Steakhouses reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 287 Reddit reviews across 17 subreddits and 19 posts to rank the best Steakhouses brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/fortwayne, r/denverfood, r/FoodNYC, r/longisland, r/chicagofood. Top-rated brands include Ruth's Chris Steak House (3.8/5), Peter Luger (4.3/5), Guard and Grace (4.9/5).
Stats
Reviews287
Subreddits17
Posts19
Brands97
Products17
287 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Ruth's Chris Steak House
3.8
(12)
"Ruth’s recommended"
"Ruth’s recommended"
"Black Canyon and Club Soda do not have better steaks than Ruth’s.."
"3. Ruths chris."
"Desquis, Ruth’s Chris and proximo does a fantastic rib eye with chimmichuri."
"Copper Spoon, Black Canyon, Ruth’s Chris"
"My favorite are cork n cleaver and Ruth Chris"
"Personal Opinion: Ruth’s Chris, Proximo, and Club Soda!"
"Ruth’s Chris, Hideout 125 and a tie for Copper Spoon & Catablu.."
"Ruth’s crest"
#2
Peter Luger
4.3
(9)
"Always was Peter Lugers. Still is. For the experience"
"Damnit, Peter Luger's"
"Honestly. Peter Luger still has the best steak in the city."
"Peter Lugers! Downtown Brooklyn. 178 Broadway. Been an institution since 1887."
"My favorite is the ribeyes at both strip house and Peter Lugers."
"Smith and Wollenskys or if u can get in, Lugers"
"I've had rib steaks at both Luger's and Gallagher's that were pretty good."
"Luger's is literally the best example because it's still considered one of the top places in nyc"
"Lugers is honestly the worst example you could have picked."
#3
Guard and Grace
4.9
(8)
"Guard and grace. It’s gonna run you about $300 but it’s worth it."
"Guard and Grace. You can get the gnocchi and the mushroom apps. Throw them together in one bowl and your vegetarian self will be more than happy."
"Guard and Grace is the top steakhouse in Denver."
"Guard and Grace"
"Some of my clients prefer Guard & Grace."
"I’d rather pay for guard and grace once a year and cook at home the other times than look for value steakhouses."
"Guard and Grace oak fires everything."
"Guard and Grace is good… I need to go again bc I went with a flight of different steaks and it was just ok."
#4
Cork N Cleaver
3.9
(9)
"Cork N Cleaver recommended"
"Cork N Cleaver recommended"
"Eddie Merlot, Cork n Cleaver, Chops"
"2. Cork n cleaver"
"Cork n cleaver, club soda, black canyon. For everyone saying Ruth Chris… these other places are like half the price and definitely a better steak."
"Cork !!!!!!"
"Cork n Cleaver"
"My favorite are cork n cleaver and Ruth Chris"
"We didn’t like it as much as we like Cork n Cleaver."
#5
Baker Street
3.8
(8)
"I like Baker Street."
"Baker Street"
"3. Baker Street"
"Copper Spoon, Baker Street, Chops."
"Baker Street."
"Baker street"
"Baker Street recommended but less favored"
"Baker Street recommended but less favored"
#6
Keens
3.0
(9)
"Keens made for a great birthday experience last time I was there."
"Keens is regularly recommended in answer to similar questions"
"My last visit was as magical as it always was."
"I wasn't impressed, although their prime rib was absolutely decent."
"Keens or Gallagher’s"
"Keens"
"Keens"
"Keens . New owners likely to destroy it"
"Don’t go to Keens, I went recently and hated it"
#7
A5
5.0
(5)
"A5 can't be touched in the Denver Metro right now its the best of the best"
"A5. Get her the Bavette, it's a tasty cut. Chef Max style for extra flair. Their appetizers and drinks are also awesome."
"Capital Grille, A5, Jacks on Pearl, Steakhouse 10"
"I recently tried A5 and really enjoyed it! The sides were also killer (get the mac n cheese croquettes!)"
"Some of my clients prefer A5."
#8
Vintage
5.0
(5)
"Vintage is great"
"MY #1 is Vintage (St James) ..reservations a must."
"Vintage is the right answer"
"Vintage"
"Vintage"
#9
Smith & Wollensky
3.8
(6)
"Smith & Wollensky"
"Smith & Wollensky is my favorite overall dining experience at a steakhouse"
"Smith and Wollenskys or if u can get in, Lugers"
"Smith & Wollensky"
"I've also enjoyed dry aged steaks at Red and Smith & Wollensky's."
