippy for the win"

"Skippy"

"Skippy the best!"

"Skippy supremacy when it comes to peanut butter para sa kare-kare"

"I use Skippyyyyy creamy and Mama Sita’s Kare kare mix."

"SKIPPPYYYYYY 😋"

"Skippy forever 😅"

Fix & Fogg

4.8

(5)

"Fix & Fog Super Crunchy."

"Fix and Fog Smoke and Fire!"

"Fix & Fogg - smooth"

"Fix and Fogg super crunchy is my favorite."

"Fix and Fogg of the commercial ones though; Pics do way too light a roast imo."

Pic's

4.6

(5)

"Pics peanut butter the best imho"

"Pics smunchy is the best peanut butter I've ever had."

"We only buy Pic’s Crunchy with No Salt, everything else is too salty"

"Pics ‘smunchy’ (cross of smooth and crunchy)"

"My husband and kids love Pic's Smunchy. Both smooth and crunchy."

Pintola

5.0

(4)

"I have not had any other brand since I found Pintola."

"Pintola has no stabilizers and added sugar."

"Been usin Pintola for quite a few years now."

Pam's

4.5

(4)

"Pam's Crunchy is king."

"I prefer Pam's crunchy over anything else."

"Pam’s (I think?) version with the blue lid. I don’t love the ‘natural’ peanut butter and hate when it’s sweet so Pam’s is the sweet spot for me!"

"Pam's crunchy, haven't seen their Finest label in my local."

Lily's

4.3

(4)

"Only the original **Lily's peanut butter** for me. No hydrogenated vegetable oil in the ingredients!"

"I use half kilo na nabili ko sa palengke then 1/4 to 1/2 cup ng lily's 😄"

"Lily's is good."

"Lily's. I like it a bit sweeter."

Tillamook

5.0

(3)

"Has the best quality pb in the ice cream that I’ve found."

"Is amaze."

"Try Tillamook!"

#10

Crazy Richard's

5.0

(3)

"Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter is just peanuts, and it is delicious."

"Crazy Richard's."

"If I had to pick between the 2, Justin’s. But Crazy Richard’s is by far my fav."

#11

Trader Joe's

5.0

(3)

"I love Trader Joe’s peanut butter… My favorite."

"Trader Joe’s."

"Try Trader Joe’s honey peanut butter. Two ingredients."

#12

Justin’s

4.7

(3)

"I hated peanut butter my entire life until a friend made pb&js on a camping trip with Justin’s."

"Justin’s"

"Both taste great. Justin has fewer ingredients if thats important to people."

#13

Natural Peanut Butter

5.0

(2)

"Try natural peanut butter with no added sugar—perfect for that authentic, savory kare-kare taste!"

"Just make sure its NATURAL peanut butter. Stay away from anything else artificially sweetened...especially XYLITOL."

#14

Baskin Robbins

5.0

(2)

"I really like Baskin Robbins Peanut Butter and Chocolate."

#15

Kashi

5.0

(2)

"The Kashi one is my fave."

"The Kashi one is soooooo good!"

#16

I Love Peanut Butter

5.0

(2)

"This brand is by far the best I've had"

"This brand is by far the best....."

#17

Turkey Hill

5.0

(2)

"The peanut butter in turkey Hill's peanut butter cup is crazy good."

#18

Happy

4.5

(2)

"For branded na peanut butter, yung pinaka bet ko talaga is Happy."

"Try mo happy brand ng peanut butter. Not too sweet and may hint ng saltiness :)"

#19

Reese's

4.5

(2)

"The most delicious guilty pleasure peanut butter is without a doubt the Reeses PB in a jar."

"Reeses Peanut Butter."

#20

Pics

4.5

(2)

"We’re a Pics household here."

"Pic’s, Fix and Fogg do some interesting blends."

#21

PBfit

4.5

(2)

"It has a lot of extra protein and is only 1 pt per serving."

"PBfit is good with less calories."

#22

Teddies

4.5

(2)

"It's pricier but all natural and worth it."

#23

Kirkland

4.5

(2)

"Otherwise, Kirkland is great."

"Kirkland peanut butter is a solid choice and affordable"

#24

Bega

4.5

(2)

"I love sweet smooth peanut butter so i buy the BEGA brand peanut butter….i know it’s not popular but i love it."

"Bega crunchy. I wish they sold it in larger jars"

#25

Once Again

4.0

(2)

"I'm partial to Once Again but I'll have to try this!"

#26

PB Fit

5.0

(1)

"Super tasty and only 1 point per 2.5 tbsp."

#27

Naked

5.0

(1)

"The best peanut butter powder is Naked Peanut Butter, purchased on Amazon."

#28

Peter Pan Creamy Honey Roasted

5.0

(1)

"Peter Pan Creamy Honey Roasted is best."

#29

Peter Pan Honey Roasted

5.0

(1)

"Honey roasted Peter Pan is my favorite."

#30

Golden Harvest Honey-Roasted Peanut Butter

5.0

(1)

"If you're ever in Kittery, check out the honey-roasted peanut butter over at Golden Harvest!"

#31

Skippy Peanut Butter Protein Powder

5.0

(1)

"The best I was able to create was with Skippy Peanut Butter Protein Powder from Ryse Brand."

#32

Tillamook Chocolate PB

5.0

(1)

"Tillamook Chocolate PB is my fav!!!"

#33

JIF Chunky

5.0

(1)

"My faves: Dark chocolate dipped in chunky JIF."

#34

Whole Foods 365 Organic All Natural Smooth

5.0

(1)

"Which is beautifully gritty and I love it"

#35

Nature Valley Peanut Butter Wafer

5.0

(1)

"I’m addicted to those peanut butter wafer things by nature valley."

