Resort reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 300 Reddit reviews across 42 subreddits and 109 posts to rank the best Resort brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/AllInclusiveResorts, r/PuntaCana, r/WaltDisneyWorld, r/VisitingHawaii, r/UniversalOrlando. Top-rated brands include Secrets (4.3/5), Breathless (4.4/5), Xcaret (4.9/5).
Stats
Reviews300
Subreddits42
Posts109
Brands91
Products14
300 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Secrets
4.3
(13)
"Wife and I went to Secrets Akumal for a week and I don’t see how another AI could best it."
"It would have to be one of the Secrets... Maroma or Akumal."
"In Cancun!"
"Secrets Playa Mujeres/Dreams Playa Mujeres."
"Check out secrets cap cana"
"We just got back from secrets cap Cana and really enjoyed it. Club level ocean front. It was very quiet in the club side."
"I’ve been and it’s nice, but Secrets Akumal is waaaaay better."
"If you are looking out side of Cancun try Secrets Impression Moxche or Isla Murjeres"
"If you're looking for a bougie Secrets resort take a look at Moxche or (even fancier) Impressions Moxche."
"Secrets Akumal is a really nice resort. The beach is top notch. The snorkeling is great. The staff was great."
#2
Breathless
4.4
(10)
"Recommend Breathless out of your list of possibles."
"Will give you what you want."
"Hi! Out of the options you mentioned, Breathless is better for parties like bachelorette parties."
"Breathless punta Cana or breathless soul Cancun."
"Breathless"
"We just got back from Breathless this past Saturday."
"Breathless was a great play it a big party for middle aged people."
"Check out Breathless or The Cape."
"I’d consider looking at Breathless, Royalton Chic or Live Aqua."
"The Breathless or CHIC resorts maybe!"
#3
Xcaret
4.9
(8)
"I'll recommend La Casa de La Playa by Xcaret in Riviera Maya."
"La Casa de La Playa is true luxury. Can’t even compare to anything else"
"This. La Casa is hands down the best! We loved it."
"If you really want the bougiest and best food, look at La Casa de la Playa."
"Xcaret is pricey but if you can afford it, THIS is the place."
"From personal experience, Xcaret, Or Hard Rock in Cancun or Moon Palace."
"Xcaret in Mexico. Stay there and you get access to all the parks."
"Xcaret was fun for our 4 year old! They had a lot of options for activities."
#4
Saratoga Springs
4.2
(9)
"SSR The Paddock is our favourite neighborhood. Always try to stay there."
"The pool at the Paddock area has an awesome slide, a hot tub, and a splash pad, along with a poolside bar."
"Love Saratoga Springs."
"Love Saratoga Springs. Two bigger pools with slides and a great splash pad for little kids."
"On Disney property there are 4 options. I’ll put them in order for you Saratoga springs>Port Orleans>Old Key West>Coronado Springs."
"Great pool, great theming, and nice boat ride to the Springs."
"I liked Saratoga Springs and we could take the boat over to Disney Springs."
"It’s worth noting that one end of Saratoga Springs is easily walkable to Disney Springs."
"Saratoga has some areas that are less than a 10 minute walk to DS."
#5
Iberostar
4.3
(8)
"Is likely the nicest."
"Great food, no children and everyone is asleep by 11."
"Iberostar!"
"I’d choose Iberostar or Melia resorts for food quality and entertainment."
"The best beach in the area."
"Check out the Iberostar resorts in Mayan Riviera."
"Any Iberostar is a great all arounder."
"Iberostar. There are multiple levels at different price points."
#6
Animal Kingdom Lodge
4.9
(7)
"Animal kingdom lodge or Polynesian for Oahana."
"Animal kingdom is the way. Sanaa is great."
"Love AK and Coronado Springs; Wilderness Lodge is one of my favorites too."
"Animal Kingdom Lodge is the easy answer."
"I agree with what previous commenters said, Animal Kingdom Lodge is fantastic!"
"Animal Kingdom Lodge easily - Sanaa is excellent for lunch."