"Smiths"
#10
Fogo de Chao
4.6
(5)
"Fogo de chao has their 39 dollar special. Enough meat for her and a great salad and hot bar for you!"
"Fogo de Chao would be perfect for a celebration and has a huge variety of stuff to try which is a more fun vibe I think."
"A pro-tip is to go to Fogo de Chão for their gaucho lunch. It's all you can eat and has plenty of options for veggie and non. All under $20 each."
"Fogo De Chao is a fun experience if you have never been."
"If you don't mind the drive, Fogo de Chao in Portland."
#11
801 Chophouse
4.6
(5)
"It’s 801 Chop or Steakhouse 10 for me."
"801 is just that old school steak house vibe, dark, woody, leather, big Peruvian, classic. Elegant."
"I think 801 Chophouse doesn’t get enough love for how good it is."
"801 chophouse is also good."
"We’ve been to 801, STK, Fogo de chao, Ruth’s Chris, but in terms of the entire experience with food, the cap grille is mine and hers favorite!"
#12
Joseph Decuis
4.4
(5)
"Jospeh ducuis has the best steaks"
"Joseph Decuis in Roanoke. Worth every penny."
"Joseph Decuis"
"Desquis, Ruth’s Chris and proximo does a fantastic rib eye with chimmichuri."
"Joseph Decuis in Roanoke is really good but not technically in Fort Wayne."
#13
Barry's
4.2
(5)
"Barry's at Circa. Try the rib eye cap."
"Barry’s is delicious! We have reservations at Hugo’s this weekend and I can’t wait!"
"Barry's!"
"Also worth it--Barry's at Circa."
"Barry's"
#14
Shanahan's
4.5
(4)
"The single best steak Ive ever had in my life was at shanahan’s, and our service was excellent."
"Everything is good at Shanihans. It’s more traditional than hip. Ambiance and service are fantastic."
"Shanahan's has been hot or miss tor me but mostly hit."
"Shanahans in the Tech Center is pretty solid too."
#15
The Capital Grille
4.3
(4)
"I really love the capital grille, took my lady for her bday this year and she loved."
"The Capital Grille at South Coat Plaza"
"Capital Grille, A5, Jacks on Pearl, Steakhouse 10"
"Capitol Grille is excellent too."
#16
Bowery Meat Company
4.3
(4)
"Their dry aged burger patties are truly incredible and have produced some of the best burgers I’ve ever cooked at home."
"Bowery Meat Company is always one of my faves."
"Bowery Meat Company has a 100 day I believe"
"Look at Bowery Meat Co. They have 100 day aged and some specials usually"
#17
Tellers
4.3
(4)
"Tellers hands down"
"Ask for their Pittsburgh filet mignon. Delicious."
"Tellers is great"
"George Martin Strip Steak and Tellers."
#18
Strip House
4.0
(4)
"I've found strip house and wolfgangs to be pretty consistent and reliable"
"Benjamins Steakhouse, Strip House, and Carne Mare."
"My favorite is the ribeyes at both strip house and Peter Lugers."
"I’m a fan of the dry aged at Strip House"
#19
Fogo de Chão
4.0
(4)
"Las Tablas or Fogo are your best bets."
"Not a traditional steakhouse, but I would say Fogo De Chao."
"Costco sells Fogo de Chao cards at $75 for $100 worth of food and drink."
"Fodo had more side options and was more expensive, but both were delicious."
#20
Copper Spoon
4.0
(4)
"Hideout, copper spoon, and catablu are fantastic. some of the best we have"
"Copper Spoon, Baker Street, Chops."
"Copper Spoon, Black Canyon, Ruth’s Chris"
"Ruth’s Chris, Hideout 125 and a tie for Copper Spoon & Catablu.."
#21
George Martin
4.0
(4)
"George Martin Strip or King's would be the answer to your inquiry."
"George Martin in Great River"
"George Martins Strip Steak"
"George Martin Strip Steak and Tellers."
#22
Perry's
5.0
(3)
"Perry’s is sooo good. They also have the Friday pork chop special which is heavenly"
"Can confirm Perry's is delightful."
"Perry’s in Coral Gables is a gem."
#23
Vic & Anthony's
5.0
(3)
"+1 for Vic and Anthony’s."
"Vic & Anthony’s. You may see mafia eat there."
"Vic and Anthony’s, Barry’s, Oscar’s Steakhouse, Hugo’s Cellar."
#24
Ocean Prime
5.0
(3)
"I do recommend Ocean Prime because they are higher quality AND they have some spectacular veg dishes"
"Ocean Prime is a good option for everyone to get an actual meal that includes a great steak. Shanahan’s is good, too."
