Indestructible Toys reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 176 Reddit reviews across 21 subreddits and 34 posts to rank the best Indestructible Toys brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/dogs, r/pitbulls, r/BelgianMalinois, r/greatdanes, r/Catahoula. Top-rated brands include Kong (4.5/5), Goughnuts (4.8/5), Nylabone (4.1/5).
Stats
Reviews176
Subreddits21
Posts34
Brands65
Products63
176 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Kong
4.5
(45)
"Black rubber tends to stand up to rough play and chewing."
"Kong balls are the best just the black rubber balls great for our chewed he goes through stuff so fast and he loves them we call it his precious."
"Antlers and black kong. Only things that last with one of my girls, otherwise she destroys everything."
"Black Kongs"
"All Kong toys have survived by mini-schnauzer's playful and terroristic personality."
"Kong products are the only thing that lasts in our house."
"The only things that seem to work are the hard rubber Kong beehive shaped toy and real bones."
"Kongs! Only toy mine hasn’t destroyed."
"The only toys my dogs have access to all the time are king and goughnuts."
"Kongs are the premium for durability. The black ones in particular can last a dog's lifetime."
#2
Goughnuts
4.8
(13)
"The XL goughnut still looks brand new after a year"
"The xl one is the only thing he hasn’t broken. We tug with it and he can sit for hours and chew on it and it’s still perfect."
"They have different levels of durability, but all have a lifetime guarantee."
"Recommended them to a family member with a pitbull enthusiastic chewer and she said it’s the first toy that’s ever lasted."
"Guaranteed for life, though my boy has not been able to destroy one yet."
"We purchased them almost a year ago and they are still in perfect condition and our Dane loves them!"
"Most durable ones I've found so far."
"The only toys my dogs have access to all the time are king and goughnuts."
"Not even the black kongs survive, but goughnuts do."
"Another must-have is Goughnuts."
#3
Nylabone
4.1
(7)
"Nylabone toys rated 50lbs plus are great."
"My dog loves nylabones, they last quite a long time."
"Nylabones."
"Chew toys would be nylabones etc."
"Those Nylabone type bones that are made with real wood are nice."
"Nylabone. Check out some of the For Powerful Chewers options. These are some of the only toys I feel comfortable leaving for my dogs to chew unsupervised."
"My bully loves her nylabone ... also she has a kong ball that she likes"
#4
Tuffy
4.3
(6)
"I highly recommend the companies Tuffys and Playology."
"None have any sign of wear after 3-4 years."
"Look up Tuffies! Our boy chews up everything and these last for a while with him."
"Toys from the company Tuffys."
"We got our dog who sounds very similar to yours a Tuffy brand turtle. They're made to be really challenging to disembowel and they're not completely indestructible but it took a full month vs. days or even minutes to really destroy this thing."
"You can look up Tuffy dog toys, they have a rating scale for strength. My pup has gotten through the lvl 7 but not the 9."
#5
Benebone
4.4
(5)
"All indestructible."
"I also really like the benebone stick chews. My pup destroys basically everything but we’ve has the same benebone for about 9 months."
"I give her free access to benebones which she loves and which last a long time even with her very aggressive chewing."
"Benebones/Nylabones are good for intense chewing."
"My guys also do well with benebones and nylabones, but these are a personal choice."
#6
Chuck It
4.4
(5)
"A chuck it ball has been the ONLY dog toy my mal has not been able to destroy."
"Chuckit! Max Glow and Strato balls are great. The super bouncy material is really resilient."
"Chuck It balls are always my go to."
"I’ve found the Chuck It orange and blue balls to hold up pretty well."
"For balls, get the Chuck-it kick and fetch ball for playing but don't let her have it alone."
#7
Jolly
4.2
(5)
"Mine frigging LOVES his Jolly ball."
"Jolly balls."
"My GSD has yet to destroy this. He loves Jolly Balls but they only last about a week before he takes a chunk out of them."
"Jolly ball! I got two of the 4.5 inch ones that come on a rope."
"Our dogs are huge fan of jolly ball toys! They can puncture them but it will still hold their shape so they love grabbing on to them and play tug with them."
#8
BarkBox
4.2
(5)
"Super chewers bark box was a game changer."
"I love my superChewer box! If they break a toy (which hasn’t happened to me yet) the company will send you a few more for free!"
"I like toys from BarkBox- Superchewers."
"Some of the Nylabone toys last awhile I’ve found. My youngest hasn’t gotten to the point where it’s out of control but you should give the Bark Box a try or the Bullymake."
"I had the Super Chewer box for my 1.5 year old GSP for about a year and they were tough, but not tough enough."
#9
GoDog
4.2
(5)
"The only squeaker not surgically removed."
"Were my boxer’s absolute favorite."
