Toilet Paper reviews from Reddit

Summary

We analyzed 314 Reddit reviews across 22 subreddits and 31 posts to rank the best Toilet Paper brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/hygiene, r/Costco, r/Frugal, r/Healthyhooha, r/CostcoCanada. Top-rated brands include Charmin (4.3/5), Scott (4.1/5), Kirkland (3.6/5).

Stats

Reviews314

Subreddits22

Posts31

Brands69

Products47

Top communities

r/hygiene59 r/Costco55 r/Frugal26 r/Healthyhooha25 r/CostcoCanada18

314 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

Charmin

4.3

(60)

"Charmin ultra strong. It’s all I buy, I’ve never used a TP out in public or at friends houses that I liked more."

"Definitely charmin ultra strong. I refuse to use any other tissue. No coochie confetti!!!!!"

"Charmin hands down"

"Charmin Ultra Strong. Not Basic and not Ultra Soft. You want the one in the red packaging."

"Charmin. It’s the best."

"Charmin ultra strong or gtfo! 😤"

"Pretty sure that’s Charmin Ultra Strong. That’s all we use in this house."

"House in septic tank & RV."

"Have been using it for years and never had a problem."

"Charmin Ultra *Soft* is the best option."

Scott

4.1

(46)

"I switched to Scott 1 ply years ago and haven’t looked back since."

"I tried Scott one-ply. and oh my god. I’ve never looked back."

"Bidet. Follow with original Scott TP in the paper wrapper."

"Agreed I can’t stand thick soft fluffy TP. Original Scott in the paper wrapper for me!"

"Looks slightly different, but reminds me of a Scott roll. Best toilet paper imo."

"It’s Scott, it’s all I buy."

"Scott is the best. The single ply."

"Only buy Scott single-ply to prevent problems."

"12 pack at Walmart is the cheapest way we’ve found to buy it."

"Scott brand."

Kirkland

3.6

(50)

"I wouldn’t give up my Kirkland brand toilet paper for anything."

"Never had a problem."

"Septic safe."

"Surprisingly costco Kirkland brand toilet paper is amazing"

"Costcos Kirkland brand is usually highly recommended."

"I use the KS TP and have never had a problem with it."

"Kirkland if you’re a Costco member."

"Definitely Kirkland from Costco. Lasts ages in bulk and decent quality good size rolls."

"Kirkland if you have costco."

"I use a bidet and Kirkland brand toilet paper from Costco, just the regular stuff not the ultra soft. Never had a problem with bits left behind."

Cottonelle

4.3

(22)

"Cottonelle Ultra Clean, Quilted Northern Ultra Plush. Nothing's better."

"I got a sample roll of Cottonelle TP with my Sunday paper delivery way back in 1998, and I've been buying it almost exclusively since then."

"I adore cottonelle"

"We use Cottonelle Ultra Clean without any black tank issues."

"Cottonelle comfort care for pat dry."

"I second cottenelle."

"I love cottenelle brand.. the purple one over the blue.. but both are fine."

"Cottonelle ultra clean has never failed me, i went on a quest when i was 18 to find a flake free paper and this is my go to!"

"DUDE WIPES OR COTTONELLE (all are flushable ) leaves me feeling very clean"

"Cottonelle"

Angel Soft

3.9

(17)

"Period. End of story."

"It virtually disintegrated in less than 5 minutes."

"Believe it or not it’s Angel Soft. I would only use Cottonelle for years until the pandemic. I found that I prefer Angel Soft."

"Angel Soft is my choice."

"I stick with angel soft mega rolls."

"Angel Soft mega rolls. I used to loathe Angel Soft but it's gotten much better."

"Or cottonelle. Just use plenty plenty plenty of water."

"Says septic safe on it. Worked fine so far."

"Angel Soft. I haven’t been able to afford it in ages. I miss it."

"I like Angel soft. It’s durable and not “linty.”"

