Underwear reviews from Reddit

Summary

We analyzed 444 Reddit reviews across 74 subreddits and 110 posts to rank the best Underwear brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/mensfashion, r/BuyItForLife, r/exmormon, r/AskMen, r/PeriodUnderwear. Top-rated brands include Saxx (4.7/5), Pair of Thieves (4.7/5), Jockey (4.2/5).

Stats

Reviews444

Subreddits74

Posts110

Brands78

Products30

Top communities

r/mensfashion46 r/BuyItForLife41 r/exmormon35 r/AskMen29 r/PeriodUnderwear28

444 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

Saxx

4.7

(27)

"Sooooo comfy."

"I recommend SAXX and RM Real Men."

"Brands like Saxx and BN3TH are highly recommended for their ergonomic pouches and anti-chafing designs."

"My absolute favorite are saxx."

"The comfiest underwear ever, have a useful “pouch” for the boys."

"Saxx."

"My husband is obsessed with saxx."

"I settled on SAXX as the brand I was gonna test first."

"Saxx"

Pair of Thieves

4.7

(20)

"I love pair of thieves"

"Pair of thieves, or I like the target brand good fellow as a cheaper alternative"

"Pair of thieves boxer briefs are my go to. A little pricey but very high quality."

"They are amazing at the gym. No chaffing, no excessive sweat, very breathable."

"I like Pair of Thieves."

"Pair of Thieves are very soft and comfortable."

"Pair of Thieves are pretty damn comfy."

"These worked great for me."

"I really like Pair of Thieves."

"Pair of Thieves is my favorite brand."

Jockey

4.2

(22)

"I wear the stretch ones bikini ones from jockey n can barely feel them on."

"Jockeys. The elastic never feels tight and I barely notice them on."

"Covers the elastic."

"Has some excellent ones!"

"Jockey. 💯"

"Go to Jockey."

"Jockey.."

"The answer will always be jokey."

"Bhai jockey or levis hi hai acche brands yahan."

"Women's Jockey Elance. Available on Amazon in brief, french cut, hipster, bikini, and string bikini."

MeUndies

4.8

(16)

"They’re real comfy and durable."

"I wore MeUndies brand all through my last pregnancy."

"My personal favorite underpants are MeUndies. They unfortunately don’t have pouch style underpants, but the fabric is soooo comfy."

"MeUndies is fantastic."

"Modal is incredibly soft."

"Meundies are the softest I’ve ever owned."

"I really love meundies. So comfy and so many patterns and styles."

"MeUndies always feels better"

"MeUndies. So soft, and fun designs."

"Very comfortable and they have cute prints."

Aerie

4.8

(16)

"I keep coming back to either Aerie cheeky or VS cheeky, the absolute best are the ones with lace trim."

"Aerie has a cheeky laser cut cotton underwear that are my current favorite. They’re 87% cotton and 13% elastane."

"Cheap, cute, and they feel amazing."

"I love Aerie!"

"Aerie, hollister, and pink (not victoria secret but PINK) all fit me in the smallest size."

"Aerie’s modal undies are all I wear."

"I loooooove the Aerie "Smoothez" line!"

"I love love love aerie underwear."

"I buy all my underwear from Aerie and just went up a size, which is still working for me at 34 weeks!"

"They come in all sorts of different cuts, colors, and fabrics, and you can get a bunch in whichever design you like."

Duluth

4.8

(14)

"Duluth Armachillo. They're made with some kind of magical fabric that keeps you cool."

"Both make quality pouch underwear with dividers."

"Duluth underwear with the ball hammock option."

"They last for years."

"Huge fan of Duluth's Buck Naked."

"Duluth. My go to for the last five years."

"They are having 50% off sales for the Black Friday weekend."

"Delueth buck naked underwear. I like the active wear “wicking” version."

"My entire underwear drawer has become Duluth “Buck Naked” underwear."

"Duluth Trading and TommyJohn have been the best fitting, most comfortable undies I've tried."

