Steak Houses reviews from Reddit
Summary
We analyzed 274 Reddit reviews across 16 subreddits and 16 posts to rank the best Steak Houses brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/oklahoma, r/Calgary, r/Birmingham, r/FoodNYC, r/AskChicago. Top-rated brands include Caesar's (4.6/5), Gibsons Bar & Steakhouse (4.1/5), Rolli's (4.4/5).
Stats
Reviews274
Subreddits16
Posts16
Brands100
Products1
274 reviews from
and
By Brand
/By Product
#1
Caesar's
4.6
(11)
"Perfectly seasoned and charcoal grilled 8 oz ribeye steak sandwich"
"The south location of Caesars has a modern atmosphere and excellent steaks"
"Caesar’s for the win. Traditional aged Alberta beef worthy of a 50th celebration!"
"Caesars, hands down."
"Caesar's - again, a warmer more intimate atmosphere. You can sit near the brazier and watch the chefs as they cook the steaks."
"Ceasar's - classic old school steakhouse, good food and feels like you're back a couple decades."
"Caesar’s (old school like 80s red leather interior, best bang for your buck high q"
"Get the tenderloin, rare. They make the best tenderloin in the city and get the twice baked potatoes"
"Don’t miss out on the garlic bread"
"Caesar's is really good and hasn't changed its décor in like 50 years which is really cool."
#2
Gibsons Bar & Steakhouse
4.1
(9)
"It's old Chicago, it's an institution, and still a great meal."
"Gibsons or Baettes, Boefhaus for a dream small place."
"Gibson's on Rush...you'll need a reservation."
"Gibson’s is the classic, Bavettes was a long time favorite but I feel like they lost their fastball, personally think Kinzie’s Chophouse is a good option."
"Gibbon’s. Great food and great energy."
"Gibson’s or Cut"
"Gibsons - Chicago Staple (Hard to Hate)"
"Gibson's on Rush for the true Chicago experience."
"Gibsons - old school vibe"
#3
Rolli's
4.4
(7)
"Rolli's for sure."
"I love Rolli's!! Good quality and service, and worth the price :)"
"If you liked US and Canada definitely go to Rolli’s."
"Rollis is awesome."
"Rolli’s."
"If you prefer something cheaper.. try one of the "Rolli's". I visited twice the one in Schlieren and it was good."
"Rolli's Steakhouse"
#4
Cattlemen's
3.2
(9)
"Cattlemen's is still decent."
"Cattleman’s you hit the nail on the head it’s largely nostalgia, but I do think you still get a pretty darn solid steak for the price point."
"I love their steaks, and their salad dressing is to die for."
"Cattleman’s :)"
"Cattlemans still holds a nostalgic place in my Okie heart though."
"Cattleman’s > mahogany. In that order."
"Cattleman's."
"Hella overrated and only old people hold it in high regard."
"Cattlemen's is extremely overrated. Even a rare steak is dry and tough every time I get one there."
#5
Armour House
4.7
(6)
"Steak House for a business dinner screams Armour House/ pogo Imo. Phenomenal beef priced reasonably for what you’re getting."
"I have never made as perfect of a steak."
"For business, Armour House is the correct choice."
"More people should know about Armour House. Those guys be dry aging their steaks in house, so good"
"Try Armour House"
"Haven’t been myself but heard good things about Armour House."
#6
Vintage
4.7
(6)
"Vintage, hands down."
"Vintage- for a warm and more intimate atmosphere, plus you get a meat seminar where they bring out all the cuts and explain the differences."
"Vintage - My usual "go-to" steakhouse. Has always been consistent and delicious"
"Vintage is so good!"
"Vintage is the best if you're going for quality at middle range"
"My favourite steak place in Calgary - consistently top notch with a stellar wine list as well."
#7
Perry's
3.3
(8)
"Expensive but no more than a flemmings or Perry’s with much better quality, vibe and wine."
"Perry’s wagyu!!"
"Steakhouse - Perry’s"
"Perrys and Flemings are always solid choices."
"Or a classic- Ruths’ Chris (chain but so good) in the gables."
"Perry's is fucking stupid but it's perfect for this. Idiot proof parking situation."
"The last two times I've been to Perry's my steak was dramatically over cooked."
"Perry's absolutely blows. It was once respectable, but is currently a joke."
