Whey Protein reviews from Reddit

Summary

We analyzed 340 Reddit reviews across 32 subreddits and 77 posts to rank the best Whey Protein brands recommended by redditors, including communities like r/Fitness_India, r/naturalbodybuilding, r/PHitness, r/nutrition, r/Chennai. Top-rated brands include Optimum Nutrition (4.4/5), MyProtein (4.2/5), Nakpro (3.9/5).

Stats

Reviews340

Subreddits32

Posts77

Brands67

Products52

Top communities

r/Fitness_India100 r/naturalbodybuilding62 r/PHitness49 r/nutrition22 r/Chennai12

340 reviews from

and

By Brand

By Product

Optimum Nutrition

4.4

(64)

"Expensive imported? ON, Ghost, MuscleTech"

"ON is the best imo"

"ON (Optimum Nutrition) is great"

"ON tlga ang the best lalo na bilhin mo yung 5kg pack nila with huge discounts sa shopee or lazada."

"ON is the best budget friendly."

"The general consensus is that Optimum Nutrition makes the best tasting and most economic whey powder."

"Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard has been the go-to for me for years."

"The vanilla ice cream optimum nutrition gold standard is the absolute best."

"Optimum Nutrition no question for me is the best tasting."

"Buy ON gold standard from their official site you will get the genuine product."

MyProtein

4.2

(18)

"Their protein is really good."

"MyProtein. The only brand that is made outside of India in 2025."

"Myprotein(best reviewed on lab testing at labdoor)"

"I go with the cheapest and least additives."

"I just bought myprotein casein 2.5kgs for just 2916/- It's manufactured in January(not expired)"

"Labdoor says the quality and purity is good"

"I like unflavored MyProtein."

"I have been using my myprotein these past few years since it's the only one that 1) has some third party testing online (labdoor) so I feel kinda safe with it and 2) it's cheap."

"Its cheaper then ON. Has better nutrients and blends better."

"Myprotein you can occasionally get 11 lbs for $60-75 when they have a good sale which is BY FAR the cheapest on the market right now"

Nakpro

3.9

(17)

"NAKPRO and it’s not even close"

"Results are good and no issues whatsoever."

"Nakpro platinum /iso zero (Malai kulfi)"

"Cheapest and tastiest is Nakpro"

"Nakpro vanilla tasted best to me with water. Their fruit flavours were great too."

"Worth trying."

"I have tried myprotein,ON,nutrabay and am currently using nakpro."

"Nakpro Platinum Malai Kulfi."

"For me nakpro works fine, you can try that"

"Nakpro is a good brand. Been using nakpro for about an year."

Rule1

4.8

(13)

"Rule1 mint chocolate flavor, for me the best I’ve tasted so far!"

"Go for Rule 1. Goods ‘yon mura na quality."

"Rule 1 is the Whey, pero mag-rotate ka din sa ibang brands na recommended ng iba para di magkaroon ng irritation or side effects pag gumamit ng ibang brand kasi nakasanayan na ng katawan yung isang brand."

"Rule 1, 5lbs @2.5k++ - super bang for the buck. Lift well!"

"Athlene, ON, Rule 1"

"RULE1 isolate. Best overall."

"Rule 1 🔛🔝"

"My go-to is rule 1, muscletech, and athlene, in that order based on flavor (cookies and cream/choco fudge)"

"Want imported but affordable? Rule1"

"Or mag Rule1 ka or ON if gusto mo international product"

Dymatize

4.6

(13)

"Dymatize 100% whey or the isolate if you prefer and don’t mind paying a higher price tag."

"High budget(unlimited money):- Dymatize ISO 100"

"A great option to check out is Dymatize ISO100 Whey Protein."

"Iso100- Amazing macros, chocolate peanut butter 10/10."

"Favorite is iso100."

"Buy dymatize or optimum nutrition they are the best"

"I like the Dymatize ISO100 stuff since I'm lactose intolerant."

"They come in various flavors, are gluten-free, easy to cook and bake, absorb quickly, and are easy to digest."