"They usually de-stuff/de-squeak them within a few days, but the outer shell is solid and lasts forever."
"It IS a stuffy toy so obviously not INDESTRUCTABLE for all dogs, but it's the only stuffy our boy hasn't destroyed."
"I like the GoDog brand plush toys. They're a little more difficult to get to and my destructive lady dog has a harder time downright destroying the dragons and getting to the squeaker."
#10
Kong Black
4.8
(4)
"The black kongs"
"Big black Kong."
"Only the black Kong, but we fill that with peanut butter."
"The black kongs are pretty good, so is the jolly ball, level 9 or 10 tuffy, water buffalo horns"
#11
Westpaw
4.5
(4)
"Seconding West Paw. If your dog does manage to chew one up, they will give you one free replacement per toy type."
"I've gotten WestPaw for many destructive dogs. The most I've seen are tiny teeth marks after constantly chewing for a solid week."
"WestPaw"
"And the West Paw Jive Dog ball (also a durable rubber one)."
#12
Bullymake
4.7
(3)
"Bullymake is amazing. Not great for tiny chihuahuas but their toy size is more for medium-XL dogs. They have a satisfaction and destruction proof guarantee."
"BULYMAKE is the only toys that hold up. I have a subscription which I ordered monthly."
"Bullymake and Super Chewer toys are excellent."
#13
Jolly Pets
4.3
(3)
"My pit destroyed everything. He’s had one of these for *2 years!!*"
"I’d also recommend getting a large push and play by jolly pets, it’s made to be near impossible to grab so they exhaust their chasing/herding instinct by chasing it around and nipping at it"
"Then she can also have the Jolly Pet ball while she's just out in the yard."
#14
Antlers
4.0
(3)
"Second antlers. Not indestructible, but they last my chewer quite some time."
"Antlers are the only chews that last for my dogs. You need to supervise until they learn to gnaw and not try to bite/eat them, but they last a LONG time!"
"Antlers. My dog loves them and takes her forever to get threw even one small one."
#15
Barkbox Super Chewer Toys
5.0
(2)
"Super chewer toys from Barkbox or Barkshop."
"I started trying the bark box super chewer toys and they are pretty epic."
#16
DogTuff
5.0
(2)
"Also this ball has been good to us https://www.dogtuff.com/virtually-indestructible-ball.html"
"It's the only cloth/squeaky toy my dog has not been able to destroy."
#17
Hotspot Pets
5.0
(2)
"Long-lasting chew for aggressive chewers"
"Antlers have lasted us for a long long time."
#18
Fire Hose Toys
4.5
(2)
"Firehose has worked wonders with my girl."
"Toys made out of fire hose last her years."
#19
West Paw
4.5
(2)
"West Paw. If your dog manages to destroy one, they will replace each design once for free."
"Our boy really likes the toys from West Paw."
#20
Monster K9
4.5
(2)
"My Mal goes to town on this exact toy and it only had a few teeth marks after several months so far."
"Monster K9 Dog Toys - Ultra Durable ChewRing - Lifetime Replacement Guarantee"
#21
Orka
4.5
(2)
"The orkas are awesome too - the flyer kicks ass if your dog will play frisbee."
"We love orka toys too. The jacks are my pup's favorite, she's had two with the ropes and the ropes last a day or so, but the toy itself has been around for 2 years with minimal destruction."
#22
Happy Staffy Co.
4.0
(2)
"My boy is a certified power chewer. They last pretty solid."
"Happy Staffy Co. makes toys that are part hard nylon and part soft rubbery. My new guy is fairly young and loves to chew and these have stood up very well."
#23
Bark
4.0
(2)
"We truly can’t find an indestructible toy. We get close with a lot of the heavier “Bark” toys."
"Have you tried the Bark SuperChewer line? My intense chewer has had some of those for months."
#24
Nerf
4.0
(2)
"Got the nerf solid rubber tennis balls had them for about a year now still going strong"
"Aside from Kong's the only other thing that we found are one specific kind of Nerf for dogs squeaky balls."
#25
Zogoflex
4.0
(2)
"I got the Tizzi for my dog first and he destroyed it within 48 hours. I shipped it in and got the Hurley instead - he's had it for a bit and it's not showing any signs of wear at all!"
"I really like the Zogoflex line from West Paw. My dog loves the bumi and it doesn't have a mark on it after 3 months of tons of tug."
#26
Chew King
4.0
(2)
"I bought these for my super chewer. He got a few small pieces off of it but it's still holding strong."
"Chew King is an amazing Kong alternative"
#27
Tonka
5.0
(1)
"A Tonka rubber bone was literally the only toy my dog never destroyed."
#28
Ruffdawg
5.0
(1)
"All of their products come with a lifetime warranty and my dog has only managed to put a small dent in it after over 6 months."
