Trail Bike reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 294 Reddit reviews across 12 subreddits and 71 posts to rank the best Trail Bike brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/MTB, r/mountainbiking, r/Dirtbikes, r/Hardtailgang, r/enduro. Top-rated brands include Specialized (4.5/5), Trek (4.3/5), Ibis (4.6/5).
Stats
Reviews294
Subreddits12
Posts71
Brands41
Products85
294 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Specialized
4.5
(29)
"For trails bikes can’t go wrong with the Specialized Stumpjumper."
"Specialized stumpjumper Evo."
"The highest level Stumpjumper you can get for the price."
"Stumpjumper by far!"
"I absolutely love my Specialized Status 160 mullet. It rips on the downhill."
"I just got a brand new Stumpjumper Evo Comp Carbon for $2550."
"The in frame storage is great for the longer rides."
"10/10 I’d buy another tomorrow."
"It’s a wicked fuckin bike. Favorite bike I’ve ever owned by far"
"I love the stumpjumper."
#2
Trek
4.3
(30)
"I got one a few weeks ago and it rips!"
"Super playful, yet planted."
"My riding buddy who is also very tall has a fuel ex gen 6 and loves it."
"Trek fuel ex8"
"I live in Texas and ride a Trek Roscoe 7."
"I love my trek Roscoe 8. It feels like the perfect hardtail."
"Trek Roscoe 7 shreds!"
"Can't not mention the Trek Fuel EX in a post asking about trail bikes."
"The Trek will do you well and is a solid, reliable rig."
"I love my fuel ex 8. Great trail bike."
#3
Ibis
4.6
(26)
"Ibis Ripmo AF is on sale right now. I would go with the SLX build."
"For trails bikes can’t go wrong with the new Ibis Ripley."
"I can't speak highly enough about it. Changed the sport for me."
"Just got a ripley AF. I fuckin love it and it rips."
"I love my Ripmo AF"
"Ripmo"
"I love my Ripmo AF. Although, I had to put a Cascade Link on the rear, and a 170mm fork out front."
"The answer is Ibis. Either a Ripmo Af or Ripley Af."
"Don't even need to look at others."
"My ripmo is honestly the perfect bike for out here."
#4
Marin
4.3
(20)
"My Marin rift zone 2 was WELL under 3k and it’s been the best bike I’ve ever owned."
"Marin rift zone xr best all around bike ive ever had."
"Marin Rift Zone XR under $2700."
"Marin Alpine Trail. Got mine for $1500 but there's still some for $2000-2500."
"Went the Rift zone XR. Great reviews all round and good components for the price."
"Marin alpine trail, the older model was really playful"
"I own an alpine trail and its incredibly playful"
"This. And the Rift Zone for FS. A lot of the trials oriented riders on social media are with the Marin brand."
"I’ve been eyeing the 27.5 versions of the Marin San Quentin."
"I’d say that either of these two would be solid pics for your budget: Marin rift zone 2"
#5
Giant
4.2
(17)
"Giant fathom 2 is just under your price range, would probably weigh around 27 lb before any upgrades and is a great trail bike."
"Giant Trance X 29 1. They also have an even better 275er version if you like to play on the trails."
"I love it because of the Shimano Alevio 3X8 drive train."
"I switched to a Giant Trance and now I can go on much longer rides."
"Giant trance."
"You can get a brand new Giant Trance or Trance x with SLX for $2700."
"Giant Trance have always been good value for beginners."
"I'd personally go Trance X."
"Medyo limited ka sa Trek Marlin, GT Avalanche/Aggressor, Giant Talon, Polygon Premier."
"Giant Stance 1 is the bike I bought 2 years ago at 2200 and I love it."
#6
Santa Cruz
4.7
(15)
"Bought a SC Bronson MX, put on riser bars, couldn’t be happier."
"My main bike is a Tallboy. It's a blast on all sorts of trails."
"Just got an S build Bronson for 4.2k"
"I got a Hightower S spec (gx, fox performance) for less than 4k otd."
"Hightower!"
"Hightower is a sick bike."
"It’s awesome."
"Hightower."
"Trek remedy, scott genius, giant trance X, forbidden druid, evil offering, yeti sb130, Santa Cruz Bronson."
"Absolutely LOVE my 5010."
#7
YT
4.5
(15)
"I’m about your height and I got a YT Izzo xxl and it does what they say it does. Loving it"
"YT Jeffsy no question."
"Managed to snag a yt Jeffsey core two."
"YT Jeffsy. Great climber."
"If we are talking best value for the money, it’s probably going to be the YT Jeffsy core 1 right now."
"The YT Izzo core 2 is on sale in their outlet store for 1700."
"YT Jeffsy. It has served me well."