"Loved Mara at Animal Kingdom Lodge if you are on a budget."
#7
Port Orleans
4.3
(8)
"POFQ great for 10 n under kiddos esp while POR also a fav can go to teens."
"Port Orleans French Quarter. Has one of the best pools ever for kids."
"French Quarter/Riverside, Old Key West or Saratoga Springs. They all have boats to Disney Springs and Saratoga, you can walk over."
"I second this- I stayed at port Orleans recently and while the boat to Disney springs was nice (and the rest of the resort was great!)"
"Port Orleans."
"POR/POFQ or Saratoga Springs are all solid choices."
"Either of the Port Orleans resorts. Boats that take you to Disney Springs are a nice change of pace from the buses."
"Port Orleans is decent and it has a direct boat to DS."
#8
Riu
3.9
(8)
"Any Riu in Jamaica 8 1/2 to 9"
"Riu all the way, ive stayed at the Riu in Cabo and those parties were so much fun!"
"Riu is dope because they have a theme party a few nights a week."
"Brands that are more budget-friendly are Riu, Sandos, Barcelo."
"Riu is probably your best bet."
"Riu brands tend to have a party vibe."
"Also stay at the riu, food is not the best but you’re either 18 or 22 and probably want to be where the girls your age are."
"The Riu Republica might be a little too lively."
#9
Atelier
4.7
(6)
"Atelier was amazing. Highly recommended."
"Atelier - hands down! Excellent choice. I just got back from 8 nights and adored everything about it."
"We chose Atelier and booked INSPIRA."
"We have great rates and amenities plus Amazon gift card for booking."
"The rooms and overall hotel is more modern and elevated at Atelier. Food better at Atelier too."
"Atelier!"
#10
Excellence Playa Mujeres
5.0
(5)
"Excellence playa mujeres is our favorite."
"Excellence playa Mujeres is our favorite."
"Excellence playa Mujeres is our favorite."
"We loved Excellence Playa Mujeres in Cancun Mexico."
"I like Excellence Playa Mujeres."
#11
Fairmont Orchid
4.8
(5)
"It’s really beautiful resort with a nice beach."
"We stayed at the Fairmont Orchid on the Big Island for our honeymoon and it was perfect!"
"Fairmont Orchid!"
"Absolutely loved the fairmont orchid on our first visit and will be going back."
"Fairmont Orchid, or Four Seasons Hualalai will be within budget."
#12
Sandals
4.2
(5)
"Currently at Curacao now- amazing. Been to a few other sandals over the years - this is the best so far."
"Any Sandals 10"
"A couple of the Sandals resorts would hit a lot of your bullet points."
"Sandals is one but as previously mentioned it is geared towards couples."
"I am a Sandals Certified travel specialist and have been 10 properties."
#13
Dreams Playa Mujeres
5.0
(4)
"We were at the Dreams Playa Mujeres last year specifically because we were with a large group and some had kids and it was great."
"Dreams Playa Mujeres is my go to blanket recommendation for clients with kids in Mexico."
"Dreams Playa Mujeres is our current family favorite."
"Dreams Playa Mujeres is the family friendly resort I book the most."
#14
Secrets Akumal
5.0
(4)
"Secrets Akumal should be at the top of your list."
"Secrets Akumal has a good beach with good snorkeling."
"Every room has a two person hot tub, the beach is one of the best in Mexico (snorkeling right off the beach with the turtles!) and overall food and service at the resort is excellent."
"All the rooms at Secrets Akumal have a jacuzzi in the room."
#15
Royal Pacific Resort
5.0
(4)
"Royal Pacific. It's my go to. Absolutely love it there."
"Royal Pacific has consistently been my favorite."
"Loew’s royal pacific, Portifino, or hard rock hotel is the way to go."
"Just got back from Royal Pacific and have no complaint at all."
#16
Atelier Playa Mujeres
5.0
(4)
"Atelier playa mujeres. went last month."