#29
Plush Puppies
5.0
(1)
"They love it. They haven't been able to chew it open yet, I highly recommend the brand."
#30
Bionic
5.0
(1)
"I've found the bionic ball to be indestructible."
#31
Rope Ball
5.0
(1)
"Rope balls are amazing. They last us several months in a house with 3 dogs."
#32
Katie's Bumper
5.0
(1)
"My pit and australian cattle dog both cant chew through these. they're great."
#33
Green Toys
5.0
(1)
"Green Toys are pretty solid, colourful, affordable, and you can wash them in the dishwasher."
#34
Jolly Ball
5.0
(1)
"Perfect for Danes!"
#35
Chuck-it, Kong
4.0
(1)
"Chuck- it rubber balls and a toy made by Kong called a Wubba."
#36
BarkBone
4.0
(1)
"Try BarkBone Sticks. They aren’t too expensive and they last a while. Also safer and tougher than nylabones because chunks don’t come off very easily."
#37
LNKOO
4.0
(1)
"My smaller pit (40 lbs) has not been able to destroy these two toys I bought in November. Both squeakers still work too!"
#38
MASBRILL
4.0
(1)
"My smaller pit (40 lbs) has not been able to destroy these two toys I bought in November. Both squeakers still work too!"
#39
Boots & Barkley
4.0
(1)
"Boots & Barkley Rubber stick. My houla and 125lb pit Bull have been chewing on it daily and playing tug o war with it and has just now started to show chew marks."
#40
Tall Tails
4.0
(1)
"Tall tails leather toys and Kong floppy knot toys have been our saviors!"
#41
Multipet
4.0
(1)
"The only stuffed toy that has survived my destructive chewer is the Multipet Duckworth Duck thats sold on Amazon. We've had this for about 6 months and it is still hole free."
#42
VANFINE
4.0
(1)
"My lab Malinois mix looooves this and it’s the same material of a Kong."
#43
Spot
4.0
(1)
"Antlers or the Spot Bambone Plus chewing toy you can find on amazon."
#44
Gnawsome
4.0
(1)
"Look up the gnawsome balls on Amazon or chewy. I kill the squeaker by stabbing it with a screwdriver so I don't go insane but it lasts a while."
#45
Sodapup
4.0
(1)
"Sodapup.com has kong like toys and other stuff and a 30 day guarantee."
#46
Bully Max
4.0
(1)
"Goughnuts and Bully Max brands have had some good stuff too."
#47
Real Bones
4.0
(1)
"Real bones last for weeks."
#48
Benebone, Nylabone, Kong, Westpaw, Mammoth
4.0
(1)
"My favorite ones that are very tough are Benebone, nylabone, Kong, westpaw and mammoth"
#49
Lacrosse Balls
4.0
(1)
"Lacross balls are my favorite. Just like a kong ball but only cost 1-2$"
#50
Kong, Benebone
4.0
(1)
"My dog hasn't even put a mark in her kong. I also got her a benebone, peanut butter flavor, and she loves it."
#51
Bully Mate
4.0
(1)
"Bully Mate is the only thing I have been able to find that my Houla does not completely destroy within 30 minutes."
#52
Bulletproof Chews
4.0
(1)
"Bulletproof chews are great. My Rottweiler has had his for over a year."
#53
Wood Toys
4.0
(1)
"I’d recommend different wood toys. Eventually, these will perish but should last for quite a bit before your bun destroys them."
#54
Baby Stacking Cups
4.0
(1)
"Baby stacking cups are another good option. Since they’re made for babies, the plastic is safe."
#55
Solid Wood Toys
4.0
(1)
"Look for solid wood toys instead of willow or seagrass. :) Wood lasts much longer and is harder to chew!"
#56
Outward Hound
4.0
(1)
"Bass Pro Shops has a toy that has lasted for months with our BC."
#57
ThinkDog
4.0
(1)
"But the ThinkDog brand toys have lasted very well."
#58
Hear Doggy and GoDog
4.0
(1)
"With “chew guard technology” which seems to be primarily reinforced fabric and seams."
#59
Arm & Hammer
4.0
(1)
"Some hard nylon Arm & Hammer (mint flavor) that are pretty darn tough."
#60
Skineeez
4.0
(1)
"Makes leather stuffing free toys."
#61
Tire Biter
4.0
(1)
"My dog really likes the Tire Biter toys, they make several other types of toys that are all pretty durable."
#62
West Paw Design
4.0
(1)
"They are supposed to be crazy durable"
#63
Candylab
4.0
(1)
"Candylab are great. Similar solid feel."
#64
Playmobil
4.0
(1)
"Good old Playmobil as well."
#65
Snoop Ball
3.0
(1)
"They aren’t cheap at around $20, but the Snoop Ball is good for chewers."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
