Best milkshake on Reddit

"Five guys peanut butter bacon vanilla shake!!"

"Five Guys will make you a salted caramel shake with bacon."

"For another option Five Guys make a pretty solid strawberry milkshake."

"Five Guys has a really decent shake, but Imma send you to Braums."

"Very good"

"Five guys."

"Five guys is surprisingly great but Steak ‘n Shake still pretty good."

"I'd probably go to Five Guys, they have shakes now."

"I enjoy five guys milkshakes."

"Five guys makes delicious shakes."

"And if any of you have ever been blessed enough to try Dairy Star in Lincolnwood …. Wow."

"Oberweis. IMO they have the best."

"Makes a hell of a milkshake."

"Oberweis. Chocolate Malt with extra malt. Best thing ever."

"Oberweis is hand down the best milkshake."

"Oberweis was my go-to before Covid."

"I’m a milkshake fiend — Oberweis or Devil Dawgs is the answer."

"Oberweis, The Region, and Fatso’s all have great milkshakes imo."

"I absolutely love burger boy, and its very inexpensive"

"Burger boy fruiti pepples shake on point"

"Anything from Burger Boy!!"

"Burger boy shakes are top tier"

"The Cookies and Cream milkshake is amazing"

"The shakes of the month always slap"

"Has a really good Fruity Pebble milkshake!"

"For the Coconut Cream shake"

"Especially when they have the almond joy milkshake"

"Does a good one."

"Howley’s, Culver’s, Steak & Shake or Shake Shack"

"I mean I do love Culver’s…"

"I would happily choose a Culver’s shake more than most shakes in Chicago."

"For my money it’s Culver’s."

"Culver’s!!!"

"Culver's."

"I think about more than I think I should."

"Devil Dawgs truly does have great shakes."

"Devil dawgs. Easily some of the best shakes in the city."

"Devil Dawgs chocolate milkshake, add peanut butter, add pretzel. Heaven sent."

"Devil dawgs for elite milkshake from a new fangled business."

"Devil Dawgs continues to have the best chocolate milkshake."

"I quite like Devil Dawgs milkshakes. I love their Oreo one."

"Don’t sleep on UDF shakes."

"Best thing in earth."

"UDF! Get a malt though."

"UDF Peach"

"UDF is legitimately a pretty solid place to go."

"Can be wildly inconsistent depending on who is working."

"Toni’s Hawaiian shake is the best!"

"Go get a Toni’s chocolate shake and then go get one at redwood yogurt and tell me for yourself."

"Toni's or fresh freeze."

"Toni's does a good milkshake."

"Toni’s does some amazing milkshakes, but for some reason it takes like an hour between ordering and getting your food regardless of what you order"

"I wouldn’t feed Toni’s food to my dog but their milkshakes are really great"

"Freddy's has custard shakes and they are bomb AF."

"Freddy's chocolate milkshakes are divine."

"Freddy's is damn good for fast food shake"

"Freddys are good. Scoop n dough makes a good one too."

"Freddys is good"

"Freddys is real good!"

"Arnold's has great old fashioned shakes!"

"Arnold’s!!"

"Arnolds"

"Arnold’s is tough to beat"

"Arnold’s in west Tulsa."

"Is legit the best milkshake I’ve ever had"

"Or Hopdoddy"

"I second cheesy Jane’s. Chester’s is also good and even EZs but cheesy Jane’s is known for their shakes"

"Has the best milkshake atmosphere and isn’t a chain!"

"The PB&J shake is GOATed"

"Ragadan blueberry baklava with halva milkshake."

"I like the baklava milkshake at Ragadan."

"The baklava milkshake at Ragadan has to be in the top 5 milkshakes I've ever had."

"The baklava milkshake at Ragadan is amazing."

"Basbousa shake from Ragadan is life changing."

"Is my favorite."

"Margie’s Fudge Royal shake is insane."

"I always liked Margie’s milkshakes, particularly the strawberry and chocolate."

