Best best carrot cake on Reddit

145 reviews from r/Calgary, r/londonontario, r/foodies_sydney and 34 more subreddits

145 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

Carrot Cake

4.4

(8)

"They are in Linden but it was soo good I would say it's worth the drive!"

"Yum bakery. I suggest pre-ordering off the website."

"Yum Bakery do cakes to order and imo, everything they have is delicious, including their carrot cake."

"Co-op maybe- their carrot cake is top notch."

"Costco makes a solid one, and in significant sizes."

"Glamorgan is fantastic and not too pricey."

"I'm recommending Amandine bakery. They have been making cakes for years."

"The Glamorgan Bakery makes very good cakes."

VG's

5.0

(4)

"VGs does a lot of things better than Magpies and carrot cake is definitely one of them."

"Never had Magpies carrot but VGs rocks."

"Definitely VG’s!! I like Magpies, but for carrot cake specifically go to VG’s."

"VG's or magpies would be your best bets."

Nothing Bundt Cakes

5.0

(4)

"Oh and Nothing Bundt cakes is amazing."

"That's absolutely delicious."

"Is delicious."

"Carrot cake is awesome."

Whole Foods

4.5

(4)

"Is excellent!"

"The whole foods one is incredible."

"I love the carrot cake at Whole Foods."

"Has a really great carrot cake!"

La Rocco

5.0

(3)

"Pretty much anything La Rocco makes is good."

"The La Rocca carrot cake is so good."

"Just had a piece the other week and it was the best carrot cake I've ever had."

Freeport Bakery

5.0

(3)

"I grabbed a cake from Freeport!!! So good. Would recommend."

"Freeport Bakery. Cream cheese frosting is the best!"

"Is the bomb for carrot cake"

Flour and Stone

5.0

(3)

"Seconded Flour and Stone. Unbeatable!"

"Flour and stone in wooloomooloo, it always comes up top for me in taste and looks."

"Not cheap but very good."

Harbord Bakery

4.7

(3)

"Very moist, good flavor."

"Is great."

"Came to say Harbord Bakery."

V&W

4.3

(3)

"V&W f979"

"V&W or Ann & Co for me"

"I really like V&W's carrot cake 🥺"

#10

Costco

5.0

(2)

"Honestly...the Costco one is 🔥"

"Do an amazing carrot cake!"

#11

BakeryB

5.0

(2)

"The best carrot cake I had was from BakeryB/Best Bakers."

"They make the best. No other carrot cake comes close."

#12

Brighton Bar & Grill

5.0

(2)

"Brighton Bar & Grill too! The serving is enough for an entire family."

"The best carrot cake I've had is in Brighton at the Brighton bar and grill."

#13

Lilac Bakery

5.0

(2)

"I had carrot cake from Lilac Bakery for my birthday. It was really good."

"Another vote for Lilac Bakery!"

#14

Carrot Top

5.0

(2)

"Is better than Lloyd's."

"No better cakes in the city."

#15

Bakerbots

5.0

(2)

"Bakerbots is incredible."

"It always delivers."

#16

Pizza Luce

5.0

(2)

"Has the best carrot cake."

"I agree that Luce carrot cake is fantastic!"

#17

Jack Stack

5.0

(2)

"Jack Stack carrot cake and its icing are amazing."

"So good! Get the big one, not the cupcakes."

#18

Roeser's

5.0

(2)

"Is the way to go."

"OUTSTANDING."

#19

VG’s

5.0

(2)

"I third VG’s carrot cake!"

"I second this one, their carrot cake is awesome."

#20

Toboggan

5.0

(2)

"One of my favourite carrot cakes is from Toboggan on Richmond."

"Toboggan and fellini koolini as well as joe Kool’s I believe all have the same amazing carrot cake."

#21

A La Creme

5.0

(2)

"A La Creme!!!!"

"A La Creme! 💯😋"

#22

Zingerman's

5.0

(2)

"Zingerman's is my favorite."

"Came here to say zingermans I love how cream cheesey their frosting is lol."

#23

Black Walnut

5.0

(2)

"I love Black Walnut's cakes."

"I do love the Carrot Cake from Black Walnut."

#24

Amy's Bread

5.0

(2)

"Is the bomb."

"They have several locations in Manhattan."

#25

Double Musky

5.0

(2)

"Has the best carrot cake."

"When you get a chance to eat at the Double Musky, order their carrot cake. It’s outstanding."

#26

Metzgers

4.5

(2)

"Metzgers for sure!!!"

"Giant carrot cake piece, as big as your head."

#27

Wegmans

4.5

(2)

"Wegmans for the win!"

"Wegmans and Shilla bakery have pretty good ones."

#28

Ettore's

4.5

(2)

"It's perfect. Damn I love carrot cake 🤤"

"Ettore's is also very good and similar."

#29

Humble Bakery

4.5

(2)

"Humble Bakery for sure."

"I do recommend Humble. Very rich though."

#30

Publix

4.0

(2)

"Came here to say this! Publix carrot cake is solid."

"Publix has a good one."

#31

Prairie Ink

4.0

(2)

"I’ve loved Prairie Ink."

"Good: Prairie Ink."

#32

Remark, Black Walnut Bakery, La Noisette Bakery

5.0

(1)

"We have been happy with the carrot cake"

#33

IZ Bakery

5.0

(1)

"The best!!!"

#34

Gejos

5.0

(1)

"Some of the best."