"We went to Atelier Playa mujeres last September and we loved it."
"We did Atelier Playa Mujeres and it was premium."
"My family loves Atelier in Playa Mujeres."
#17
Excellence El Carmen
5.0
(4)
"5star perfect."
"We just got back this week from Excellence El Carmen."
"We went to Excellence El Carmen and loved it."
"All their rooms have a two-person whirlpool tub that has blinds you can pull for complete privacy."
#18
Sleeping Giant
4.8
(4)
"They also have a cave on the property."
"Amazing location, amazing food and amazing staff!!"
"Had a great experience."
"Great hiking trails, nice pool and restaurant."
#19
Couples Resorts
4.8
(4)
"Couples Reports is amazing."
"If want the most authentic tasting Jamaican food at Jamaican hotel, you have to go to the Jamaican owned hotels."
"Couples Resorts 7/ 10"
"Look at the Couples Resorts in Jamaica."
#20
Excellence
4.5
(4)
"Sanctuary, Secrets, Hyatt Zilara, either Excellence resort and Live Aqua all superior."
"Some of the best value and great resorts w private pool rooms is Excellence Resorts."
"Try for adults only all inclusive: any Excellence, Secrets, JOIA Iberostar, Sandals, Hyatt Zilara."
"Any of the Excellence resorts in Mexico sound like what you’re looking for."
#21
Live Aqua
4.5
(4)
"We were here for 6 nights! The resort food and service was literally the best part."
"Live Aqua."
"Live Aqua if you want really good food."
"Beautiful water, very good food, laid back but not boring."
#22
Hyatt Ziva
4.5
(4)
"Hyatt Ziva, Excellence Playa Mujeres, and Atelier in Playa Mujeres."
"I love Hyatt Ziva and Moon Palace."
"Just stayed at Hyatt Ziva. There were A LOT of kids. The resort seems very family friendly"
"This is a family-friendly resort."
#23
Valentin
4.5
(4)
"This is where I send my clients that want a mix like you do."
"Travel agent here as well. Valentin. Atelier. Secrets Moxche."
"I can provide general advice."
#24
Riu Palace
4.3
(4)
"Adult only, beautiful, and great food."
"Beautiful resort - good drinks - all inclusive- would definitely do again."
"I typically send people to Riu Palace Las Americas (adults only higher end)."
"Riu Palace Las Americas, adults-only, within walking distance to popular Cancun nightclubs."
#25
Finest
4.3
(4)
"We stayed at Finest this past May for our honeymoon and had an amazing time!"
"I would say Finest or Dreams for food quality and overall modernness."
"The food at Finest was excellent."
"Finest Playa Mujeres."
#26
Hard Rock Hotel
5.0
(3)
"We really enjoy Hard Rock."
"We stayed at Hard Rock last time and it was a blast."
"Hard Rock Hotel! My boyfriend and I just went there this year and were 23. We both absolutely loved it."
#27
Art of Animation
5.0
(3)
"Art of Animation I think would be your best bet."
"Art of animation is my favorite for kiddos."
"AoA was prefect for my family and our two toddlers."
#28
Mauna Lani
5.0
(3)
"Mauna Lani and book through a travel agent so you can get the added benefits which include their excellent breakfast buffet."
"My clients always rave about mauna lani and hualalai."
"Mauna Lani is a great honeymoon option that fits in your budget!"
#29
Royalton Chic
5.0
(3)
"We loved Royalton CHIC. Get diamond club, it’s worth it!!"
"Royalton Chic."
"Royalton chic however is my choice! I had so much fun there every single night."
#30
Wilderness
5.0
(3)
"Wilderness hands down. NOT Chula Vista."
"Wilderness is enough for 5-6 days, seriously."
"I would say wilderness is a good option with the number of indoor and outdoor parks in the summer."
#31
Hyatt Zilara
5.0
(3)
"All 3 may be more than grand Palladium but they are adults only."
"I would recommend Hyatt Zilara"
"I would look at Hyatt Zilara or Live Aqua."