"MARGIESSSSSSSSS the goat."

"In the city is Margie’s."

"Portillo’s chocolate cake shake. Always."

"Portillos! They have a dark chocolate cake shake that is amazing!"

"The strawberry shake from Portillo's is my favorite these days."

"Have you ever had Portillo’s lemon cake shake?"

"Portillos has good basic shakes and chocolate cake"

"Braums - get a hot fudge milkshake."

"Braums"

"Honestly it Braums. They have the best and cheapest prices"

"Braums"

"BJ's Velvet Freeze, Colorado City Creamery (provides ice cream to Bingo Burger and the zoo) and Culver's."

"The banana split iceberg is the truth."

"But BJs velvet freeze is where it's at for milkshakes, plus they sell a killer pork tenderloin sammich"

"Go to BJs Velvet Freeze"

"Kawartha dairy! The mint chip milkshake made with chocolate milk.. 👌"

"Kawartha Dairy"

"Kawartha and flashback. No question"

"Kawartha dairy’s, they make it with any of their icecream you choose"

"Has one of the best milkshakes I've ever had."

"Some of the best milkshakes I’ve found"

"Honestly... potbelly chocolate shakes make my lunch break sm better."

"Potbelly - love the Oreo shake."

"Dairy Queen brings me to the yard!"

"I like Dairy Queen shakes."

"DQ and Five Guys were my favorites."

"They're vegan, thus lactose free."

"Chicago Diner made me the best milkshake I’ve ever had and it was non-dairy so that was cool"

"Especially a watermelon milkshake between July and August."

"Fizzy’s."

"It's Fizzy's. NA or alcoholic, they're the best."

"Fizzy's in Little Bohemia has some really solid boozy milkshakes."

"Peanutbutter milkshake from Fielder's Choice in Raymond."

"I really loved Fielder's Choice in Bangor. Their Baked Indian Pudding as a malt was A++++."

"The OG Fielder's Choice in Sabattus."

"Zestos on Ida near Blair High Road."

"Banana malt with an extra scoop of malt powder at Zestos in Florence."

"Only pace I’ve found Butterscotch milkshakes."

"And UDF."

"Graeters or UDF."

"Graeter's, buckeye blitz milkshake is superior."

"Fresh Freeze always is bomb for me"

"Fresh freeze hands down"

"Fresh Freeze does a good old school milkshake."

"If you want it a little boozy, i highly recommend the Blue Moon shake at Red Robin."

"Red Robin, they’re ~$8 but massive."

"Red Robin has great shakes."

"Strawberry shake at Small Cheval."

"Is amazing."

"The jack in the box oreo milkshake is fantastic."

"I’ve always been a fan of jack in the box milkshakes"

"Makes a damn good shake in a pinch."

"Handel’s. They make them extra thick and you can mix flavors."

"Has some really good shakes."

"Has good shakes."

"Hot fudge banana shake from Sonic...🔥"

"Sonic, but of course there's only one in the area and it's in Springfield."

"Some of the Sonic's have really great shakes."

"Portillo’s chocolate cake shake."

"Have you ever had Portillo’s lemon cake shake?"

"Portillo’s is good."

"I like a marshmallow shake made with strawberry soft serve from Zesto in Florence."

"Usually has a good shake."

"Usually has a good shake."

"Yesterday I had the best shake in years at Shake Shack. Chocolate + Salted Caramel. Perfect thickness. Delicious."

"Love shake shack but they are small."

"Possibly best in state!"

"Oberweiss. Not even close."

"Oberweiss has the best milk shack!"

"Milkshakes are slept on."

"Has some really good milkshakes too."

"For me."

"Clintonville."

"Comfortland!"

"Comfortland and emoji burger have great milkshakes."

"Is really good."

"Is off WadeHampton."

"The milkshakes at Po’ Boys and Pickles are 10/10!!!!"

"Thick malted vanilla"

"Houlton Farms is the only answer here."

