Pumpkin Pie reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 257 Reddit reviews across 47 subreddits and 53 posts to rank the best Pumpkin Pie brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/boston, r/TwinCities, r/orlando, r/ottawa, r/SouthJersey. Top-rated brands include Pumpkin Pie (4.4/5), Costco (4.2/5), Whole Foods (4.6/5).
Stats
Reviews257
Subreddits47
Posts53
Brands94
Products77
257 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Pumpkin Pie
4.4
(78)
"Kowalski's has the best pumpkin pie."
"Kowalski's pies are awesome! Pumpkin for fall, blueberry/blackberry lemon for summer."
"I love the pies from Seward co-op. Whole Foods also has really good pumpkin pies."
"I really like the Trader Joe’s pumpkin pie."
"Rinzlers carries a really good pumpkin pie that’s made locally."
"Super pricey, but the pie hole is my fave!!"
"Earl's has great pumpkin pie this month as their feature dessert."
"Blue Ribbon Bakery has a great pumpkin Pie."
"Find the recipe online and make it. Its well worth it."
"I highly suggest going to the apple factory in brampton."
#2
Costco
4.2
(63)
"I think the pumpkin pie at Costco beats the pants off the Sams Club version. Much tastier pumpkin flavor and much better pie crust to my palate."
"$6 massive pie at Costco. So good"
"Costco and Traders Joes"
"Nothing beats Costco's pumpkin pie."
"Costco. Not kidding."
"Costco has large pumpkin pies for a good price, and jars of praline pecans. Get both, arrange the pecans on top of the pie, and warm it up in the oven until the sugary coating melts a bit."
"Costco’s are elite tier. Huge, cheap, and delicious - don’t have the aftertaste that you’d expect from a grocery store bakery."
"Amazingly delicious, and they're huge and only seven dollars."
"Costco has fantastic pie."
"Costco’s pumpkin pie is incredible"
#3
Whole Foods
4.6
(5)
"Whole Foods has some great pies."
"Whole Foods."
"Whole Foods."
"Whole foods."
"Best pumpkin pie I had was Whole Foods."
#4
Libby's
4.6
(5)
"Buy a can of Libby’s pumpkin and follow directions it’s 100 times better than store-bought"
"The recipe on the libbys can is honestly great just add a tablespoon of “pumpkin pie spice” to give it more of a kick."
"Fyi if you use the Libby’s pumpkin pie recipe and use a Pillsbury pie crust, it’s super easy!"
"If you can purchase Libby’s pure pumpkin at your grocery store there is a pumpkin pie recipe on the label."
"Libby's pumpkin pie filling has a no fail recipe."
#5
Life of Pie
4.7
(3)
"Life of Pie."
"They are one of the few that get the spices right imo"
"Life of Pie is pretty good"
#6
Springdale Farms
4.0
(3)
"Gotta say it's pretty darn good! I normally just get one from ShopRite but this is miles better."
"Spring dale farms omg order it now"
"I just picked up one from Springdale Farms.... First time trying it."
#7
Dyments Farm
5.0
(2)
"Seconding Bennetts or Dyments."
"Dyments farm in Dundas."
#8
Libby
5.0
(2)
"Nothing has been better or as good as that dang recipe on the side of the Libby Pumpkin can."
"Make your own from Libby’s can and a pillsbury crust. Just as good as the grocery, and you can spice as much as you want."
#9
Silver State Pie Co.
5.0
(2)
"Silver State Pie Co! Amazing new local food truck that does pie."
"Silver State Pie Co. is a local food truck that is SO good!!"
#10
Gayle's
5.0
(2)
"Gayle’s"
"Gayles in Santa Cruz."
#11
Wanda's
4.5
(2)
"I’ve had their pumpkin pie (not this year) and it was as good as I can do."
"Wanda's Pie in the Sky at Kensington Market."
#12
Baker Square
4.5
(2)
"Bakers square at Famous Daves"
"Baker Square. Still one in Palatine."
#13
Chudleighs
4.5
(2)
"Chudleighs, warmed up in the oven and topped with vanilla bean ice cream"
"Chudleighs or costco"
#14
Florence Pie Bar
4.5
(2)
"It's out near North Hampton but it's amazing."
"Depends on your location - Florence Pie Bar, Verrill, Petsi."