Modibodi

4.4

(15)

"Modibodi."

"Modibodi, I used to have very heavy flow on the 1st day (pads would leak less than an hour on) and Modibodi never let me down."

"Second modibody. I got some moderate heavy, super overnight and heavy overnight and they come in cute colours and boy shorts too which I love."

"Modibodi do good ones, I like them anyway!"

"I have bought two sizes up and had a sewing friend put velcro on the sides to hold it together."

"I love Modibodi however I’m a light flow girl."

"Modibodi! X"

"I like modibodi’"

"Modibodi has pieces that I think would meet this requirement."

"I was thinking Modibodi as well. They ship internationally (have different only stores I think)."

Lululemon

4.8

(13)

"Lulu lemon has some dope ass underwear for men."

"Lululemon: Always in Motion."

"Also lululemon. You probably want more of a brief style too to prevent chafing."

"By all accounts, the lululemon ones are insanely comfortable."

"I love the Lululemon underwear"

"I like Lululemon personally. Great for wearing under slacks to work or under shorts for a workout and everything in between."

"Those keep me cool."

"Lululemon boxer briefs are worth every penny."

"Lululemon hands down."

"They’re tight enough for the gym and day to day but soft and loose enough for chilling and sleeping."

Calvin Klein

4.6

(13)

"Calvin Klein are rly good looking in my opinion."

"He prefers Calvin Kline"

"Calvin Klein for life!"

"I've found them to be very durable."

"Did me wonders."

"Calvin Klein 👌"

"The finest I’ve found."

"Yup calvin Klein will not budge and are comfy."

"Calvin Klein - a bit expensive but well worth it."

"My current favourite is Calvin Klein."

#10

Under Armour

4.5

(13)

"Best underwear period."

"Make THE BEST underwear."

"UnderArmor Boxerjocks."

"Under Armour Boxerjock"

"So comfy and actually last."

"First i found that got No holes between legs. Love Them"

"Genuinely can't wear anything else"

"Under Armour or Volcom long compression shorts."

"For gym and other sports."

"Simple."

#11

Bambody

4.5

(12)

"I have a couple styles & love them!"

"They cover front to back."

"I use bambody. Both for periods and recently for postpartum bleeding."

"Bambody has a boyshort style that is very comfortable."

"I've been using BamBody period panties for several years now, and I've never had a leak."

"I love Bambody! It’s the only one I’ve personally used that’s not had any leakage."

"I have sensory issues and i really like bambody."

"I use bambody."

"I would recommend the bambody or modibody."

"I wear the bambody brand from Amazon."

#12

TomboyX

4.3

(12)

"I also use period underwear from TomboyX."

"TomboyX has some undies in xxxs."

"I usually wear men's underwear or stuff like tomboy x that are made for a female body but more of the style of men's underwear."

"Has good period and leak free undies."

"I used tomboyx and had no problems."

"There are boxers with loose gussets to attach pads! Such as the tomboyx brand and many others."

"Any of their brief styles work great."

"Is what I use not that great of a name but no bulge at all."

"Both have their packs on sale for really good discounts."

"Has good period underwear."

#13

Tommy John

4.4

(11)

"I really like Tommy John Second Skin."

"The comfiest ive worn and the most accentuating too."

"No digging."

"Duluth Trading and TommyJohn have been the best fitting, most comfortable undies I've tried."

"If you like the longer style."

"Tommy John."

"The whole front is different than most brands."

"Second Skin from Tommy John. Their briefs and trunks will ride up a little bit but are still comfortable even after they ride up."

"I'd suggest a variety pack so he can ultimately decide on the material he prefers."

"Tommy John Sport 360 long boxer brief."

#14

Skims

4.9

(9)

"Is elite"

"My favorites… 1 Skims."

"Skims was surprisingly my favorite to wear over my stomach."

"I use skims!"

"Skims xxs"

"I'm a huge fan of boxer brief style underwear when I'm looking for comfort, like the boxers from Skims."

"Pretty sure Skims makes them now."