#8
Jeff Ruby's
4.8
(5)
"Jeff Ruby."
"Jeff Ruby’s steakhouse."
"Steak Burrow at Jeff Ruby's *chef's kiss*."
"The steak was perfectly cooked (rare), and the service was excellent."
"I’ve had Ruby’s and it’s amazing but I was looking for a hidden gem type place that’s better then Ruby’s."
#9
Hawksmoor
3.7
(6)
"Hawksmoor but be prepared to drop guap"
"Looking into hawkmoor n Wolfgang’s, and anslem"
"I just had a boys steak and martini night at Hawksmoor. ... we had a great time"
"Hawksmoor"
"Hawksmoor was great."
"Hawksmoor is out. Really dropped in quality. Sadness."
#10
Wellington's
4.4
(5)
"Wellingtons hands down."
"The best. But hard to get in on short notice"
"Wellington's is the best for the Old-School vibe. Their escargot and tableside caeser are fabulous"
"Wellington's is still around and doing fine. It is far better than Hy's and I feel better than Ceasars."
"Don't forget Wellington's. Overlooked too often but at least as good as Ceasars."
#11
Bavette's
5.0
(4)
"Bavettes or Steak 48. But make a reservation ahead of time with the former if you want to go there."
"I second Bavettes!"
"Bevettes has my favorite steak right now! I also like Gibson Italia."
"Bavettes - The Best (lives up to the hype.. everytime)"
#12
Mahogany
3.8
(5)
"I’ve had Mahogany and it was great albeit pricy."
"Tulsa: Bull in the Alley, Phryme, Hemingways, Mahogany."
"I like mahogany ranch and bobs all are good options."
"Mahogany and Red Prime are solid as well."
"If you want an overpriced steak, mahogany or ranch I guess?"
#13
Hy's
4.8
(4)
"Hys is the best if you're going for their high end dry aged steaks"
"Hy's is the best fit for sure."
"Hy’s (best atmosphere, best service, superb steak, weak sides, where I would go for Wagyu, most expensive I’ve been to in Calgary)"
"I'd add Hy's Steakhouse to this list."
#14
The Ranch
4.5
(4)
"I think the Ranch has the best steaks."
"The Ranch or Boulevard are my favorites."
"I hear Ranch is the best from multiple folks."
"I liked The Ranch over Red or Broadway 10."
#15
Smith and Wollensky
4.3
(4)
"Smith and Wollensky has a weekend wine dinner ... Old school vibes and the food doesn’t miss."
"For boys night, we always do wolensky’s grill: I like it better than smith and wollenskys"
"Wollensky’s Grill ... great vibe, super friendly staff ... reasonably priced for the quality"
"Smith and Wollensky $$$ but great steaks!"
#16
Napa Grill
4.0
(4)
"Napa grill, the best of the best. Meat quality and service top top top."
"The Napa Grill."
"Napa grill is good as well."
"I was very disappointed with Napa recently. The meat was good quality but it wasn't cooked well."
#17
Ocean Prime
4.0
(4)
"Even the not-technically a steak house like Ocean Prime, Flemings, and Eddie Vs beat everything I've had in lakeland."
"The filet at Ocean."
"Filet at Ocean"
"Filet from Ocean (I know it’s a seafood restaurant, but the steak is always incredible)"
#18
Steak 48
5.0
(3)
"Love Steak 48. I'm always surprised it does not get mentioned more in Chicago steak threads."
"Steak 48 is the best right now"
"Overall experience is Steak 48, for sure. The service, ambiance, and all dishes were stellar."
#19
Jervois
5.0
(3)
"Jervois is very good."
"Jervois will be your best."
"Jervois steakhouse."
#20
Carlo and Johnny
5.0
(3)
"Carlo and Johnny is my favorite Ruby concept."
"Carlo and Johnny and The Precinct are my favorites. Steak always perfectly cooked."
"Had a 10/10 experience at Carlo and Johnny but for a regular night I would suggest longhorn."
#21
Bright Star
3.5
(4)
"The Greek Tinderloin with a loaded baked potato and Greek salad with Greek Dressing. I’m an addict."
"Greek Style Tenderloin from Bright Star"
"The beef tenderloin at the Bright Star"
"Bright Star is awful."
#22
Simon's
4.7
(3)
"Simon's is incredible!"