"I love the bike and will serve you well imo"
"There’s a XXL Izzo core 2 on YT’s outlet page with OUTLET10 coupon code you can get it for ~2250$."
"I picked up my YT Jeffsy core 3 for $2600 from the outlet section of their website."
#8
Canyon
4.5
(15)
"I just bought a Canyon Spectral 29 CF 7 for $2700."
"Just picked up a Canyon Spectral 29 CF. Such a sick bike, and it was $1000 off."
"I have a Spectral 29 CF7, and my wife has the Neuron 6. Both bikes are spectacular deals."
"I have a Spectral 29 CF7, and my wife has the Neuron 6. Both bikes are spectacular deals."
"It's an amazing bike for $1800!"
"My wife has that bike! She loves it."
"I ride a Spectral 7 and LOVE it."
"I went from a Giant Talon 2, to a Specialized Fuse Comp, to my current Canyon Neuron 9."
"I got myself a Canyon Neuron 6 (AL) which was great for a start for the easier trails."
"What about a Canyon Spectral for $2099 currently?"
#9
Norco
4.3
(15)
"Mostly Norco Optic but definitely Santa Cruz 5010."
"I have an Alu Norco sight and I love it."
"Norco fluid line is probably the best in this range for all mountain, trail, etc."
"Norco Optic. Excellent bike for what you're describing"
"Put the Norco optic on your list to check out."
"I have a quiver killer bike that can do it all (Norco Optic)"
"I’d say that either of these two would be solid pics for your budget: Norco Sight"
"Been seeing some great Stumpy closeout deals or grab one of last year's Norco Optics."
"Got a Norco sight A2 2023 shimano for 2600 recently."
"Jenson has some Norco Optics with SRAM C2 build kits for $3000."
#10
Yamaha
4.5
(13)
"Love my ttr 230 good bike had it for about 5 years an no problems"
"YZ250FX if you want something your skillset will never outgrow."
"Amazing bike. Flameout is a non issue."
"Plenty of power when you want it and great suspension"
"Plenty of power when you want it and great suspension"
"Get a wr250f, all the power and reliability of the yz250f with the added bonus of electric start and lights."
"Yamaha TTR 230 or a CRF250F. Both sit a little lower which will help with confidence. They’re easy to maintain, good for putting around and trail riding."
"We have both a YZ250FX and a CRF250F. The CRF is softer and more forgiving (also lower) while the YZF has a much higher performance ceiling."
"XR200/TTR230 or a RT180. Everyone goes right to YZ CR KX...Those are race bikes. For a NOOB you want fun cheap reliable."
"TTR230 if you want casual, easy and slow."
#11
Honda
4.3
(13)
"I am absolutely loving my CRF250f. It's just unstoppable!!!"
"Crf250f is an excellent choice for your criteria."
"100% Honda crf 230. Very cheap, absolutely bullet proof, easy to work on."
"100% Honda crf 230. Very cheap, absolutely bullet proof, easy to work on."
"Yamaha TTR 230 or a CRF250F. Both sit a little lower which will help with confidence."
"I would go CRF250F, and I just bought one for my wife."
"Cr500"
"We have both a YZ250FX and a CRF250F. The CRF is softer and more forgiving (also lower)"
"I like my Honda CRF250F for trail riding."
"A CR500 is an excellent bike"
#12
Polygon
4.5
(11)
"Hard to beat the Polygon Siskiu T8 from bikesonline."
"Polygon siskiu t8 or yt izzo are hard to beat."
"Grab and polygon siskiu t8. 140/135 for the larger sizes, full fox suspension."
"T8 by a mile"
"Polygon Siskui T8."
"The polygon t8 is the answer."
"Medyo limited ka sa Trek Marlin, GT Avalanche/Aggressor, Giant Talon, Polygon Premier."
"The [Polygon Siskiu T8] comes to mind."
"Seems like the best value purchase under $3k."
"Check out the Polygon Siskui models."
#13
Transition
4.6
(8)
"The absolute best bikes I've ever ridden."
"The Spur is quite possibly the BEST bike I’ve ever ridden."
"I vote Spur. Not much less capable than my Spire on anything less than absolute gnar."
"Transition spur or evil following."
"You can get onto a Transition Smuggler for 3k right now."
"You should have the Transition Smuggler on your list. Last years model is only different in color and build kit at deep discount."
"Transition"
"Have you looked at the Transition Smuggler?"
#14
Beta
4.6
(7)
"The Xtrainer is fantastic."
"Adjust power valve as needed, which will happen quickly because they’re super easy to ride."
"A beta 300 xtrainer might be a better option being that she’s more experienced."
"Beta Xtrainer. 300cc 2t but not like other 300cc 2t. Fun for all experience levels."
