Vegan Milk reviews from Reddit

Summary

We analyzed 202 Reddit reviews across 12 subreddits and 40 posts to rank the best Vegan Milk brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/vegan, r/veganuk, r/veganrecipes, r/Serverlife, r/veganfitness. Top-rated brands include Oatly (4.9/5), Silk (4.4/5), Oat Milk (4.4/5).

Stats

Reviews202

Subreddits12

Posts40

Brands61

Products66

Top communities

r/vegan108 r/veganuk41 r/veganrecipes18 r/Serverlife9 r/veganfitness7

202 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

Oatly

4.9

(28)

"Oatly whole & barista taste super milky to me."

"Another vote for Oatly."

"Hands down the best and closest to milk in texture and taste."

"Oatly Barista is the best by far."

"Oatly Barrista"

"The Oatly whole dark blue milk tastes the most like milk to me"

"Personally, I feel that oat milk comes closest to the real deal. Specifically Oatly and Rude Health."

"The Oatly whole dark blue milk tastes the most like milk to me."

"Oatly full fat!"

"I love full fat oatley and their corresponding batista version."

Silk

4.4

(24)

"I love Silk organic unsweetened soy milk."

"Organic Unsweetened Silk Soy Milk."

"Silk unsweetened soy is all I use all day baby."

"I use the silk brand unsweetened cashew milk. It's the best."

"Silk unsweetened soy milk, it's the green cartoon."

"Silk Extra Creamy Oatmilk is my favorite hands down."

"I tried Silk NextMilk and boy did it taste so similar to real milk."

"Oatmilk supremacy (I usually get silk or chobani)"

"Silk chocolate soy milk. I think tastes just like chocolate milk."

"[Silk Chocolate Soy] gets my vote."

Oat Milk

4.4

(14)

"I gave oat milk a try a year ago and it's better in EVERYTHING."

"Oat is my favorite."

"I've tried loads of plant milks and now use oat milk pretty much exclusively."

"I’m on team oat milk! from a completely not health standpoint, it’s just the one i like the best."

"Just had my first oat milk latte. It's the best, full stop."

"Oat milk by far, it doesn’t separate like most nut milks do with temperature variation. Also it’s very creamy"

"Oat milk or cashew milk."

"I prefer oat milk. It has the most neutral flavor for cooking."

"Oat milk. Doesn’t curdle."

"For me oat milk. Others may disagree but I find it very tasty and close to to real thing."

Ripple

4.6

(12)

"Love oat milk too, have also enjoyed using Ripple unsweetened lately."

"Ripple is the best. My non vegan husband like taste and it is creamy and high protein."

"Ripple is what got my dairy loving mom to swap to non dairy."

"I am a big fan of the Ripple pea protein milk."

"I love Ripple, 8g of protein."

"Ripple: chocolate milk (i had to double check it wasn't actual milk the first time)."

"All are deliciously thick and creamy."

"Needa get yourself some Ripple! pea milk from target."

"Ripple: sweet vanilla (nice for indulgent drinks)."

"My favorite is flax milk, but if you're looking for thick, I'd probably check out Ripple or soy milk."

Alpro

4.3

(12)

"Alpro My Cuppa by far. Perfect in tea."

"Alpro My Cuppa. All day long."

"Alpro hazelnut is amazing straight from the carton"

"Tastes almost like cow milk, it’s actually insane"

"Alpro soya for professionals is hands down the best one I've tried"

"Alpro Oatmilk Professional is used throughout the UK."

"Unroasted, unsweetened almond. The green alpro one"

"The new Alpro full fat and semi Not m!lk ones imo!"

"Is my personal fave!"

"I really like their coconut rice drink, give it a try if you like coconut."

Soy Milk

4.6

(8)

"My number one choice is soy milk. It has a creamy texture and a neutral flavor."

"You're right, soy has the most protein of any plant milk."

"If you want thicker I'd say soy milk is best, it's my personal favorite."

"Soy milk. Soy is one of the healthiest foods you can eat!"

"My top three for drinking plain are unsweetened soy milk, oat milk, and hemp milk."

"Soy milk imo is delicious."

"Soy for cooking meals and actually works really well in baking."

"I love soy milk. First, because chocolate soy milk is delicious."

Oat

5.0

(7)

"Oat milk because it’s perfect for everything."

"Barista blend oat milk will be the creamiest and most milk-like substitute."

"Oat milk has the most comparable texture, works the best in espresso drinks."

"But I think oat is your best bet for avoiding allergens and most neutral flavour."

"Oat milk tastes the best in everything, and steams well."

"Go for oat milk. In bechamel it is a great substitute."

"Oat milk from the milkman, fresh delivered 3 times a week."

Cashew Milk

4.1

(7)

"Unsweetened cashew milk is my favorite."

"You can get cashew or oat milk, it’s lot more neutral."

"I find cashew milk to have the most neutral flavor for cooking."

"Cashew milk! Almond and soy absorbs into the cereal too fast."

"I'm a big fan of cashew or almond milks."

Chobani

5.0

(4)

"I stick to my Chobani extra creamy oat milk."

"Chobani extra creamy oatmilk is my go-to for everything."

"Chobani extra creamy oat milk is by far the best."

"All are deliciously thick and creamy."

#10

Soy

5.0

(4)

"Everyone gonna say oat. WRONG. It's soy. All the way. Creamy smooth texture or if you want to froth it soy is what you need."

"Soy all the way! I mean there's really no competition."

"Soy milk is highest in protein and it also has the best flavor/consistency imo."

"Soy for protein content, oat for environmental concerns."

#11

Applewood

4.0

(5)

"I use Meatless Farms mince and Applewood cheese in the bechamel, it's our favourite meal to have and one of the best recipes I've made, pre or post vegan."

"The smoked applewood is pretty good when heated up in a toasty."

"Defo applewood or sheese for me but I will say like everyone else the first few times it’s a taste shock lol"

"The Applewood smoked is really nice too."

"Yeah none of them are cheese cheese. But as stated applewood is good."

#12

Planet Oat

5.0

(4)

"Planet Oat Extra Creamy"

"Planet oat’s extra creamy, unsweetened. i can drink a whole carton in one sitting and not even give a toot"

"Planet Oat original or extra creamy is the best oat milk I’ve ever tasted."

":)"

#13

Coconut Milk

4.3

(4)

"Personally coconut milk is my favorite."

"Coconut milk for baking, and thai/indian dishes."

"I also love using coconut milk (the canned kind) in soups of all sorts."

"I myself love the taste of Coconut milk but recently tried Soy milk and love it too."

#14

Not Milk

4.7

(3)

"The brand “Not Milk” is as close to cow milk as I’ve had."

"If you like the taste of dairy milk, I recommend Not Milk."

"Not Milk is the closest I’ve tasted to cow milk."

#15

Starbucks

4.3

(3)

"Completely neutral and it goes great with all drinks."

"I hardly ever go to Starbucks like once a month so maybe i just don’t remember the taste"

"It was pretty good. Oat milk, mocha syrup, brown sugar syrup (for cookie flavor), and mint syrup."

#16

La Fauxmagerie

4.0

(3)

"You can get La Fauxmagerie in Waitrose now, really good vegan cheese."

"Ive really enjoyed some of their cheeses."

"I'd get some ordered from La Fauxmagerie tbh"

#17

Almond Milk

3.7

4.0

(1)

"Earths Own: plain oat milk (use the most)."

#61

Koko

3.0

(1)

"Koko original coconut milk, but it's pricy!"

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started