"Piemontes steak at Ocean Prime is the best in Denver."
#25
Brazilian Grill
5.0
(3)
"Brazilian Grill is amazing!!"
"Brazilian Grill in Hyannis is top tier!! Love it there"
"Brazilian Grill in Hyannis is one of the best ones around."
#26
DaVinci
4.7
(3)
"The pork shank osso bucco at DaVinci is one of the best things I've ever eaten as well. Never had a meal there that didn't impress."
"I had one of the best steaks of my life here a couple years ago. It was a truly delicious birthday meal."
"In order of expense- Davincis, Cozy, Rudy’s, Best Little, West Side Station"
#27
New York Prime
4.7
(3)
"New York Prime, hands down"
"NY Prime is the only real answer"
"NY Prime, Thoroughbreds, Bistro 90, The Library."
#28
Folklore
4.7
(3)
"Folklore is legit."
"Came here to say this. Or their sister restaurant folklore!"
"At least for Folklore I was able to get out of there for $150 for a bottle of wine, two apps, 1 steak split, and two sides and it was plenty for two."
#29
LongHorn Steakhouse
3.3
(4)
"You really can’t beat their prices and the food is pretty good."
"Best Steaks in FW, in this order: Longhorn"
"Long horn"
"Longhorn steak house"
#30
Outback Steakhouse
4.3
(3)
"Outback and it’s not close"
"THE Outback Steakhouse."
"Best Steaks in FW, in this order: Outback"
#31
Carne Mare
4.3
(3)
"Carne Mare was excellent."
"You may enjoy the Gorgonzola cured aged steak at Carne Mare"
"Benjamins Steakhouse, Strip House, and Carne Mare."
#32
Golden Steer
4.3
(3)
"You take the lady to the Golden Steer in Forest Park. The food is great. Classic old Chicago."
"Not in DT, but you can’t go wrong with the golden steer."
"Take an Uber to Golden Steer"
#33
Pace's
4.3
(3)
"This is the answer. Blows away Tellers, 5 mins away."
"Paces in Hauppague is my wife and I’s go to"
"Pace’s"
#34
Morton's
4.3
(3)
"Morton’s in the gables in the best."
"Been to Morton’s. I’m a fan of"
"Morton’s is always good."
#35
St Anselm
4.3
(3)
"I pick up steaks from there regularly on the way home, cooked or raw just depending how early it is. Zero ambience, incredible steaks"
"St Anselm in Williamsburg"
"Also for recently priced steaks in general, I highly recommend St Anselm."
#36
Texas Roadhouse
4.3
(3)
"I’ve never ever order steak out before, until he had me try theirs. Wasn’t even a fan of steak until Texas Roadhouse."
"We usually go to Texas Roadhouse. It's a good bang for the buck."
"Honestly, Texas Roadhouse"
#37
Minetta Tavern
4.3
(3)
"Minetta Tavern. Excellent long aged steaks."
"Black label burger at Minetta Tavern uses Pat LaFrieda beef"
"The Côte De Boeuf at Minetta Tavern gets 60 days."
#38
Wolfgang's
4.3
(3)
"Wolfgangs has some of the best steaks."
"Up there; Wolfgangs ( exact same formula)"
"I've found strip house and wolfgangs to be pretty consistent and reliable"
#39
Insignia
4.0
(3)
"Insignia in Smithtown is top notch. Everything I had I've enjoyed."
"Insignia or Prime"
"Insignia"
#40
Cut
4.0
(3)
"Cut is great, but can get rather pricey."
"Cut is a reasonable place for steak but the better ones just went the extra mile in terms of service/atmosphere/experience."
"Cut recommended"
#41
Hideout 125
4.0
(3)
"Hideout 125 has great steaks"
"Hideout, copper spoon, and catablu are fantastic. some of the best we have"
"Ruth’s Chris, Hideout 125 and a tie for Copper Spoon & Catablu.."
#42
Eddie Merlot's
4.0
(3)
"Eddie merlots"
"Eddie Merlot, Cork n Cleaver, Chops"
"1. Eddie merlots"
#43
CataBlu
4.0
(3)
"Catablu recommended"
"Hideout, copper spoon, and catablu are fantastic. some of the best we have"
"Ruth’s Chris, Hideout 125 and a tie for Copper Spoon & Catablu.."
#44
Del Frisco's
4.0
(3)
"I’m not a red meat eater and I love Del Frisco’s sides - like the vibe, too."