#32
Le Blanc
4.7
(3)
"We thoroughly enjoyed Le Blanc back in 2014."
"If you're looking for the BEST relaxing AI hands down its Grand Velas then Le Blanc."
"Le Blanc was really nice!"
#33
Paradisus Playa del Carmen
4.7
(3)
"Check out paradisus playa del Carmen, we loved it!"
"Just got back from a wedding at Paradisus in Playa del Carmen on Saturday and it was great!!"
"Paradisus Playa del Carmen in a Family Concierge Swim-Up Suite."
#34
Grand Colorado Peak 8
4.7
(3)
"+1 to Grand Colorado Peak 8. Super nice & new hotel."
"Grand Colorado Peak 8."
"If you are wanting a hotel I would look at the Grand Colorado at the base of peak 8."
#35
Impressions
4.7
(3)
"Impressions moxche is definitely the bougiest. We had a swim out and it was amazing."
"Both great resorts but I would definitely recommend Impression Moxche"
"Check out impressions moxche."
#36
Hilton La Romana
4.7
(3)
"Hilton La Romana would be your best option."
"IMO, of these three, Hilton La Romana is the highest quality."
"It’s a great option in my opinion."
#37
Moon Palace
4.7
(3)
"I love Hyatt Ziva and Moon Palace."
"I would recommend Moon Palace"
"Moon palace sunrise is a great option, especially with kids!"
#38
Couples Swept Away
4.7
(3)
"We just booked at Couples Swept Away in Jamaica in Feb."
"We have loved the food at Couples Resorts. At Swept Away they have Caribbean food available at the grill and every resort does a Caribbean buffet once a week."
"Reasonably priced, great food, and a phenomenal beach."
#39
Hyatt Ziva Cap Cana
4.7
(3)
"Hyatt Ziva Cap Cana 100%. Amazing resort and the water park is even better!"
"Is an amazing family resort!"
"Hyatt Ziva Cap Cana."
#40
Sapphire Falls Resort
4.7
(3)
"Was just at Sapphire Falls for four nights and loved it!"
"Sapphire Falls is the best."
"Sapphire is a really wonderful resort."
#41
Rosewood
4.7
(3)
"If you enjoyed Belmond La Samanna, Rosewood Mayakoba is definitely an awesome choice."
"Just got back from Mayakoba and rosewood Mayakoba is amazing!"
"Rosewood Mayakoba is incredible."
#42
Riu Caribe
4.3
(3)
"Riu Caribe has awesome beach, good food, parties, and everything else a young couple would appreciate."
"RIU Caribe would be the most budget friendly and fun."
"Riu Caribe is the place to be for young adults."
#43
Fairmont
4.3
(3)
"Fairmont, best spa!"
"The Fairmont is actually pretty nice."
"We were at Fairmont in October. If you go that route make sure to book with an agent and/or get a package that has the breakfast included."
#44
Hilton
4.3
(3)
"Hilton Lake Buena Vista Palace. This hotel has an incredible pool and lazy river, the restaurants are delicious."
"Non-Disney Hilton Orlando Buena Vista Palace."
"We’ve stayed at Hilton Lake Buena Vista a number of times. The rooms are a bit shabby/dated, but the lobby, restaurants, and pool are lovely."
#45
Sanctuary Cap Cana
4.3
(3)
"Look into Sanctuary Cap Cana."
"Excellent food & service. Beautiful and quiet."
"The Sanctuary at Cap Cana is really nice, a bit pricey."
#46
Dreams
4.3
(3)
"Check out Dreams Playa Mujeres. Our kids loved it so much."
"Dreams is a favorite of our family."
"Just booked Dreams Jade after seeing TripAdvisor reviews about how it's great for families/kids."
#47
Gravity Haus
4.3
(3)
"I would recommend Gravity Haus or the new boutique hotel the Carlin!"
"Gravity Haus has a young vibe right in town."
"Gravity Haus is a nice place that is right in town and on the mountain."