#15
Sprouts
4.5
(2)
"Sprouts is delicious honestly."
"I got a GF Pumpkin Pie and GF Pumpkin Cheesecake from there last year and plan on doing so again."
#16
Cool Whip
4.0
(2)
"Make a sort of pumpkin "fluff" which could potentially save you Cals too."
"Like a "trifle"?"
#17
Byerlys
4.0
(2)
"If I was gonna go blind into grocery stores looking for a great bakery made pie I'd hit Byerlys."
"I like Byerlys!"
#18
Perkins
4.0
(2)
"Perkins."
"Coworkers love the one from Perkins."
#19
Stop & Shop
5.0
(1)
"The recipe on the back of the stop n shop can from the 80s is the best one."
#20
Pillsbury
5.0
(1)
"Pumpkin pie is easy to make. Just use pillsbury pie crust and it takes very little time and tastes amazing."
#21
Jello
5.0
(1)
"So good n easy"
#22
Eagle Brand
5.0
(1)
"Eagle Brand sweetened condensed milk has a very good recipe."
#23
Onggi
5.0
(1)
"Onggi made some delicious pumpkin and apple pies last thanksgiving I’m hoping they do again this year"
#24
Lyndell's
5.0
(1)
"Lyndell's in Somerville."
#25
Salt and Vinegar
5.0
(1)
"Selling a sought after pumpkin pie."
#26
Amish Market
5.0
(1)
"Has a line out the door for the pumpkin pies."
#27
Solly's
5.0
(1)
"Taking orders now."
#28
Amelie’s
5.0
(1)
"Pumpkin eclairs that are to die for."
#29
Teeter
5.0
(1)
"Little pumpkin cheesecakes in a cold case."
#30
Bennetts
5.0
(1)
"I like Bennetts for any pie."
#31
Danny’s Deli & Grill
5.0
(1)
"Best pies in town hands down."
#32
Delicious Orchards
5.0
(1)
"They're known for their pies, I've never had a bad one."
#33
Booskerdoo
5.0
(1)
"Booskerdoo has the best holiday assortment of desserts including pie"
#34
Farmer's Market (Délices du Marché)
5.0
(1)
"The brand you want is "Farmer's Market (Délices du Marché)"."
#35
Local Dairy Farm
5.0
(1)
"They sell a massive assortment of dairy, meat, and home made food products. A whole freezer with 8+ kinds of pie."
#36
Manna
5.0
(1)
"Great pies. great cause."
#37
Achatz
5.0
(1)
"An Achatz pie. Mostly found at plum market"
#38
Beckman's
5.0
(1)
"Beckmans is pretty damn good too"
#39
Marie Callender's
5.0
(1)
"Marie Calendars. Hands down."
#40
San Francisco Street Bakery
5.0
(1)
"We usually get ours from the San Francisco Street bakery."
#41
Carlos Bakery
5.0
(1)
"Honestly, the one from Carlos bakery is delicious."
#42
Bakester
5.0
(1)
"A place called Bakester. Fuck me I still think about it."
#43
Proper Pie
5.0
(1)
"Proper Pie. Or sometimes WPA has it by the slice."
#44
Heidi's Pies
5.0
(1)
"On the Peninsula, Heidi's Pies in San Mateo would be the top choice."
#45
Draeger's Market
5.0
(1)
"Draeger's Market has really good pies."
#46
The Cakery
5.0
(1)
"The cakery in Burlingame has really good pies."
#47
Two Fat Cats
5.0
(1)
"Two fat cats."
#48
Amish Bakery
5.0
(1)
"Amish Bakery in the Berlin Mart. Everything they make is just fantastic."
#49
Yvonne's Southern Sweets
5.0
(1)
"I can personally highly recommend: http://www.yvonnessouthernsweets.com/."
#50
Black Walnut
5.0
(1)
"Black Walnut probably has the best, as usual."
#51
Fika
5.0
(1)
"Fika in Saco has been putting out amazing stuff since they opened."
#52
Sugar Pie Co.
5.0
(1)
"Sugar Pie Co."
#53
Homage
5.0
(1)
"Homage does special orders for desserts during the holidays."