"Of the chain steakhouses I’ve always had great Bone-in Ribeyes at Old Hickory and at Del Frisco’s."
"Del Frisco’s in DTC"
#45
Benjamin Steakhouse
4.0
(3)
"Benjamin steakhouse or Cote"
"Benjamin steakhouse is good but their longest aged steak is their tomahawk which is dry aged for I think 39 days?"
"Benjamins Steakhouse, Strip House, and Carne Mare."
#46
Delmonico's
4.0
(3)
"Followed by Delmonico’s."
"Delmonico's - either the Dry Aged Bone in Ribeye or the Delmonico"
"For a ribeye I would hit up Delmonicos"
#47
Gallagher's
3.7
(3)
"Keens or Gallagher’s"
"I've had rib steaks at both Luger's and Gallagher's that were pretty good."
"Gallagher's"
#48
Texas de Brazil
3.3
(3)
"If she’s a carnivore she might enjoy the variety of a Brazilian Steakhouse like Texas de Brazil or Fogo de Chao"
"Their “salad” bar was phenomenal. They have an option to just do the salad bar which I recommend."
"Texas de Brazil is a chain and felt like it to me."
#49
Chop
3.3
(3)
"Chop is always my go to"
"Chop is more affordable but still decent."
"Chop is a reasonable place for steak but the better ones just went the extra mile in terms of service/atmosphere/experience."
#50
Carne
5.0
(2)
"If she’s not tied to a traditional steakhouse, I recommend Carne. It’s a younger vibe than most steakhouses and will be a hit with carnivores."
"Right now it seems like Carne is the hot ticket in town."
#51
Tortoise Club
5.0
(2)
"We love going to Tortoise Club for a nicer meal on a cheaper budget. It’s fantastic value for the food and service."
"The steak frites is phenomenal for the price, the crepes are delish, and you can’t beat the atmosphere."
#52
Wildfire
5.0
(2)
"Wildfire never disappoints."
"Wildfire."
#53
Labaredas
5.0
(2)
"Labaredas is head and shoulders above the others."
"Labaredas in Marlboro is amazing"
#54
Rey
5.0
(2)
"Rey's is the only place we've been to multiple times, usually at her request. Never fails to impress."
"I love Rey’s especially the table side banana foster."
#55
Jack's on Pearl
5.0
(2)
"Jacks on Pearl…. Unbelievable steaks and service!"
"Capital Grille, A5, Jacks on Pearl, Steakhouse 10"
#56
Fleming's
5.0
(2)
"Never hit Fleming's here, but on multiple business trips to D.C, I never fail to stop in for a perfect business dinner."
"Fleming's makes one of the best steaks I've ever eaten."
#57
Steakhouse 10
5.0
(2)
"Capital Grille, A5, Jacks on Pearl, Steakhouse 10"
"Steakhouse 10. Trust me"
#58
Club Soda
3.0
(3)
"Club Soda and Hideout 125"
"Cork n cleaver, club soda, black canyon. For everyone saying Ruth Chris… these other places are like half the price and definitely a better steak."
"Personal Opinion: Ruth’s Chris, Proximo, and Club Soda!"
#59
Black Canyon
3.0
(3)
"Black Canyon"
"Cork n cleaver, club soda, black canyon. For everyone saying Ruth Chris… these other places are like half the price and definitely a better steak."
"Copper Spoon, Black Canyon, Ruth’s Chris"
#60
Peddler
4.5
(2)
"Peddler's!"
"Much better options available like Oak or Peddler."
#61
Bastien's
4.5
(2)
"Food is consistently delicious and drinks are excellent."
"Bastiens on colfax might not be ‘the best’ but it’s a fav."
#62
Bryant & Cooper
4.5
(2)
"Bryant & Cooper does some of the best dry aged steaks out there."
"Bryant and Cooper"
#63
Top of Binion's
4.5
(2)
"You need to hit up Top of Binions. Excellent services and delicious steaks."
"Also worth it--Top of Binion's"
#64
Barbarians
4.5
(2)
"J’s Steak Frites Queen, Barbarians, Black+Blue are great steak options and Jacobs at the very high end, but it’s worth it IMO."
"Barbarians is good for steak"
#65
Chops
2.7
(3)
"Eddie Merlot, Cork n Cleaver, Chops"
"Copper Spoon, Baker Street, Chops."
"Chops use to be great, last couple times we went it was absolutely awful so we quit going there."
#66
Oscar's
4.0
(2)
"Oscar’s at the Plaza a close second."