"Dons original."

"Don's Original."

"Pittsford dairy, Abbotts."

"Pittsford Dairy, Tom Wahl’s."

"ABBOTS."

"Abbots is great."

"Buddy’s has a great milkshake."

"As someone who lived here my entire life, I present to you : Buddy’s Diner."

"Heath shake bangs"

"PDQ’s banana milkshake is mind blowing."

"Little Goat has an amazing Vanilla milkshake with caramel."

"SO good, it’s like $15 but worth it lol."

"For the price, Happy Cow on 24th and Hilyard makes a great shake."

"Honestly, Happy Cow on 24th and Hilyard, they have coconut milk and Coconut Bliss milkshakes that are incredible."

"Duckfat’s crème anglaise milkshake."

"Duckfat in Portland, but since they don't really need any more pub."

"Shakedog in city center do a meal deal for 15 euro and you get the most banging milkshake."

"Shake dog or scottys do pretty good shakes."

"Has amazing ice cream and shakes."

"Scooters! They make their frozen custard in house."

"Has malted milkshakes!!"

"In Walterboro."

"Last summer they had a banana pudding shake with nilla wafers."

"Maxwell’s makes a pretty awesome shake."

"Tom Wahl's, expensive, but made from scratch."

"Tom Wahls uses abbots ice cream."

"BOOGIE's burgers pb&j but they have soooo many flavours!"

"No Brand Burger Stand does a great banana milkshake and their burgers are one of my favorites."

"No Brand Burger Stand in Ferndale has a good shake."

"Lickety split for custard milkshakes, I like the vanilla malt myself."

"Lickety Split."

"Burger Royale has fantastic standard milkshakes as well as some unique options."

"It may not be the 'best' but Burger Royale milkshakes are pretty darn good and you get to use them to wash down the best burger in the city."

"Jack Rabbit slims is my favorite. Their shakes are worth the whole five dollars they charge."

"Get the $5 shake"

"Triple O's white spot, cookies and cream shake is insane."

"Triple O's makes a good milkshake."

"Smashburger makes an amazing chocolate shake"

"Smashburger makes a fine strawberry shake."

"Theo’s chocolate peanut butter shake."

"In Peoria, I'd say either Theo's or the 50's Diner."

"Angels real fruit strawberry, my dudes!"

"Angels in Bowness!"

"It’s in Wilmette, but Homers has amazing milkshakes including peach!"

"Homers in Wilmette, worth the drive!"

"Come at me but the cherry milkshake at DQ."

"Don’t undersell DQ if what you want is a straight up milkshake."

"Arby's. Jamocha."

"I think Arby's has the best chocolate shakes of all fast food restaurants."

"I like dickie joes, the peanut butter extra thick with extra peanut butter is a dream."

"Dickie Joes my dude."

"Giffords black raspberry milkshake."

"Giffords was a good bet for a long while but I think they may have closed."

"Has great shakes IMO."

"It's in broken arrow but steak n shake is very hard to beat"

"I'm a big fan of Byrne Dairy shakes."

"Byrne Dairy."

"I second the Gibson's recommendation."

"I second the Gibson's recommendation; but am also a fan of Cool Licks."

"I keep going back to Lucy’s Fried Chicken for my milkshake fix."

"Lucy’s Fried Chicken is my sleeper pick."

"Carls Jr. it’s old school milk and chocolate ice cream with real whipped cream."

"Honestly, Carl's Jr. Has really good shakes."

"Ice Cream Shack or Double Ds."

"I prefer the ice cream shack down on Adams."

"The absolute best ice cream I’ve ever had."

"So good."

"A&C Soda Shop in Sopo"

"Tastee Freez in Madawaska"

"Kebab Den in Bangor (yes really!)"

"Best I have had was at Deb’s Burger in Redway. Real ice cream. Thick."

"Glenburn Soda Fountain & Confectionery in North Burnaby have the best milkshakes in the Lower Mainland."