#54
Walmart
5.0
(1)
"Honestly Walmart has my favorite"
#55
Sofra
5.0
(1)
"Had one from sofra one year and it was amazing."
#56
King Arthur Baking
5.0
(1)
"This is my absolute favorite filling recipe."
#57
Lueken's
5.0
(1)
"In MN? It is *Hands down* Lueken’s."
#58
Vi's
5.0
(1)
"Vi’s for pies. There is no other choice."
#59
Anna Miller
5.0
(1)
"Anna Miller. Cannot go wrong."
#60
Foodland
5.0
(1)
"Make pumpkin crunch. It is a easy failproof recipe that takes about 10 minutes of prep."
#61
Lavern's Pie Stand
5.0
(1)
"Lavern’s Pie Stand."
#62
Liliha Bakery
5.0
(1)
"Liliha Bakery. Both locations."
#63
Pie Gourmet
5.0
(1)
"My family loves it when I get them from Pie Gourmet in Vienna."
#64
Petsi Pies
5.0
(1)
"Petsi Pies"
#65
Mrs Miles
5.0
(1)
"According to my family’s lore, Mrs Miles had the best pumpkin pie ever."
#66
Jell-O
4.0
(1)
"Canned pumpkin, plus sugar-free Jell-O mix could easily make a cold Jell-O mousse."
#67
One Pie
4.0
(1)
"You do, grab a One Pie can and refrigerated crust. It’s really not too bad to do."
#68
Joy of Cooking
4.0
(1)
"You can get the recipe from the “Joy of Cooking” and the pie crust recipe from “Salt Fat Acid Heat.”"
#69
Myers’
4.0
(1)
"Try the Myers’ house down in Haddonfield, IL."
#70
Community Servings
4.0
(1)
"The one through Community Servings' Pie in the Sky fundraiser is pretty good imo."
#71
Weil's
4.0
(1)
"I always enjoyed the pumpkin pie from Weil's in Westdale."
#72
Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen
4.0
(1)
"The pumpkin was good."
#73
Brown Loaf
4.0
(1)
"Brown Loaf on Elgin has often had pumpkin pies."
#74
Target
4.0
(1)
"Pumpkin cheesecake bites from the frozen section."
#75
Keagan's
4.0
(1)
"Keagan's in Plymouth."
#76
Mrs. Smith
4.0
(1)
"Mrs. Smith."
#77
Nations
4.0
(1)
"Nations is also a classic for a variety of different pies."
#78
Shyndigz
4.0
(1)
"Looks like Shyndigz has pumpkin pie - maybe on specific days of the week."
#79
Duarte's
4.0
(1)
"I’ve never had their pumpkin pie (not a pumpkin pie person), but all the other pies from Duarte’s in Pescadero kick ass."
#80
Nightmoves
4.0
(1)
"Nightmoves has had amazing ones in the past."
#81
One-Pie
4.0
(1)
"Can of One-Pie Pumpkin pie and Pillsbury Pie Crust."
#82
Rosemont
4.0
(1)
"Rosemont is best value pie preorder."
#83
Russo's
4.0
(1)
"I get my thanksgiving pies from Russo's in Tabernacle every year."
#84
The Crafty Cottage
4.0
(1)
"The Crafty Cottage pies are local and homemade"
#85
Unnamed
4.0
(1)
"It's probably the best store bought pumpkin pie out there."
#86
Serious Eats
4.0
(1)
"I've had the best luck with this pie crust recipe."
#87
Styer's
4.0
(1)
"If I had to buy one probably in a supermarket or wholesale Club, perhaps Styer's-order ahead well in advance."
#88
Backers Square
4.0
(1)
"Backers square was really good."
#89
Bakers Pie
4.0
(1)
"Bakers Pie."
#90
Pane Del Sol Bakery
4.0
(1)
"Pane Del Sol Bakery 175 John st. S."
#91
Haggen
4.0
(1)
"Given that the rest of Haggen's baked goods are pretty damn good, I'd wager a bet that theirs will be great."
#92
Wegman's
4.0
(1)
"Wegman’s has a great gluten free pumpkin pie but their crust is too sweet."
#93
Sam's Club
3.0
(1)
"The sams club pumpkin used to be my favorite but now it seems under-spiced."
#94
Farmboy
3.0
(1)
"Farmboy was decent for a good price!"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