#36

Smucker's Natural

5.0

(1)

"I only like natural peanut butter like Smuckers Natural or Teddy's."

#37

Quinn's Maple Almond Butter

5.0

(1)

"The PB is really good too."

#38

Kashi Peanut Butter Puffins

5.0

(1)

"The best!"

#39

Magic Spoon Low-Carb Cereals

5.0

(1)

"There's a PB flavour."

#40

Ghost PB Cereal

5.0

(1)

"A healthier version of Reese puffs with 18g protein and way less sugar."

#41

Graeter's Buckeye Blitz

5.0

(1)

"It’s an Ohio ice cream brand."

#42

Oberweis

5.0

(1)

"They have a peanut butter sundae that’s amazing."

#43

Hudsonville Triple Peanut Butter

5.0

(1)

#44

Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter World

5.0

(1)

"It’s *that* good."

#45

Adirondack Creamery Chocolate Peanut Butter

5.0

(1)

"Andriondak creamery chocolate peanutbutter"

#46

Schwan's PB Fudge Ripple

5.0

(1)

"Schwan's used to have a pb fudge ripple. That was the best ever."

#47

Hood Peanut Butter Ripple

5.0

(1)

"Hood peanut butter ripple!!!! Or"

#48

Umpqua Duck Tracks

5.0

(1)

"Umpqua makes peanut butter ice creams called Duck Tracks/Beaver Tracks during football season."

#50

Comet Peanut Butter

5.0

(1)

"If you are near the nw suburbs of Illinois a Custard place called comet does a most excellent peanut butter."

#51

Haagen-Dazs Chocolate PB

5.0

(1)

"Hagen Daas ice cream- Chocolate PB is bangin."

#52

Tillamook Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream

5.0

(1)

"Tillamook Chocolate peanut butter ice cream is my one weakness."

#53

TruFruit Chocolate Peanut Butter Covered Bananas

5.0

(1)

"Tru fruit chocolate peanut butter covered bananas."

#54

Somerset Splits Peanut Butter Elvis

5.0

(1)

"Somerset Splits has a couple awesome peanut butter ones. I love their take on an Elvis."

#55

Sanitarium Crunchy

5.0

(1)

"Sanitarium Crunchy is the only one I like, all the others aren't salty enough for me..."

#56

Nut Brothers Crunchy

5.0

(1)

"Imo Nut Brothers crunchy is the best, followed closely by Fix & Foggs super crunchy"

#57

Nut Brother

5.0

(1)

"Nut Brother Super Smooth Slightly Salted is my fave these days, very good taste and consistency."

#58

Just Peanuts

5.0

(1)

"Their "Just peanuts - Sea Salt" might be the best natural peanut butter on the planet next to Adam's Dark Roast"

#59

Mable’s Smokehouse

5.0

(1)

"I loved Mable’s smokehouse peanut butter pie. It’s amazing"

#60

Wegman’s

5.0

(1)

"Wegman’s peanut butter cookies, they’re vegan and incredible."

#61

Trader Joe’s

5.0

(1)

"Trader Joe’s peanut butter is the GOAT and it’s like $2 for a jar."

#62

Bay Road

5.0

(1)

"Lifelong PB fanatic here. Converted to Bay Road a couple of years ago."

#63

Central Market

5.0

(1)

"If anyone in here lives near a central market, their honey salted peanut butter is soooo good."

#64

PB2

4.0

(1)

"It tastes pretty good!"

#65

Powdered Peanut Butter

4.0

(1)

"Can try Powdered Peanut Butter"

#66

Yung Happy

4.0

(1)

"Di masyadong matamis. Bagay ilagay"

#67

Nature's Nuts

4.0

(1)

"The best I have found is Nature's Nuts Light at Walmart, light blue label."

#68

Costco

4.0

(1)

"I've never had a recipe fail using Costco PB which is just peanuts, oil, and salt."

#69

Kraft Creamy

4.0

(1)

"Everyone has a different favorite, mine is Canadian Kraft creamy."

#70

Kroger Natural Peanut Butter

4.0

(1)

"Punches way above its weight class."

#71

Smucker's Natural Peanut Butter

4.0

(1)

"I prefer Smucker’s natural peanut butter."

#72

Kirkland Organic Creamy

4.0

(1)

"Just Peanuts and Salt."

#73

Skippy Natural with Honey

4.0

(1)

"The Skippy Natural with Honey is a good alternative."

#74

Jiffy

4.0

(1)

"Try Jiffy!"

#75

Didi's Peanut Butter

4.0

(1)

#76

Skippy Creamy

4.0

(1)

"Plus dinurog na tinustang mani"

#77

Sprouts PB Chocolate Pretzels

4.0

(1)

"They come in nuggets."

#78

Quinn's

4.0

(1)

"Gluten free pb pretzels are great"

#79

Kroger Peanut Butter Cheerios Knock Off

4.0

(1)

"That’s really good! And cheap!"

#80

Turkey Hill Vanilla and PB

4.0

(1)

"Is the way to go."

#81

Marco's PB and Caramel

4.0

(1)

"Marco's PB and caramel. It's got a chile kick and it's dense af."

#82

Skippy Super Chunk Peanut Sauce

4.0

(1)

"Skippy super chunk peanut sauce."

#83

Adams Peanut Butter

4.0

(1)

"...I sometimes still buy the Adams because it just has a uniquely good flavor and consistency."

#84

Maranatha

4.0

(1)

"Maranatha is very good, just a little oily."

#85

Peter Pan

4.0

(1)

"Justins is yummy, but if I’m going the no-stir route I love Peter Pan Honey Roast."

#86

Skippy Zero Sugar

3.0

(1)

"Di kasi masarap ang kare kare pag matamis na peanut butter nagamit e."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your first customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started