Indestructible Toy reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 265 Reddit reviews across 24 subreddits and 52 posts to rank the best Indestructible Toy brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Dogtraining, r/dogs, r/pitbulls, r/BelgianMalinois, r/germanshorthairs. Top-rated brands include Kong (4.5/5), Goughnuts (4.9/5), West Paw (4.3/5).
Stats
Reviews265
Subreddits24
Posts52
Brands45
Products71
265 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Kong
4.5
(96)
"Kong but make sure it’s the “power chewer” (black) one which is specifically designed to withhold from being destroyed by dogs like ours!"
"The “power chewer” Kong (the one in black) is the only one that has lasted!"
"We have had excellent luck with our Lab-brat-dor by taking a couple of large Kongs... stuffing them with peanut butter and mini-carrots...then sticking them in the freezer."
"Kong toys worked best for our “labragator” Especially the one you can put a treat in the center and they have to work for it."
"Hasn't destroyed any of the black Kong toys."
"I've yet to meet a dog that could destroy this."
"Anything made by the 'kong' company for large dogs."
"Kong toys, jolly balls or toys built for horses."
"The Kong XL Extreme Tumbler. They last a year for my 4 year old boy even with playing rough."
"Kong - their Bone specifically, I have a Staffy and English Bull Terrier, both go through toys like no tomorrow. The kong bone is the only toy that holds up!"
#2
Goughnuts
4.9
(19)
"Have a destructive lab and he now only gets chew toys from https://www.goughnuts.com/. (They are available on Amazon and Chewy also) Recommended them to a family member with a pitbull enthusiastic chewer and she said it’s the first toy that’s ever lasted."
"Great products that are the perfect mix of strong and soft enough not to break teeth."
"What last longest to us is the Goughnuts."
"Https://www.goughnuts.com Guaranteed for life, though my boy has not been able to destroy one yet"
"We purchased them almost a year ago and they are still in perfect condition and our Dane loves them!"
"Look up Goughnuts on Amazon. Most durable ones I've found so far."
"The only toys my dogs have access to all the time are king and goughnuts."
"Not even the black kongs survive, but goughnuts do."
"My GSD has yet to destroy this. He loves Jolly Balls but they only last about a week before he takes a chunk out of them."
"Goughnuts have done pretty good by us."
#3
West Paw
4.3
(21)
"My dog is an aggressive chewer and we love the west paw dog toys!"
"If your dog does manage to chew one up, they will give you one free replacement per toy type."
"West Paw. If your dog manages to destroy one, they will replace each design once for free."
"Check out West Paw products!"
"The only ones that last with our Aussie are Kongs and West Paw Designs toys."
"I like the hurley, but I kind of wish the tizzi wou"
"For your dog I might suggest the Hurley or Jive ball."
"My dog loves the bumi and it doesn't have a mark on it after 3 months of tons of tug."
"I second west paw design and their "zogoflex" line for tough chewers."
"Zogoflex toys by West Paw Design are indestructible."
#4
Nylabone
4.3
(20)
"I've been giving her the nylabones for the last 7 years and they tend to last FOREVER."
"Galileo by Nylabone is indestructible, it will not break even dogs that destroy black Kongs in an hour can't destroy this."
"Galileo by Nylabone is indestructible, it will not break even dogs that destroy black Kongs in an hour can't destroy this."
"Ours rotates between the Galileo (by nylabone), a variety of antlers and bones."
"Nylabones would last my American Bulldog several months."
"Sounds like Nylabone. Indestructible and maybe cleans teeth?"
"The large nylabones do last and last tho."
"We have moved to nylabones and kongs to be out all the time"
"This toy is really really great. It’s nylabone type except it shaves down easier."
"Those Nylabone type bones that are made with real wood are nice."
#5
BarkBox
4.3
(9)
"Bark Box Superchewer boxes are awesome!! PLUS if your doggo destroys a toy, email them and they will send a new one out for FREE!!!"
"Bark box super chewer. We actually had to cancel because we accumulated so many toys and our demolition crew wasn’t able to destroy any"
"I love my superChewer box! If they break a toy (which hasn’t happened to me yet) the company will send you a few more for free!"
"Super chewers bark box was a game changer."
"The rubber toys from bark box (super chewer) have been great."
"My intense chewer has had some of those for months."
"Toys from BarkBox- Superchewers."
"I found super chewer had good times for extreme chewers."
"You should give the Bark Box a try or the Bullymake."
#6
Jolly Ball
4.4
(8)
"My girl loves her very big Jollyball"
"Jollyball are so dang underrated. It's my pitty girls favorite toy."
"I got mine a jolly ball, hard plastic ball, with a smallr ball inside. I dont think this thing is going anywhere. Got it at petco"
"While not indestructable, Jolly Balls are made of a heavy duty rubber and is designed to reinflate back to ball shape after a good chomping."
"Jolly Balls can absolutely work great, and they do last reasonably well for most dogs."
"They don't last forever, but to me a month is a lot longer than her usual five minutes or couple days before she destroys things."
