r/PeanutButter is a subreddit with 74k members. The community frequently discusses peanut butter, chocolate, cookies, butter, and toast, and they frequently recommend/review peanut butter, bread, and chocolate, and the most common flair used is personal picture, new pb discovery, recipe, news, and critique.
A subreddit for peanut butter, in all its evolution disproving awesomeness.
And for all things peanuts and nut-buttery, from the most delicious American peanut butter on a piece of white bread to savory Malian meat stew with a garnish of peanuts eaten out of a wooden bowl, and not excluding all of the alternatives for our allergic bretheren.
Pictures, discussion, and news from around the world that has to do with our favorite nut that's not a nut: Arachis hypogaea
Popular Topics in r/PeanutButter
#1
Peanut Butter
: "The baking page said these didn’t count, so hopefully you’ll like them here 🥹 Peanut Butter cups, with homemade strawberry jam 🐞🦋🍓🍫"
352 posts
#2
Chocolate
: "Homemade peanut butter rice krispie bars with a thick milk Chocolate layer chewy, Chocolatey, and dangerously snackable."
47 posts
#3
Cookies
: "Friday night chocolate chip peanut butter Cookies!"
36 posts
#4
Butter
: "Home made peanut Butter"
35 posts
#5
Toast
: "Anyone else like peanut butter Toast"
15 posts
#6
Banana
14 posts
#7
Reeses
: "Homemade chocolate peanut butter balls stuffed with Reese's!"
11 posts
#8
Snack
8 posts
#9
Cookie
: "peanut butter Cookie"
8 posts
#10
Fudge
: "Peanut Butter Chocolate Fudge at Costco"
8 posts
Products Discussed in r/PeanutButter
Peanut Butter
181 reviews
#1
Jif
4.5★ from 49 reviews
#2
Justin's
4.6★ from 25 reviews
#3
Skippy
4.6★ from 8 reviews
Bread
11 reviews
#1
Sara Lee
4.0★ from 2 reviews
#2
Dave's Killer Bread
5.0★ from 2 reviews
#3
Honey Wheat
4.0★ from 1 review
Chocolate
2 reviews
#1
Dymatize
5.0★ from 1 review
#2
PEScience
5.0★ from 1 review
Flair Used in r/PeanutButter
#1
Personal Picture
: "Homemade giant peanut butter cups"
31 posts
#2
New PB Discovery
: "Found this today, basically a melted Reese’s in a jar 10/10"
28 posts
#3
Recipe
: "I made peanut butter fudge topped brownies"
9 posts
#4
News
: "New Reese's Candy Ice Cream Bar"
4 posts
#5
Critique
: "What’s your favorite crunchy peanut butter snack?"
1 post
Member Growth in r/PeanutButter
Yearly
+23k members(46.7%)
Similar Subreddits to r/PeanutButter
r/52weeksofbaking
110k members
8.2% / yr
r/AskBaking
362k members
21.4% / yr
r/Baking
4.5M members
9.6% / yr
r/BakingNoobs
162k members
76.4% / yr
r/dessert
147k members
22.3% / yr
r/DessertPorn
2.0M members
1.2% / yr
r/EdiblesPorn
5k members
14.4% / yr
r/Oatmeal
102k members
66.1% / yr
r/Old_Recipes
542k members
8.9% / yr
r/veganrecipes
628k members
7.6% / yr
About
GummySearch helps people research Reddit communities by organizing activity, growth, themes, and post-level signals into one place.
This page gives a focused view of r/PeanutButter, including current member size, discussion patterns, product reviews, and related communities to explore.
This data is synced periodically so insights stay current and useful for ongoing research.
Last updated: June 16, 2026