"I know they’re pricey but they work."

"Checkout SKIMS!"

#15

Uniqlo

4.7

(9)

"Uniqlo. Everything they make is great."

"No joke."

"They also don't have some obnoxious brand name written all over them."

"A pair usually lasts me 5-7 years."

"Uniqlo is the play & can replace the entire rotation."

"Very luxurious bras."

"The material is very soft, and there's a cotton gusset."

"Uniqlo low rise brief"

"They're cheap and will last about a year or more."

#16

Victoria's Secret

4.3

(9)

"I bought the VS XS underwear buy 7 for $35. all of them fit amazing."

"I love the victoria secret boxer briefs or cheekies."

"I wear them everyday and I forget I have them on."

"Victoria's Secret seamless underwear saved my sanity."

"I love their stuff!"

"VS pink panties run small in my opinion!"

"Victoria’s Secret underwear runs really small."

"Has the best elastics in the leg holes so nothing falls out."

"Don't bother with Victoria's Secret lol."

#17

Shinesty

4.9

(7)

"Shinesty. They’re fun, and so comfy."

"Shinesty. I give it my stamp of approval."

"Super comfy and has ball hammocks."

"Shinesty changed my life."

"It's soft, doesn't have rough edges, and is the first underwear I've bought that I don't hate."

"10/10 recommend Shinesty."

"I’m on the subscription plan and get three new ones every three months."

#18

Thinx

4.3

(8)

"Thinx has been my absolute favs for sure"

"The best that I've tried."

"My favorite so far have been Thinx."

"The Thinx I picked up from Target a few years ago to try the concept of period underwear. I like them too!"

"Thinx is a good brand along with Hanes. They do the job."

"Thinx has some black shorts that are really nice, I recommend them."

"Thinx goes up to size 3x."

"I switched from pads to Thinx underwear and they were a life changer."

#19

David Archy

4.6

(7)

"Soft, comfy, no chafy."

"David Archy makes comfortable briefs."

"David Archy in Amazon. Inexpensive and super comfortable."

"I say David archy boxer briefs from Amazon."

"I’ve liked David Archie."

"Similar to Tommy John but not as expensive."

"I just recently snagged up some David Archey brand thanks to Reddit."

4.5

(6)

"After Mack weldon, i only buy mack weldon."

"If you want quality."

"I like mack Weldon boxer briefs."

"I like the boxer briefs from Mack Weldon."

"Mack Weldon."

"Mack Weldon airknit 8in"

#24

Bodily

5.0

(5)

"They are literally the softest underwear. I wore them when I was pregnant and they were great for when I had a c section and I STILL wear them 9 months later."

"I still wear my 5-pack that I got 3 years ago as my “sleep undies”. I have given them as a gift to every pp mom I know and they all rave about them."

"I bought these Bodily underwear and I’m OBSESSED. So soft, so comfy."

"I just splurged and bought from Bodily. It’s spendy but I put them on and immediately knew I needed more."

"I love my bodily’s. good for pregnancy thru postpartum!"

#25

La Coochie

4.8

(5)

"I design the underwear for La Coochie (yes I know I'm biased when I say this) but they're very cute, organic cotton AND the gusset is longer & actually a normal width and sewn down."

"They love our high rise styles because the waistband is so gentle."

"Super soft organic cotton and some styles have zero elastic in the waistband!"

"La Coochie! Super soft organic cotton."

"La Coochie! Sewn down gusset for extra durability :)"

#26

Huha

4.8

(5)

"If this is a Canadian post. Simons has amazing cotton underwear and my all time fave is Huha. The gusset has zinc in it and I’ve never felt more comfortable!"

"Huha - it’s a woman owned Canadian company. They designed their underwear for long wear and is designed to help with BV and yeast infection symptoms/aggravation."

"Huha underwear!! Simply amazing, pricey-ish but last a long while and so comfy with lots of dif styles."

"So far the only one I've tried and loved so much I bought several is huha brand."

"Pricey but Huha is so well made."