"Her favorite right now is a Jolly Ball that she's working on."
"The Jolly ball is one thing that can stand up to her chewing for a couple months."
#7
Chuckit!
4.3
(8)
"A chuck it ball has been the ONLY dog toy my mal has not been able to destroy."
"Chuckit! Max Glow and Strato balls are great. The super bouncy material is really resilient."
"Chuckit! brand, I've used the Whistler ones with a large GSD who insisted on carrying the ball in his mouth 24/7... flexible enough to withstand the wear and tear."
"Chuck it ultra squeaker balls. My boy loves them."
"The chuck-it balls are the only things our dogs haven’t been able to completely wreck in 2 hours."
"For balls, get the Chuck-it kick and fetch ball for playing but don't let her have it alone."
"Chuck- it rubber balls and a toy made by Kong called a Wubba."
"Chuckit balls have lasted a while with my lab."
#8
Starmark
4.7
(7)
"Pickle pockets are by far the best toy I've found for my rigorous chewer."
"It is a great treat dispensing chew toy."
"The Everlasting line of puzzle toys are AWESOME at being indestructible without being hard on your dog's teeth."
"It's definitely durable, which is worth it to me. Both the family dog and my dog adore theirs, and they are both heavy chewers and smarty-pants dogs that need mental challenges, so the pickle pocket fits the bill!"
"My dog loves her PicklePocket! You can put treats and what not in three sides of it, it keeps her entertained for a quite a while."
"Get her a Pickle by StarMark. They're really very nice and widely available."
"I was also going to say starmark. Our pits at the shelter haven"t torn them up yet and they have the added incentive of being particularly bored."
#9
Tuffy
3.7
(9)
"I highly recommend the companies Tuffys and Playology"
"It took him FOUR MONTHS to chew through the giant t-Rex tuffy toy!"
"Tuffy brand turtle. They're made to be really challenging to disembowel."
"The last Tuffy ring lasted 3 months before he got to the stuffing."
"You can look up "Tuffy" dog toys, they have a rating scale for strength."
"I like Tuffies. We have a lobster one that has surprisingly still held up."
"Only other company I found that is a close second is Tuffys but even those last a few days at best."
"I bought the ox tuffy and within two hours my Rotti/Shep had the but eaten off."
"My beagle mix also ripped the hell out of a #8 tuffy in less than 24 hours."
#10
Benebone
4.5
(6)
"Get a “Bene Bone” they’re amazing and every dog goes nuts for them."
"You could try the benebone products. They work well for my aggressive chewing GSD mixes."
"Benebone stick chews. My pup destroys basically everything but we’ve has the same benebone for about 9 months and she chews it just about everyday but it is still intact!"
"My guys also do well with benebones and nylabones."
"My favorite ones that are very tough are Benebone, nylabone, Kong, westpaw and mammoth"
"I also got her a benebone, peanut butter flavor, and she loves it."
#11
Barkbox
4.4
(5)
"Barkbox sent us some great indestructible toys. My older lab picks most toys apart with his front teefs. He can’t do that to these."
"I’m a fan of Barkbox. Each month you get 2 toys, 2 bags of treats, and a chew treat."
"My fiancé gets bark box for our golden and it’s honestly pretty great."
"I’m a fan of Barkbox. Each month you get 2 toys, 2 bags of treats, and a chew treat."
"95% of Bark Box toys work great. And Kongs."
#12
Bullymake
4.8
(4)
"Bullymake is amazing. Not great for tiny chihuahuas but their toy size is more for medium-XL dogs. They have a satisfaction and destruction proof guarantee."
"BULYMAKE is the only toys that hold up. I have a subscription which I ordered monthly."
"BullyMake subscription. Had it for a few months for my SBT back in 2018 and the toys are still going strong."
"Bullymake and Super Chewer toys are excellent."
#13
Tuffy's
4.5
(4)
"This is it it's by tuffie and it ( From what I have seen) is great for pit bulls."
"We have the pig and giraffe that our two dogs have yet to even get any stuffing out of. Had them for at least 2 years."
"We use tuffys! it lasts about 4 or 5 months longer than usual."
"I got my monster a ring with squeakies in it, and while he did eventually get them out, it took months rather than the typical <1 minute."
#14
JW Pet
4.7
(3)
"I bought these for my dog and they've held up remarkably well. Plus, my dog loves to tug. The Kong Classic also has held up over a year... but they also make an "Extreme" version."
"Jw tug rings are the only thing that last in my house."
"I have an extremely high drive Malinois and if he’s not working he’s super bored and gets destructive. This is like a $15 toy and it is the longest lasting toy."
#15
Benebones
4.3
(3)
"Benebones!!! Worth every penny."
"Benebones last a long time for our GSP when most chew toys are toast in minutes."
"Benebones or deer antlers! My dogs take weeks/months to get through those and they love them."
#16
Planet Dog
4.3
(3)
"My boxer loved the Planet Dog brand. Very durable!"
"Our two dogs would destroy any other toy including the black kong."
"Planet dog has awesome stuff. My dog shreds everything but planet dog."