"Munchies have excellent milkshakes!"

"Jimmy Z’s coffee cake and nothing is particularly close."

"If you have a Stewarts near you, they are the best."

"O’Charleys Strawberry milkshake"

"Head to Kuchie's On The Water and get the shake of the month: Playing in the mud."

"PB- choco-banana at Smoothie Whirld is their nod to a traditional milkshake."

"Marymar on 6th makes an awesome Oreo shake"

"Oatmeal shake at Irazu for sure."

"Mint chocolate chip from Mooyah Burgers!"

"Y'all crazy, Max and Louies has phenomenal shakes!"

"Surprised no one said TJs Burgers…They have a legit milkshake…"

"Go to the yard. They have the best milkshakes."

"Bucks in woodstock is outta the way but seriously so good."

"Oooof def forgot to add the huckleberry shake from Don Pez."

"Dr Pepper shake at Whataburger."

"Frost. dark chocolate and roasted almond 😩."

"They have an amazing Churro shake that has pecans and churro pieces in it."

"I'm a malt guy and they have an amazing chocolate malt."

"Screamery or Little Anthony's"

"Culvers"

"The Devine Bovine's shakes are surprising great."

"Divine Bovine at Speedway and Wilmot"

"Sweet Cow has milkshakes!"

"Goodfellas has delicious milkshakes and cozy diner feel."

"Freaky Wizard has a whole menu of wizard-themed shakes and yummy potions."

"Downtown McDonald's hands down!"

"Burgerstory on sparch do hard shakes. Bourbon chocolate is SO good."

"Best I've found is the creamery in Salthill."

"A whiskey vanilla shake from Mr. Juicy"

"Has one called a Velvet cake shake that is really good."

"Mel’s diner makes my favorite shakes 🤤"

"Giant Burger in Springfield has some killer shakes."

"Duck Fat's Salted Caramel shake. It's the balls."

"Has some amazing crazy shakes at times."

"How is Mitchells not on this list yet? Best in SF!"

"Liftoff Creamery was my go to when pregnant and working downtown! Super good."

"I love their Milkshakes and almost always go there."

"Prince Puckler’s."

"Jersey Scoops in Loleta! Best ice cream in the county!"

"They use bluebell in all their shakes and are perf"

"Has a great chocolate shake"

"Uptown burger has the beeeeesssssssttttttt chocolate milkshake"

"I had a chocolate milkshake at Aunt Alice’s last night & it was so good."

"The best ever"

"Blizzards at DJ’s Burger Bar in Rio Dell are the best ‘Shake’ in Humboldt, no contest!"

"The milkshakes are sooo good."

"Incredible. Their ice cream is some of the best anyway, so naturally their milkshakes are too."

"Made with quality ice cream."

"The alamo has amazing milkshakes."

"Pittsford Farms Dairy has milkshakes from another planet."

"Halal and Out has really good shakes."

"Chili Hots makes a great shake."

"Russell's Ice Cream on Chili Ave."

"Worth the day trip to Penn Yan to try food, ice cream, and/or shakes at Seneca Farms."

"I love the strawberry milkshake from Lou’s!"

"Strawberry Bullshake Youngs Jersey Dairy."

"Some of the best shakes I’ve ever had, particularly their vanilla and Nutella shakes"

"Red’s, Peanut Butter & Banana."

"Chick Fil A has good shakes made with real milk and ice cream. The peach one is my fav but it’s only during summer months."

"Ask for extra J."

"Peter’s Drive In, my favourite combo is oreo and marshmallow!"

"Bouchard Farm in Fort Kent! My younger daughter is in love with their Oreo milkshake."

"Cafe Tiztal in Uptown has some incredible oatmeal milkshakes."

"Witch Spring Hill in West Bath has an amazing Nutella Oreo frappe."

"Wimpys milkshakes are unappreciated. they are superior. the nutella one to be exact"

"Sarah's Scoops in Boothbay Harbor makes a really good 'real mocha frappe' with espresso that is 100% worth it."