Quilted Northern

4.6

(9)

"My all time favorite TP to wipe Quilted Northern. Since your Bum Bum will be already washed just a few swiped of that quilted goodness to dry and you are all set."

"Cottonelle Ultra Clean, Quilted Northern Ultra Plush. Nothing's better."

"Quilted northern is the top of the line."

"I really like Quilted Northern- it's like the purple package on the outside."

"Quilted Northern is the best I’ve found."

"Quilted Northern soft and strong. you may have to pay a little more"

"Quilted Northern!"

"Quilted Northern. Ultra plush? You're callin' my name."

"Quilted Northern. Don't even try."

Who Gives a Crap

4.5

(8)

"Who Gives A Crap, the premium bamboo version."

"Who Gives a Crap toilet paper is the best!"

"It's been nicer to me than anything I’ve gotten off the shelf, and is cheaper, too."

"Litterally, thats the paper we use."

"I really like the Who Gives A Crap premium TP."

"Please consider TP made from 100% post consumer cellulose."

"Good quality, not rough on the hole, kind to the environment."

"Litterally, thats the paper we use."

Charmin Ultra Strong

4.2

(6)

"Charmin Ultra Strong. Only requires 2 squares per pass."

"Charmin ultra strong is our go-to."

"Charmin ultra strong. It’s soft and doesn’t leave little bits behind."

"I use the charm in ultra strong or the sam’s club brand in the purple wrapper!"

"I use Charmin Ultra Strong."

"Charmin ultra strong. It used to be the Kirkland one, but they changed it over covid and it's terrible now."

Bamboo Toilet Paper

4.8

(5)

"I would go with bamboo toilet paper if I were you."

"My wife really loves Fanny bamboo toilet paper."

"I got some bamboo toilet paper, and boom. Within a week, all the symptoms were gone."

"The bamboo TP breaks down easily and is septic tank friendly."

"I buy bamboo TP on line. It’s great but pricey."

#10

Marathon

4.6

(5)

"Marathon if your store sells it."

"I buy marathon now, it's amazing"

"Marathon and Kirkland"

"We use the Marathon because it fits on our holders."

"I’m on a septic so I gotta go with Marathon… because it’s pretty much the only choice."

#11

Sam's Club

4.2

(5)

"My mom just got me the big ass thing of toilet paper from sam’s club."

"Sam's club."

"Sam’s club off brand."

"Sam's club brand is the only way to go."

"Sam’s club for TP and Costco for paper towels."

#12

Costco

4.0

(5)

"I genuinely believe Costco is the best deal . It’s $26 and for a family of two it lasts way longer than I can remember"

"Honestly I get Costco brand for all the paper products."

"Costco toilet paper, paper towels and dish and laundry detergents."

"Costco has good quality for cheap"

"Costco brand tp with the ribbed pattern shreds on my binger...charmin blue from costco does not."

#13

Aldi

4.3

(4)

"The Aldi Confidence double length or Coles SoSoft double length for the win."

"I really like their Willow brand."

"The Aldi one. I buy the double rolls, they last ages and are kind to your bits."

"I think Aldis brand is made by Quilton, just not their price."

#14

Great Value

4.0

(4)

"Toilet paper Great Value brand at Walmart per consumer report magazine."

"Great Value Ultra Strong (same as Charmin Ultra Strong) for the adults."

"I was completely surprised that Walmart Great Value breaks down as well as Scott but feels like Charmin."

"I like the great value, strong, from wal mart."

#15

Reel

4.7

(3)

"There's a brand I get from target called Reel. I am an aggressive dryer of my skin in every way so this has been amazing for me."

"Reel bamboo TP"

"I use Reel."

#16

Quilton

4.3

(3)

"Quilton or the Cole’s soft so double length one."

"Quilton loves your bum."

"My go to is usually their 3 ply double length rolls."

#17

Purex

4.3

4.0

(1)

"It is 100% recycled, at least 50% PCR."

#51

3.0

(1)

"I usually stick with Page, especially the 4-pack with the blue dog on it."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started