"I love Simon's. While I thought it was just personal preference and maybe I'm exaggerating, I went with some colleagues who were visiting Zurich recently. They keep talking about this restaurant until now."
"Simon's steakhouse is really good, solid good tier"
#23
Helen
4.7
(3)
"Never anything less than an amazing meal at Helen, the ribeye is amazing."
"My bf got a wagyu strip there and it was divine"
"Helen"
#24
PS Steak
4.7
(3)
"PS Steak. Excellent service, deft touch in the kitchen, and high quality across the menu."
"Have only been able to afford P.S. once but it was the best steak I've ever had in my life."
"PS Steak has the best house martini."
#25
Nineteen61
4.7
(3)
"In Lakeland, I think Nineteen61 has the best filet by far!"
"The delmonico at Nineteen61 is one of the best steaks I’ve had anywhere."
"Nineteen61 has a delicious flat iron steak."
#26
Morton's
4.3
(3)
"Is so good man I love it."
"I love Morton’s in the gables."
"Morton's."
#27
Klaw
4.3
(3)
"Has the best steak I’ve had in south Florida."
"Not only the steak is great, if you like tartare, theirs is one of the best."
"Another vote for Klaw."
#28
Bessie
4.3
(3)
"Bessie #1 Otherwise Bloody Mary's"
"Bessie is great, Bloody Mary’s is ok but the sides are average."
"Bessie is our favourite. Not as good value as Jabba but good for a special occasion."
#29
Chairman's
4.3
(3)
"Chairman’s. It’s unreal, old school classy, and a pleasure."
"Chairman's is delicious"
"Chairman's - I have never actually been here but hear good things"
#30
Harry's
4.0
(3)
"Harry’s"
"Harry’s. I thought the prices weren’t too bad for a top notch steakhouse vs comparison in big us cities."
"Harry's or Sonora Grill... There is one Brazilian steakhouse called Bovinos that is good too."
#31
Sunny's
4.0
(3)
"For more traditional American steakhouse."
"(fun vibes)"
#32
Keens
4.0
(3)
"Keens"
"Keens"
"Keens"
#33
Council Oak
4.0
(3)
"I second council oak if you don't mind to sit in a space where people can smoke"
"2nd Council Oak. Really good choice."
"Big fan of counsel oak that’s at the hard rock. It’s pricey but worth it."
#34
Bob's Steak & Chop House
4.0
(3)
"Bob's is tied for the best in OKC."
"I like mahogany ranch and bobs all are good options."
"How about Bob’s steak and chop?"
#35
Gallagher's
4.0
(3)
"Gallaghers"
"Gallaghers"
"Gallagher’s"
#36
Jamil's
2.8
(4)
"For old school: Jamil's"
"Since The Coach House closed about 10 years ago... Jamil's."
"Jamil's is no longer good."
"Jamil's is terrible lately."
#37
Little Betty
2.8
(4)
"Little Betty is good, but not worth the price tag and attitude."
"Little Betty (it gets way too much hate because of it price and location, but I’ve never had a bad meal)"
"Little Betty, Oak House, or if you are really trying to wine and dine le outback."
"Not Little Betty. Inconsistent food, poor atmosphere at ridiculous prices."
#38
Williams Butcher Table
3.7
(3)
"Williams butcherstable (there is a mini butcher counter inside, you can pick your meat : highly recommend the bone marrow rinsed with vodka : it seems gimmicky, it's amazing)"
"Williams, and go to the Bellevue location. It's smaller but the staff there can be a lot of fun."
"Williams Butcher table is way below average… that’s not a steakhouse."
#39
Churrascaria Plataforma
3.7
(3)
"Plataforma Churrascaria"
"Churrascaria Plataforma."
"Plataforma is alright"
#40
Texas Cattle Company
2.0
(5)
"If you want to get out of the rut of chain restaurants like Texas Roadhouse and Longhorn there's Texas Cattle Company downtown."
"Texas Cattle Company used to be a great steak house, not any longer."
"Texas cattle company"
"Texas cattle company"
"Texas cattle is terrible, not even a good as longhorn"
#41
Modern Steak
3.3
(3)
"Modern has far better steak than Saltlik."
"The food was really great but not worth the price tag imo. portions were REALLY small"
"The steaks and sides were acceptable but not any better than a Vintage or Ceasars or Modern"
#42
Scarpas
5.0
(2)
"Yep, Scarpas is amazing."