#35

Texas de Brazil

5.0

(1)

"Had the best carrot cake I’ve ever tried"

#36

DOC's Cake Shop

5.0

(1)

"Fantastic too."

#37

Quack's

5.0

(1)

"Was the clear winner for us."

#38

Kings

5.0

(1)

"Kings single slice of carrot cake is the best I've had so far around NYC."

#39

G&D Steakhouse

5.0

(1)

"Has FIRE carrot cake."

#40

Trulucks

5.0

(1)

"Is so much better closer to room temperature."

#41

Murray's

5.0

(1)

"Full stop."

#42

Bek's

5.0

(1)

"Amazing food and my favorite carrot cake!"

#43

Cake World

5.0

(1)

"Makes fantastic cakes."

#44

J. Alexander's

5.0

(1)

"The best is at J Alexander's."

#45

Tony's

5.0

(1)

"Tony’s is melt in your mouth delicious. And doesn’t have raisins!!"

#46

Walton's Bakery

5.0

(1)

"So tasty and moist and the cream cheese topping is great."

#47

Ocean Prime

5.0

(1)

"Is so good."

#48

Angelo’s

5.0

(1)

"The cheesecake carrot cake at Angelo’s is pretty amazing."

#49

Atlantic Wholesalers

5.0

(1)

"Large slab of carrot cake and is F***** DELICIOUS."

#50

Canoe Market

5.0

(1)

"Hands down the best carrot cake I have had in the area is from Washago though."

#51

Wheatfields

5.0

(1)

"I’m a huge fan of Wheatfields carrot cake in Lawrence."

#52

Nanny B’s

5.0

(1)

"Nanny B’s is incredible."

#53

The Warbler

5.0

(1)

"Has a great carrot cake."

#54

Bear Tooth

5.0

(1)

"My girlfriend and I have tried almost every carrot cake in town, and we agree Bear Tooth has the best one."

#55

Sydney Cakery

5.0

(1)

"Their carrot cake is as good as it gets."

#56

Black Star Bakery

5.0

(1)

"Black Star Bakery can't do much wrong."

#57

Sigrids

5.0

(1)

"Sigrids is very very good."

#58

Fuda Italian Bakery

5.0

(1)

"Makes an amazing carrot cake."

#59

Shana’s

5.0

(1)

"Shana’s in Midland is amazing!"

#60

Sweet Mandy B's

5.0

(1)

#61

Le Torta Cake Shop

5.0

(1)

"Love their carrot and honey cake"

#62

Jaya Bakery

5.0

(1)

"Yo'll get the best carrot cake in jaya bakery, opposite police station."

#63

Cake Hut

5.0

(1)

"Cake Hut carrot cakes are too good."

#64

Love Pastel

5.0

(1)

"Brazilian style carrot cake is the best!"

#65

Miren's

5.0

(1)

"I've always loved Miren's"

#66

Virtue

5.0

(1)

"That carrot cake is incredible."

#67

Kristoffer’s

5.0

(1)

"Makes a pretty amazing carrot cake."

#68

Tracy Dempsey Originals

5.0

(1)

"Has a fabulous one."

#69

The Italian Eatery

5.0

(1)

"Has an amazing carrot cake - with no raisins."

#70

Symposium

5.0

(1)

"Has an incredible carrot cake!"

#71

Bank Cafe

5.0

(1)

"Literally called 'the best carrot cake ever'."

#72

BabyCakes

5.0

(1)

"Has a brown butter carrot cake that is to die for."

#73

South by Lowe’s

5.0

(1)

"Makes the best carrot cake I’ve had anywhere."

#74

Salma's Canteen

5.0

(1)

"Salma's Canteen's carrot cake is sensational!"

#75

Rosine's

4.0

(1)

"Is verrrrry good"

#76

Cheesecake Factory

4.0

(1)

"Has a really good carrot cake."

#77

Willies

4.0

(1)

"Carrot cake is not always available."

#78

Paris Bakery, Angelina’s

4.0

(1)

#79

Cake Artist

4.0

(1)

"IMHO Cake Artist in Champaign."

#80

Caffe Paradiso

4.0

(1)

"Is pretty good."

#81

Maui Wedding Cakes

4.0

(1)

"Makes a decent one."

#82

Scolas Bakery

4.0

(1)

#83

Nick & Jake's

4.0

(1)

"Is my fave in KC."

#85

Cody's

4.0

(1)

"Has really good carrot cake."

#86

Good Batch

4.0

(1)

"When they do its great."

#87

McAlister's

4.0

(1)

"It was really, really good."

#88

Lloyd's

4.0

(1)

"Was delicious."

#89

HEB

4.0

(1)

"I kinda love the HEB carrot cake."

#90

Little Deli

4.0

(1)

"Goes well with their Reuben."

#91

Alliance Bakery

4.0

(1)

"Looks amazing."

#92

Vendome

4.0

(1)

"(no raisins)."

#93

Bob's

4.0

(1)

"Favorite ko gd ang Choco Carrot Cake sa Bob's."

#94

AH Bakery

4.0

(1)

"The AH backery ones are pretty nice."

#95

Litton’s

4.0

(1)

"Litton’s used to have a great carrot cake."

#96

Bourke St Bakery

4.0

(1)

"Do a decent one most of the time."

#97

Homestead Bakery

4.0

(1)

"Had a delicious looking carrot cake on their Thanksgiving menu."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started