"Oscar's at the Plaza is second."
#67
DeStefano's
4.0
(2)
"DeStefanos is Williamsburg is SO slept on"
"DeStefano’s"
#68
Las Tablas
4.0
(2)
"Las Tablas or Fogo are your best bets."
"Las Tablas, great spot."
#69
Proximo
4.0
(2)
"Desquis, Ruth’s Chris and proximo does a fantastic rib eye with chimmichuri."
"Personal Opinion: Ruth’s Chris, Proximo, and Club Soda!"
#70
Wolfgang's Steakhouse
4.0
(2)
"Wolfgang’s recommended"
"Tokyo has Wolfgang’s Steakhouse, Peter Luger, Ruth Chris’s, Morton’s, for example, if you’re looking for the American steakhouse experience."
#71
Hugo's Cellar
4.0
(2)
"Hugo's Cellar at the Four Queens is my favorite."
"Hugo's Cellar at the Four Queens."
#72
Eataly
4.0
(2)
"You might also look at butchers like for instance Eataly where they have dry aged ribeyes 2 inches thick you can cook in a cast iron skillet and it’s fantastic"
"You might also look at butchers like for instance Eataly where they have dry aged ribeyes 2 inches thick you can cook in a cast iron skillet and it’s fantastic"
#73
Frank's
4.0
(2)
"I like Franks in Pawleys or Aspen Grille."
"Franks and franks outback Pawleys Island."
#74
Auburn City Steakhouse
4.0
(2)
"Auburn City Steakhouse"
"Auburn City Steakhouse"
#75
Triple George Grill
4.0
(2)
"Triple George Grill."
"Triple George Grill at Downtown Grand isn't a steakhouse per se, but it's also excellent."
#76
Logan's Roadhouse
3.5
(2)
"1. Logan’s"
"There's a Logan's Roadhouse and Longhorn Steakhouse in that area."
#77
Barrington Steakhouse
3.5
(2)
"Barrington Steakhouse is a reasonable place for steak but the better ones just went the extra mile in terms of service/atmosphere/experience."
"Barrington Steakhouse is the middle ground of the two imo"
#78
Edna
5.0
(1)
"Highly recommend the steak @ Edna, it’s one of the best steaks I’ve ever had"
#79
CUT
5.0
(1)
"I'd definitely go for the $74 14oz. Prime grade Alberta Angus ribeye from CUT over the $69 14 oz. Ribeye from Barrington."
#80
Sip
5.0
(1)
"The best steak in the HRM, in my opinion, is the aged rib eye at Sip in Dartmouth. Almost life changing steak."
#81
Dana's on The Landing
5.0
(1)
"The cote de boeuf at Dana’s on The Landing is one the best steaks I’ve ever had."
#82
Comeketo
5.0
(1)
"Comeketo in Leominster is lights out"
#83
Anthony's
5.0
(1)
"Anthony’s at the M Resort. 99/100."
#84
Gauchos Churrascaria Brazilian Steakhouse & Butchery
5.0
(1)
"Would love to go back as it was absolutely amazing."
#85
Vinland Winery
5.0
(1)
"Vinland Winery's ribeye is excellent"
#86
Tolon
5.0
(1)
"Tolon has a exquisite ribeye"
#87
Spinoli's
5.0
(1)
"Their spinolis (ribeye cap) is one of the best steaks I’ve ever had"
#88
Artango
4.0
(1)
"Artango was very reasonable imo."
#89
Brazilian Steakhouse
4.0
(1)
"Do a Brazilian steakhouse."
#90
A+ Steakhouse
4.0
(1)
"There's a new steakhouse in Edison Park. A+ Steakhouse I hear good things and I think way more affordable than the big guys."
#91
Tango Sur
4.0
(1)
"Tango Sur is your best bet. Incredibly good and affordable"
#92
Mirabella
4.0
(1)
"Mirabella! Old school Italian steak house. Best bang for the buck in Chicago"
#93
Chance Bar
4.0
(1)
"Try a truly local and chef owned/ran place like tolon, rune, or chance bar and hope they’re running a steak"
#94
Rune
4.0
(1)
"Try a truly local and chef owned/ran place like tolon, rune, or chance bar and hope they’re running a steak"
#95
L Woods
4.0
(1)
"LWoods’ filet is wonderful and all of their steaks come with a potato choice."
#96
Dana's
4.0
(1)
"Dana’s duh"
#97
Steak 'n Shake
3.0
(1)
"Steak n shake Maysville road"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