"Whey protein isolate is better than whey protein concentrate for everyone imo."

"As the OP recommended."

Athlene

4.8

(12)

"Athlene/Rule1 ftw!"

"Second athlene and rule 1."

"Athlene na lang, true to it's content mura pa"

"Athlene, ON, Rule 1"

"Athlene or Wheyl."

"Want affordable local? Athlene"

"Go for Athlene. Masarap din flavours nila lalo na strawberry."

"Check local brands like Athlene and Wheyl Co."

"For local brand, go for Athlene and Wheyl - I can say sobrang worth it and mapag kakatiwalaan tong brand na to"

"Kaya gusto ko yung vanilla na whey ng athlene. Parang good enough as base for the protein content."

Avvatar

4.0

(14)

"My personal fav after trying multiple ones is Avvatar and AMUL but its relatively expensive"

"I've been using Avvatar for over one year now. Worked well for me."

"Muscle blaze is very hard on the gut i would recommend you go for ON performance whey or avvatar's chocolate hazelnut"

"You can go for: Avvatar"

"Avvtaar kulfi flavour.. it has around 32gms of protein per scoop if i remember correctly and is safe to consume (lab tested)"

"Go for mb or avvtar they cost less then this and better flavour and for taste just remeber this choclate is allrounder for every whey you can drink eat do everything."

"Choose anyone from avvatar or amul."

"Other would be Avvtar, Asitis."

"Try Avvatar. Its good."

"They have good whey protein under 2k."

Asitis

3.8

(13)

"It's great, tastes like choclate milk, I'm on my 2nd pack rn"

"You can go for: Asitis Atom"

"A bit higer range is ATOM"

"Using the unflavoured 'Asitis' from the past few months Easy to digest, it's good."

"Their hazelnut flavor is good. I am using their Atom 27 gm protein variant with choco hazelnut flavor and I really like it."

"Go for flavoured atom whey. It has 27g protein per scoop."

"Go for atom concentrate 27g one that is trustified taste is also good (choco one)"

"Bro, just grab some crude whey from ASITIS (no flavor drama). Toss it in coffee, orange juice, or whatever magic potion you fancy."

"Atom's mango flavour is good."

"I've been having Asitis, it's beginner-friendly and affordable, and has unflavoured ones."

Isopure

4.2

(11)

"I use isopure! It’s low carb and low sugar!"

"I've loved the low carb Isopure for a long time."

"Isopure, for me since I worked at a gym for a while and it was so easy to grab and drink after a workout."

"Isopure has always been a good one for low calorie, no fat, high protein and mixes well."

"Isopure has been mine because it has a lot of vitamins in it too."

"I’ve seen good results and flavor with Isopure vanilla."

"Isopure for me. I like the unflavored but they make flavors too."

"Isopure or something similar. Look at ingredients."

"0 carbs and some of the flavors are pretty great."

"Isopure vanilla from Costco"

#10

Amul

3.6

(11)

"Lactose free, Easy to digest and trustworthy."

"Amul 😎"

"Go for AMUL"

"Its on the cheaper side as compared to other companies like ON, but the quality is up There"

"It's a bit expensive compared to some other brands but they got 27/30 g protein so it's worth it id say."

"Amul Lelo, it foams alot but that is the nature of whey."

"Amul , nakpro , atom etc."

"3500 for 1.92kg so roughly 1750 per kilo."

"Amul is good yaar unko website dekho."

"Amul"

#11

Muscletech

4.1

(8)

"Can’t beat Muscletech"

"ON and Muscletech"

"Great stuff. Mildly overpriced but great. I’d go muscletech before nutribio for whey."

"My go-to is rule 1, muscletech, and athlene, in that order based on flavor (cookies and cream/choco fudge)"

"Muscletech was yummy"

"Try mo yung bagong ISO whey ng Muscletech vanilla flavor, sarap din ihalo sa smoothies."

"Tastes good with water, tastes amazing with milk"

"I suggest trying Nitrotech."

#12

The Whole Truth

4.8

(6)

"I use 'the whole truth' unflavoured after trying a few available options."

