Best cookie recipe on Reddit

113 reviews from r/Cooking, r/Baking, r/VeganBaking and 4 more subreddits
113 reviews from
and
By Brand
/
By Product
#1

Sally's Baking Addiction

5.0
(13)
"They honestly taste like a delicious brownie on their own without frosting."
·
"With these, you will win. TRUST me!"
·
"Choose your favorite from Sally's Baking Addiction website. I completely trust her!"
·
"My absolute favorite cookie!"
·
"Fantastic cookie recipes."
·
"This is my favourite recipe."
·
"Her cookies are consistently excellent."
·
"You have to make these easy Florentine sandwich cookies!"
·
"I LOVE this recipe."
·
"She has a ton of great recipes."
·
#2

N/A

5.0
(8)
"I make it a day in advance so the dry ingredients really get a good deal of time to hydrate."
·
"Super easy and pretty damn delicious."
·
"In festive fluted wrappers."
·
"Find any chocolate chip cookie recipe and add a package of vanilla pudding mix into it."
·
"They are actually pretty easy."
·
"I personally suggest a nice pistachio and cranberry biscotti."
·
"I have a great recipe for the Italian rainbow cookies."
·
"Been baking these cookies for 30 years and everyone adores them."
#3

Personal Recipe

4.8
(6)
"My partner thinks they are the best almond cookies he has ever known."
·
"You need to put the cookie dough in plastic wrap in a tube shape for an hour in the fridge."
·
"Do yourself a favour and let the dough rest in the fridge overnight."
·
"Here's my no fail chocolate chip cookie recipe."
·
"Find a the best chocolate chip cookie recipe you can."
·
"I have a recipe for vegan, gluten free molasses spice cookies."
#4

Nora Cooks

5.0
(5)
"Every non-vegan who tries them are astounded."
·
"They're hearty and so satisfying!"
·
"Guys fight over the container."
·
"Her chocolate chip cookies are a regular occurrence in my house."
·
"These are quick, easy, tasty and look really pretty."
#5

America's Test Kitchen

5.0
(5)
"I always chill the dough for an hour or so before I bake them."
·
"They never make it passed 3 days at home."
·
"My top recommendation would probably be 'The Perfect Cookie'."
·
"ATK's sugar cookies are killer."
·
"If you do it right, it’ll be the most perfect chocolate chip cookie you’ve ever had."
#6

Bon Appétit

5.0
(4)
"They are so good."
·
"I’ve made the brown butter toffee chocolate chip cookies."
·
"These are my go-tos: For chocolate chip [https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/bas-best-chocolate-chip-cookies]"
·
"When I want to impress I go for his brown butter toffee cookies."
#7

Homemade

4.8
(4)
"I love cream cheese sugar cookie cutouts for Christmas."
·
"This is a link to a sugar cookie that has been my favorite for years."
·
"Shortbread cookies are the way to go."
·
"Make a shortbread but infuse the butter with rosemary beforehand."
#8

Betty Crocker

4.8
(4)
"They are always everyone's favorite."
·
"I love Betty Crocker’s Cooky Book."
·
"My go to is the Betty Crocker Best of Baking cookbook."
·
"What ab the Betty Crocker sugar cookie mix? i’m just giving out suggestions."
#9

Nestle

4.8
(4)
"That’s what my grandmother does."
·
"Buy a bag of Nestle’s Tollhouse semi-sweet Chocolate Chips."
·
"They’ll be gooey and addictive."
·
"Honestly I've just gotten the nestle toll house tub."
#10

Shortbread

4.5
(4)
"My recipe never fails: 120g flour 120g butter 60g semolina 60g sugar"
·
"Shortbread cookies ❤️ they're just butter, powdered sugar, flour, and salt."
·
"Shortbread works better than sugar cookies for cutouts"
·
"Shortbread or gingerbread, but you want to refrigerate it for at least an hour after cutting."
#11

New York Times

5.0
(3)
"They're always perfect."
·
"Here's the best chocolate chip cookie recipe that I've found."
·
"My wife said it to try the New York Times salted chocolate chip cookies."
#12

King Arthur

5.0
(3)
"[Magic in the Middles] are chocolate peanut butter filled cookies."
·
"I love these."
·
"Can’t recommend it enough!"
#13

Christina Tosi

5.0
(3)
"The recipe I make that is super simple and gets rave reviews."
·
"They sound a little weird but are amazing."
·
"It's the ONLY ONE THAT MATTERS IMO."
#14

Chef John

5.0
(2)
"Chef John has the best chocolate chip cookie recipe."
·
"Pepper nut cookies"
#15

Smitten Kitchen

5.0
(2)
"They are so good that I won’t make them unless we are taking them somewhere."
·
"Try the Brownie Roll Out cookies from smitten kitchen."
#16