"The Milkshakes there are the best I've had in the city."

"Vilis still do one of the best standard milkshakes out there."

"Chuck wagon dose the best and crazy milkshakes."

"Super Scoops is a seemingly simple milkshake that absolutely crushes each and every time."

"K’s in Troy. Yes a bit of a drive but you’ll not find a better shake."

"Midway Diner had the best milkshakes that you needed a spoon with it."

"The best one I’ve had is at The Dugout in North Windham."

"Found the best at the Dunks drive thru in Scarborough."

"La Michoacana Emerita in Arleta. Get the Mazapan milk shake"

"Is my favorite."

"Kinder Bueno Thiccshake @ CREAM in Brighton is a delish option"

"Black Bear diner, huckleberry shake is delicious"

"Had this really good horchata shake"

"The absolute bestest espresso milkshake from little goat diner."

"Bell the Cat's Espresso Milkshake"

"(on North Ave, technically Elmwood Park I think)."

"Way more than I expected to enjoy one."

"Martha’s chocolate espresso shake is top tier."

"Cake shakes from Pop Up Chicken!!"

"The Bumblebee milkshake at Boogie's is a godsend."

"Cold stone creamery has my vote. Their birthday cake shake. Mmmmm"

"A classic strawberry."

"Las Delicias - Mexican fruit drinks and their milkshakes man..."

"Silver Linings is fantastic, if you enjoy a THICC shake"

"Vaca Creamery and Chicago Diner make delicious non-dairy milkshakes."

"They have one that includes whole pieces of Cinnamon Toast Crunch."

"Maggie's hands-down and you can get great sundaes."

"Gayetteys in Indiana is the best milkshake in Chicago."

"Comes with an absurd amount of edible accoutrements/decorations, and there's a boozy upgrade option"

"2 favorites. And malt is the only way to go."

"Just peek at the menu and imagine an amazing shake to wash down a hangover burger or some good ol’ wings."

"Has reaaaally good milkshakes."

"Has some of the best milkshakes around."

"24/7 shakes."

"The best shake in town!"

"Also their blizzards are the best."

"Mix the hot fudge and peanut butter bro."

"Pineapple shake at Sandy's. Lemonade milkshake at Mighty Fine. Root Beer milkshake at P. Terry's."

"Is easily the best around."

"Has good milkshakes."

"Has some really really good ones"

"Honey cone in deep river"

"Uses real ice cream and it’s a around $7"

"Banana milkshake from the old Burger Inn on Macleod Tr"

"Burger House in the Delta Oaks area!"

"Smiling Hill Farm Chocolate Milk. Technically not a milkshake, but it is super thick and amazing"

"Just fucking awesome milkshakes. Simple and delicious."

"Tastes like liquid banana bread and heaven"

"Makes a fabulous shake."

"I’m a fan of Dan’s chocolate malt."

"Is my jam."

"Has been my goto, and my parents before me, for like 60 years"

"Definitely my fave!"

"My favorite is definitely from sandy’s hamburgers"

"Are a little thicker than what you get at P.Terry’s and so good."

"Is great."

"They used to have phenomenal milkshakes."

"Is pretty damn good."

"Is tough to beat."

"Fantastic."

"Regular shakes at Scoop 50 in Summerville."

"Was out of this world."

"Is my personal favorite."

"Is my favorite."

"Are really good."

"Get the HOMEMADE ice cream shakes"

"Get the HOMEMADE ice cream shakes"

"The fucking birthday cake one is so ridiculously good"

"Has a great campfire milkshake that tastes like s’mores"

"Incredible"

"The best chocolate milkshake I've ever had"

"Best milkshakes I've ever had."

"Truly to die for"

"That is soooooo good."

"Has the best around."

"Elite malts and milkshakes."

"It will change his life."

"Check out the Zanzibar chocolate shake....you will thank me later."

"I’m a fan of the vanilla milkshake from Williams"