"Best steak I’ve ever had ever was from Scarpas in Lakeland."
#43
Mancini's
5.0
(2)
"Mancini’s is the only answer needed!"
"I'm not even a very big fan of steak, and I loved Mancinis."
#44
Houston's
5.0
(2)
"Houston’s restaurants that sell Rutherford ribeye. Best steak and value."
"Ribeye at Houston’s Pasadena"
#45
Capital Grille
5.0
(2)
"100% agree that Capital Grille is so much better than Ruby's. I'm never one to pick a chain over a local, but it is just so much better, cleaner, nicer staff, and more for your money."
"We always have had great experiences and meals at Capital Grille."
#46
Prime
5.0
(2)
"I am a firm believer Prime has the best steak I have ever had."
"The only steak I dream about and can still taste was from Prime."
#47
Baldamar
5.0
(2)
"Baldamar is my vote too. Their sides are almost better than their steaks."
"Baldamar by the Roseville mall. Their sides are almost better than the steaks."
#48
Hemingway's
4.5
(2)
"The Hemingway in Tulsa has a damn fine steak."
"Tulsa: Bull in the Alley, Phryme, Hemingways, Mahogany."
#49
Old Homestead
4.5
(2)
"Old Homestead in the West Village. Been around for 150 years so comes with history."
"Old Homestead"
#50
St. Anselm
4.5
(2)
"St Anselm in Williamsburg is one of my favorites, and also budget friendly"
"St anselm has reopened"
#51
Strip House
4.5
(2)
"I love Striphouse on 12th"
"Strip house (12th st)"
#52
Sonora Grill
4.5
(2)
"Sonora is our preference for a steakhouse experience in Playa, like what you’d compare to DelFriscos in TX. Great service and wine selection."
"Sonora grill is good also."
#53
The Joint Cafe
4.0
(2)
"Try the Joint Cafe in Galleria. They make really good steak."
"There is one in galleria. The Joint Cafe. Its really good"
#54
Monday Room
4.0
(2)
"The Monday Room is excellent and so is 5th Street - neither are ‘steak houses’ but they do a superb steak special & sides"
"Can get good steak at Monday Room"
#55
Boulevard
4.0
(2)
"Boulevard is super underrated IMO."
"The Ranch or Boulevard are my favorites."
#56
Gianni's
4.0
(2)
"Agree Gianni’s in Wayzata is great."
"High End- Gianni’s in Wayzata. Moderate- Bennet’s Chop and Rail House in St.Paul."
#57
McClintock Saloon & Chop House
4.0
(2)
"For those that crave Cattleman’s: McClintock Saloon & Chop House."
"Mickey Mantles used to be great. Now I suggest McClintocks."
#58
The Grill
4.0
(2)
"The Grill has a pdr upstairs. They know their stuff."
"The grill on federal st is good also but not sure about the booking size."
#59
George Bar & Grill
4.0
(2)
"George Bar & Grill above Casino Zürich."
"Go George Bar & Grill or Bärengasse."
#60
Ivory House
4.0
(2)
"Yes! Ivory house is a hidden gem."
"Ivory House."
#61
Butcher's Cut
4.0
(2)
"High quality dry aged steak eatery"
"Butcher's Cut is not too far from Myeongdong and its quite good"
#62
Petrelli's
4.0
(2)
"Petrelli's in Culver City is iconic."
"If you want something more traditional, try Petrelli's"
#63
Born & Bred
4.0
(2)
"Born & Bred is better if you want a more Korean experience. I would also say their quality and taste is better"
"They had some cuts of very high quality Korean beef (hanwoo)"
#64
Jaba
4.0
(2)
"Thanks everyone ❤️ gonna give Jaba a try"
"Jaba is pretty good."
#65
Fleming's Prime Steakhouse
4.0
(2)
"Flemings and helen haven't ever disappointed."
"I also really enjoy Flemings."
#66
Arroyo Chop House
4.0
(2)
"Arroyo Chop House in Pasadena."
"So was Arroyo Chop House."