Preppy Kitchen

4.5
(2)
"This recipe works amazingly!"
·
"I use Preppy Kitchen recipe and works great, also before putting the cutouts into the oven I freeze them for at least 15min."
#17

In Fine Taste

5.0
(1)
"In Fine Taste brown butter chocolate chip!"
#18

Salt and Baker

5.0
(1)
"Follow their biscoff buttercream"
#19

Sarah Kieffer

5.0
(1)
"I absolutely ADORE Sarah Kieffer's 100 Cookies!"
#20

Better Bold Baking

5.0
(1)
"Also the recipe on Better Bold Baking is amazing!"
#21

King Arthur Flour

5.0
(1)
"King arthur flour’s website has some amazing recipes."
#22

Melting Moments

5.0
(1)
"My family love Melting Moments."
#23

Vegan 8

5.0
(1)
"I was going to try the snickerdoodle recipe on the vegan 8 website."
#24

Alison Roman

5.0
(1)
"Pretty much broke the internet last year."
#25

NYT Cooking

5.0
(1)
"They are so easy and people RAVE about them."
#26

Wilton

5.0
(1)
"Look up the Wilton's Roll Out Cookie recipe."
#27

Ovenly

5.0
(1)
"Ovenly’s peanut butter cookie is so. Damn. Good."
#28

Dessert Person

5.0
(1)
"They take effort and multiple steps but I made them for thanksgiving and ppl went insane for them."
#29

Stella Parks

5.0
(1)
"If not pick any recipe by Stella parks, Dorie Greenspan or Sally Mckenny."
#30

/r/Old_Recipes

5.0
(1)
"Some of the most reliably well-reviewed cookies."
#31

Taste of Home

5.0
(1)
"They are my favorite and they aren’t commonly made."
#32

It Doesn't Taste Like Chicken

5.0
(1)
"I’ve gotten totally rave reviews when I make these Linzer cookies."
#33

A Bountiful Kitchen

5.0
(1)
"My favorite is a Levain cookie copycat recipe."
#34

A Beautiful Plate

5.0
(1)
"Lemon basil shortbread cookies are my favorite!"
#35

Love From The Oven

5.0
(1)
"They're like crack. My family loves them and they're gone within a couple of days."
#37

NYT

5.0
(1)
"Honestly the gingerbread latte cookies from NYT blow everyone away."
#38

Plated Cravings

5.0
(1)
"They have yet to fail and wow."
#39

Sugar Spun Run

5.0
(1)
"I use this recipe every year and these don’t move AT. ALL."
#40

Doubletree

5.0
(1)
"The doubletree cookie recipe is incredible."
#41

Allrecipes

5.0
(1)
"These have been a huge hit everywhere I’ve taken them."
#42

Jacques Torres

5.0
(1)
"Classic Jacques Torres cookie recipe but crush some heath bars into it."
#43

Everyday Annie

5.0
(1)
"I've used this one for years and they never lose shape!"
#44

Food.com

5.0
(1)
"People go NUTS for chocolate oatmeal drop cookies."
#45

Tollhouse

5.0
(1)
"The chocolate chip cookie recipe on the back of the tollhouse bag is 🤤."
#46

Broma Bakery

5.0
(1)
"I have been asked for this recipe every time i make them."
#47

AllRecipes

5.0
(1)
"Award winning soft chocolate chip cookies."
#48

The Girl Who Ate Everything

5.0
(1)
"Made these recently and a friend told me they were the best cookie she’s ever had."
#49

Lilaloa

5.0
(1)
"I’ve been using the lilaloa recipes - vanilla 2.0 and her chocolate no chill recipe - since I started."
#50

Alton Brown

5.0
(1)
"I’ve tried a bunch. Always go back to the Alton brown."
#51

Baker by Nature

5.0
(1)
"These are always a hit."
#52

Emma’s Goodies

4.0
(1)
"I tried Emma’s Goodies mini vanilla sugar cookies recipe yesterday and it surprisingly held its shape quite well!"
#53

Martha Stewart

4.0
(1)
"I can highly recommend MarthaStewart.com. Hundreds of varied cookie recipes there."
#54

School Night Vegan

4.0
(1)
"I love a stuffed cookie and these ones from school night vegan are delicious."
#55

New York Times Cooking

4.0
(1)
"Orange Spice Crumble Cookies are quite tasty and different."
#56

Claire Saffitz

4.0
(1)
"A bit labor intensive but SO worth it!"
#57

Serious Eats

4.0
(1)
"Brown butter ricotta cookies are relatively easy to make."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your first customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.

Tell me more
Get started
Audience Research