#17
Boomer Ball
4.3
(3)
"A Boomer Ball. I’ve got 2. 1 of them I’ve had for over 10 years ! It’s only now it’s got a small little hole in it."
"Try a boomer ball. Zoos use them for their animals, too."
"If your dog likes to chase a ball, a boomer ball might be a good choice."
#18
KONG
5.0
(2)
"We’ve had great success with the Kong extreme chew toy."
"KONG - Extreme Dog Toy - Toughest Natural Rubber, Black - Fun to Chew, Chase and Fetch"
#19
ChuckIt
5.0
(2)
"The only thing my walking garbage disposal hasn't been able to destroy."
"My male can shred a tennis ball in a day, but he’s been struggling with the same chuckIt for months."
#20
Kong Ball
5.0
(2)
"My girl loved her Kong ball. Was a huge red one with rope."
"Kong ball has lasted longer than any other toy I've tried even the goughnuts."
#21
Monster K9
5.0
(2)
"My Mal goes to town on this exact toy and it only had a few teeth marks after several months so far."
"Monster K9 Dog Toys - Ultra Durable ChewRing - Lifetime Replacement Guarantee."
#22
Acadia Antlers
4.5
(2)
"Moose antlers are the most economical choice because they last so long. Check out these http://www.acadiaantlers.com/ they are the highest quality antlers."
"My dogs love their antlers! ... they last forever."
#23
Hartz
4.5
(2)
"My puppy has a duraplay bone and it's lasted her forever!"
"Hartz Dura-Play toys... have a couple that have lasted for a few years, squeakers intact."
#24
Fire Hose
4.0
(2)
"The fire hose toys are the only inside toy that’s held up for us."
"Search for fire hose toys. Our dog tears regular toys apart in 5 minutes but toys made out of fire hose last her years."
#25
Jolly Pet
4.0
(2)
"Jolly balls stand up to a good amount of chewing, my girl was a very dedicated toy destroyer and it took her a couple months to even puncture her jolly."
"My parents' GSD Max is also a chewer, and that's the only toy that lasts for him."
#26
Hotspot Pets
4.0
(2)
"Long-lasting chew for aggressive chewers"
"Antlers have lasted us for a long long time."
#27
Jolly Egg
5.0
(1)
"The Jolly Egg lasts pretty much forever. I've known a number of pits who obsess over that toy."
#28
Big Black Dildo
5.0
(1)
"Highly recommend the Big Black Dildo, I have a Rottweiler, Chocolate Lab, and Doberman puppy. They haven't managed to put a dent into it yet."
#29
UnbreakoBall
5.0
(1)
"Try http://www.unbreakoball.com/ they have fantastic stuff, balls, Frisbees, elk antlers, etc. they have a pretty good return policy if your dog is able to break a ball."
#30
Fluff'n'Tuff
5.0
(1)
"Fluff'n'Tuff! We have a squirrel and a rabbit - for 6 months now. Totally intact."
#31
Fidobones
5.0
(1)
"There’s a damn near indestructible ball called the Bowser Ball. We’ve bought maybe 4 of them in the last 18 years."
#32
One World Futbol
4.0
(1)
"The indestructible One World Futbol is a bit pricy, but supposed to be pretty good."
#33
DogTuff
4.0
(1)
"These guys carry tough toys with guarantees. The black kongs are also great for tough chewers."
#34
Candylab
4.0
(1)
"Candylab are great. Similar solid feel."
#35
Green Toys
4.0
(1)
"Green Toys are pretty solid, colourful, affordable, and you can wash them in the dishwasher."
#36
Bullymade
4.0
(1)
"Bullymade Box- A monthly box subscription for heavy chewers. Some of those toys last and some she destroys."
#37
Blockhead Box
4.0
(1)
"Still have quite a few toys he never could destroy from them, and he was a black Kong destroyer."
#38
Andis Plush Dumplings
4.0
(1)
"It’s the toughest/longest lasting toy he’s ever got."
#39
Deer Antlers
4.0
(1)
"We use deer antlers for this. Works great."
#40
Toppl
4.0
(1)
"We just got our boy the toppl for christmas, so he hasn't had it very long, but the last hard plastic "tough" toy we got him was ripped in two within 4 hours, so, so far so good."
#41
Outward Hound
4.0
(1)
"The other thing mine enjoys are the squeaky toys made of "fire hose", outward hound has one that is very resistant."
#42
Tiger Tested
4.0
(1)
"We've actually had decent luck with this "Tiger Tested" ring we got from petsmart. It's been around for a few months and our dogs play tug with it all the time."
#43
Pawstruck
4.0
(1)
"Stuffed bone you can buy really cheap lasted ages. Another plus with these bones is that they can be re-filled with peanut butter."
#44
Booda Bonkers
4.0
(1)
"Booda Bonkers Woosh frisbees take my German Shepherd ages to destroy."
#45
Barkshop
4.0
(1)
"This is the only toys our GSP has been unable to destroy, and the other toys they make out the same material last a long time too!"
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