"The whole truth!"

"If you can afford high end products, this is the only choice that I would recommend."

"The whole truth, honestly the lightest and best."

"Try the whole truth protein, has no artificial flavors."

"The whole truth is bit pricey but worth the money."

#13

MuscleBlaze

3.6

(7)

"Muscle Blaze is quite affordable."

"I found MB best in terms of mixability but other than that ON is good overall."

"If you are on a budget or ON"

"Go for muscleblaze instead."

"I use this along with muscle blaze protein oats, it tastes average."

"Muscleblaze bhi sahi hai, idk the price tho but its cheaper than myprotein"

"On behest of my gym bro, I purchased muscle blaze whey."

#14

Naturaltein

4.2

(6)

"Naturaltein"

"If you can afford something expensive, then check out Naturaltein"

"I ordered naturaltein having 72g protein per 100g. This one is flavoured."

"You can go for: Naturaltein"

"Try any unflavoured Protein Concentrate and you won't have that problem."

"Will Never use Muscleblaze even if given for free."

#15

Ghost

4.8

(5)

"Ghost whey protein is the best tasting by far in my opinion."

"Ghost makes a ton of fun flavors that are actually tasty"

"Ghost has the best flavors."

"Ghost makes the best proteins and its not even close for m.e."

"If you’re looking for taste but it’s pricey"

#16

Transparent Labs

4.6

(5)

"Transparent labs is goated. 28g a serving, 1g of sugar. Kinda expensive but imo worth every cent"

"Second transparent labs, all my supps are from them."

"Transparent labs. Best stuff on the market IMO."

"Transparent Labs, Planta cinnamon roll, pb&j, and the maple french toast"

"I like Transparent Labs. They seem to have the cleanest product I’ve found from independent testing"

#17

Legion

4.4

(5)

"Legion Athletics"

"Legion whey is my go to."

"Legion!!!!! USE CODE CAMMAL"

"I like Legion."

"I would look for one that has good macros and is third party tested."

#18

Wheyl

5.0

(4)

"Wheyl for the win!! Tastes super good, sometimes that's what u need after a workout"

"Want expensive local? Wheyl"

"Check local brands like Athlene and Wheyl Co."

"For local brand, go for Athlene and Wheyl - I can say sobrang worth it and mapag kakatiwalaan tong brand na to"

#19

Ryse

4.0

(5)

"I’d also recommend Ryse sa expensive and imported."

"Ryse Peanut Butter!!! I’ve also tried Ghost in Chips Ahoy, ok lang."

"Ryse and Ekkovision are my favorites out of the 15+ brands I’ve tried."

"I use ryse bc it tastes good"

"I’d recommend Ryse, Ghost, and Dymatize - Optimum Nutrition is a pretty decent choice as well."

#20

Whey Protein Isolate

4.3

(4)

"Whey isolate 100% best flavour and low in calories compared to some others."

"Best is unflavored whey isolate, however it's also the most expensive."

"I've only tried the chocolate so far, but I'm a big fan of this one."

"Just started using whey protein isolate. It’s a lot easier on the stomach."

#21

Muscle Nectar

4.3

(4)

"Muscle nectar any day."

"I use muscle nectar whey protien, its good."

"Can never go wrong with muscle nectar."

"I prefer muscle nectar because of pricing and quality."

#22

ON

4.3

(4)

"On is the best plus they directly sell online don’t waste money on Indian brands consistently failing quality control."

"ON, Gnc, Muscle blaze these are my recommendations."

"ON is good (cookies n crean,strawberry,extreme milk chocolate), Muscle Tech is also equally good (vanilla)."

"ON is the most recommended mid budget one."

#23

GNC

3.8

3.7

3.0

(1)

"It's super expensive."

#67

Sport Research

3.0

(1)

"Why do I never see anyone recommend sport research whey protein isolate??"

Discover your audience

GummySearch is an audience research toolkit for 130,000 unique communities on Reddit.

If you are looking for startup problems to solve, want to validate your idea or find your customers online, GummySearch is for you.

Tell me more

Get started