"Beta X Trainer was specifically designed for this use."
"A Beta XTrainer or Beta 200rr are much better suited to that."
"Beta xtrainer/KTM freeride?"
#15
Commencal
4.1
(7)
"I love my commencal meta ht."
"Meta TR."
"Commencal has Meta Tr4s on sale for $1900 right now... Little more expensive but still a decent price to me."
"Commencal meta ht."
"I love my commencal meta ht."
"Really solid park and trail bike."
"Commencal Meta TR."
#16
Intense
4.2
(5)
"Just got two intense xc 951's, fantastic, Lite & stiff."
"Intense 951 Trail - Costco"
"Look for a sale on an Intense 951 or look for a second hand 27.5 bike."
"Big fan of my Intense Primer."
"I have an Intense Primer 275 that I really like."
#17
KTM
4.0
(5)
"KTM 380"
"Ktm 500 exc or the ktm 300 xc."
"Ktm 500 exc or the ktm 300 xc."
"500 EXC."
"KTM 300's, everyone has them for a reason lol"
#18
Suzuki
4.3
(4)
"I recommend the E model in particular though. It's a little lighter since it has a plastic tank."
"I’m interested in either getting a DRZ400 or a WR250F."
"For your price point, I definitely recommend the DRZ or the WR250."
"Drz 400"
#19
Pivot Switchblade
4.7
(3)
"Switchblade is a perfect all arounder that will climb anytime your legs can handle."
"I third the Switchblade! I also ride in Texas, DFW area."
"For bikes that can roll in the more aggressive end of the trail category, they are very energetic on the pedals."
#20
Kawasaki
4.7
(3)
"KDX200 or KDX220. Cheap, extremely reliable, predictable power, comfortable, and an absolute trail weapon that can be ridden by all skill levels."
"KDX200 is perfect!"
"For that budget look for a nice kdx200 Kawasaki."
#21
Kona
4.3
(3)
"Honzo - The Hardtail Trail Bike"
"I have been happy with it."
"Kona is having a sale. Their honzo is a great entry level mtb at that price point."
#22
Rocky Mountain
4.3
(3)
"Picked me up a Rocky Mountain! Thing rips up and down."
"Saw some great deals on Rocky Mountain aluminum bikes recently."
"Rocky mountain element xs"
#23
Ibis Ripmo
5.0
(2)
"Ibis Ripmo has to be in this conversation."
"I own a ripmo and have tried the switchblade and a couple different transition bikes."
#24
Norco Optic
5.0
(2)
"Amazing bikes. Norco till the end for me"
"Norco Optic current or prior gen had 125mm with 140mm fork but had dh capabilities like a Enduro."
#25
YT Spectral
4.5
(2)
"I have the spectral cf8 and it’s amazing for everything."
"The newer spectrals are good for doing everything."
#26
Devinci
4.5
(2)
"I've ridden a 140/150 devinci troy at Northstar and it was a blast."
"Devinci Troy"
#27
Orbea
4.0
(2)
"Ended up going with a Orbea Occam M30"
"Orbea Occam!"
#28
Evil
4.0
(2)
"I have an Evil Following, and it'll take just about anything out here."
"I rode an Evil Following for years."
#29
Scott Genius
4.0
(2)
"It took a little bit of getting used to the different modes and learning when to switch."
"Its seems like the twinlock is a game changer for people who go on a long bike mission."
#30
Vitus
4.0
(2)
"Vitus escarpe if you want a more aggressive trail bike."
"If you can get the vitus escarpe when they are back in stock, I would recommend that."
#31
Specialized Status 160
5.0
(1)
"Love mine."
#32
Specialized Stumpjumper EVO
5.0
(1)
"Man, that thing is a beast!"
#33
State
4.0
(1)
"Maybe the State 4130 Trail."
#34
GT
4.0
(1)
"Medyo limited ka sa Trek Marlin, GT Avalanche/Aggressor, Giant Talon, Polygon Premier."
#35
Surly
4.0
(1)
"Initial recommendations are the Surly Karate Monkey"
#36
Trailcraft
4.0
(1)
"Trailcraft maxwell 27.5"
#37
Orbea Occam SL
4.0
(1)
"Orbea Occam SL 140mm is a great climber."
#38
Banshee
4.0
(1)
"Banshee Spitfire. Full 26 for jibbing or 27/26 for a middle ground."
#39
Santa Cruz Hightower
4.0
(1)
"I’ll add a plug for the Hightower since pretty much no one talked about it."
#40
Yeti SB140
4.0
(1)
"I'd look into a Yeti SB140 and a Pivot Switchblade given your XC background."
#41
Husqvarna
4.0
(1)
"TBI husky te250"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