#27

Fabletics

4.6

(5)

"Have my favorites but you gotta find them on sale."

"Are honestly amazing."

"I am partial to fabletics blueprint and Duluth trading co buck naked boxer briefs!"

"Fabletics."

"Fabletics boxer briefs"

#28

Fruit of the Loom

4.4

(5)

"Fruit of the loom has been my go-to for years."

"Fruit of the loom, fit for me ( hi cut breathable micro mesh)."

"They are comfortable and affordable."

"Reasonable price, good fit."

"They are comfortable and last."

#29

Woxer

4.2

(5)

"I like Woxer and similar shorts format."

"I have a Woxer subscription. I will never go back to anything else."

"Great bc it has briefs & they’re also high waisted."

"These undies are very soft and comfy!"

"I like Woxer."

#30

Exofficio

4.2

(5)

"Antimicrobial fabric keeps the funk down."

"They last too long, keep everything fresh."

"I have been happy with Exofficio."

"ExOfficio offers durable, quick-drying options great for everyday wear."

"Before they went to shit."

#31

Target

4.2

(5)

"The seamless from Target are my favorite, they’re soft and unnoticeable when wearing them!"

"The target ones are a good transition."

"Honestly, target brand compressions are great."

"I've also had Meundies for years but they're micromodal."

"Target has a lot of seamless underwear that is extremely comfortable."

#32

Torrid

4.8

(4)

"I recommend Torrid. That is where I get all mine from now."

"Love all the high rise briefs."

"Torrid, Amazon basics and these [underwear](https://a.co/d/cDpZ7jW)"

"I actually have found some pretty decent stuff from Torrid, if you're a bigger person."

#33

Manmade

4.8

(4)

"I absolutely love them. I find man made to be better in every way."

"My husband’s favourite underwear are Manmade."

"My hubby says the best underwear he has ever worn"

"I’ve found their shape, softness, and durability to be my favorite."

#34

Frida

4.8

(4)

"The Frida disposable underwear was a total life saver after my c section."

"I used the Frida mom disposable undies with a maxi pad. 10/10 recommend!"

"I find the frida mom briefs to be very comfortable."

"I liked the Frida disposable underwear for the first couple weeks after my c section. I appreciated that they were stretchy and I didn’t have a band sitting on my scar."

#35

Obviously

4.8

(4)

"Obviously is my favourite."

"Made from bamboo lycra, super comfortable and last forever."

"Please please invest in some external pouch underwear that allows the boys to hang separately"

"I wear Obviously. Very comfortable, and contained within a pouch."

#36

Natori

4.5

(4)

"I highly recommend Natori Bliss girl briefs."

"Natori girl briefs. They are SO comfortable."

"Natori is expensive but amazing"

"Is expensive but so good."

#37

Old Navy

4.5

(4)

"It's literally the most comfortable underwear I've ever owned."

"They are no show and seamless. The gusset is cotton."

"Super cheap :) "

#38

Period.co

4.3

4.3

(3)

"By far the most comfortable pair I’ve owned and it’s not even close."

"Icebreaker gets close on comfort and the 20% nylon they add to their merino massively extends their lifespan"

"It's doing wonders."

#51

5.0

(2)

"It feels like you’re not wearing underwear at all."

"Incredibly comfortable."

#55

Knix

5.0

(2)

"Knix is wonderful."

"Knix— because I pee every time I sneeze."

#56

Cheekboss

5.0

(2)

"They are incredibly comfortable!"

"Get two free pairs for the cost of shipping."

#57

evry

5.0

(2)

"They don’t dig, roll down, or ride up."

"I do really like them and reach for them first after I do laundry."

#58

(2)

"Super soft, comfy, stretchy, they don’t cut in anywhere."

"Stripe and stare - I just learned about them I love the high rise ones they are not seamless but VERY thin"

#71

Clovia

4.0

(2)

"Clovia is good."

#72

3.5

(2)

"Lane Bryant has some!"

"Lane Bryant may have some like you’re looking for."

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started