#48
Alexandra
4.0
(3)
"Alexandra is definitely a solid choice."
"I think this is a solid option and you will be very content at the alexandra."
"We love the Alexandra. The beach there is gorgeous."
#49
Zilara
3.7
(3)
"Zilara cap cana."
"La Perla and Zilara are 💯all inclusive."
"Went to Zilara in February 2025. Water, both pool and beach was cold. Food scene was decent but at the buffets, the employees serve you and most are very inattentive."
#50
Lovango Resort
5.0
(2)
"Lovango resort is probably what you’re looking for. It’s on its own island with a beach and pool and the food is excellent."
"Staying at lovango you can ask... Lovango resort is probably what you’re looking for."
#51
Pearl Farm
5.0
(2)
"If samal, Pearl Farm would be the best."
"Will never go wrong with Pearl Farm. Top class service."
#52
Fairmont Kea Lani
5.0
(2)
"I prefer the Fairmont Kea Lani."
#53
Castle Hot Springs
5.0
(2)
"Castle Hot Springs is amazing and has outdoor soaking tubs, hot springs, cold plunge and everything is included in your stay."
"1000% go to Castle Hot Springs for this. It is “AI” except alcohol so works in your favor on pricing."
#54
Gaylord Palms
5.0
(2)
"The Gaylord Palms is phenomenal."
"Gaylord Palms is awesome for families."
#55
Grand Velas
5.0
(2)
"Not sure what your budget is but we just got back from Grand Velas and it was perfect."
"If you're looking for the BEST relaxing AI hands down its Grand Velas then Le Blanc."
#56
El Dorado Casitas Royale
5.0
(2)
"All rooms have in room jacuzzi for 2. Indoor and outdoor shower!"
"A resort that I have the most return guests to is called El Dorado Casitas Royale."
#57
Club Med Cancun
5.0
(2)
"Closest ones would be Club Med Cancun and Moon Palace."
"Club Med Cancun hits all your boxes here!"
#58
Four Seasons Hotels
5.0
(2)
"My understanding is that they have cabanas for all guests."
#59
Garza Blanca
5.0
(2)
"My family and I really like Garza Blanca outside Puerto Vallarta."
"Garza Blanca. Roof top pool is adults only."
#60
Shangri-La
5.0
(2)
"This is top tier even better than Palawan."
"Not too pricey for a Shangrila and the exclusiveness of the beach and service of the staff is top tier!"
#61
Finest Punta Cana
5.0
(2)
"Finest Punta Cana. Took our kids there twice."
"Finest Punta Cana was excellent."
#62
Grand Luxxe
5.0
(2)
"Grand Luxxe for sure. It’s the best for couples I think."
"The upgrade was worth every penny."
#63
Xcaret Arte
5.0
(2)
"Xcaret Arte… best ever."
"99% of the guests were couples."
#64
Secrets Maroma
5.0
(2)
"Check out Secrets Maroma. Great beach, pretty tranquil."
"Secrets Maroma and Akumal are exactly what you’re looking for!"
#65
Westin Hapuna Beach Resort
5.0
(2)
"We were at the Westin a few weeks ago and it was spectacular!! The beach is incredible!!"
"Personally I’d go with Westin Hapuna. The beach is amazing."
#66
Paradisus
5.0
(2)
"Paradisus is amazing for families. Lots of activities and options for kids."
"Paradisus if you want to swim. This is the only good swimming beach."
#67
Secrets Cap Cana
5.0
(2)
"Secrets Cap Cana in the Dominican Republic!"
"Secrets Cap Cana in the Dominican is absolutely wonderful!"
#68
Four Seasons Hualalai
5.0
(2)
"FS can often feel very private, especially if you use certain pools."
"It’s a beautiful property that’s worth the money!"
#69
Compass Cove
4.5
(2)
"Compass Cove"
"Compass cove"
#70
Mousai
4.5
(2)
"If you're open to Puerto Vallarta, check out Mousai. It rivals Unico, maybe even better views and better balconies."