#67
Nic's Steakhouse
4.0
(2)
"Great service. Very reasonable good for the price"
"They age their meat 28 days and do a really good job at seasoning and cooking"
#68
Gene & Georgetti's
4.0
(2)
"Gene & Georgetti’s - The Classic Old School (in a good way)"
"Gene and Georgetti"
#69
Delmonico's
4.0
(2)
"Delmonicos"
"Delmonicos"
#70
Wolfgang's Steakhouse
4.0
(2)
"Wolfgangs"
"Wolfgang’s (park ave location)"
#71
Berns
4.0
(2)
"Berns is great but more of like an amusement park, great to experience once but hands down the most expensive restaurant Tampa has to offer."
"Go to Tampa Berns Terra Gaucha Charleys"
#72
Bloody Marys
4.0
(2)
"Never been disappointed with the butchers board at bloody Mary’s"
"Bloody Marys, Whiskey Fiddle both very good."
#73
Quality Meats
4.0
(2)
"Quality Meats ... if you want midtown"
"Quality meats"
#74
EastWest
4.0
(2)
"The ribeye at East West is vastly underrated."
"Don’t sleep on the Mongolian Ribeye at EastWest!"
#75
Gianmarco's
4.0
(2)
"The best steak I’ve had consistently is at Gianmarco’s."
"Ribeye at GiamMarcos."
#76
Asador Bastian
3.5
(2)
"Asador Bastian - The fanciest, gunning for the title of best (spectacular)"
"Asador Bastian - people will recommend this but skip it. It's not a traditional steakhouse style place"
#77
Maple & Ash
3.5
(2)
"Maple & Ash - trendy vibe"
"Maple & Ash - Trendy/Celebrity (lost their fastball in my opinion)"
#78
Red Prime
3.0
(2)
"I did like red prime but had a bad experience and never went back."
"Mahogany and Red Prime are solid as well."
#79
The Vintage Steakhouse
5.0
(1)
"The Vintage Steakhouse in Morrison, OK… one of the best Filets I’ve had in years!"
#80
Opus Prime
5.0
(1)
"Opus Prime is by far my favorite."
#81
Birdies
5.0
(1)
"Birdies is fantastic!"
#82
Chuck's Fish
5.0
(1)
"Chucks Fish on 280 truly has the best filet I’ve ever had."
#83
Australian Wagyu
5.0
(1)
"The Australian Waygu strip is well worth its $100 price tag. Best piece of steak I’ll probably ever eat."
#84
BLVD Steakhouse
5.0
(1)
"You need to try out BLVD Steakhouse! The interior is insane and the food is unreal!"
#85
Vinyl
5.0
(1)
"Vinyl on W. 35th is excellent."
#86
Mastro's
5.0
(1)
"Mastros is top notch!"
#87
Kean's
5.0
(1)
"Kean’s on 36th and 6th. Old school!!! Get the Mutton."
#88
Streamsong - The Canyons Restaurant
5.0
(1)
"The canyons restaurant out there can really make a quality steak."
#89
Le Cellier
5.0
(1)
"Best steak I’ve ever had though was at Le Cellier in Epcot."
#90
Grillsmith
5.0
(1)
"My husband and I enjoy Grillsmith on Southside. We've never had a bad steak there!"
#91
Charley's
5.0
(1)
"Charley's for a wonderful fin dining experience."
#92
Fox and Ferret
4.0
(1)
"Fox and ferret at the palms does those stone grills where u cook it urself, good drinks too."
#93
Casino
4.0
(1)
"Wednesday night is steak night at the casino $15 - good steak and a bargain"
#94
Bahnhöfli
4.0
(1)
"Bahnhöfli in Mettmenstetten is great."
#95
Mere Catherine
4.0
(1)
"I love the steak and fries at Mere Catherine."
#96
City Hall
4.0
(1)
"I just went to City Hall in Jenks and it was really good."
#97
Phryme
4.0
(1)
"Tulsa: Bull in the Alley, Phryme, Hemingways, Mahogany."
#98
Gaucho
4.0
(1)
"Gaucho. Decently priced (for Zurich), and the atmosphere is lovely, and of course, steak is really good."
#99
Bull in the Alley
4.0
(1)
"Tulsa: Bull in the Alley, Phryme, Hemingways, Mahogany."
#100
Junior's
4.0
(1)
"My favorite is probably a toss between Jamil’s or Juniors with the nod towards Juniors."
Discover your audience
GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.
If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.
Sign up for free, get community insights in minutes.
Tell me more
Get started