"Hotel Mousai is in the Hotel Zone (so less of a “resort feel”) but has a decent beach and pools, good food, a distinctive decor."
#71
Four Seasons
4.5
(2)
"We did the four seasons. It was absolutely phenomenal."
"There are some really great resorts in Punta Mita."
#72
Caribe Hilton
4.5
(2)
"If you can afford it, the Caribe Hilton San Juan. It’s a gigantic with many bars and a private beach."
"I would say Caribe Hilton or Fairmont El San Juan Hotel... Caribe is nice because its close to Escambron beach."
#73
Majestic Mirage
4.5
(2)
"The staff were so sweet and the drinks were strong and delicious! Food was good as well!"
"Stayed at Majestic Mirage in August. Family loved it."
#74
Royalton Bavaro
4.5
(2)
"The beach is amazing and it would be a great resort for a honeymoon."
"Maybe look at Royalton Bavaro in Punta Cana."
#75
Valentin Imperial
4.5
(2)
"Consider Valentin imperial if you want the best food and beautiful rooms!"
"Valentin Imperial or Secrets Moxche in Mexico, Excellence resorts in DR."
#76
Ritz Carlton
4.5
(2)
"It was beyond fantastic from service to food to activities."
"I think it’s one of the best and most diverse food offerings in the Maldives."
#77
Blue Angel
4.5
(2)
"Blue Angel is great!! Fun and friendly staff and great food!! Dive shop and dock on site."
"Is probably the closest to Scuba Club."
#78
Grenada
4.5
(2)
"I’d recommend Grenada or Antigua. Both were beautiful and close to the airport."
"I’d recommend Grenada or Antigua. Both were beautiful and close to the airport."
#79
Secrets Resorts
4.5
(2)
"Look up any Secrets resorts. All-inclusive and adult only."
"Secrets Resorts have a good mix of both."
#80
Sugar Beach
4.5
(2)
"Took both our kids to sugar beach at that age. Great beach, calm protected sea."
"Sugar Beach if you don't want the mega-water park vibes"
#81
Mayrhofen
4.5
(2)
"Mayrhofen ! It’s such an amazing resort!"
"Have a look at Mayrhofen - it’s easy to get to and has a lot of apres."
#82
Lions Dive
4.0
(2)
"Lions dive will be good for you. Mambo beach is fun and not quiet."
"Lions Dive will be a better choice, more activity and space then Avila. And good for families."
#83
Catalonia Royal Tulum
4.0
(2)
"Catalonia Royal Tulum is adults-only."
"You could take a look at Catalonia Royal Tulum, adults-only with a beautiful beach."
#84
Riu Santa Fe
4.0
(2)
"A crazy party scene!"
"Riu Santa Fe."
#85
Centara
4.0
(2)
"For resorts on a budget, I like Centara myself."
"They are reasonably priced, comfortable, consistent."
#86
Caribbean Beach
4.0
(2)
"Highgly recommend Caribbean Beach or AOA."
"Moderate id say CBR Coronado or French Quarter."
#87
Hedonism
4.0
(2)
"Hedonism has both a nude and a prude beach."
"Jamaica- hedonism, grande lidos."
#88
Grand Hyatt
3.5
(2)
"Would recommend the Grand Hyatt for easier access to Vail."
"Honestly, I would not stay on the big island for your honeymoon. I would look at the grand hyatt on Maui or kauai instead."
#89
Cabana Bay Beach Resort
3.5
(2)
"Spent a week at Cabana Bay 3 weeks ago. Had 4 rooms, no issues bed bugs it otherwise."
"We stayed a week at Cabana Bay earlier this year and we were shocked at all the good reviews."
#90
Vidanta
3.0
(2)
"Personally speaking, Nuevo Vallarta is a solid location."
"Don’t go to Vidanta. There are wayyy better options."
#91
Casa Dorada
3.0
(2)
"I would choose Casa Dorada and no AI. Too many great restaurants nearby."
"Casa Dorada. Do not go to Hotel Riu."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
